Compare commits

...
8 Commits
Author SHA1 Message Date
alexmandClaude 7890fa1ad7 feat: trace annotation body for traced citations; paperspec.traces
A trace follows one citation of a sentence of a citing paper to a passage of the
cited paper (spec/18 section 18.5). Minor change: a new body kind, optional
properties and two rules, with no valid file made invalid.

- annotation schema branch (source, selector, reference, note, verdict, proposer;
  proposer required for a Software creator); body_kind in sql/store.sql; the note
  and proposer terms of the JSON-LD context; rules layer.trace.source and
  layer.trace.target.
- paperspec.traces: resolve(annotation, citing_state, cited_state, same_as) gives
  current, changed, stale, unlinked or misresolved with open and cites; problems,
  disputes, disputed.
- fixtures/records/traces/ on writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3 and vectors/traces.jsonl
  (29 cases); check.py runs the record checks over both layers; counts, glossary,
  examples and CHANGELOG updated.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Uy4ZYbWRoCdUtWLEfigysY
2026-10-17 20:12:04 -04:00
alexmandClaude 44a8e3f07c docs: the converter is named paperform
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01SarHTuHhV9cS85XWy2NrLJ
2026-10-17 10:39:56 -04:00
alexmandClaude c7f54320dd refactor!: claim references are claim:TAG
lode is renamed paperclaim. A claim reference is claim:TAG or
claim:host/TAG and a pin claim:TAG@hex6 (claimRef and claimPin in
common.schema.json, spec/18 §18.4, spec/02, spec/20); the eight-character
tags do not change. A project names its claim namespace as
claims.paperclaim, and the main example's targeted receipts take the
scope targeted:paperclaim. No old prefix or name is accepted.

paperspec build regenerated the fixtures and vectors: the claim link's and
the symbol's record IDs, the layer receipt, project.json, the two targeted
receipts and Ben's spot-check, the QA report, the inclusion proof, the log's
checkpoint and tiles, and the signature, spot-check, VRF and checkpoint
vectors. The walkthrough and examples quote the new receipt IDs.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01SarHTuHhV9cS85XWy2NrLJ
2026-10-17 10:38:53 -04:00
alexmandClaude 568e0271d3 docs: scienting-math/1 tree kinds prescript and mark
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_017R7sgDNvUGWY2zFPCq2JH6
2026-10-17 07:15:55 -04:00
alexmandClaude 17880686fa feat: scienting-math/1 sources and derived/math.jsonl; lode references; stress fixes
Math content may say its source is in scienting-math/1's canonical TeX (form,
in no hash); derived/math.jsonl holds papermath's tree, symbols and issues,
and the validator now checks derived files. A symbol annotation names its
symbol by key; lode claim references use lode's tag and pin syntax. The zip
reader refuses entries zipfile cannot read, and checkpoint lines end in LF only.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_017R7sgDNvUGWY2zFPCq2JH6
2026-10-17 06:44:28 -04:00
alexmandClaude 8b5ee87275 feat: comment categories; emend, relink and resolve corrections
scienting-layer/1: an optional, fixed category on comment, caveat and
question bodies (comment, context, critique, question, correction,
feedback, resource).

Corrections: emend fixes the authors' own slip and keeps what was printed
(a run's printed), never lowering fidelity or a witness match; relink sets
or removes what a citation names; resolve sets a reference's resolution.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_017R7sgDNvUGWY2zFPCq2JH6
2026-10-17 06:17:10 -04:00
alexmandClaude 4d59b29b63 chore!: the converter is named papervert (short form pvt)
paperstract becomes papervert, the paper converter: package, command,
PAPERVERT_* variables, the [papervert] settings section, tools/pvt.py
and the .pvt- CSS classes. No old name is kept as an alias.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_017R7sgDNvUGWY2zFPCq2JH6
2026-10-17 05:44:51 -04:00
alexmandClaude 3836a6c885 feat: alignment pairs a misread sentence with its other reading; a suspect names its witness
spec/05 §5.6 gains a substitution step: an unpaired sentence beside one at
least 0.8 alike (2L/(|a|+|b|) over the lossy projections' code points) is
paired with it, so a misread is one number, equation or word suspect rather
than a dropped and an added one. §5.7 and suspect.schema.json gain an
optional `witness`, checked by doc.suspect.witness. alignment.jsonl gains a
`substitutions` case; the first case is unchanged.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-10-16 22:41:15 -04:00
78 changed files with 2547 additions and 197 deletions

No files matched your search

+68 -1
View File
@@ -7,7 +7,7 @@ A change to any computed value is a breaking change and needs a new major versio
The first release. The first release.
- The specification, in chapters 0 to 23, covering every format: 32 formats, of which 19 are `candidate` and 13 `provisional`. - The specification, in chapters 0 to 23, covering every format: 32 formats, of which 19 are `candidate` and 13 `provisional`.
- 42 JSON Schemas, using a keyword subset that independent validators read alike. - 43 JSON Schemas, using a keyword subset that independent validators read alike.
- Tables for SQLite, Dolt and PostgreSQL, a team's store, and the SQLite bundle with full-text search. - Tables for SQLite, Dolt and PostgreSQL, a team's store, and the SQLite bundle with full-text search.
- The JSON-LD context for layers, and registries of formats, rules, download-stamp rules and default stage requirements. - The JSON-LD context for layers, and registries of formats, rules, download-stamp rules and default stage requirements.
- Test vectors for every computed value, from canonical JSON to anchor resolution, grading and the target set of targeted F3. - Test vectors for every computed value, from canonical JSON to anchor resolution, grading and the target set of targeted F3.
@@ -35,3 +35,70 @@ Packaging, commands and lazy imports only; the formats stay at 0.1.0, and no com
- `src/` is Apache-2.0, as `tools/` was, and the package metadata states `Apache-2.0 AND CC0-1.0` for the code and the data it carries. - `src/` is Apache-2.0, as `tools/` was, and the package metadata states `Apache-2.0 AND CC0-1.0` for the code and the data it carries.
- The pixi workspace installs the package editable, and a `dev` environment builds the sdist and the wheel with `pixi run -e dev dist`. - The pixi workspace installs the package editable, and a `dev` environment builds the sdist and the wheel with `pixi run -e dev dist`.
- Pushing a version tag publishes the package to the Gitea package registry through `.gitea/workflows/publish.yml` ([deploy/](deploy/README.md#publish-the-python-package)); a release tag versions the package, and [CONTRIBUTING.md](CONTRIBUTING.md#releasing) says how that relates to the format version. - Pushing a version tag publishes the package to the Gitea package registry through `.gitea/workflows/publish.yml` ([deploy/](deploy/README.md#publish-the-python-package)); a release tag versions the package, and [CONTRIBUTING.md](CONTRIBUTING.md#releasing) says how that relates to the format version.
### Unreleased
Two changes asked for by the first producer that compares a converted reading with a second witness (paperform with a JATS file).
Both are minor changes in the sense of [spec/00](spec/00-introduction.md): no valid file becomes invalid, and no hash, ID or key changes; the next release numbers them.
- Alignment has a substitution step ([spec/05 §5.6](spec/05-hashes.md#56-alignment), step 3): in each stretch between pairs, an unpaired sentence of the first reading is paired with the first unpaired sentence of the second whose similarity (2*L* / (|*a*| + |*b*|) over code points of the lossy projections, *L* their longest common subsequence) is at least 0.8, both of prose length 20 or more.
A sentence one reading misread is now one `number`, `equation` or `word` suspect rather than a `dropped` and an `added` one, so a producer re-aligning the same two readings can get different suspects than before; the pairs and suspects of readings with no such sentence are unchanged, as the first alignment vector is.
`paperspec.align` gains `lcs_length` (bit-parallel, Hyyrö 2004) and `similarity`, and `alignment.jsonl` a second case, `substitutions`: a misread number, a misread word, a sentence too short to be paired this way and two sentences too unlike to be one.
- A suspect may name the witness its second reading came from (`witness`, a witness ID; [spec/05 §5.7](spec/05-hashes.md#57-suspects), `suspect.schema.json`), and a package whose suspect names a witness it does not have breaks `doc.suspect.witness`.
No broken package exercises the rule yet: adding one changes the count of broken packages that the 0.1.0 entry above states, so it waits for the release.
Four more, asked for by editors who correct and discuss papers rather than readings.
They are minor changes too: new operations, enumeration values and optional properties, with no valid file made invalid, no value of an existing file computed differently, and no existing vector case or package changed.
- Annotation categories ([spec/18 §18.4](spec/18-layers.md#184-bodies), `annotation.schema.json`, the `category` term of the JSON-LD context): a `comment`, `caveat` or `question` body may carry a `category` from the fixed list `comment`, `context`, `critique`, `question`, `correction`, `feedback` and `resource`, which a producer that supports categories SHOULD set on every such body.
The store's `annotations` table gains a nullable `category` column with its CHECK ([sql/store.sql](sql/store.sql)).
The example layer's comment, question and reply gain categories, which changes their record IDs, and it gains a caveat; no other fixture changes.
- `emend`, a correction of the authors' own typo, spelling, grammar, punctuation or wording, where the reading matches the page and the page is wrong ([spec/11 §11.6](spec/11-corrections.md#116-emendations)).
The emended text keeps what was printed in a new optional run property, `printed` ([spec/03 §3.5](spec/03-nodes.md#35-inline-runs), `runs.schema.json`), so a leaf as printed is recovered from the package alone ([3.6](spec/03-nodes.md#36-the-plain-projection), `paperspec.hashing.printed` and `as_printed`), and runs with `printed` are never joined.
The strict and lossy projections are of the runs as printed, so an emend changes the leaf's `text_hash`, `own_hash` and `node_hash` but not its `match_hash` or `align_key`, and alignment, corroboration and suspects never report an emendation ([spec/05 §5.1](spec/05-hashes.md#51-the-five-values)).
The gate refuses an emend in math, across runs, or that changes a digit or edits beside one, and refuses a `replace`, text `insert` or `split` inside an emended run (`correction.emend`).
- `relink` makes a run a citation of other references, a text run a cite run, or a cite run text, without changing its text, and `resolve` sets a reference's resolution in `references.jsonl`, keeping the one before in `from` ([spec/11 §11.7](spec/11-corrections.md#117-citations-and-references)); a package whose last resolve of a reference is not its resolution breaks `doc.correction.resolution`.
Like an emend, neither lowers a leaf's level, and a receipt keeps counting across all three ([spec/08 §8.1–8.2](spec/08-fidelity.md#82-levels), `receipts.carried_hashes`).
- The rules `correction.emend`, `correction.relink`, `correction.resolve` and `doc.correction.resolution` are registered, the `corrections` table's CHECK takes the three operations ([sql/doc.sql](sql/doc.sql)), `corrections.State` carries the reference records, and `paperspec stress` walks the three operations with their invariants.
`corrections.jsonl` gains thirteen cases and `projections.jsonl` and `projection-groups.jsonl` two each; no existing case changes.
Four more, asked for by papermath, which defines the math form `scienting-math/1`, and by paperclaim, the claim store whose claims and symbols layers point at.
The first two are minor changes: an optional property, a derived file and its schema, with no hash, ID or key of an existing file changed.
The last two make some files that were valid invalid, which [spec/00](spec/00-introduction.md) calls breaking; they are made now because no release of `scienting-doc/1` or `scienting-layer/1` has been tagged, and a reference worth changing is changed before one is ([CONTRIBUTING.md](CONTRIBUTING.md#releasing), item 4).
- Math forms ([spec/03 §3.7](spec/03-nodes.md#37-math-forms), [spec/09 §9.4](spec/09-figures-tables-equations.md#94-the-math-form), `node.schema.json`, `runs.schema.json`, `mathForm` in `common.schema.json`): an equation's content and a `math` run may carry `form`, whose one value, `scienting-math/1`, says that the source is canonical TeX; the notation is then `tex`.
A consumer may rely on the source being canonical and idempotent, carrying no label, and on everything else being derived from it.
`form` enters no content value ([spec/05 §5.2](spec/05-hashes.md#52-own-content)): own content leaves it out of math runs (`paperspec.hashing`), an equation's own content never held more than its notation and source, and no projection reads it, so adding `form` to a source already in the form changes no hash, ID or anchor, while respelling a source changes it as any edit does.
Because a complex formula's key compares sources, a producer aligning a reading in a form with another reading respells the other's math first.
`hashes.jsonl` gains a case, `math-form`, whose values `paperspec check` also computes without `form`; the rule `doc.math.form` is registered for validators that implement the form, which the reference validator does not.
- `derived/math.jsonl` ([spec/12 §12.7](spec/12-package.md#127-derived-files), [spec/09 §9.4](spec/09-figures-tables-equations.md#94-the-math-form), `math.schema.json`): one line per formula, `{node, run, tool, form, tree, symbols, complete, issues, label?}`, papermath's reading without the canonical TeX, which is the source; `run` is null for an equation, as in `derived/mathml.jsonl`, and `label` is omitted when the source has no `\tag`.
A tree node is an array whose first item is its kind; the schema takes any lowercase kind and issue code, so the form can add some in a minor version, and lists the 49 kinds and six codes of version 1.
The validator now checks derived files: each line against its schema, that it names a formula of the package (`doc.derived.node`), that a math line's formula is TeX and its `complete` and `symbols` agree with its tree (`doc.derived.math`), and that a checks-only package carries none (`doc.policy.withheld`), since a tree or MathML reads the withheld text.
The main example gains `derived/math.jsonl`, papermath 0.1.0's reading of its equation and of two math runs, copied by hand because the oracle does not implement the form; `paperspec check` validates fourteen variants of it, and no fixture's hashes change.
There are now 43 schemas, which the 0.1.0 entry above, held to the repository by `paperspec check`, states too.
- Claim references ([spec/18 §18.4](spec/18-layers.md#184-bodies), [spec/02 §2.4](spec/02-model.md#24-work-and-document-keys), [spec/20](spec/20-projects.md), `claimRef` and `claimPin` in `common.schema.json`): the `source` of a `claim-link` or `symbol` body, a `claim:` identifier in `same_as`, and a project's claim step are paperclaim references, `claim:<tag>` or `claim:<host>/<tag>` with the tag eight Crockford base32 capitals, and a `pin` is the reference, `@` and six lowercase hex digits of the claim's statement hash, as paperclaim writes them; a project names its claim namespace as `claims.paperclaim`.
A reference by slug, such as `amber/k-bond`, which paperclaim may rename, or under any other prefix, was valid before and is not now.
The fixtures' slug reference and `illustrative-pin` become `claim:272XTX7C` and `claim:272XTX7C@02f47b`, the claim `amber/k-bond` of paperclaim's example store, which changes the claim link's and the symbol's record IDs, the layer receipt and `project.json`.
The main example's two targeted receipts take the scope `targeted:paperclaim`, which changes their IDs and signatures, Ben's spot-check of the second (its seed and its sample of ten, still without errors), the QA report, the inclusion proof, the transparency log's checkpoint and tiles, and the signature, spot-check, VRF and checkpoint vectors built from them; no node's level or the report's counts change.
- Symbol keys ([spec/18 §18.4](spec/18-layers.md#184-bodies), `annotation.schema.json`, the `key` term of the JSON-LD context, `sct:symbolKey`): a `symbol` body names its symbol by `key`, its `scienting-math/1` key, besides the span its target selects, so a symbol is found across papers and matched to its claim by key; a `symbol` body without `key` was valid before and is not now.
The example layer gains a proposed symbol annotation on `$K_r$`, with the key `K_{r}`.
- Three failures of `paperspec stress` with the seeds 1, 2 and 7, in code the earlier changes did not touch.
The zip reader let `zipfile`'s own errors escape on an archive it cannot read, such as `NotImplementedError` for an entry that needs zip version 9.8; `paperspec.package.read_zip` now refuses every such archive with `package.zip.entry` ([spec/12 §12.2](spec/12-package.md#122-paths)), and `paperspec check` crafts one of each kind.
A checkpoint note was split into lines with `str.splitlines`, which also breaks at U+000B and other separators and so accepted a note whose last newline was replaced by one; [spec/23 §23.2](spec/23-log.md#232-checkpoints) now says every line ends in U+000A alone, `paperspec.log.parse_checkpoint` splits on it, and `paperspec check` tries ten other separators.
The third was the stress harness's own: a truncation could cut a file at its full length, leaving the package unchanged and valid, so it now always shortens the file.
So was a fourth, with 1000 rounds: the random walk of corrections could delete the body section, leaving nothing to correct and too few corrections accepted, so a delete now leaves at least eight nodes.
One more, asked for by paperdesk, which lets a reader follow a citation to the passage it rests on.
It is a minor change in the sense of [spec/00](spec/00-introduction.md): a new body kind, optional properties and two rules, with no valid file made invalid, no computed value changed and no existing vector case or package changed.
- Traced citations ([spec/18 §18.5](spec/18-layers.md#185-traced-citations), `annotation.schema.json`, the `note` and `proposer` terms of the JSON-LD context): a `trace` body follows one citation of a sentence of a citing paper to a passage of the cited paper.
The target is a leaf or span anchor on the citing sentence, which must cite the body's `reference`; the body names the cited document in `source`, the passage in `selector` (an `AnchorSelector` with its pin and span, then a `TextQuoteSelector` when the quote is plain), and optionally a `note`, a `verdict` and a `proposer` (`{model, run, score?, rank?}`, required when the creator is `Software`).
A `crosslink` stays what it was, a symmetric correspondence of two spans with no room for a note, the reference meant or a proposer's provenance.
The state of a trace is the annotation's `status`, and a trace is disputed while an `assessing` reply to it stands, which is computed from the replies.
The `body_kind` CHECK of the store's `annotations` table takes `trace` ([sql/store.sql](sql/store.sql)), and `paperspec check` holds it to the schema's list of body kinds.
- `paperspec.traces` and the rules `layer.trace.source` and `layer.trace.target` ([spec/22 §22.4](spec/22-conformance.md#224-rules)).
`resolve(annotation, citing_state, cited_state, same_as)` resolves both anchors by [spec/06 §6.5](spec/06-anchors.md#65-resolution) and returns `current`, `changed`, `stale` (with the side), `unlinked` (a `relink` removed the citation) or `misresolved` (a `resolve` points the reference at another work), with `open`, the passage's current address, and `cites`, the citations inside it, so a chain of citations is followed one trace at a time.
`problems` reports the two rules, and `disputes` and `disputed` read the replies.
- `fixtures/records/traces/` is a second layer, on the Typst draft, with a model's confirmed trace to the main example's abstract and its receipt, a rejected candidate, a person's trace to Table 1 and a reply that disputes the first, and `vectors/traces.jsonl` has 29 cases that correct either paper and show every outcome and both rules.
`paperspec check` runs both layers through the record checks and the store.
The example project holds the new layer, which changes `project.json`; no other fixture changes.
+15 -8
View File
@@ -33,7 +33,7 @@ The repository's name, paperspec, is a separate matter.
## An example from the fixtures ## An example from the fixtures
[`fixtures/records/layer/annotations.jsonl`](../fixtures/records/layer/annotations.jsonl) holds nine annotations on the example paper `hale2026harmonic-damb`. [`fixtures/records/layer/annotations.jsonl`](../fixtures/records/layer/annotations.jsonl) holds twelve annotations on the example paper `hale2026harmonic-damb`.
The first is a `gloss`, an explanation for a novice, of the phrase "bond force constant". The first is a `gloss`, an explanation for a novice, of the phrase "bond force constant".
Shortened, it reads: Shortened, it reads:
@@ -57,14 +57,14 @@ This context defines `kind`, `status`, `audience`, `AnchorSelector` and `anchor`
## What it defines ## What it defines
The file defines 23 terms. The file defines 27 terms.
Twenty-two map to IRIs under `https://paperspec.scient.ing/vocab#`: `format`, `kind`, `status`, `receipt`, `layer`, `audience`, `visibility`, `purpose`, `project`, `docs`, `pin`, `role`, `symbol`, `verdict`, `reason`, `reference`, `for`, `generator`, `exercise`, `anchor`, `rights_use` and the class `AnchorSelector`. Twenty-six map to IRIs under `https://paperspec.scient.ing/vocab#`: `format`, `kind`, `status`, `receipt`, `layer`, `audience`, `visibility`, `purpose`, `project`, `docs`, `pin`, `role`, `symbol`, `key`, `verdict`, `reason`, `reference`, `note`, `proposer`, `for`, `category`, `generator`, `exercise`, `anchor`, `rights_use` and the class `AnchorSelector`.
Three are renamed: `for` is `sct:questionFor`, `generator` is `sct:generatedBy`, and `rights_use` is `sct:rightsUse`. Five are renamed: `key`, the key of a `symbol` body's symbol, is `sct:symbolKey`, `for` is `sct:questionFor`, `generator` is `sct:generatedBy`, `proposer`, the tool that found a trace, is `sct:proposedBy`, and `rights_use` is `sct:rightsUse`.
The twenty-third, `total`, maps to `totalItems` in the ActivityStreams namespace. The twenty-seventh, `total`, maps to `totalItems` in the ActivityStreams namespace.
Two terms carry a type rule. Two terms carry a type rule.
A processor reads `layer` as an IRI, and it always reads `docs` as a set, so a one-element list stays a list. A processor reads `layer` as an IRI, and it always reads `docs` as a set, so a one-element list stays a list.
The file declares `anchor` and `exercise` as JSON literals (`"@type": "@json"`, a JSON-LD 1.1 feature, which is why the file sets `"@version": 1.1`). The file declares `anchor`, `exercise` and `proposer` as JSON literals (`"@type": "@json"`, a JSON-LD 1.1 feature, which is why the file sets `"@version": 1.1`).
A JSON-LD processor then keeps a `scienting-anchor/1` record intact instead of expanding it. A JSON-LD processor then keeps a `scienting-anchor/1` record intact instead of expanding it.
An anchor holds hashes (fixed-length fingerprints of text) and a `span`, a pair of character offsets whose order carries meaning. An anchor holds hashes (fixed-length fingerprints of text) and a `span`, a pair of character offsets whose order carries meaning.
Expansion would drop the anchor's unmapped field names ([JSON-LD 1.1 API, expansion step 13.3](https://www.w3.org/TR/json-ld11-api/#alg-expand-each-key-value)) and would give its arrays no order ([JSON-LD 1.1 §4.3](https://www.w3.org/TR/json-ld11/#sets-and-lists)). Expansion would drop the anchor's unmapped field names ([JSON-LD 1.1 API, expansion step 13.3](https://www.w3.org/TR/json-ld11-api/#alg-expand-each-key-value)) and would give its arrays no order ([JSON-LD 1.1 §4.3](https://www.w3.org/TR/json-ld11/#sets-and-lists)).
@@ -88,7 +88,14 @@ Such a tool still reads the annotation's body and its `TextQuoteSelector`; the c
That is the repository's statement; no Web Annotation client has been tested against these files. That is the repository's statement; no Web Annotation client has been tested against these files.
The fallback is not always there. The fallback is not always there.
Three of the nine fixture annotations have only an `AnchorSelector` (the section-level question, the `generated` annotation on a figure and the exercise on a table), because the anchor points at a container and has no quote. Three of the eleven fixture annotations have only an `AnchorSelector` (the section-level question, the `generated` annotation on a figure and the exercise on a table), because the anchor points at a container and has no quote.
## A body that points at another paper
A `trace` body ([spec/18 §18.5](../spec/18-layers.md#185-traced-citations)) follows a citation in the annotated sentence to a passage of the cited paper, so its `source` and `selector` name the cited paper, not the annotated one.
[`fixtures/records/traces/annotations.jsonl`](../fixtures/records/traces/annotations.jsonl) holds four annotations on the draft `writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3`, which cites the example paper.
The Web Annotation context defines `source` and `selector` for a body as it does for a target, so a trace's selector list puts the `AnchorSelector` first and the `TextQuoteSelector` after it, as a target's does.
This context adds the rest of the body: `reference`, the reference of the draft that the sentence cites, `note`, `verdict` and `proposer`, which a processor keeps whole, as it keeps an anchor, because its model's hashes and its score are values and not terms.
## Using the context ## Using the context
@@ -97,7 +104,7 @@ Three of the nine fixture annotations have only an `AnchorSelector` (the section
The file `vectors/resolve.jsonl` resolves seventeen anchors against `fixtures/packages/hale2026harmonic-damb` and gives every outcome. The file `vectors/resolve.jsonl` resolves seventeen anchors against `fixtures/packages/hale2026harmonic-damb` and gives every outcome.
- JSON-LD processor: Use a JSON-LD 1.1 processor; the context relies on `@json` and `@version` 1.1. - JSON-LD processor: Use a JSON-LD 1.1 processor; the context relies on `@json` and `@version` 1.1.
- Checker: `schemas/annotation.schema.json` and `schemas/layer.schema.json` validate the files. - Checker: `schemas/annotation.schema.json` and `schemas/layer.schema.json` validate the files.
`paperspec check` also checks that each annotation's ID derives from its content and that the receipt at `fixtures/records/layer/receipt.json` covers each `confirmed` annotation. `paperspec check` also checks that each annotation's ID derives from its content and that the receipt of its layer, at `fixtures/records/layer/receipt.json` or `fixtures/records/traces/receipt.json`, covers each `confirmed` annotation.
The traps: The traps:
+7
View File
@@ -21,10 +21,17 @@
"pin": "sct:pin", "pin": "sct:pin",
"role": "sct:role", "role": "sct:role",
"symbol": "sct:symbol", "symbol": "sct:symbol",
"key": "sct:symbolKey",
"verdict": "sct:verdict", "verdict": "sct:verdict",
"reason": "sct:reason", "reason": "sct:reason",
"reference": "sct:reference", "reference": "sct:reference",
"note": "sct:note",
"proposer": {
"@id": "sct:proposedBy",
"@type": "@json"
},
"for": "sct:questionFor", "for": "sct:questionFor",
"category": "sct:category",
"generator": "sct:generatedBy", "generator": "sct:generatedBy",
"exercise": { "exercise": {
"@id": "sct:exercise", "@id": "sct:exercise",
+1 -1
View File
@@ -428,7 +428,7 @@ Keep using it as a reading and distribution format.
*Status.* *Status.*
The specification is version 0.1.0. The specification is version 0.1.0.
`registry/formats.json` lists 32 formats: 19 are `candidate` (complete, with vectors and fixtures, ready to implement) and 13 are `provisional` (complete; expected to change as implementations gain experience): project, bundle, dataset, digitization, view, snapshot, draft-ids, exercise, submission, grade, checklist, log-entry and checkpoint ([spec/00 §0.4](../spec/00-introduction.md#04-status)). `registry/formats.json` lists 32 formats: 19 are `candidate` (complete, with vectors and fixtures, ready to implement) and 13 are `provisional` (complete; expected to change as implementations gain experience): project, bundle, dataset, digitization, view, snapshot, draft-ids, exercise, submission, grade, checklist, log-entry and checkpoint ([spec/00 §0.4](../spec/00-introduction.md#04-status)).
The repository holds 24 chapters, 42 JSON Schemas, 25 vector files, five valid fixture packages, one of them also zipped, and 31 invalid ones, each naming the rule it breaks, and a reference checker, `paperspec check`. The repository holds 24 chapters, 43 JSON Schemas, 26 vector files, five valid fixture packages, one of them also zipped, and 31 invalid ones, each naming the rule it breaks, and a reference checker, `paperspec check`.
Licenses: prose CC BY 4.0; schemas, SQL, the JSON-LD context, registries, vectors and fixtures CC0 1.0; the code in `src/` Apache-2.0 ([README.md](../README.md#licenses)). Licenses: prose CC BY 4.0; schemas, SQL, the JSON-LD context, registries, vectors and fixtures CC0 1.0; the code in `src/` Apache-2.0 ([README.md](../README.md#licenses)).
*No adoption claim.* *No adoption claim.*
+8 -3
View File
@@ -212,7 +212,9 @@ Every fix is a correction: an operation with its evidence, its author and a reas
``` ```
A document's history is its first reading plus its corrections, and its revision is the index of the last one. A document's history is its first reading plus its corrections, and its revision is the index of the last one.
The operations are `replace`, `insert`, `delete`, `split`, `merge`, `move`, `reclassify`, `relabel` and `set`. The operations are `replace`, `insert`, `delete`, `split`, `merge`, `move`, `reclassify`, `relabel`, `set`, `emend`, `relink` and `resolve`.
A `replace` fixes what the converter misread; an `emend` fixes a typo the authors printed, and keeps the printed text, so the sentence still agrees with the PDF and keeps its level.
A `relink` changes which references a citation names, and a `resolve` what a reference resolves to.
Evidence is a crop (an image of the page region), a witness, a source file by SHA-256, or a named person. Evidence is a crop (an image of the page region), a witness, a source file by SHA-256, or a named person.
A gate refuses any correction that would change a digit without a crop of the page as evidence, or that would let a digit change anywhere it did not declare. A gate refuses any correction that would change a digit without a crop of the page as evidence, or that would let a digit change anywhere it did not declare.
@@ -371,10 +373,13 @@ A statement true independently of the paper is a claim, which is checked and lev
A statement about reading the paper belongs in a layer, where it is attributed and signed and not checked. A statement about reading the paper belongs in a layer, where it is attributed and signed and not checked.
Claims are not defined in this repository. Claims are not defined in this repository.
A comment, caveat or question also says what it is about with a `category` from a fixed list: a general `comment`, `context`, a `critique`, a `question`, a `correction` of an error in the paper, `feedback` for the authors, or a `resource`.
Model-written text is always a `generated` annotation, never source, and a model's annotation stays `proposed` until a person confirms it. Model-written text is always a `generated` annotation, never source, and a model's annotation stays `proposed` until a person confirms it.
Whether a generic Web Annotation client displays an `AnchorSelector` has not been tested; the fallback exists so that it can still use the quote. Whether a generic Web Annotation client displays an `AnchorSelector` has not been tested; the fallback exists so that it can still use the quote.
A `trace` annotation follows a citation to the passage it rests on: it targets the citing sentence and its body names the reference, the cited paper and the passage in it.
Whether a trace still leads there is computed from both papers rather than stored: `current`, `changed`, `stale`, `unlinked` or `misresolved`.
Layers are `candidate`. Layers are `candidate`.
Pinned by the layer records in `fixtures/records/layer/`. Pinned by the layer records in `fixtures/records/layer/` and `fixtures/records/traces/`, and by [vectors/traces.jsonl](../vectors/traces.jsonl).
See [chapter 18](../spec/18-layers.md). See [chapter 18](../spec/18-layers.md).
## Exercises ## Exercises
@@ -431,7 +436,7 @@ hale2026harmonic-damb/
provenance.json tools, versions and where each stage ran provenance.json tools, versions and where each stage ran
assets/ images, by SHA-256 assets/ images, by SHA-256
datasets/ datasets reported from the document datasets/ datasets reported from the document
derived/ MathML and other renderings, rebuildable derived/ MathML, math trees and other renderings, rebuildable
``` ```
Only `MANIFEST.json`, `document.json`, `nodes.jsonl`, `witnesses.json` and `provenance.json` are required, and an optional file with no records is left out; the example package omits `suspects.jsonl`. Only `MANIFEST.json`, `document.json`, `nodes.jsonl`, `witnesses.json` and `provenance.json` are required, and an optional file with no records is left out; the example package omits `suspects.jsonl`.
+36 -4
View File
@@ -193,12 +193,12 @@ for (row,) in rows:
('a4jrz2t', 'F0') ('a4jrz2t', 'F0')
('xjns57z', 'F0') ('xjns57z', 'F0')
('hca6dc5',) ('hca6dc5',)
('ana', 'targeted:lode', 3) ('ana', 'targeted:paperclaim', 3)
('ana', 'targeted:lode', 23) ('ana', 'targeted:paperclaim', 23)
('ana', 'section:p36k8t6', 2) ('ana', 'section:p36k8t6', 2)
('cara', 'page:2', 3) ('cara', 'page:2', 3)
('ana', 'targeted:captions', 3) ('ana', 'targeted:captions', 3)
('ben', 'qa:y2zw8ctg5s8dp', 10) ('ben', 'qa:fhhvg9qrzqp0n', 10)
('ben', 'qa:gx2s84z9jf9xv', 3) ('ben', 'qa:gx2s84z9jf9xv', 3)
Bond parameters Bond parameters
CT–CT | 310.0 | 1.526 | 305.2 | 1.5260 CT–CT | 310.0 | 1.526 | 305.2 | 1.5260
@@ -210,7 +210,39 @@ The first query reads the level the converter recorded, not the final one.
A receipt is a signed record that a reviewer checked certain nodes against the page. A receipt is a signed record that a reviewer checked certain nodes against the page.
Receipts by `ana` raise `ec5jc93` and `a4jrz2t` to F3; `xjns57z` stays at F0 because the only receipt that covered it, by `cara`, was revoked. Receipts by `ana` raise `ec5jc93` and `a4jrz2t` to F3; `xjns57z` stays at F0 because the only receipt that covered it, by `cara`, was revoked.
To compute the final level, check each receipt's signature, revocations and spot-checks, as [chapter 8](../spec/08-fidelity.md#82-levels) describes. To compute the final level, check each receipt's signature, revocations and spot-checks, as [chapter 8](../spec/08-fidelity.md#82-levels) describes.
The `scope` column of the third query shows the value `targeted:lode`, which is data in the fixture, copied here exactly as the query prints it. The `scope` column of the third query shows the value `targeted:paperclaim`, which is data in the fixture, copied here exactly as the query prints it.
## Follow a traced citation
This shows how a citation leads to the passage it rests on, and how to tell that it still does.
A trace is an annotation from the sentence that cites a paper to a passage of that paper, with the reference it follows ([chapter 18](../spec/18-layers.md#185-traced-citations)).
The draft in the fixtures cites the main example once, and its layer of traces holds three: a model's, a person's, and a candidate a person rejected.
The Python package `paperspec.traces` judges each against the current state of both papers:
```python
import json
from paperspec import package, traces
draft = package.read_state("fixtures/packages/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3")
paper = package.read_state("fixtures/packages/hale2026harmonic-damb")
same_as = json.load(open("fixtures/packages/hale2026harmonic-damb/document.json"))["work"]["same_as"]
annotations = [json.loads(line) for line in open("fixtures/records/traces/annotations.jsonl", encoding="utf-8")]
for a in annotations:
if a["body"]["kind"] == "trace":
r = traces.resolve(a, draft, paper, same_as)
print(a["status"], r["result"], r["open"], traces.disputed(a["id"], annotations))
```
```text
confirmed current smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb#mhp0at8@ee42c4[48:60] True
rejected current smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb#kea5026@b836d5[81:105] False
confirmed current smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb#hj4s7pb@6c6fba False
```
Each line gives the trace's status, its outcome, the current address of the passage it leads to, and whether a reply disputes it.
The first trace is disputed by a reply that says the table is the better passage, which is where the third trace leads.
The outcomes here are all `current`; [vectors/traces.jsonl](../vectors/traces.jsonl) corrects the draft or the paper and shows the others: `changed` when the passage was reworded but is still found, `stale` when it is gone, `unlinked` when the sentence no longer cites the reference, and `misresolved` when the reference now resolves to another paper.
Resolving a trace also lists the citations inside the passage, so a chain of "as previously reported" is followed one trace at a time.
## Test your implementation against a vector ## Test your implementation against a vector
+1 -1
View File
@@ -107,7 +107,7 @@ A `candidate` format is complete, with vectors and fixtures, and ready to implem
A `provisional` one is complete and expected to change as implementations gain experience. A `provisional` one is complete and expected to change as implementations gain experience.
The provisional formats are dataset, digitization, view, project, bundle, snapshot, draft-ids, exercise, submission, grade, checklist, log-entry and checkpoint. The provisional formats are dataset, digitization, view, project, bundle, snapshot, draft-ids, exercise, submission, grade, checklist, log-entry and checkpoint.
The repository holds a reference checker (`paperspec check`), 25 vector files, five valid packages, one of them also as a zip, and 31 deliberately broken packages ([spec/00 §0.4](../spec/00-introduction.md#04-status), [spec/22](../spec/22-conformance.md)). The repository holds a reference checker (`paperspec check`), 26 vector files, five valid packages, one of them also as a zip, and 31 deliberately broken packages ([spec/00 §0.4](../spec/00-introduction.md#04-status), [spec/22](../spec/22-conformance.md)).
## What does it not do? ## What does it not do?
+17
View File
@@ -62,6 +62,10 @@ Drift
: The amount that has changed below a container since an anchor on it was made, counted from the corrections: the share of the container's leaves touched by later corrections. : The amount that has changed below a container since an anchor on it was made, counted from the corrections: the share of the container's leaves touched by later corrections.
It is reported as `none`, `low` or `high`, with a default threshold of a quarter. ([6.6](../spec/06-anchors.md#66-drift)) It is reported as `none`, `low` or `high`, with a default threshold of a quarter. ([6.6](../spec/06-anchors.md#66-drift))
Emend
: A correction of the authors' own typo, spelling, grammar, punctuation or wording, where the reading matches the page and the page is wrong; a `replace` fixes a misreading instead.
The emended run keeps the text as printed, so the leaf as printed, which is what witnesses are compared with, stays what it was, and so do its match hash and its level. ([11.6](../spec/11-corrections.md#116-emendations), [3.6](../spec/03-nodes.md#36-the-plain-projection))
Exercise Exercise
: An annotation whose body holds a prompt, an answer key and a grading rule. : An annotation whose body holds a prompt, an answer key and a grading rule.
The key is anchors, a verdict, a chain, a value or planted errors, by exercise kind. ([19.1](../spec/19-exercises.md#191-exercises)) The key is anchors, a verdict, a chain, a value or planted errors, by exercise kind. ([19.1](../spec/19-exercises.md#191-exercises))
@@ -96,6 +100,11 @@ Match hash
Two readings agree only when their match hashes are equal and their complex-notation keys are equal. Two readings agree only when their match hashes are equal and their complex-notation keys are equal.
A complex-notation key is `notation:source` for a piece of math too complex for the formats to normalize, with the source's whitespace removed ([5.3](../spec/05-hashes.md#53-the-strict-projection)). ([5.1](../spec/05-hashes.md#51-the-five-values), [5.3](../spec/05-hashes.md#53-the-strict-projection)) A complex-notation key is `notation:source` for a piece of math too complex for the formats to normalize, with the source's whitespace removed ([5.3](../spec/05-hashes.md#53-the-strict-projection)). ([5.1](../spec/05-hashes.md#51-the-five-values), [5.3](../spec/05-hashes.md#53-the-strict-projection))
Math form
: A standard spelling of formulas, so that one formula is written alike in every paper and claim.
`scienting-math/1` is canonical TeX, with a tree read from it and a key for each symbol; papermath implements it.
An equation or math run in the form says so with `form`, which enters no hash, and its tree lives in `derived/math.jsonl`. ([3.7](../spec/03-nodes.md#37-math-forms), [9.4](../spec/09-figures-tables-equations.md#94-the-math-form))
ML-DSA-65 ML-DSA-65
: Outside term. : Outside term.
The lattice-based signature scheme of FIPS 204, believed to resist quantum computers. The lattice-based signature scheme of FIPS 204, believed to resist quantum computers.
@@ -168,6 +177,10 @@ Strict projection
Suspect Suspect
: A doubtful reading raised for a person or a review session to answer. ([5.7](../spec/05-hashes.md#57-suspects)) : A doubtful reading raised for a person or a review session to answer. ([5.7](../spec/05-hashes.md#57-suspects))
Symbol key
: The name of a symbol in a formula, its canonical TeX with `\mathrm` spelled `\text`: `K_{r}` for `K_r`.
A paper's symbols and a paperclaim claim's have one key, so a `symbol` annotation names its symbol by it. ([9.4](../spec/09-figures-tables-equations.md#94-the-math-form), [18.4](../spec/18-layers.md#184-bodies))
Targeted F3 Targeted F3
: Proofreading the nodes a team's claims, quotations and datasets rest on, rather than every node. : Proofreading the nodes a team's claims, quotations and datasets rest on, rather than every node.
The target set also includes the leaves of every anchored container, every equation and, under the project's digit rule (`all`, `anchored-sections` or `none`), sentences and cells with a digit in a text or math run (an inline stretch of plain text, or of TeX or Typst math, within the node; [3.5](../spec/03-nodes.md#35-inline-runs)). ([8.10](../spec/08-fidelity.md#810-targeted-f3)) The target set also includes the leaves of every anchored container, every equation and, under the project's digit rule (`all`, `anchored-sections` or `none`), sentences and cells with a digit in a text or math run (an inline stretch of plain text, or of TeX or Typst math, within the node; [3.5](../spec/03-nodes.md#35-inline-runs)). ([8.10](../spec/08-fidelity.md#810-targeted-f3))
@@ -181,6 +194,10 @@ Text policy
Tile Tile
: One file of a transparency log served statically: 256 hashes of one level of the tree, or 256 entries, so a client fetches only the subtrees it needs. ([23.4](../spec/23-log.md#234-serving-a-log)) : One file of a transparency log served statically: 256 hashes of one level of the tree, or 256 entries, so a client fetches only the subtrees it needs. ([23.4](../spec/23-log.md#234-serving-a-log))
Trace
: An annotation that follows one citation of a sentence to the passage of the cited paper it rests on, naming the reference it follows and, when a tool found the passage, the tool, its run, score and rank.
Whether it still leads there is computed from both papers as current, changed, stale, unlinked or misresolved, and it is disputed while a reply assesses it. ([18.5](../spec/18-layers.md#185-traced-citations))
Verdict Verdict
: A judgment of whether a cited passage supports a citing sentence: supports, partly, does not, or cannot tell. ([19.2](../spec/19-exercises.md#192-verdicts)) : A judgment of whether a cited passage supports a citing sentence: supports, partly, does not, or cannot tell. ([19.2](../spec/19-exercises.md#192-verdicts))
+2 -2
View File
@@ -52,11 +52,11 @@ It appears inside hashed data and test vectors, and it is separate from the repo
| Folder | Holds | | Folder | Holds |
| --- | --- | | --- | --- |
| [spec/](../spec/README.md) | The specification, in 24 chapters (00 to 23). Normative. | | [spec/](../spec/README.md) | The specification, in 24 chapters (00 to 23). Normative. |
| [schemas/](../schemas/README.md) | 42 JSON (plain-text data format) Schemas for the files and records. | | [schemas/](../schemas/README.md) | 43 JSON (plain-text data format) Schemas for the files and records. |
| [registry/](../registry/README.md) | The list of formats, the rule IDs a checker reports, download-stamp rules, and default rights requirements. | | [registry/](../registry/README.md) | The list of formats, the rule IDs a checker reports, download-stamp rules, and default rights requirements. |
| [tools/](../tools/README.md) | How to run the reference commands: `paperspec check` checks everything, `paperspec build` rebuilds the fixtures and vectors, and `paperspec load` loads packages into SQLite. | | [tools/](../tools/README.md) | How to run the reference commands: `paperspec check` checks everything, `paperspec build` rebuilds the fixtures and vectors, and `paperspec load` loads packages into SQLite. |
| [src/paperspec/](../src/paperspec/) | The oracle, a compact implementation of every rule, which the other repositories of the project install as the Python package `paperspec`. | | [src/paperspec/](../src/paperspec/) | The oracle, a compact implementation of every rule, which the other repositories of the project install as the Python package `paperspec`. |
| [vectors/](../vectors/README.md) | 25 files of test vectors: inputs and the exact outputs every implementation must compute. | | [vectors/](../vectors/README.md) | 26 files of test vectors: inputs and the exact outputs every implementation must compute. |
| [fixtures/](../fixtures/README.md) | Five valid example packages, one of them also as a zip, 31 deliberately broken ones that each break one named rule, example records, and the test keys that signed them. All text is synthetic. | | [fixtures/](../fixtures/README.md) | Five valid example packages, one of them also as a zip, 31 deliberately broken ones that each break one named rule, example records, and the test keys that signed them. All text is synthetic. |
| [sql/](../sql/README.md) | Tables for SQLite, Dolt and PostgreSQL, and a SQLite bundle with full-text search. | | [sql/](../sql/README.md) | Tables for SQLite, Dolt and PostgreSQL, and a SQLite bundle with full-text search. |
| [context/](../context/README.md) | The JSON-LD context that makes annotation layers W3C Web Annotations. | | [context/](../context/README.md) | The JSON-LD context that makes annotation layers W3C Web Annotations. |
+4 -4
View File
@@ -143,11 +143,11 @@ It lifts a node to F3, the top fidelity level (F0 is one reading; F1, every doub
One signature covers a Merkle tree, a hash over everything reviewed in a sitting, built as in RFC 6962 (a Request for Comments standard; replaced by [RFC 9162](https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc9162), which defines the same tree). One signature covers a Merkle tree, a hash over everything reviewed in a sitting, built as in RFC 6962 (a Request for Comments standard; replaced by [RFC 9162](https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc9162), which defines the same tree).
The receipts are in [`receipts.jsonl`](../fixtures/packages/hale2026harmonic-damb/receipts.jsonl), and the keys that signed them in [`roster.json`](../fixtures/packages/hale2026harmonic-damb/roster.json). The receipts are in [`receipts.jsonl`](../fixtures/packages/hale2026harmonic-damb/receipts.jsonl), and the keys that signed them in [`roster.json`](../fixtures/packages/hale2026harmonic-damb/roster.json).
- **Before the corrections**, `ana` had signed receipt `npc15pn6675z5` for three cells at revision 0. - **Before the corrections**, `ana` had signed receipt `vskq18t5sxydz` for three cells at revision 0.
Two of them never changed, so the receipt still counts for them. Two of them never changed, so the receipt still counts for them.
For the corrected cell it no longer counts, because the cell's hash moved on. For the corrected cell it no longer counts, because the cell's hash moved on.
- After the corrections, `ana` signs `y2zw8ctg5s8dp` at F3 for 23 nodes: the cells of Table 1's three data rows (15), its four column headers, the equation, and three sentences (`ec5jc93`, `hca6dc5` and `rr20tev`, the one holding the equation). - After the corrections, `ana` signs `fhhvg9qrzqp0n` at F3 for 23 nodes: the cells of Table 1's three data rows (15), its four column headers, the equation, and three sentences (`ec5jc93`, `hca6dc5` and `rr20tev`, the one holding the equation).
`ben` spot-checks it with receipt `mg18668nzxvap`. `ben` spot-checks it with receipt `ksx5sc327xp97`.
His signature, made with his separate spot-check key `ben-spot`, picks 10 nodes nobody could have chosen, and he finds no errors. His signature, made with his separate spot-check key `ben-spot`, picks 10 nodes nobody could have chosen, and he finds no errors.
- `ana` signs `mvjmb94nz7rdh` for two sentences of section 1, including the new `a4jrz2t`. - `ana` signs `mvjmb94nz7rdh` for two sentences of section 1, including the new `a4jrz2t`.
- `cara` signs `q465jpwz8afhe` for three sentences on page 2, then revokes it herself (`pcbhtpwvysgq6`) because she had compared them with the crops of another paper. - `cara` signs `q465jpwz8afhe` for three sentences on page 2, then revokes it herself (`pcbhtpwvysgq6`) because she had compared them with the crops of another paper.
@@ -155,7 +155,7 @@ His signature, made with his separate spot-check key `ben-spot`, picks 10 nodes
- `ana` signs `gx2s84z9jf9xv` for the figure's three caption sentences. `ben`'s spot-check `yt70fcc3qm0xb` finds a missing period in `caehhp6`, which suspends the receipt until she reviews the sitting again and signs a new one. - `ana` signs `gx2s84z9jf9xv` for the figure's three caption sentences. `ben`'s spot-check `yt70fcc3qm0xb` finds a missing period in `caehhp6`, which suspends the receipt until she reviews the sitting again and signs a new one.
The document's report, in [`document.json`](../fixtures/packages/hale2026harmonic-damb/document.json), counts the result over 45 leaves: 27 at F3, 13 at F2, 4 at F1 and 1 at F0. The document's report, in [`document.json`](../fixtures/packages/hale2026harmonic-damb/document.json), counts the result over 45 leaves: 27 at F3, 13 at F2, 4 at F1 and 1 at F0.
The 27 are the 23 nodes of `y2zw8ctg5s8dp`, the 2 of `mvjmb94nz7rdh`, and 2 of the 3 caption sentences. The 27 are the 23 nodes of `fhhvg9qrzqp0n`, the 2 of `mvjmb94nz7rdh`, and 2 of the 3 caption sentences.
Those two still count because Ben's spot-check is itself a valid receipt, and he compared them with the page and found them right. Those two still count because Ben's spot-check is itself a valid receipt, and he compared them with the page and found them right.
The third, `caehhp6`, stays at F2: a spot-check never raises a node it found in error ([spec/08 §8.2](../spec/08-fidelity.md#82-levels)). The third, `caehhp6`, stays at F2: a spot-check never raises a node it found in error ([spec/08 §8.2](../spec/08-fidelity.md#82-levels)).
+3 -2
View File
@@ -25,7 +25,7 @@ A conforming reader accepts each one and recomputes every hash it contains.
| Package | What it is for | | Package | What it is for |
| --- | --- | | --- | --- |
| `packages/hale2026harmonic/` | The main example, followed step by step in [the walkthrough](../docs/walkthrough.md): a chemistry paper that was read once with mistakes and then fixed by twelve corrections. It has a table with two levels of column headers and grouped rows, an equation inside a sentence, a footnote, a figure with text inside its panels and a real image, references, legacy aliases, boxes on fingerprinted pages, receipts in every state (counting, partly invalidated, spot-checked, revoked and suspended), the roster of public keys that checks their signatures, a dataset taken from the table, and derived MathML. | | `packages/hale2026harmonic/` | The main example, followed step by step in [the walkthrough](../docs/walkthrough.md): a chemistry paper that was read once with mistakes and then fixed by twelve corrections. It has a table with two levels of column headers and grouped rows, an equation inside a sentence, a footnote, a figure with text inside its panels and a real image, references, legacy aliases, boxes on fingerprinted pages, receipts in every state (counting, partly invalidated, spot-checked, revoked and suspended), the roster of public keys that checks their signatures, a dataset taken from the table, derived MathML, and the derived reading of three formulas in the math form `scienting-math/1`, one of which the form's tree cannot read ([spec/09 section 9.4](../spec/09-figures-tables-equations.md#94-the-math-form)). |
| `packages/hale2026harmonic.checks-only/` | The same document prepared for sharing within the team: text withheld, every hash an HMAC (a hash computed under a secret key) under the team key. The team key is derived from the team secret in `keys/` ([spec/05](../spec/05-hashes.md), [spec/12 section 12.5](../spec/12-package.md#125-text-policies)). It shows how a team can share its checks on a paywalled paper without sharing the paper. | | `packages/hale2026harmonic.checks-only/` | The same document prepared for sharing within the team: text withheld, every hash an HMAC (a hash computed under a secret key) under the team key. The team key is derived from the team secret in `keys/` ([spec/05](../spec/05-hashes.md), [spec/12 section 12.5](../spec/12-package.md#125-text-policies)). It shows how a team can share its checks on a paywalled paper without sharing the paper. |
| `packages/okafor2025open/` | An open-access paper established from a JATS file (an XML format for journal articles) and a PDF that agree, so every leaf is at fidelity F2, corroborated by an independent witness. | | `packages/okafor2025open/` | An open-access paper established from a JATS file (an XML format for journal articles) and a PDF that agree, so every leaf is at fidelity F2, corroborated by an independent witness. |
| `packages/smithlab2027charges/` | A short draft written in Typst (a typesetting language). One of its sentences holds a cross-reference whose target is the address `hale2026harmonic#a4jrz2t`, a sentence of the main example. | | `packages/smithlab2027charges/` | A short draft written in Typst (a typesetting language). One of its sentences holds a cross-reference whose target is the address `hale2026harmonic#a4jrz2t`, a sentence of the main example. |
@@ -47,7 +47,8 @@ Each record is a single file, or a folder where a format needs several files.
| `backend-docling.json`, `backend-examplevendor.json` | The code and weight licenses of a conversion tool and the conditions attached to them. | | `backend-docling.json`, `backend-examplevendor.json` | The code and weight licenses of a conversion tool and the conditions attached to them. |
| `profile-acme.json`, `profile-smithlab.json` | What those conditions ask about a team: its purpose, its funding and whom it competes with. | | `profile-acme.json`, `profile-smithlab.json` | What those conditions ask about a team: its purpose, its funding and whom it competes with. |
| `roster.json` | The keys that may sign, the role of each key's holder in the team, and what each key may sign. Ana is the owner, so she may revoke anyone's receipt. | | `roster.json` | The keys that may sign, the role of each key's holder in the team, and what each key may sign. Ana is the owner, so she may revoke anyone's receipt. |
| `layer/` | A layer of annotations on the main example (`layer.json`, `annotations.jsonl`) and the receipt that confirms them (`receipt.json`). | | `layer/` | A layer of annotations on the main example (`layer.json`, `annotations.jsonl`) and the receipt that confirms them (`receipt.json`). Its claim link and its symbol name the claim `amber/k-bond` of paperclaim's example store as paperclaim references it, `claim:272XTX7C`, pinned at `claim:272XTX7C@02f47b`; the symbol names `K_r` by its key, `K_{r}`. |
| `traces/` | A layer of traced citations on the Typst draft, which cites the main example (`layer.json`, `annotations.jsonl`, `receipt.json`): a trace a model proposed from the draft's citation of "a two-step fit" to the abstract of the main example and a person confirmed, with its receipt; a second candidate, the introduction's sentence, that a person rejected; a person's trace of the same sentence to Table 1; and a person's reply that disputes the first ([spec/18 §18.5](../spec/18-layers.md#185-traced-citations)). `vectors/traces.jsonl` resolves them after corrections. |
| `submissions/`, `grades/` | A student's answers to exercises in the layer, and the grader's result for each. | | `submissions/`, `grades/` | A student's answers to exercises in the layer, and the grader's result for each. |
| `suspect.json` | A doubtful reading raised for review: the converter's reading of an exponent in the main example, before the first correction answered it. | | `suspect.json` | A doubtful reading raised for review: the converter's reading of an exponent in the main example, before the first correction answered it. |
| `qa-report.json` | Reviewer error bounds for a delivery that covers two of the main example's receipts, signed by the team's owner key. | | `qa-report.json` | Reviewer error bounds for a delivery that covers two of the main example's receipts, signed by the team's owner key. |
@@ -1 +1 @@
{"doc":"scienting-doc/1","files":[{"path":"assets/586f92512b294a1c325bfc16207771fb9acc7bb67bb206f25a429a055134056f.png","present":false,"sha256":"586f92512b294a1c325bfc16207771fb9acc7bb67bb206f25a429a055134056f","size":18213},{"path":"assets/a18e1eb7f434c85ee180399dc55d2ee78c5ceb915c4a004c5dd0e490399d4c75.png","sha256":"a18e1eb7f434c85ee180399dc55d2ee78c5ceb915c4a004c5dd0e490399d4c75","size":73},{"path":"corrections.jsonl","sha256":"026b493baaecba29c15a834e29933b840f306956d377fe85f350372313cab18f","size":8310},{"path":"datasets/ds-hale-bond-params/anchors.jsonl","sha256":"cfacea27f25c0ca912b82882c1f9221b693ae6bcf91c888628b780243ba7e625","size":6046},{"path":"datasets/ds-hale-bond-params/data.csv","sha256":"dbde72e4526e469e1535b87272eb50683160b2fe7c40b7f064e6592341f754a8","size":206},{"path":"datasets/ds-hale-bond-params/datapackage.json","sha256":"d8bbf8bd7c1b0207ada817d10580e835bda3a8691ad3e14fc1910519f4341974","size":574},{"path":"derived/mathml.jsonl","sha256":"47981f878391f3c733072081a0f6d1ad59ba8fa37507c8a4d774feb780c7df6c","size":348},{"path":"document.json","sha256":"f9d3fd85dec8b32378be5b045d0734ec05f3745ec88737bd0554749290e2fbbd","size":1088},{"path":"ids.jsonl","sha256":"d19c4716a605352d4cd84f81381d99a5e2db6b59c88e926611dd13a5a16e4155","size":852},{"path":"locations.jsonl","sha256":"37a3f73ff3dc81082e98b4a02afff535fbdf0f1439cf56fdb39566d28076c6e2","size":7396},{"path":"nodes.jsonl","sha256":"87eeac4b781f67872da36f44f74b859fe5a7c528e3c46276ec0b7dd4f5e2cb71","size":45649},{"path":"pages.jsonl","sha256":"948177c6b7e5e361ac1da0ecff6b52406d3513f14d58cd27cd84f17e6f1c054e","size":438},{"path":"provenance.json","sha256":"4bc7649bf6d3113f6c72b4016713654f57c8f03069632eabd1e6025c05cb9dac","size":226},{"path":"receipts.jsonl","sha256":"da6a4d9cf8af852dff7a175585867d6f2a224c664bd2935f4d47733cb76d1f5d","size":13150},{"path":"references.jsonl","sha256":"25c7a54848e0c3167475236846b85bcea1a35698f6ae5b24a31b6a3690078697","size":567},{"path":"roster.json","sha256":"3c71b0c007924cbacd3b4af02485214ab904db8ff8fca133ab32e67c5c76d481","size":6941},{"path":"witnesses.json","sha256":"99ae654df4fb461a424bb51edd476a89041182c7df9c98653a81b78031f92ada","size":1006}],"format":"scienting-package/1","key":"hale2026harmonic-damb"} {"doc":"scienting-doc/1","files":[{"path":"assets/586f92512b294a1c325bfc16207771fb9acc7bb67bb206f25a429a055134056f.png","present":false,"sha256":"586f92512b294a1c325bfc16207771fb9acc7bb67bb206f25a429a055134056f","size":18213},{"path":"assets/a18e1eb7f434c85ee180399dc55d2ee78c5ceb915c4a004c5dd0e490399d4c75.png","sha256":"a18e1eb7f434c85ee180399dc55d2ee78c5ceb915c4a004c5dd0e490399d4c75","size":73},{"path":"corrections.jsonl","sha256":"026b493baaecba29c15a834e29933b840f306956d377fe85f350372313cab18f","size":8310},{"path":"datasets/ds-hale-bond-params/anchors.jsonl","sha256":"cfacea27f25c0ca912b82882c1f9221b693ae6bcf91c888628b780243ba7e625","size":6046},{"path":"datasets/ds-hale-bond-params/data.csv","sha256":"dbde72e4526e469e1535b87272eb50683160b2fe7c40b7f064e6592341f754a8","size":206},{"path":"datasets/ds-hale-bond-params/datapackage.json","sha256":"d8bbf8bd7c1b0207ada817d10580e835bda3a8691ad3e14fc1910519f4341974","size":574},{"path":"derived/math.jsonl","sha256":"7c2e892825f2eb503187d6ac683d4a5f50b99e1d186ddd9ce64597eb0ba3493c","size":774},{"path":"derived/mathml.jsonl","sha256":"47981f878391f3c733072081a0f6d1ad59ba8fa37507c8a4d774feb780c7df6c","size":348},{"path":"document.json","sha256":"f9d3fd85dec8b32378be5b045d0734ec05f3745ec88737bd0554749290e2fbbd","size":1088},{"path":"ids.jsonl","sha256":"d19c4716a605352d4cd84f81381d99a5e2db6b59c88e926611dd13a5a16e4155","size":852},{"path":"locations.jsonl","sha256":"37a3f73ff3dc81082e98b4a02afff535fbdf0f1439cf56fdb39566d28076c6e2","size":7396},{"path":"nodes.jsonl","sha256":"87eeac4b781f67872da36f44f74b859fe5a7c528e3c46276ec0b7dd4f5e2cb71","size":45649},{"path":"pages.jsonl","sha256":"948177c6b7e5e361ac1da0ecff6b52406d3513f14d58cd27cd84f17e6f1c054e","size":438},{"path":"provenance.json","sha256":"4bc7649bf6d3113f6c72b4016713654f57c8f03069632eabd1e6025c05cb9dac","size":226},{"path":"receipts.jsonl","sha256":"ece8011e110d663b91a86b828d9c66b2396b3e03a5fd10554a1bfd3f4b53de20","size":13162},{"path":"references.jsonl","sha256":"25c7a54848e0c3167475236846b85bcea1a35698f6ae5b24a31b6a3690078697","size":567},{"path":"roster.json","sha256":"3c71b0c007924cbacd3b4af02485214ab904db8ff8fca133ab32e67c5c76d481","size":6941},{"path":"witnesses.json","sha256":"99ae654df4fb461a424bb51edd476a89041182c7df9c98653a81b78031f92ada","size":1006}],"format":"scienting-package/1","key":"hale2026harmonic-damb"}
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
{"complete":true,"form":"scienting-math/1","issues":[],"node":"tkxsmts","run":null,"symbols":["E_{\\text{bond}}","K_{r}","r","r_{\\text{eq}}"],"tool":{"name":"papermath","version":"0.1.0"},"tree":["rel",["sym","E_{\\text{bond}}"],"=",["mul",["frac",["num","1"],["num","2"]],["sym","K_{r}"],["pow",["add",["sym","r"],["neg",["sym","r_{\\text{eq}}"]]],["num","2"]]]]}
{"complete":true,"form":"scienting-math/1","issues":[],"node":"rr20tev","run":3,"symbols":["K_{r}"],"tool":{"name":"papermath","version":"0.1.0"},"tree":["sym","K_{r}"]}
{"complete":false,"form":"scienting-math/1","issues":[{"at":"_{2}","code":"opaque","message":"a part after the formula's end"}],"node":"hca6dc5","run":1,"symbols":[],"tool":{"name":"papermath","version":"0.1.0"},"tree":["opaque","_{2}"]}
@@ -1,8 +1,8 @@
{"at":"2026-10-01T16:00:00Z","by":"ana","doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","evidence":[{"kind":"crop","node":"bnyvykm","sha256":"2c560caeaf914f3521fd0e3fca433922fcb9408c184c9b72bcfa869adf5ed409"},{"kind":"crop","node":"c20cna6","sha256":"bdbf7a4d9e86609675e3fc124c21ce808053a52d6bc0f35b15e1ba39027f13af"},{"kind":"crop","node":"ztww0g8","sha256":"902e8ca35e1a313a81130c4c100aeb2233fd53854677b3a992fb16f744fe3151"},{"kind":"witness","sha256":"23b6b2aaece9cb0a828a2f0265539500fcf34d5195bf720b934b8bfdeccb9834"}],"format":"scienting-receipt/1","id":"npc15pn6675z5","level":"F3","nodes":[["bnyvykm","13b0c5e01b52e467de5975acc898c2387fcc015d222517a865810a330a336c94"],["c20cna6","7252bb19f33a3be672d74a8aa8323750311b5c7d2b8f6cf21e07f17f2b27f3a1"],["ztww0g8","bda85639faacb77e504c891c035012602836171c009ecfd21584de4d6461ba93"]],"rev":0,"root":"5aeacf3cbd00a10320411c374b3b503583d1786f10c31fa04cc55117eba266ea","scope":"targeted:lode","signature":{"key":"ana","scheme":"ed25519","value":"IVRJwo1fygoctDfalPkrwvd5G5JARIqlV2FqzdPmL/BMvdVSKU9sRFJeLKHR+lXDVy3DY7GJgrjPh6VDdJAkCg=="}} {"at":"2026-10-01T16:00:00Z","by":"ana","doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","evidence":[{"kind":"crop","node":"bnyvykm","sha256":"2c560caeaf914f3521fd0e3fca433922fcb9408c184c9b72bcfa869adf5ed409"},{"kind":"crop","node":"c20cna6","sha256":"bdbf7a4d9e86609675e3fc124c21ce808053a52d6bc0f35b15e1ba39027f13af"},{"kind":"crop","node":"ztww0g8","sha256":"902e8ca35e1a313a81130c4c100aeb2233fd53854677b3a992fb16f744fe3151"},{"kind":"witness","sha256":"23b6b2aaece9cb0a828a2f0265539500fcf34d5195bf720b934b8bfdeccb9834"}],"format":"scienting-receipt/1","id":"vskq18t5sxydz","level":"F3","nodes":[["bnyvykm","13b0c5e01b52e467de5975acc898c2387fcc015d222517a865810a330a336c94"],["c20cna6","7252bb19f33a3be672d74a8aa8323750311b5c7d2b8f6cf21e07f17f2b27f3a1"],["ztww0g8","bda85639faacb77e504c891c035012602836171c009ecfd21584de4d6461ba93"]],"rev":0,"root":"5aeacf3cbd00a10320411c374b3b503583d1786f10c31fa04cc55117eba266ea","scope":"targeted:paperclaim","signature":{"key":"ana","scheme":"ed25519","value":"OQmqG6r3mrl7bYq1pIUX+zoF8MprYLEmVu3rPoe632s7NZgH/Go2tIW+TGHcg+BuBStaBJCW/L47/5Z6OyayCQ=="}}
{"at":"2026-10-11T15:02:11Z","by":"ana","doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","evidence":[{"kind":"crop","node":"avbhhey","sha256":"942c23ea73a297e69c2ae8a82abe88d688de2532cb3f6d3543d1107c54f65b2e"},{"kind":"crop","node":"b5gd0h1","sha256":"a0b6f761fe95f8f29ef6dc37901fa85c7a62857b50b0163ca67b0aab048e4d17"},{"kind":"crop","node":"bnyvykm","sha256":"2c560caeaf914f3521fd0e3fca433922fcb9408c184c9b72bcfa869adf5ed409"},{"kind":"crop","node":"c20cna6","sha256":"bdbf7a4d9e86609675e3fc124c21ce808053a52d6bc0f35b15e1ba39027f13af"},{"kind":"crop","node":"d1mhw8b","sha256":"3104c57d9f8fb38302b057ead3bc44456da94f7c17d7c5c8f6db8732d4812c31"},{"kind":"crop","node":"ec5jc93","sha256":"321a926653b9e097987d255d9286880893d71abf895d73f1649403ed9ac0877d"},{"kind":"crop","node":"exms5gc","sha256":"cfc0e42e734470df5cfb741f92080526ef796bf48bcf05847d44f7091cfaaab1"},{"kind":"crop","node":"ganq1ns","sha256":"81d88697cd002fdfd770ee11413c550e4e4ffaa464d35841648311f278fc13bc"},{"kind":"crop","node":"hca6dc5","sha256":"a26619c3a9824bc19fddcf89ee618d9a4792d69110439f121eb717b6f98e88a6"},{"kind":"crop","node":"j6y45v6","sha256":"e689deda15dde9ad24433eb946200417473d273a1bf3136df67bf572256a483f"},{"kind":"crop","node":"jv1741a","sha256":"de60579bacfab769f614fa74d26d20c7b1aa02caf60af1479dc46b98ddcbc106"},{"kind":"crop","node":"k6a6616","sha256":"37b29d7ba293b27f913868690a785591d89ba9a4f47da8adaf764a4d5ae9675b"},{"kind":"crop","node":"m1p1n2g","sha256":"369c69758d2d09cc3d42b2424723c4fbc75f9ceb6817da81ce183be7d36f045f"},{"kind":"crop","node":"rr20tev","sha256":"f57e2cfe704d52c712b01e993e492b121ffe8c4d0174b11a0b0fa21fc5b9930b"},{"kind":"crop","node":"ryhrskg","sha256":"e6f816d93cfff8418dbb771ba03a09fb89a3b2438f97fabfc4ebef7f78af0dbf"},{"kind":"crop","node":"tkxsmts","sha256":"5d8e205660c2c59dcaff119b5671ac11650974b5287d7d7b239a9118e9171a85"},{"kind":"crop","node":"vd76637","sha256":"389742a44f1291e2dc7d7a69acd09410c92ed8a305718b2ab86b0b09b23253f4"},{"kind":"crop","node":"w0gr97q","sha256":"588a38407463e5674714899e6cf359810ccfed98fefdd2c1a90e8cb2ed0a9d64"},{"kind":"crop","node":"w264b74","sha256":"0babb0cef51933b8744f5b22d075069d51e431d3bdc08cb5e35d7822097b5953"},{"kind":"crop","node":"x3ns64d","sha256":"6bd7423a5933eb89572ded1d40d2f5baf6f6fa2f3c46791de8210f201a94b9d1"},{"kind":"crop","node":"ycwgbx1","sha256":"5ee72aca6b32e45f961f9cb2ff70408e71fc9ed7fccd28e91eb86e872041fed3"},{"kind":"crop","node":"yvkd7xr","sha256":"62fd5beecb3e76f430dfd142f443158b84657196af17173a976345a0cdd74449"},{"kind":"crop","node":"ztww0g8","sha256":"902e8ca35e1a313a81130c4c100aeb2233fd53854677b3a992fb16f744fe3151"},{"kind":"witness","sha256":"23b6b2aaece9cb0a828a2f0265539500fcf34d5195bf720b934b8bfdeccb9834"}],"format":"scienting-receipt/1","id":"y2zw8ctg5s8dp","level":"F3","nodes":[["avbhhey","c51730c0b1d7e11b51b317163ae42838f1be808b3690f196923482c9021f97c0"],["b5gd0h1","9635a750ac2acf526a4db28746fd3ed84659f4e384f5a73fef85d002b4e9308b"],["bnyvykm","13b0c5e01b52e467de5975acc898c2387fcc015d222517a865810a330a336c94"],["c20cna6","c8e6a553f5ae1377776e86dde6ee7d48a923dea7de417408841ea33b81563272"],["d1mhw8b","557a47334329925d191e772172fddbc1bd1a035eb2217240c476ee6bc43c92ab"],["ec5jc93","5421e9cf0ef3a995792963d0371b79e11a8efad519b02efb5cb88311a896d0cc"],["exms5gc","b7c47f8360eb7272d2ac0943e8bf1aec9d71cb4ea4e5e1d02f8acee5b430a038"],["ganq1ns","40d46db2088057debc3b1d5b4a3c972ff3a94fc3d5463565f98876d0927f1e67"],["hca6dc5","8cfed5a34aab28517e89e8a164f0f96c14361de83ebc800439116e83ef479f34"],["j6y45v6","00c4b92e220303ebc2bfb36aa557ac80ae4dba1675e9ed47adb82f6aeff10634"],["jv1741a","f644190803b5ea36aa24738e7f168a7fdf0d05cb5123c14a814b7628dab71f1e"],["k6a6616","90aa63a43587bdcee8e428c7dc7a95ac1502bdbcb9f49cae05c433db6d18348b"],["m1p1n2g","0847b5d75c2259257c3619e761c64d5571d3ca3932e96a96ee07e8ce68cc63be"],["rr20tev","76e06b4811a688357ac4b912172283463cfaf1b7a1f0795d274fc733a2309ba7"],["ryhrskg","525583990e7871a2ba55739e8206abac2df0f19d30c86ad74f6cafdd7c3cbe25"],["tkxsmts","cc0bf73dd84e298da0d36c4b363c8d2bdc9b6d5738d1923d14c4a9028dca08d6"],["vd76637","33810e4da42f8e65a224b5369c06fe8db254890294b7b6760808fe6e039da21a"],["w0gr97q","f738a008336ac59b2f1d45cda2f045dc96d34f0f1378c431ce6ff8e434feb8a7"],["w264b74","2ba9cea0f5c07ee9f7b47c5d541c85e92465709322869fb6c0d994ab61c56cad"],["x3ns64d","6bfc0a055148d877dbaf28b7f62565de7b6926137bf032c382282c39a4876797"],["ycwgbx1","167d1551ca64cad5b1143431c5af6d3fc24530887470b7fd265df88d1f54f267"],["yvkd7xr","aab8791a24bc4067c7e37fc5f0244d2128205e0a169e65c2c0fad977aabce313"],["ztww0g8","bda85639faacb77e504c891c035012602836171c009ecfd21584de4d6461ba93"]],"rev":12,"root":"373a7d860a14b58e5bfa9b9ad3bc916091bcb6db7556f0dbc9c71972a612494d","scope":"targeted:lode","signature":{"key":"ana","scheme":"ed25519","value":"2sraHCMlItocGta02EhvPlDW+F8rB1ZYMXBzA5lmNmtH0h+AlrNOPTbtykVSAWQXfKT2DXuB81/6x5jyNsIVBA=="}} {"at":"2026-10-11T15:02:11Z","by":"ana","doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","evidence":[{"kind":"crop","node":"avbhhey","sha256":"942c23ea73a297e69c2ae8a82abe88d688de2532cb3f6d3543d1107c54f65b2e"},{"kind":"crop","node":"b5gd0h1","sha256":"a0b6f761fe95f8f29ef6dc37901fa85c7a62857b50b0163ca67b0aab048e4d17"},{"kind":"crop","node":"bnyvykm","sha256":"2c560caeaf914f3521fd0e3fca433922fcb9408c184c9b72bcfa869adf5ed409"},{"kind":"crop","node":"c20cna6","sha256":"bdbf7a4d9e86609675e3fc124c21ce808053a52d6bc0f35b15e1ba39027f13af"},{"kind":"crop","node":"d1mhw8b","sha256":"3104c57d9f8fb38302b057ead3bc44456da94f7c17d7c5c8f6db8732d4812c31"},{"kind":"crop","node":"ec5jc93","sha256":"321a926653b9e097987d255d9286880893d71abf895d73f1649403ed9ac0877d"},{"kind":"crop","node":"exms5gc","sha256":"cfc0e42e734470df5cfb741f92080526ef796bf48bcf05847d44f7091cfaaab1"},{"kind":"crop","node":"ganq1ns","sha256":"81d88697cd002fdfd770ee11413c550e4e4ffaa464d35841648311f278fc13bc"},{"kind":"crop","node":"hca6dc5","sha256":"a26619c3a9824bc19fddcf89ee618d9a4792d69110439f121eb717b6f98e88a6"},{"kind":"crop","node":"j6y45v6","sha256":"e689deda15dde9ad24433eb946200417473d273a1bf3136df67bf572256a483f"},{"kind":"crop","node":"jv1741a","sha256":"de60579bacfab769f614fa74d26d20c7b1aa02caf60af1479dc46b98ddcbc106"},{"kind":"crop","node":"k6a6616","sha256":"37b29d7ba293b27f913868690a785591d89ba9a4f47da8adaf764a4d5ae9675b"},{"kind":"crop","node":"m1p1n2g","sha256":"369c69758d2d09cc3d42b2424723c4fbc75f9ceb6817da81ce183be7d36f045f"},{"kind":"crop","node":"rr20tev","sha256":"f57e2cfe704d52c712b01e993e492b121ffe8c4d0174b11a0b0fa21fc5b9930b"},{"kind":"crop","node":"ryhrskg","sha256":"e6f816d93cfff8418dbb771ba03a09fb89a3b2438f97fabfc4ebef7f78af0dbf"},{"kind":"crop","node":"tkxsmts","sha256":"5d8e205660c2c59dcaff119b5671ac11650974b5287d7d7b239a9118e9171a85"},{"kind":"crop","node":"vd76637","sha256":"389742a44f1291e2dc7d7a69acd09410c92ed8a305718b2ab86b0b09b23253f4"},{"kind":"crop","node":"w0gr97q","sha256":"588a38407463e5674714899e6cf359810ccfed98fefdd2c1a90e8cb2ed0a9d64"},{"kind":"crop","node":"w264b74","sha256":"0babb0cef51933b8744f5b22d075069d51e431d3bdc08cb5e35d7822097b5953"},{"kind":"crop","node":"x3ns64d","sha256":"6bd7423a5933eb89572ded1d40d2f5baf6f6fa2f3c46791de8210f201a94b9d1"},{"kind":"crop","node":"ycwgbx1","sha256":"5ee72aca6b32e45f961f9cb2ff70408e71fc9ed7fccd28e91eb86e872041fed3"},{"kind":"crop","node":"yvkd7xr","sha256":"62fd5beecb3e76f430dfd142f443158b84657196af17173a976345a0cdd74449"},{"kind":"crop","node":"ztww0g8","sha256":"902e8ca35e1a313a81130c4c100aeb2233fd53854677b3a992fb16f744fe3151"},{"kind":"witness","sha256":"23b6b2aaece9cb0a828a2f0265539500fcf34d5195bf720b934b8bfdeccb9834"}],"format":"scienting-receipt/1","id":"fhhvg9qrzqp0n","level":"F3","nodes":[["avbhhey","c51730c0b1d7e11b51b317163ae42838f1be808b3690f196923482c9021f97c0"],["b5gd0h1","9635a750ac2acf526a4db28746fd3ed84659f4e384f5a73fef85d002b4e9308b"],["bnyvykm","13b0c5e01b52e467de5975acc898c2387fcc015d222517a865810a330a336c94"],["c20cna6","c8e6a553f5ae1377776e86dde6ee7d48a923dea7de417408841ea33b81563272"],["d1mhw8b","557a47334329925d191e772172fddbc1bd1a035eb2217240c476ee6bc43c92ab"],["ec5jc93","5421e9cf0ef3a995792963d0371b79e11a8efad519b02efb5cb88311a896d0cc"],["exms5gc","b7c47f8360eb7272d2ac0943e8bf1aec9d71cb4ea4e5e1d02f8acee5b430a038"],["ganq1ns","40d46db2088057debc3b1d5b4a3c972ff3a94fc3d5463565f98876d0927f1e67"],["hca6dc5","8cfed5a34aab28517e89e8a164f0f96c14361de83ebc800439116e83ef479f34"],["j6y45v6","00c4b92e220303ebc2bfb36aa557ac80ae4dba1675e9ed47adb82f6aeff10634"],["jv1741a","f644190803b5ea36aa24738e7f168a7fdf0d05cb5123c14a814b7628dab71f1e"],["k6a6616","90aa63a43587bdcee8e428c7dc7a95ac1502bdbcb9f49cae05c433db6d18348b"],["m1p1n2g","0847b5d75c2259257c3619e761c64d5571d3ca3932e96a96ee07e8ce68cc63be"],["rr20tev","76e06b4811a688357ac4b912172283463cfaf1b7a1f0795d274fc733a2309ba7"],["ryhrskg","525583990e7871a2ba55739e8206abac2df0f19d30c86ad74f6cafdd7c3cbe25"],["tkxsmts","cc0bf73dd84e298da0d36c4b363c8d2bdc9b6d5738d1923d14c4a9028dca08d6"],["vd76637","33810e4da42f8e65a224b5369c06fe8db254890294b7b6760808fe6e039da21a"],["w0gr97q","f738a008336ac59b2f1d45cda2f045dc96d34f0f1378c431ce6ff8e434feb8a7"],["w264b74","2ba9cea0f5c07ee9f7b47c5d541c85e92465709322869fb6c0d994ab61c56cad"],["x3ns64d","6bfc0a055148d877dbaf28b7f62565de7b6926137bf032c382282c39a4876797"],["ycwgbx1","167d1551ca64cad5b1143431c5af6d3fc24530887470b7fd265df88d1f54f267"],["yvkd7xr","aab8791a24bc4067c7e37fc5f0244d2128205e0a169e65c2c0fad977aabce313"],["ztww0g8","bda85639faacb77e504c891c035012602836171c009ecfd21584de4d6461ba93"]],"rev":12,"root":"373a7d860a14b58e5bfa9b9ad3bc916091bcb6db7556f0dbc9c71972a612494d","scope":"targeted:paperclaim","signature":{"key":"ana","scheme":"ed25519","value":"wTBxOxNPgseU/6ENyaRVcQKc6AChkmfqnkNbXfTEwQkIXlcSnh9GIHEerGOYUy2sTzm146sL3PQMnfU3LkucBA=="}}
{"at":"2026-10-11T16:30:00Z","by":"ana","doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","evidence":[{"kind":"crop","node":"a4jrz2t","sha256":"46790e75ae8cff068515a73b05642be78939e4dd8bad40a080e0d135ba838799"},{"kind":"crop","node":"kea5026","sha256":"1ee24fc6dec45a1372134888b70ad35e4823bdfe7d3e57d2dab08e9d7d329356"},{"kind":"witness","sha256":"23b6b2aaece9cb0a828a2f0265539500fcf34d5195bf720b934b8bfdeccb9834"}],"format":"scienting-receipt/1","id":"mvjmb94nz7rdh","level":"F3","nodes":[["a4jrz2t","f64c6a5040f9c773d5ac4e559b58465aeae30bba79a82fc38b14ac7b61826ba8"],["kea5026","b836d5872ca37471fa996be04c538254a8b1e37ca12e8f1b4a40837b503afa33"]],"rev":12,"root":"5e3134a4583e5ea26e575da2a363a0520a7ee111f4da782c641e8c24070f8895","scope":"section:p36k8t6","signature":{"key":"ana","scheme":"ed25519","value":"tprithiSRx7h9KjqJrVCq7zK3ZufvNmACZNFORVde8I0sQUZgq6RTx9orJP3okDZj1I9/gGwJ9Fv1cCVBCYEAw=="}} {"at":"2026-10-11T16:30:00Z","by":"ana","doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","evidence":[{"kind":"crop","node":"a4jrz2t","sha256":"46790e75ae8cff068515a73b05642be78939e4dd8bad40a080e0d135ba838799"},{"kind":"crop","node":"kea5026","sha256":"1ee24fc6dec45a1372134888b70ad35e4823bdfe7d3e57d2dab08e9d7d329356"},{"kind":"witness","sha256":"23b6b2aaece9cb0a828a2f0265539500fcf34d5195bf720b934b8bfdeccb9834"}],"format":"scienting-receipt/1","id":"mvjmb94nz7rdh","level":"F3","nodes":[["a4jrz2t","f64c6a5040f9c773d5ac4e559b58465aeae30bba79a82fc38b14ac7b61826ba8"],["kea5026","b836d5872ca37471fa996be04c538254a8b1e37ca12e8f1b4a40837b503afa33"]],"rev":12,"root":"5e3134a4583e5ea26e575da2a363a0520a7ee111f4da782c641e8c24070f8895","scope":"section:p36k8t6","signature":{"key":"ana","scheme":"ed25519","value":"tprithiSRx7h9KjqJrVCq7zK3ZufvNmACZNFORVde8I0sQUZgq6RTx9orJP3okDZj1I9/gGwJ9Fv1cCVBCYEAw=="}}
{"at":"2026-10-11T17:00:00Z","by":"cara","doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","evidence":[{"kind":"crop","node":"qwgfg51","sha256":"886b5234b8240653d2a1f9551552592d3e64792658980b06b2d38f1af61b51d8"},{"kind":"crop","node":"vya7t4n","sha256":"4ef9dce7bed5821302a3fe118dbe32395df49cab231723cc1fe1d2b3b15093f1"},{"kind":"crop","node":"xjns57z","sha256":"57d07288058274f0e54c57899476eec6ddfc2662043ec609b5b91315bf0a4786"},{"kind":"witness","sha256":"23b6b2aaece9cb0a828a2f0265539500fcf34d5195bf720b934b8bfdeccb9834"}],"format":"scienting-receipt/1","id":"q465jpwz8afhe","level":"F3","nodes":[["qwgfg51","4a3be03766323b3c88d5b43591b0f573823b89fe582f2c3a6f0b43474685a30d"],["vya7t4n","5e7362eb5c7cd2db425e557982083a51c2607521b6b1f73d79d98956616965df"],["xjns57z","42b1de7852cdc68730984fff789fe248ecd5b43198c0e7d671931ff3fe561dc3"]],"rev":12,"root":"36aeaeab7720b10ffbbe12d07751ac3273c77fc642355e00e795cbe7db73b3b0","scope":"page:2","signature":{"key":"cara","scheme":"ed25519","value":"QY2hQLVWKyOLkSCQNzTOskn5suI4s1WmflgrQDvB43IyBx5AOP4qXdvyKdkvb1YJ+puHdpDi53/4Ad92jKYPCQ=="}} {"at":"2026-10-11T17:00:00Z","by":"cara","doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","evidence":[{"kind":"crop","node":"qwgfg51","sha256":"886b5234b8240653d2a1f9551552592d3e64792658980b06b2d38f1af61b51d8"},{"kind":"crop","node":"vya7t4n","sha256":"4ef9dce7bed5821302a3fe118dbe32395df49cab231723cc1fe1d2b3b15093f1"},{"kind":"crop","node":"xjns57z","sha256":"57d07288058274f0e54c57899476eec6ddfc2662043ec609b5b91315bf0a4786"},{"kind":"witness","sha256":"23b6b2aaece9cb0a828a2f0265539500fcf34d5195bf720b934b8bfdeccb9834"}],"format":"scienting-receipt/1","id":"q465jpwz8afhe","level":"F3","nodes":[["qwgfg51","4a3be03766323b3c88d5b43591b0f573823b89fe582f2c3a6f0b43474685a30d"],["vya7t4n","5e7362eb5c7cd2db425e557982083a51c2607521b6b1f73d79d98956616965df"],["xjns57z","42b1de7852cdc68730984fff789fe248ecd5b43198c0e7d671931ff3fe561dc3"]],"rev":12,"root":"36aeaeab7720b10ffbbe12d07751ac3273c77fc642355e00e795cbe7db73b3b0","scope":"page:2","signature":{"key":"cara","scheme":"ed25519","value":"QY2hQLVWKyOLkSCQNzTOskn5suI4s1WmflgrQDvB43IyBx5AOP4qXdvyKdkvb1YJ+puHdpDi53/4Ad92jKYPCQ=="}}
{"at":"2026-10-11T17:20:00Z","by":"cara","format":"scienting-revocation/1","id":"pcbhtpwvysgq6","reason":"Signed against the crops of another paper.","receipt":"q465jpwz8afhe","signature":{"key":"cara","scheme":"ed25519","value":"hObSv+xgW3GLZPkkR08CB+9LdxPP+16j/C/eI4OnqeuvbamQwDv7uZJmHBNBG1GkU+TcVM0V4IbDNfpuYyO4DQ=="}} {"at":"2026-10-11T17:20:00Z","by":"cara","format":"scienting-revocation/1","id":"pcbhtpwvysgq6","reason":"Signed against the crops of another paper.","receipt":"q465jpwz8afhe","signature":{"key":"cara","scheme":"ed25519","value":"hObSv+xgW3GLZPkkR08CB+9LdxPP+16j/C/eI4OnqeuvbamQwDv7uZJmHBNBG1GkU+TcVM0V4IbDNfpuYyO4DQ=="}}
{"at":"2026-10-11T18:00:00Z","by":"ana","doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","evidence":[{"kind":"crop","node":"caehhp6","sha256":"03932451473e6756936d196da5db53b9027220ab90402f32c212ed02a3e0cb69"},{"kind":"crop","node":"nms5qjg","sha256":"87a410886dac6569211ac21d5787953e6cb538b691d1cee916eb9ae72061ebba"},{"kind":"crop","node":"z86b2za","sha256":"3bd36b4ee0d38edfcd3e8feb546e24693cd8034e6ce3c11f01d2be8871f38c76"},{"kind":"witness","sha256":"23b6b2aaece9cb0a828a2f0265539500fcf34d5195bf720b934b8bfdeccb9834"}],"format":"scienting-receipt/1","id":"gx2s84z9jf9xv","level":"F3","nodes":[["caehhp6","9f9c9a412cd08d0634daa3f23c63f5125c1270c13834c45c045c1a9a7452af86"],["nms5qjg","e2f0b1d093c2f38f329c16edae255aed6e913d489e730a9d4857a3c3b5040f63"],["z86b2za","9a1c438b0f413d63b7e9f1ed7037cc6ad1665efd335baee2ef31d3d232c79552"]],"rev":12,"root":"1d4c44e1018708ff37d9e4b6b722b55388f627a2a9d00c32ea4dcbb0dad4a976","scope":"targeted:captions","signature":{"key":"ana","scheme":"ed25519","value":"nsms22ca/Cff9M6lamEOyn81qL/+OJg9uSDcXVny91XFQAlKZ3s3hS/Xf+8snrhCsuNEOqEfHYpg0nnVAFnwAQ=="}} {"at":"2026-10-11T18:00:00Z","by":"ana","doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","evidence":[{"kind":"crop","node":"caehhp6","sha256":"03932451473e6756936d196da5db53b9027220ab90402f32c212ed02a3e0cb69"},{"kind":"crop","node":"nms5qjg","sha256":"87a410886dac6569211ac21d5787953e6cb538b691d1cee916eb9ae72061ebba"},{"kind":"crop","node":"z86b2za","sha256":"3bd36b4ee0d38edfcd3e8feb546e24693cd8034e6ce3c11f01d2be8871f38c76"},{"kind":"witness","sha256":"23b6b2aaece9cb0a828a2f0265539500fcf34d5195bf720b934b8bfdeccb9834"}],"format":"scienting-receipt/1","id":"gx2s84z9jf9xv","level":"F3","nodes":[["caehhp6","9f9c9a412cd08d0634daa3f23c63f5125c1270c13834c45c045c1a9a7452af86"],["nms5qjg","e2f0b1d093c2f38f329c16edae255aed6e913d489e730a9d4857a3c3b5040f63"],["z86b2za","9a1c438b0f413d63b7e9f1ed7037cc6ad1665efd335baee2ef31d3d232c79552"]],"rev":12,"root":"1d4c44e1018708ff37d9e4b6b722b55388f627a2a9d00c32ea4dcbb0dad4a976","scope":"targeted:captions","signature":{"key":"ana","scheme":"ed25519","value":"nsms22ca/Cff9M6lamEOyn81qL/+OJg9uSDcXVny91XFQAlKZ3s3hS/Xf+8snrhCsuNEOqEfHYpg0nnVAFnwAQ=="}}
{"at":"2026-10-12T09:00:00Z","by":"ben","doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","evidence":[{"kind":"crop","node":"bnyvykm","sha256":"2c560caeaf914f3521fd0e3fca433922fcb9408c184c9b72bcfa869adf5ed409"},{"kind":"crop","node":"c20cna6","sha256":"bdbf7a4d9e86609675e3fc124c21ce808053a52d6bc0f35b15e1ba39027f13af"},{"kind":"crop","node":"d1mhw8b","sha256":"3104c57d9f8fb38302b057ead3bc44456da94f7c17d7c5c8f6db8732d4812c31"},{"kind":"crop","node":"exms5gc","sha256":"cfc0e42e734470df5cfb741f92080526ef796bf48bcf05847d44f7091cfaaab1"},{"kind":"crop","node":"ganq1ns","sha256":"81d88697cd002fdfd770ee11413c550e4e4ffaa464d35841648311f278fc13bc"},{"kind":"crop","node":"m1p1n2g","sha256":"369c69758d2d09cc3d42b2424723c4fbc75f9ceb6817da81ce183be7d36f045f"},{"kind":"crop","node":"ryhrskg","sha256":"e6f816d93cfff8418dbb771ba03a09fb89a3b2438f97fabfc4ebef7f78af0dbf"},{"kind":"crop","node":"w264b74","sha256":"0babb0cef51933b8744f5b22d075069d51e431d3bdc08cb5e35d7822097b5953"},{"kind":"crop","node":"yvkd7xr","sha256":"62fd5beecb3e76f430dfd142f443158b84657196af17173a976345a0cdd74449"},{"kind":"crop","node":"ztww0g8","sha256":"902e8ca35e1a313a81130c4c100aeb2233fd53854677b3a992fb16f744fe3151"}],"format":"scienting-receipt/1","id":"mg18668nzxvap","level":"F3","nodes":[["bnyvykm","13b0c5e01b52e467de5975acc898c2387fcc015d222517a865810a330a336c94"],["c20cna6","c8e6a553f5ae1377776e86dde6ee7d48a923dea7de417408841ea33b81563272"],["d1mhw8b","557a47334329925d191e772172fddbc1bd1a035eb2217240c476ee6bc43c92ab"],["exms5gc","b7c47f8360eb7272d2ac0943e8bf1aec9d71cb4ea4e5e1d02f8acee5b430a038"],["ganq1ns","40d46db2088057debc3b1d5b4a3c972ff3a94fc3d5463565f98876d0927f1e67"],["m1p1n2g","0847b5d75c2259257c3619e761c64d5571d3ca3932e96a96ee07e8ce68cc63be"],["ryhrskg","525583990e7871a2ba55739e8206abac2df0f19d30c86ad74f6cafdd7c3cbe25"],["w264b74","2ba9cea0f5c07ee9f7b47c5d541c85e92465709322869fb6c0d994ab61c56cad"],["yvkd7xr","aab8791a24bc4067c7e37fc5f0244d2128205e0a169e65c2c0fad977aabce313"],["ztww0g8","bda85639faacb77e504c891c035012602836171c009ecfd21584de4d6461ba93"]],"qa":{"errors":[],"key":"ben-spot","minimum":10,"of":"y2zw8ctg5s8dp","rate":"0.05","sample":["bnyvykm","c20cna6","d1mhw8b","exms5gc","ganq1ns","m1p1n2g","ryhrskg","w264b74","yvkd7xr","ztww0g8"],"seed":"3vORmZaL4zpWgtbZM29fKrWxgKOHhtXspIkutCyqgZgWUaBvmYCQfHtmCID+YNW2M+LIr8uMlpq/LD5cIp0omQRDdKSTIdrxoCxQHFgcwg0="},"rev":12,"root":"1819b7c2f0e597c440ac79096630f9e2e3cf915bedde34a0dbacae09e4ffee13","scope":"qa:y2zw8ctg5s8dp","signature":{"key":"ben","scheme":"ed25519","value":"iQZEJAY4djubmhFAFBq/wu4N0zoZly8ahIuVwQtra10NCxqSce2v+NCxu8dj+5xTWuOObdUHFVnbAVDdRBFJDQ=="}} {"at":"2026-10-12T09:00:00Z","by":"ben","doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","evidence":[{"kind":"crop","node":"b5gd0h1","sha256":"a0b6f761fe95f8f29ef6dc37901fa85c7a62857b50b0163ca67b0aab048e4d17"},{"kind":"crop","node":"ec5jc93","sha256":"321a926653b9e097987d255d9286880893d71abf895d73f1649403ed9ac0877d"},{"kind":"crop","node":"hca6dc5","sha256":"a26619c3a9824bc19fddcf89ee618d9a4792d69110439f121eb717b6f98e88a6"},{"kind":"crop","node":"j6y45v6","sha256":"e689deda15dde9ad24433eb946200417473d273a1bf3136df67bf572256a483f"},{"kind":"crop","node":"jv1741a","sha256":"de60579bacfab769f614fa74d26d20c7b1aa02caf60af1479dc46b98ddcbc106"},{"kind":"crop","node":"m1p1n2g","sha256":"369c69758d2d09cc3d42b2424723c4fbc75f9ceb6817da81ce183be7d36f045f"},{"kind":"crop","node":"tkxsmts","sha256":"5d8e205660c2c59dcaff119b5671ac11650974b5287d7d7b239a9118e9171a85"},{"kind":"crop","node":"w0gr97q","sha256":"588a38407463e5674714899e6cf359810ccfed98fefdd2c1a90e8cb2ed0a9d64"},{"kind":"crop","node":"x3ns64d","sha256":"6bd7423a5933eb89572ded1d40d2f5baf6f6fa2f3c46791de8210f201a94b9d1"},{"kind":"crop","node":"ztww0g8","sha256":"902e8ca35e1a313a81130c4c100aeb2233fd53854677b3a992fb16f744fe3151"}],"format":"scienting-receipt/1","id":"ksx5sc327xp97","level":"F3","nodes":[["b5gd0h1","9635a750ac2acf526a4db28746fd3ed84659f4e384f5a73fef85d002b4e9308b"],["ec5jc93","5421e9cf0ef3a995792963d0371b79e11a8efad519b02efb5cb88311a896d0cc"],["hca6dc5","8cfed5a34aab28517e89e8a164f0f96c14361de83ebc800439116e83ef479f34"],["j6y45v6","00c4b92e220303ebc2bfb36aa557ac80ae4dba1675e9ed47adb82f6aeff10634"],["jv1741a","f644190803b5ea36aa24738e7f168a7fdf0d05cb5123c14a814b7628dab71f1e"],["m1p1n2g","0847b5d75c2259257c3619e761c64d5571d3ca3932e96a96ee07e8ce68cc63be"],["tkxsmts","cc0bf73dd84e298da0d36c4b363c8d2bdc9b6d5738d1923d14c4a9028dca08d6"],["w0gr97q","f738a008336ac59b2f1d45cda2f045dc96d34f0f1378c431ce6ff8e434feb8a7"],["x3ns64d","6bfc0a055148d877dbaf28b7f62565de7b6926137bf032c382282c39a4876797"],["ztww0g8","bda85639faacb77e504c891c035012602836171c009ecfd21584de4d6461ba93"]],"qa":{"errors":[],"key":"ben-spot","minimum":10,"of":"fhhvg9qrzqp0n","rate":"0.05","sample":["b5gd0h1","ec5jc93","hca6dc5","j6y45v6","jv1741a","m1p1n2g","tkxsmts","w0gr97q","x3ns64d","ztww0g8"],"seed":"28DienSItno55u/F/YFtP1uuY8zgyDpx/5AzTw98mEzXjKJ3MnG6NgX5c7FDY3iSYkuKqRGUkKmy3eRt7AWoCIQFQW6prIZQnDC4+slwKgE="},"rev":12,"root":"acdb858e72b9911e01809b400e3c6e8a5c8fd0d8da808ebd4078e7ea60db0865","scope":"qa:fhhvg9qrzqp0n","signature":{"key":"ben","scheme":"ed25519","value":"e3p1wQgF7KCKJunNOT7zersemSK3UXzYxJolH6yCZzLfBenpPi+937Uz+10x3gG/+/9WqF33lLDn+xFLEeKEAQ=="}}
{"at":"2026-10-12T09:30:00Z","by":"ben","doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","evidence":[{"kind":"crop","node":"caehhp6","sha256":"03932451473e6756936d196da5db53b9027220ab90402f32c212ed02a3e0cb69"},{"kind":"crop","node":"nms5qjg","sha256":"87a410886dac6569211ac21d5787953e6cb538b691d1cee916eb9ae72061ebba"},{"kind":"crop","node":"z86b2za","sha256":"3bd36b4ee0d38edfcd3e8feb546e24693cd8034e6ce3c11f01d2be8871f38c76"}],"format":"scienting-receipt/1","id":"yt70fcc3qm0xb","level":"F3","nodes":[["caehhp6","9f9c9a412cd08d0634daa3f23c63f5125c1270c13834c45c045c1a9a7452af86"],["nms5qjg","e2f0b1d093c2f38f329c16edae255aed6e913d489e730a9d4857a3c3b5040f63"],["z86b2za","9a1c438b0f413d63b7e9f1ed7037cc6ad1665efd335baee2ef31d3d232c79552"]],"qa":{"errors":[{"kind":"word","node":"caehhp6","note":"The page prints a period the reading lacks."}],"key":"ben-spot","minimum":10,"of":"gx2s84z9jf9xv","rate":"0.05","sample":["caehhp6","nms5qjg","z86b2za"],"seed":"OGWvNMD0Wsd3kUTzvby0kVC6P1h4UKOMD+vVidd489IfuQIsp68CVEYuGwovPKNdHuIvBCYZL+2WoHbY5ClR8yH0r4t4JXV+2JGsGPbb+gs="},"rev":12,"root":"1d4c44e1018708ff37d9e4b6b722b55388f627a2a9d00c32ea4dcbb0dad4a976","scope":"qa:gx2s84z9jf9xv","signature":{"key":"ben","scheme":"ed25519","value":"9j18am+VrPqloaPVfPZoh0nbyGB4d1rWDwQdsb+NjD3+TMjNQbcVv0CRtgwWCLTw9ibMtk4XNRqDN7ImqpV0CA=="}} {"at":"2026-10-12T09:30:00Z","by":"ben","doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","evidence":[{"kind":"crop","node":"caehhp6","sha256":"03932451473e6756936d196da5db53b9027220ab90402f32c212ed02a3e0cb69"},{"kind":"crop","node":"nms5qjg","sha256":"87a410886dac6569211ac21d5787953e6cb538b691d1cee916eb9ae72061ebba"},{"kind":"crop","node":"z86b2za","sha256":"3bd36b4ee0d38edfcd3e8feb546e24693cd8034e6ce3c11f01d2be8871f38c76"}],"format":"scienting-receipt/1","id":"yt70fcc3qm0xb","level":"F3","nodes":[["caehhp6","9f9c9a412cd08d0634daa3f23c63f5125c1270c13834c45c045c1a9a7452af86"],["nms5qjg","e2f0b1d093c2f38f329c16edae255aed6e913d489e730a9d4857a3c3b5040f63"],["z86b2za","9a1c438b0f413d63b7e9f1ed7037cc6ad1665efd335baee2ef31d3d232c79552"]],"qa":{"errors":[{"kind":"word","node":"caehhp6","note":"The page prints a period the reading lacks."}],"key":"ben-spot","minimum":10,"of":"gx2s84z9jf9xv","rate":"0.05","sample":["caehhp6","nms5qjg","z86b2za"],"seed":"OGWvNMD0Wsd3kUTzvby0kVC6P1h4UKOMD+vVidd489IfuQIsp68CVEYuGwovPKNdHuIvBCYZL+2WoHbY5ClR8yH0r4t4JXV+2JGsGPbb+gs="},"rev":12,"root":"1d4c44e1018708ff37d9e4b6b722b55388f627a2a9d00c32ea4dcbb0dad4a976","scope":"qa:gx2s84z9jf9xv","signature":{"key":"ben","scheme":"ed25519","value":"9j18am+VrPqloaPVfPZoh0nbyGB4d1rWDwQdsb+NjD3+TMjNQbcVv0CRtgwWCLTw9ibMtk4XNRqDN7ImqpV0CA=="}}
+1 -1
View File
@@ -1 +1 @@
{"format":"scienting-checkpoint/1","note":"scient.ing/log/smithlab\n9\nGa0n103p3Gl136z6XWmM92kGvsvMYGXlk+ijjX4KWiA=\n\n— ana dBv7wtCAdNnczkCO5KwtrmDvtWUVPRusBSuLPeBDQoLZi9Hm34IHuNjvnjyPEar5afNf7xqcDtokk2XZEP31uJMVuwE=\n— wit h7ghDsJGkhWLaPO7+TIZQUenslhiQh/E/TKWU4ddphpFcuylQBZM2kG/o8H1nyPfUT0MkbvnFqPFfHPH3OaN5W1EwAI=\n","origin":"scient.ing/log/smithlab","root":"19ad27d74de9dc6975dfacfa5d698cf76906becbcc6065e593e8a38d7e0a5a20","signatures":[{"key_hash":"741bfbc2","name":"ana","value":"0IB02dzOQI7krC2uYO+1ZRU9G6wFK4s94ENCgtmL0ebfgge42O+ePI8Rqvlp81/vGpwO2iSTZdkQ/fW4kxW7AQ=="},{"key_hash":"87b8210e","name":"wit","value":"wkaSFYto87v5MhlBR6eyWGJCH8T9MpZTh12mGkVy7KVAFkzaQb+jwfWfI99RPQyRu+cWo8V8c8fc5o3lbUTAAg=="}],"size":9} {"format":"scienting-checkpoint/1","note":"scient.ing/log/smithlab\n9\nWQxnIeoDxqOJ/rIz5b0uJ3pfpq4S1kUQMNvbG55bPEM=\n\n— ana dBv7wrLxQN8XFJOwKZO4L98UosXwyw3jVbYTM3a+dZWQdtZkPqd6fM8LHwgbIyBT+OEq18meE0JkqJKoYeZ2DMP7eAo=\n— wit h7ghDsbQuWAI5VIGw+jiEAMHeSpDVlubOR46YIEuxL5TWkxU1xAtrp4gwgKxCV+q72A9mZC6APgyaCAUi78euiV/SA8=\n","origin":"scient.ing/log/smithlab","root":"590c6721ea03c6a389feb233e5bd2e277a5fa6ae12d6451030dbdb1b9e5b3c43","signatures":[{"key_hash":"741bfbc2","name":"ana","value":"svFA3xcUk7Apk7gv3xSixfDLDeNVthMzdr51lZB21mQ+p3p8zwsfCBsjIFP44SrXyZ4TQmSokqhh5nYMw/t4Cg=="},{"key_hash":"87b8210e","name":"wit","value":"xtC5YAjlUgbD6OIQAwd5KkNWW5s5HjpggS7EvlNaTFTXEC2uniDCArEJX6rvYD2ZkLoA+DJoIBSLvx66JX9IDw=="}],"size":9}
+10 -8
View File
@@ -1,10 +1,12 @@
{"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"audience":"novice","format":"text/markdown","kind":"gloss","language":"en","type":"TextualBody","value":"A *harmonic* term treats a bond like a spring: the energy grows with the square of the stretch."},"created":"2026-10-11T19:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:key:ana","name":"Ana Example","type":"Person"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/f4s8pc1hdhd9d","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/kp4m2x7q","motivation":"describing","receipt":"r10e5mzvw6tja","status":"confirmed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"rr20tev","node_hash":"76e06b4811a688357ac4b912172283463cfaf1b7a1f0795d274fc733a2309ba7","own_hash":"2d7df7b8b233eab6f96d5db0d29c99062aaa94b55cf4e388c49b9995ce7548d5","quote":{"exact":"bond force constant","prefix":"rm{eq}})^2$$ where $K_r$ is the ","suffix":" and $r_\\mathrm{eq}$ the equilib"},"rev":12,"span":[111,130],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"bond force constant","prefix":"rm{eq}})^2$$ where $K_r$ is the ","suffix":" and $r_\\mathrm{eq}$ the equilib","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"} {"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"audience":"novice","format":"text/markdown","kind":"gloss","language":"en","type":"TextualBody","value":"A *harmonic* term treats a bond like a spring: the energy grows with the square of the stretch."},"created":"2026-10-11T19:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:key:ana","name":"Ana Example","type":"Person"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/f4s8pc1hdhd9d","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/kp4m2x7q","motivation":"describing","receipt":"w9j3dwgydy2e0","status":"confirmed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"rr20tev","node_hash":"76e06b4811a688357ac4b912172283463cfaf1b7a1f0795d274fc733a2309ba7","own_hash":"2d7df7b8b233eab6f96d5db0d29c99062aaa94b55cf4e388c49b9995ce7548d5","quote":{"exact":"bond force constant","prefix":"rm{eq}})^2$$ where $K_r$ is the ","suffix":" and $r_\\mathrm{eq}$ the equilib"},"rev":12,"span":[111,130],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"bond force constant","prefix":"rm{eq}})^2$$ where $K_r$ is the ","suffix":" and $r_\\mathrm{eq}$ the equilib","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"}
{"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"kind":"claim-link","pin":"illustrative-pin","role":"states","source":"lode:amber/k-bond","type":"SpecificResource"},"created":"2026-10-11T19:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:key:ana","name":"Ana Example","type":"Person"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/nzwtq23khdx4s","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/kp4m2x7q","motivation":"linking","receipt":"r10e5mzvw6tja","status":"confirmed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"rr20tev","node_hash":"76e06b4811a688357ac4b912172283463cfaf1b7a1f0795d274fc733a2309ba7","own_hash":"2d7df7b8b233eab6f96d5db0d29c99062aaa94b55cf4e388c49b9995ce7548d5","quote":{"exact":"The bond energy is given by $$E_{\\mathrm{bond}} = \\frac{1}{2} K_r (r - r_{\\mathrm{eq}})^2$$ where $K_r$ is the bond force constant and $r_\\mathrm{eq}$ the equilibrium bond length."},"rev":12,"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"The bond energy is given by $$E_{\\mathrm{bond}} = \\frac{1}{2} K_r (r - r_{\\mathrm{eq}})^2$$ where $K_r$ is the bond force constant and $r_\\mathrm{eq}$ the equilibrium bond length.","prefix":"","suffix":"","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"} {"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"kind":"claim-link","pin":"claim:272XTX7C@02f47b","role":"states","source":"claim:272XTX7C","type":"SpecificResource"},"created":"2026-10-11T19:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:key:ana","name":"Ana Example","type":"Person"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/m2vbd164hfkc3","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/kp4m2x7q","motivation":"linking","receipt":"w9j3dwgydy2e0","status":"confirmed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"rr20tev","node_hash":"76e06b4811a688357ac4b912172283463cfaf1b7a1f0795d274fc733a2309ba7","own_hash":"2d7df7b8b233eab6f96d5db0d29c99062aaa94b55cf4e388c49b9995ce7548d5","quote":{"exact":"The bond energy is given by $$E_{\\mathrm{bond}} = \\frac{1}{2} K_r (r - r_{\\mathrm{eq}})^2$$ where $K_r$ is the bond force constant and $r_\\mathrm{eq}$ the equilibrium bond length."},"rev":12,"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"The bond energy is given by $$E_{\\mathrm{bond}} = \\frac{1}{2} K_r (r - r_{\\mathrm{eq}})^2$$ where $K_r$ is the bond force constant and $r_\\mathrm{eq}$ the equilibrium bond length.","prefix":"","suffix":"","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"}
{"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"kind":"comment","type":"TextualBody","value":"The step size matters more than the text admits."},"created":"2026-10-11T19:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:key:ana","name":"Ana Example","type":"Person"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/m9e0g8r5ebnkf","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/kp4m2x7q","motivation":"commenting","status":"proposed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"xjns57z","node_hash":"42b1de7852cdc68730984fff789fe248ecd5b43198c0e7d671931ff3fe561dc3","own_hash":"4dc28d1ad57c74d044f87264dfbc744ae9d5e9644638db976dbc346361442486","quote":{"exact":"steps of 0.01","prefix":"Each bond was scanned in ","suffix":" Å around its minimum, and the e"},"rev":12,"span":[25,38],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"steps of 0.01","prefix":"Each bond was scanned in ","suffix":" Å around its minimum, and the e","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"} {"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"category":"critique","kind":"comment","type":"TextualBody","value":"The step size matters more than the text admits."},"created":"2026-10-11T19:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:key:ana","name":"Ana Example","type":"Person"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/sxj4eq8415s92","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/kp4m2x7q","motivation":"commenting","status":"proposed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"xjns57z","node_hash":"42b1de7852cdc68730984fff789fe248ecd5b43198c0e7d671931ff3fe561dc3","own_hash":"4dc28d1ad57c74d044f87264dfbc744ae9d5e9644638db976dbc346361442486","quote":{"exact":"steps of 0.01","prefix":"Each bond was scanned in ","suffix":" Å around its minimum, and the e"},"rev":12,"span":[25,38],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"steps of 0.01","prefix":"Each bond was scanned in ","suffix":" Å around its minimum, and the e","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"}
{"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"for":"group","kind":"question","type":"TextualBody","value":"Why fit to a scan first and to frequencies second?"},"created":"2026-10-11T19:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:key:ana","name":"Ana Example","type":"Person"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/x0emxkxem54hw","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/kp4m2x7q","motivation":"questioning","status":"proposed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"section","node":"d400rz3","node_hash":"e5a8eeb3c112f2dc3341da8f433540a3fc5a7e7f631e72c4dd36c6933aae808d","own_hash":"c3d50f266b05d7889c001aef16662cecd4e99ac4a2747ec331c1044e6adc8e3e","rev":12,"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"} {"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"category":"question","for":"group","kind":"question","type":"TextualBody","value":"Why fit to a scan first and to frequencies second?"},"created":"2026-10-11T19:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:key:ana","name":"Ana Example","type":"Person"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/fsg960szdyy6q","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/kp4m2x7q","motivation":"questioning","status":"proposed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"section","node":"d400rz3","node_hash":"e5a8eeb3c112f2dc3341da8f433540a3fc5a7e7f631e72c4dd36c6933aae808d","own_hash":"c3d50f266b05d7889c001aef16662cecd4e99ac4a2747ec331c1044e6adc8e3e","rev":12,"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"}
{"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"kind":"citation-context","reason":"value","reference":"vxsdvzq","type":"TextualBody","value":"Cited for the band position; the reference is not in the library.","verdict":"cannot-tell"},"created":"2026-10-11T19:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:key:ana","name":"Ana Example","type":"Person"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/gbj7nn87ndfd8","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/kp4m2x7q","motivation":"assessing","status":"proposed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"hca6dc5","node_hash":"8cfed5a34aab28517e89e8a164f0f96c14361de83ebc800439116e83ef479f34","own_hash":"c270571517825ceed31ca912b80ac76203effe47f1c84f8ee8962800d0afc92f","quote":{"exact":"1595","prefix":" case, with a bending band near ","suffix":" cm⁻¹.2"},"rev":12,"span":[71,75],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"1595","prefix":" case, with a bending band near ","suffix":" cm⁻¹.2","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"} {"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"kind":"citation-context","reason":"value","reference":"vxsdvzq","type":"TextualBody","value":"Cited for the band position; the reference is not in the library.","verdict":"cannot-tell"},"created":"2026-10-11T19:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:key:ana","name":"Ana Example","type":"Person"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/gbj7nn87ndfd8","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/kp4m2x7q","motivation":"assessing","status":"proposed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"hca6dc5","node_hash":"8cfed5a34aab28517e89e8a164f0f96c14361de83ebc800439116e83ef479f34","own_hash":"c270571517825ceed31ca912b80ac76203effe47f1c84f8ee8962800d0afc92f","quote":{"exact":"1595","prefix":" case, with a bending band near ","suffix":" cm⁻¹.2"},"rev":12,"span":[71,75],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"1595","prefix":" case, with a bending band near ","suffix":" cm⁻¹.2","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"}
{"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"generator":{"model":{"name":"example-model","parameters":"998b5161e39e01c8bc43ef81ec89141e15b7ea53b2e936707920a6097dbcb2c5","processor":"local","prompt":"9cc338fba7c62db7266f530cb555a5ee36910d41a0120a3fe7fd7de1944d0931","provider":"Example Models (illustrative)","version":"2026-09","weights":"504b2d340045b92c22682b60020c21103aae7ff41172bb632fbe305eb4af9b5e"},"run":"illustrative-run-1"},"kind":"generated","type":"TextualBody","value":"Two panels: an energy scan and its fit residual."},"created":"2026-10-11T19:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:software:example-model","name":"A model (illustrative)","type":"Software"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/szb6k3fj9z7aw","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/kp4m2x7q","motivation":"describing","status":"proposed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"figure","node":"v7cx6qs","node_hash":"f76864779843485fa9e2f3cc3cd1c76ad222e1649c56f4cface33bf20b8f33b6","own_hash":"a1e46cb40201a17903dfd6f128db1e707b0e9f5bf45fcc32ec7ca772011edeae","rev":12,"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"} {"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"generator":{"model":{"name":"example-model","parameters":"998b5161e39e01c8bc43ef81ec89141e15b7ea53b2e936707920a6097dbcb2c5","processor":"local","prompt":"9cc338fba7c62db7266f530cb555a5ee36910d41a0120a3fe7fd7de1944d0931","provider":"Example Models (illustrative)","version":"2026-09","weights":"504b2d340045b92c22682b60020c21103aae7ff41172bb632fbe305eb4af9b5e"},"run":"illustrative-run-1"},"kind":"generated","type":"TextualBody","value":"Two panels: an energy scan and its fit residual."},"created":"2026-10-11T19:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:software:example-model","name":"A model (illustrative)","type":"Software"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/szb6k3fj9z7aw","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/kp4m2x7q","motivation":"describing","status":"proposed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"figure","node":"v7cx6qs","node_hash":"f76864779843485fa9e2f3cc3cd1c76ad222e1649c56f4cface33bf20b8f33b6","own_hash":"a1e46cb40201a17903dfd6f128db1e707b0e9f5bf45fcc32ec7ca772011edeae","rev":12,"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"}
{"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"exercise":{"exercise":"anchor","format":"scienting-exercise/1","key":{"elements":[{"anchors":[{"context":{"column_path":["Set A","$K_r$ (kcal mol⁻¹ Å⁻²)"],"row_path":["Bond parameters","CT–CT"],"table_label":"Table 1"},"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"cell","node":"c20cna6","node_hash":"c8e6a553f5ae1377776e86dde6ee7d48a923dea7de417408841ea33b81563272","own_hash":"45bf6ab427d435f28b82cb2b64d93c502968921507fc9397abd5d5170731c6ab","quote":{"exact":"310.0"},"rev":12,"store":"smithlab"}],"feedback":{"hit":"That is the cell.","miss":"Look in Table 1, row CT–CT."},"points":"1"}]},"prompt":"Find the table cell that gives the Set A bond constant for the CT–CT bond.","rule":{"match":"same-node"}},"kind":"exercise","type":"TextualBody","value":"Find the table cell that gives the Set A bond constant for the CT–CT bond."},"created":"2026-10-11T19:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:key:ana","name":"Ana Example","type":"Person"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/whcypxav2cqbx","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/kp4m2x7q","motivation":"assessing","receipt":"r10e5mzvw6tja","status":"confirmed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"table","node":"hj4s7pb","node_hash":"6c6fba200faf41cd06fa8b64e06e2aa29ff8848568b859ae42d1902596348643","own_hash":"66310a9ab1c92568f4c6cae012e35d4245d4ca4b89d2542b7c2113a31ad379ed","rev":12,"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"} {"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"exercise":{"exercise":"anchor","format":"scienting-exercise/1","key":{"elements":[{"anchors":[{"context":{"column_path":["Set A","$K_r$ (kcal mol⁻¹ Å⁻²)"],"row_path":["Bond parameters","CT–CT"],"table_label":"Table 1"},"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"cell","node":"c20cna6","node_hash":"c8e6a553f5ae1377776e86dde6ee7d48a923dea7de417408841ea33b81563272","own_hash":"45bf6ab427d435f28b82cb2b64d93c502968921507fc9397abd5d5170731c6ab","quote":{"exact":"310.0"},"rev":12,"store":"smithlab"}],"feedback":{"hit":"That is the cell.","miss":"Look in Table 1, row CT–CT."},"points":"1"}]},"prompt":"Find the table cell that gives the Set A bond constant for the CT–CT bond.","rule":{"match":"same-node"}},"kind":"exercise","type":"TextualBody","value":"Find the table cell that gives the Set A bond constant for the CT–CT bond."},"created":"2026-10-11T19:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:key:ana","name":"Ana Example","type":"Person"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/whcypxav2cqbx","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/kp4m2x7q","motivation":"assessing","receipt":"w9j3dwgydy2e0","status":"confirmed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"table","node":"hj4s7pb","node_hash":"6c6fba200faf41cd06fa8b64e06e2aa29ff8848568b859ae42d1902596348643","own_hash":"66310a9ab1c92568f4c6cae012e35d4245d4ca4b89d2542b7c2113a31ad379ed","rev":12,"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"}
{"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"exercise":{"exercise":"check","format":"scienting-exercise/1","key":{"elements":[{"anchors":[{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"kea5026","node_hash":"b836d5872ca37471fa996be04c538254a8b1e37ca12e8f1b4a40837b503afa33","own_hash":"d673d236c03d9583ecf6e01fa819765ec324dc684bd9bbc6967fa50f216e34d2","quote":{"exact":"the most common description","prefix":"Harmonic bond terms remain ","suffix":" of covalent stretching in class"},"rev":12,"span":[27,54],"store":"smithlab"}],"points":"1"}],"verdict":{"points":"1","value":"supports"}},"prompt":"Does the cited passage support the claim that harmonic terms are the most common choice?","rule":{"match":"overlap","min_overlap":"0.5"}},"kind":"exercise","type":"TextualBody","value":"Does the cited passage support the claim that harmonic terms are the most common choice?"},"created":"2026-10-11T19:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:key:ana","name":"Ana Example","type":"Person"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/y7bd3he0jwjbx","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/kp4m2x7q","motivation":"assessing","receipt":"r10e5mzvw6tja","status":"confirmed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"kea5026","node_hash":"b836d5872ca37471fa996be04c538254a8b1e37ca12e8f1b4a40837b503afa33","own_hash":"d673d236c03d9583ecf6e01fa819765ec324dc684bd9bbc6967fa50f216e34d2","quote":{"exact":"Harmonic bond terms remain the most common description of covalent stretching in classical force fields.1"},"rev":12,"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"Harmonic bond terms remain the most common description of covalent stretching in classical force fields.1","prefix":"","suffix":"","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"} {"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"exercise":{"exercise":"check","format":"scienting-exercise/1","key":{"elements":[{"anchors":[{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"kea5026","node_hash":"b836d5872ca37471fa996be04c538254a8b1e37ca12e8f1b4a40837b503afa33","own_hash":"d673d236c03d9583ecf6e01fa819765ec324dc684bd9bbc6967fa50f216e34d2","quote":{"exact":"the most common description","prefix":"Harmonic bond terms remain ","suffix":" of covalent stretching in class"},"rev":12,"span":[27,54],"store":"smithlab"}],"points":"1"}],"verdict":{"points":"1","value":"supports"}},"prompt":"Does the cited passage support the claim that harmonic terms are the most common choice?","rule":{"match":"overlap","min_overlap":"0.5"}},"kind":"exercise","type":"TextualBody","value":"Does the cited passage support the claim that harmonic terms are the most common choice?"},"created":"2026-10-11T19:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:key:ana","name":"Ana Example","type":"Person"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/y7bd3he0jwjbx","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/kp4m2x7q","motivation":"assessing","receipt":"w9j3dwgydy2e0","status":"confirmed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"kea5026","node_hash":"b836d5872ca37471fa996be04c538254a8b1e37ca12e8f1b4a40837b503afa33","own_hash":"d673d236c03d9583ecf6e01fa819765ec324dc684bd9bbc6967fa50f216e34d2","quote":{"exact":"Harmonic bond terms remain the most common description of covalent stretching in classical force fields.1"},"rev":12,"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"Harmonic bond terms remain the most common description of covalent stretching in classical force fields.1","prefix":"","suffix":"","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"}
{"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"kind":"description","language":"en","role":"alt","type":"TextualBody","value":"Energy along the C–C bond stretch (panel a) and the fit residual (panel b)."},"created":"2026-10-11T19:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:key:ana","name":"Ana Example","type":"Person"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/gb5tmv3hq08vz","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/kp4m2x7q","motivation":"describing","receipt":"r10e5mzvw6tja","status":"confirmed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"figure","node":"v7cx6qs","node_hash":"f76864779843485fa9e2f3cc3cd1c76ad222e1649c56f4cface33bf20b8f33b6","own_hash":"a1e46cb40201a17903dfd6f128db1e707b0e9f5bf45fcc32ec7ca772011edeae","rev":12,"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"} {"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"kind":"description","language":"en","role":"alt","type":"TextualBody","value":"Energy along the C–C bond stretch (panel a) and the fit residual (panel b)."},"created":"2026-10-11T19:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:key:ana","name":"Ana Example","type":"Person"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/gb5tmv3hq08vz","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/kp4m2x7q","motivation":"describing","receipt":"w9j3dwgydy2e0","status":"confirmed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"figure","node":"v7cx6qs","node_hash":"f76864779843485fa9e2f3cc3cd1c76ad222e1649c56f4cface33bf20b8f33b6","own_hash":"a1e46cb40201a17903dfd6f128db1e707b0e9f5bf45fcc32ec7ca772011edeae","rev":12,"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"}
{"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"kind":"comment","type":"TextualBody","value":"Agreed; see the residual panel."},"created":"2026-10-11T19:05:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:key:ana","name":"Ana Example","type":"Person"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/j3vr50xm97cp7","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/kp4m2x7q","motivation":"replying","status":"proposed","target":{"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/m9e0g8r5ebnkf","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"} {"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"category":"comment","kind":"comment","type":"TextualBody","value":"Agreed; see the residual panel."},"created":"2026-10-11T19:05:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:key:ana","name":"Ana Example","type":"Person"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/t5cv4rec7j0mt","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/kp4m2x7q","motivation":"replying","status":"proposed","target":{"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/sxj4eq8415s92","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"}
{"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"category":"context","kind":"caveat","type":"TextualBody","value":"The band position is cited, not measured here; reference 2 is not in the library."},"created":"2026-10-11T19:10:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:key:ana","name":"Ana Example","type":"Person"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/g7ngzk3jkdy40","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/kp4m2x7q","motivation":"commenting","status":"proposed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"hca6dc5","node_hash":"8cfed5a34aab28517e89e8a164f0f96c14361de83ebc800439116e83ef479f34","own_hash":"c270571517825ceed31ca912b80ac76203effe47f1c84f8ee8962800d0afc92f","quote":{"exact":"1595","prefix":" case, with a bending band near ","suffix":" cm⁻¹.2"},"rev":12,"span":[71,75],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"1595","prefix":" case, with a bending band near ","suffix":" cm⁻¹.2","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"}
{"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"key":"K_{r}","kind":"symbol","pin":"claim:272XTX7C@02f47b","source":"claim:272XTX7C","symbol":"K_r","type":"SpecificResource"},"created":"2026-10-11T19:15:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:key:ana","name":"Ana Example","type":"Person"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/f2603vdj2e3tr","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/kp4m2x7q","motivation":"identifying","status":"proposed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"rr20tev","node_hash":"76e06b4811a688357ac4b912172283463cfaf1b7a1f0795d274fc733a2309ba7","own_hash":"2d7df7b8b233eab6f96d5db0d29c99062aaa94b55cf4e388c49b9995ce7548d5","quote":{"exact":"$K_r$","prefix":"(r - r_{\\mathrm{eq}})^2$$ where ","suffix":" is the bond force constant and "},"rev":12,"span":[98,103],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"$K_r$","prefix":"(r - r_{\\mathrm{eq}})^2$$ where ","suffix":" is the bond force constant and ","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"}
+1 -1
View File
@@ -1 +1 @@
{"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"audience":"student","created":"2026-10-11T19:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:key:ana","name":"Ana Example","type":"Person"},"docs":["smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb"],"format":"scienting-layer/1","id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/kp4m2x7q","label":"Smith lab reading of Hale and Osei","license":{"spdx":"CC-BY-4.0"},"project":"smithlab-charges","purpose":"Glosses, claim links and exercises for new students.","total":10,"type":"AnnotationCollection","visibility":"team"} {"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"audience":"student","created":"2026-10-11T19:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:key:ana","name":"Ana Example","type":"Person"},"docs":["smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb"],"format":"scienting-layer/1","id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/kp4m2x7q","label":"Smith lab reading of Hale and Osei","license":{"spdx":"CC-BY-4.0"},"project":"smithlab-charges","purpose":"Glosses, claim links and exercises for new students.","total":12,"type":"AnnotationCollection","visibility":"team"}
+1 -1
View File
@@ -1 +1 @@
{"at":"2026-10-11T19:30:00Z","by":"ana","doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","evidence":[],"format":"scienting-receipt/1","id":"r10e5mzvw6tja","level":"F3","nodes":[],"records":[["annotation","f4s8pc1hdhd9d","9db553d2150a912e4ba3027d002706e08ccaded843d3e49c79b95a2e0581b6f1"],["annotation","gb5tmv3hq08vz","3b776d37af21d1bdfd3a0130c9bfa26affa484fb4d76e41d83cbd8bb02b4975c"],["annotation","nzwtq23khdx4s","8ea94b7a3d266f51e11dd31399784019acd1b1b53ed093e15c199417327992ab"],["annotation","whcypxav2cqbx","11845db3ef685b0b9bd13895cc5b8ade5b345ee7d72737a630be60d690a2ba5d"],["annotation","y7bd3he0jwjbx","0286ede04d8bf548432e34dd7beeee0fb044bd43022a8661a292018dd2ef5578"]],"rev":12,"root":"246581b0926273458b78ece15b465f0567c150a1e071f72322ce41895f9502e1","scope":"targeted:layer","signature":{"key":"ana","scheme":"ed25519","value":"WMDdARYwB0ETltF57ks1MxJ6ny/c4XziLvYUBd8PoW7MwcfhPKmDTqNGxRNg4z5g4c/bHnWS4ftZLJiONTL/Cg=="}} {"at":"2026-10-11T19:30:00Z","by":"ana","doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","evidence":[],"format":"scienting-receipt/1","id":"w9j3dwgydy2e0","level":"F3","nodes":[],"records":[["annotation","f4s8pc1hdhd9d","9db553d2150a912e4ba3027d002706e08ccaded843d3e49c79b95a2e0581b6f1"],["annotation","gb5tmv3hq08vz","3b776d37af21d1bdfd3a0130c9bfa26affa484fb4d76e41d83cbd8bb02b4975c"],["annotation","m2vbd164hfkc3","47f154185dc5440157d81e93779b60dca9d58d6a9a35e2b4da2e1a1083d7e276"],["annotation","whcypxav2cqbx","11845db3ef685b0b9bd13895cc5b8ade5b345ee7d72737a630be60d690a2ba5d"],["annotation","y7bd3he0jwjbx","0286ede04d8bf548432e34dd7beeee0fb044bd43022a8661a292018dd2ef5578"]],"rev":12,"root":"9c6936a337abfd0732a8629568aef125953041fa9d2403991b7a47bef35b604e","scope":"targeted:layer","signature":{"key":"ana","scheme":"ed25519","value":"huZ9eQ3PZfC9Kq/yXtvIhdK9FGgPVH7WVQn+YHFgOVXPDCSSjlpLr+eqsHEdl0XsNM/ku8uXS1XiZiRzSWitBg=="}}
+3 -3
View File
@@ -1,6 +1,6 @@
scient.ing/log/smithlab scient.ing/log/smithlab
9 9
Ga0n103p3Gl136z6XWmM92kGvsvMYGXlk+ijjX4KWiA= WQxnIeoDxqOJ/rIz5b0uJ3pfpq4S1kUQMNvbG55bPEM=
— ana dBv7wtCAdNnczkCO5KwtrmDvtWUVPRusBSuLPeBDQoLZi9Hm34IHuNjvnjyPEar5afNf7xqcDtokk2XZEP31uJMVuwE= — ana dBv7wrLxQN8XFJOwKZO4L98UosXwyw3jVbYTM3a+dZWQdtZkPqd6fM8LHwgbIyBT+OEq18meE0JkqJKoYeZ2DMP7eAo=
— wit h7ghDsJGkhWLaPO7+TIZQUenslhiQh/E/TKWU4ddphpFcuylQBZM2kG/o8H1nyPfUT0MkbvnFqPFfHPH3OaN5W1EwAI= — wit h7ghDsbQuWAI5VIGw+jiEAMHeSpDVlubOR46YIEuxL5TWkxU1xAtrp4gwgKxCV+q72A9mZC6APgyaCAUi78euiV/SA8=
Binary file not shown.
+3 -3
View File
@@ -1,9 +1,9 @@
["receipt","npc15pn6675z5","37b3025b54c6397e5f8d400912b5788cd6ce203059cd9143e7d521c2cdbf2917"] ["receipt","vskq18t5sxydz","7fccee1468b9ef9bf712279f10d13f5544abb79db03e33b122a2504a3cf25789"]
["receipt","y2zw8ctg5s8dp","ae17f8866a05ca1b671d96b7758984e11ac694acd6743835f107cb513c7cc600"] ["receipt","fhhvg9qrzqp0n","f78c7704df1fbd815ac3ccf9114c82a189f9032ffcd75023e10b27b924f406b5"]
["receipt","mvjmb94nz7rdh","a4dca8b492bf3e1b190f22e09de77713523e345526fd1b01c1186d0fe80d1cf4"] ["receipt","mvjmb94nz7rdh","a4dca8b492bf3e1b190f22e09de77713523e345526fd1b01c1186d0fe80d1cf4"]
["receipt","q465jpwz8afhe","39218b2b73e853e2e66d8d4ce68cf7e155ca001f05ee4da5942a8d9b63b216bc"] ["receipt","q465jpwz8afhe","39218b2b73e853e2e66d8d4ce68cf7e155ca001f05ee4da5942a8d9b63b216bc"]
["revocation","pcbhtpwvysgq6","9062e3ab737ecc2e6d487d2076ee27f764be60f06ad01f1ad103d708d466e56a"] ["revocation","pcbhtpwvysgq6","9062e3ab737ecc2e6d487d2076ee27f764be60f06ad01f1ad103d708d466e56a"]
["receipt","gx2s84z9jf9xv","5ee8b2827d327a7bbcacb08fd19b9523fad83ebf6c29350d5ce7ca30bf5ce388"] ["receipt","gx2s84z9jf9xv","5ee8b2827d327a7bbcacb08fd19b9523fad83ebf6c29350d5ce7ca30bf5ce388"]
["receipt","mg18668nzxvap","4c80506322bfeed5649cfab303959e4ccf0aa0e594995ee6fd5ad59f9d3ee6a7"] ["receipt","ksx5sc327xp97","1fcf4b960c47ed927b2f9599bc7e54221e35b2e1c001d46d92fc18505f219395"]
["receipt","yt70fcc3qm0xb","2ad1c0f63077a03ab1cce01e6235734577d0b072b90ebab2f7db7fd481ccee2c"] ["receipt","yt70fcc3qm0xb","2ad1c0f63077a03ab1cce01e6235734577d0b072b90ebab2f7db7fd481ccee2c"]
["roster","smithlab","782c5e68f4e4f9918e69b7a44b108d9d70c89a289981acff3d25300ec8373c15"] ["roster","smithlab","782c5e68f4e4f9918e69b7a44b108d9d70c89a289981acff3d25300ec8373c15"]
+1 -1
View File
@@ -1 +1 @@
{"claims":{"lode":"amber"},"datasets":["ds-hale-bond-params","ds-hale-ctct-scan"],"documents":[{"doc":"smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","reason":"The bond constants we start from.","status":{"Ben Example":"read","Cara Example":"reading"},"tags":["parameters"]},{"doc":"okafor2025solvent-acth","reason":"Solvent shifts for the validation set.","tags":["spectra"]}],"drafts":["smithlab/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3"],"format":"scienting-project/1","key":"smithlab-charges","layers":["tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/kp4m2x7q"],"members":[{"keys":["ana"],"person":"Ana Example","role":"owner"},{"keys":["ben","ben-spot"],"person":"Ben Example","role":"editor"},{"keys":["cara"],"person":"Cara Example","role":"reader"}],"name":"Charges and bonds","paths":[{"id":"onboarding","steps":[{"note":"Read the introduction.","ref":"smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"document"},{"note":"Then the table.","ref":"smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb#hj4s7pb","type":"node"},{"ref":"lode:amber/k-bond","type":"claim"}],"title":"First week"}],"settings":{"digit_rule":"anchored-sections","drift_threshold":"0.25","log":{"origin":"scient.ing/log/smithlab","threshold":1,"witnesses":["wit"]},"rights_unknown":"refuse","spot_check":{"minimum":10,"rate":"0.05"},"stages":"scienting-stages-default"},"store":"smithlab","views":["ctct-scan"]} {"claims":{"paperclaim":"amber"},"datasets":["ds-hale-bond-params","ds-hale-ctct-scan"],"documents":[{"doc":"smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","reason":"The bond constants we start from.","status":{"Ben Example":"read","Cara Example":"reading"},"tags":["parameters"]},{"doc":"okafor2025solvent-acth","reason":"Solvent shifts for the validation set.","tags":["spectra"]}],"drafts":["smithlab/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3"],"format":"scienting-project/1","key":"smithlab-charges","layers":["tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/kp4m2x7q","tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/tr6c3q8m"],"members":[{"keys":["ana"],"person":"Ana Example","role":"owner"},{"keys":["ben","ben-spot"],"person":"Ben Example","role":"editor"},{"keys":["cara"],"person":"Cara Example","role":"reader"}],"name":"Charges and bonds","paths":[{"id":"onboarding","steps":[{"note":"Read the introduction.","ref":"smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"document"},{"note":"Then the table.","ref":"smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb#hj4s7pb","type":"node"},{"note":"The bond force constant, amber/k-bond.","ref":"claim:272XTX7C","type":"claim"}],"title":"First week"}],"settings":{"digit_rule":"anchored-sections","drift_threshold":"0.25","log":{"origin":"scient.ing/log/smithlab","threshold":1,"witnesses":["wit"]},"rights_unknown":"refuse","spot_check":{"minimum":10,"rate":"0.05"},"stages":"scienting-stages-default"},"store":"smithlab","views":["ctct-scan"]}
+1 -1
View File
@@ -1 +1 @@
{"format":"scienting-proof/1","index":3,"item":["node","c20cna6","c8e6a553f5ae1377776e86dde6ee7d48a923dea7de417408841ea33b81563272"],"kind":"inclusion","path":["1344d74efcc8182f2a1ac7501fc4a3b888bfd753b1cc9c4c02562d7d51b91a1d","be61b225edd17fe256a73b79b26c2be1e2cc43d370ba4c9e7f0536b12c305650","abe0ffd73517576e3c64411f54f854fb008b13a828695d1f9e3059cfb9bfd2cd","0497554cb70abf31d1bf919cf74b62652e21a5c4ed1875c951971ddada26bc3e","c352582a32865ce563529803845821c0227a85e06490dc069cb945a80fc9cfa9"],"receipt":"y2zw8ctg5s8dp","root":"373a7d860a14b58e5bfa9b9ad3bc916091bcb6db7556f0dbc9c71972a612494d","size":23} {"format":"scienting-proof/1","index":3,"item":["node","c20cna6","c8e6a553f5ae1377776e86dde6ee7d48a923dea7de417408841ea33b81563272"],"kind":"inclusion","path":["1344d74efcc8182f2a1ac7501fc4a3b888bfd753b1cc9c4c02562d7d51b91a1d","be61b225edd17fe256a73b79b26c2be1e2cc43d370ba4c9e7f0536b12c305650","abe0ffd73517576e3c64411f54f854fb008b13a828695d1f9e3059cfb9bfd2cd","0497554cb70abf31d1bf919cf74b62652e21a5c4ed1875c951971ddada26bc3e","c352582a32865ce563529803845821c0227a85e06490dc069cb945a80fc9cfa9"],"receipt":"fhhvg9qrzqp0n","root":"373a7d860a14b58e5bfa9b9ad3bc916091bcb6db7556f0dbc9c71972a612494d","size":23}
+1 -1
View File
@@ -1 +1 @@
{"at":"2026-10-12T10:00:00Z","by":"ana","delivery":"smithlab evidence pilot (fictional)","docs":["smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb"],"format":"scienting-qa-report/1","id":"b6dt4h4pv0x98","receipts":["y2zw8ctg5s8dp","gx2s84z9jf9xv"],"reviewers":[{"bound":"0.316340","confidence":"0.95","errors":1,"key":"ana","method":"clopper-pearson","sampled":13}],"signature":{"key":"ana","scheme":"ed25519","value":"7nFBiJ2csiX8Y0lgn3Tp5+7IKlMUMRfVEN3B3pdrgw3rCdEG2VXJaafoJ2lClb19Io2bMpfww3k0epkKfef/Dw=="}} {"at":"2026-10-12T10:00:00Z","by":"ana","delivery":"smithlab evidence pilot (fictional)","docs":["smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb"],"format":"scienting-qa-report/1","id":"whqq47rxzzkp6","receipts":["fhhvg9qrzqp0n","gx2s84z9jf9xv"],"reviewers":[{"bound":"0.316340","confidence":"0.95","errors":1,"key":"ana","method":"clopper-pearson","sampled":13}],"signature":{"key":"ana","scheme":"ed25519","value":"mLB9WGnX0DbRzug2n946waD7c7oWi+MAR4TB1n/ezpeflZBMaP5onaH9vtkm4ztI13rb/Ej04IDIUpBonTq9AA=="}}
@@ -0,0 +1,4 @@
{"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"kind":"trace","note":"The abstract states the two steps: a scan first, then vibrational frequencies.","proposer":{"model":{"name":"example-model","parameters":"998b5161e39e01c8bc43ef81ec89141e15b7ea53b2e936707920a6097dbcb2c5","processor":"local","prompt":"9cc338fba7c62db7266f530cb555a5ee36910d41a0120a3fe7fd7de1944d0931","provider":"Example Models (illustrative)","version":"2026-09","weights":"504b2d340045b92c22682b60020c21103aae7ff41172bb632fbe305eb4af9b5e"},"rank":1,"run":"illustrative-run-2","score":"0.8731"},"reference":"ebcq5cy","selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"mhp0at8","node_hash":"ee42c4780724a411697e3a95daf182d37c792d4689a7172f32929785d5fd968e","own_hash":"24cc437784bf358d639755dbf59984ad2c0c7a0e7f9448b23e965039b67f759b","quote":{"exact":"in two steps","prefix":"bond constants for twelve bonds ","suffix":", first to a scan and then to vi"},"rev":12,"span":[48,60],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"in two steps","prefix":"bond constants for twelve bonds ","suffix":", first to a scan and then to vi","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource","verdict":"supports"},"created":"2026-10-12T09:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:software:example-model","name":"A model (illustrative)","type":"Software"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/jh0e4st2c0kpt","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/tr6c3q8m","motivation":"linking","receipt":"qvckzaatz5d1v","status":"confirmed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"93a39490870e694299e88e6f475d42c38078d1442959e555bdbdf58488dcf187","own_hash":"e004436e7b28ff3dc41e0056f231ba707d9be985694e68acb911345a547842ed","quote":{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1"},"rev":0,"span":[26,38],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"}
{"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"kind":"trace","note":"Says harmonic terms are common, not how the constants were fitted.","proposer":{"model":{"name":"example-model","parameters":"998b5161e39e01c8bc43ef81ec89141e15b7ea53b2e936707920a6097dbcb2c5","processor":"local","prompt":"9cc338fba7c62db7266f530cb555a5ee36910d41a0120a3fe7fd7de1944d0931","provider":"Example Models (illustrative)","version":"2026-09","weights":"504b2d340045b92c22682b60020c21103aae7ff41172bb632fbe305eb4af9b5e"},"rank":2,"run":"illustrative-run-2","score":"0.6410"},"reference":"ebcq5cy","selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"kea5026","node_hash":"b836d5872ca37471fa996be04c538254a8b1e37ca12e8f1b4a40837b503afa33","own_hash":"d673d236c03d9583ecf6e01fa819765ec324dc684bd9bbc6967fa50f216e34d2","quote":{"exact":"classical force fields.1","prefix":"ption of covalent stretching in "},"rev":12,"span":[81,105],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"classical force fields.1","prefix":"ption of covalent stretching in ","suffix":"","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource"},"created":"2026-10-12T09:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:software:example-model","name":"A model (illustrative)","type":"Software"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/arm3zmj6be9fz","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/tr6c3q8m","motivation":"linking","status":"rejected","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"93a39490870e694299e88e6f475d42c38078d1442959e555bdbdf58488dcf187","own_hash":"e004436e7b28ff3dc41e0056f231ba707d9be985694e68acb911345a547842ed","quote":{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1"},"rev":0,"span":[26,38],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"}
{"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"kind":"trace","note":"Table 1 lists the fitted constants of both parameter sets.","reference":"ebcq5cy","selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"table","node":"hj4s7pb","node_hash":"6c6fba200faf41cd06fa8b64e06e2aa29ff8848568b859ae42d1902596348643","own_hash":"66310a9ab1c92568f4c6cae012e35d4245d4ca4b89d2542b7c2113a31ad379ed","rev":12,"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource","verdict":"supports"},"created":"2026-10-12T09:10:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:key:ana","name":"Ana Example","type":"Person"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/fhnynfb8jx0wc","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/tr6c3q8m","motivation":"linking","receipt":"qvckzaatz5d1v","status":"confirmed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"93a39490870e694299e88e6f475d42c38078d1442959e555bdbdf58488dcf187","own_hash":"e004436e7b28ff3dc41e0056f231ba707d9be985694e68acb911345a547842ed","quote":{"exact":"Its constants come from a two-step fit (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1"},"rev":0,"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"Its constants come from a two-step fit (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1","prefix":"","suffix":"","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"}
{"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"category":"critique","kind":"comment","type":"TextualBody","value":"The abstract names the two steps but not the constants; the table is the better passage."},"created":"2026-10-12T10:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:key:ben","name":"Ben Example","type":"Person"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/g4fm8f93czwkk","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/tr6c3q8m","motivation":"assessing","status":"proposed","target":{"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/jh0e4st2c0kpt","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"}
+1
View File
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
{"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"audience":"expert","created":"2026-10-12T09:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:key:ana","name":"Ana Example","type":"Person"},"docs":["smithlab/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3"],"format":"scienting-layer/1","id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/tr6c3q8m","label":"Where the draft's citations lead","license":{"spdx":"CC-BY-4.0"},"project":"smithlab-charges","purpose":"Traces from the draft's citations of Hale and Osei to the passages they rest on.","total":4,"type":"AnnotationCollection","visibility":"team"}
+1
View File
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
{"at":"2026-10-12T09:30:00Z","by":"ana","doc":"writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","evidence":[],"format":"scienting-receipt/1","id":"qvckzaatz5d1v","level":"F3","nodes":[],"records":[["annotation","fhnynfb8jx0wc","a1115243473b190f7ed8877780f29c935f29801d6c9fe0b423601247ebf078f8"],["annotation","jh0e4st2c0kpt","b774528344f096051420b6df73c089fdce4d0e1093e4ea3d845fff023c17dee7"]],"rev":0,"root":"d1b96ae5b9887ae843cd209d7da5ea9bb454f1bab77b93d05d38fbfc2b21e826","scope":"targeted:traces","signature":{"key":"ana","scheme":"ed25519","value":"d2xj2bQY3AoDEVV7yzs31mQpMoGre+V919NUM/Ba/qj+ySb1QKs7D9ZidM6+ksl1xlNsCLNU2rdeclUduoZZBA=="}}
+2 -2
View File
@@ -153,8 +153,8 @@
"paragraph-moved": {"node": "@para7"} "paragraph-moved": {"node": "@para7"}
}, },
"receipts": [ "receipts": [
{"name": "r0", "by": "ana", "level": "F3", "scope": "targeted:lode", "at": "2026-10-01T16:00:00Z", "rev": 0, "nodes": ["@cc_ak", "@cc_br", "@cc_ar"], "crops": true}, {"name": "r0", "by": "ana", "level": "F3", "scope": "targeted:paperclaim", "at": "2026-10-01T16:00:00Z", "rev": 0, "nodes": ["@cc_ak", "@cc_br", "@cc_ar"], "crops": true},
{"name": "r1", "by": "ana", "level": "F3", "scope": "targeted:lode", "at": "2026-10-11T15:02:11Z", "nodes": ["@cc", "@cc_ak", "@cc_ar", "@cc_bk", "@cc_br", "@ch2", "@ch2_ak", "@ch2_ar", "@ch2_bk", "@ch2_br", "@ow", "@ow_ak", "@ow_ar", "@ow_bk", "@ow_br", "@h_ak", "@h_ar", "@h_bk", "@h_br", "@s2", "@eq1", "@s3", "@s4"], "crops": true}, {"name": "r1", "by": "ana", "level": "F3", "scope": "targeted:paperclaim", "at": "2026-10-11T15:02:11Z", "nodes": ["@cc", "@cc_ak", "@cc_ar", "@cc_bk", "@cc_br", "@ch2", "@ch2_ak", "@ch2_ar", "@ch2_bk", "@ch2_br", "@ow", "@ow_ak", "@ow_ar", "@ow_bk", "@ow_br", "@h_ak", "@h_ar", "@h_bk", "@h_br", "@s2", "@eq1", "@s3", "@s4"], "crops": true},
{"name": "q1", "qa_of": "r1", "by": "ben", "key": "ben-spot", "at": "2026-10-12T09:00:00Z", "errors": []}, {"name": "q1", "qa_of": "r1", "by": "ben", "key": "ben-spot", "at": "2026-10-12T09:00:00Z", "errors": []},
{"name": "r2", "by": "ana", "level": "F3", "scope": "section:@sec1", "at": "2026-10-11T16:30:00Z", "nodes": ["@s1", "@s5"], "crops": true}, {"name": "r2", "by": "ana", "level": "F3", "scope": "section:@sec1", "at": "2026-10-11T16:30:00Z", "nodes": ["@s1", "@s5"], "crops": true},
{"name": "r3", "by": "cara", "level": "F3", "scope": "page:2", "at": "2026-10-11T17:00:00Z", "nodes": ["@s6a", "@s7", "@fns"], "crops": true}, {"name": "r3", "by": "cara", "level": "F3", "scope": "page:2", "at": "2026-10-11T17:00:00Z", "nodes": ["@s6a", "@s7", "@fns"], "crops": true},
+52 -2
View File
@@ -5,9 +5,14 @@
"rules": [ "rules": [
{ {
"id": "correction.digits", "id": "correction.digits",
"description": "A digit changes without crop evidence, or a leaf's digits change undeclared.", "description": "A digit changes without crop evidence, an emend changes a digit or edits beside one, or a leaf's digits change undeclared.",
"chapter": "spec/22-conformance.md" "chapter": "spec/22-conformance.md"
}, },
{
"id": "correction.emend",
"description": "An emend targets no runs, falls in math or across runs, or another operation changes an emended run or writes `printed`.",
"chapter": "spec/11-corrections.md"
},
{ {
"id": "correction.evidence", "id": "correction.evidence",
"description": "An insert has no crop evidence.", "description": "An insert has no crop evidence.",
@@ -48,11 +53,21 @@
"description": "The kind takes no label.", "description": "The kind takes no label.",
"chapter": "spec/22-conformance.md" "chapter": "spec/22-conformance.md"
}, },
{
"id": "correction.relink",
"description": "A relink names no text or cite run of a node with runs, or unlinks a run that is not a cite.",
"chapter": "spec/11-corrections.md"
},
{ {
"id": "correction.replace", "id": "correction.replace",
"description": "Runs replace text outside a text run, or include an equation run.", "description": "Runs replace text outside a text run, or include an equation run.",
"chapter": "spec/22-conformance.md" "chapter": "spec/22-conformance.md"
}, },
{
"id": "correction.resolve",
"description": "A resolve names a node that is not a reference, or a resolution that is not doi, document or none.",
"chapter": "spec/11-corrections.md"
},
{ {
"id": "correction.schema", "id": "correction.schema",
"description": "A proposed correction does not match the correction schema.", "description": "A proposed correction does not match the correction schema.",
@@ -88,11 +103,26 @@
"description": "Correction indexes do not count from 1 without gaps.", "description": "Correction indexes do not count from 1 without gaps.",
"chapter": "spec/22-conformance.md" "chapter": "spec/22-conformance.md"
}, },
{
"id": "doc.correction.resolution",
"description": "The last resolve of a reference does not end at its resolution in references.jsonl.",
"chapter": "spec/11-corrections.md"
},
{ {
"id": "doc.correction.rev", "id": "doc.correction.rev",
"description": "document.json's rev is not the number of corrections.", "description": "document.json's rev is not the number of corrections.",
"chapter": "spec/22-conformance.md" "chapter": "spec/22-conformance.md"
}, },
{
"id": "doc.derived.math",
"description": "A line of derived/math.jsonl names a formula that is not TeX, says it is complete when its tree has an opaque node or the reverse, or lists symbols that are not the sym keys of its tree.",
"chapter": "spec/09-figures-tables-equations.md"
},
{
"id": "doc.derived.node",
"description": "A line of a derived file names no equation, equation line or math run of the package.",
"chapter": "spec/12-package.md"
},
{ {
"id": "doc.fidelity.report", "id": "doc.fidelity.report",
"description": "document.json's fidelity distribution does not recompute.", "description": "document.json's fidelity distribution does not recompute.",
@@ -188,6 +218,11 @@
"description": "A location's page_fp is not a page of any witness.", "description": "A location's page_fp is not a page of any witness.",
"chapter": "spec/22-conformance.md" "chapter": "spec/22-conformance.md"
}, },
{
"id": "doc.math.form",
"description": "A source with a form is not that form's canonical spelling. Only a validator that implements the form can check it; the reference validator does not.",
"chapter": "spec/03-nodes.md"
},
{ {
"id": "doc.node.attrs", "id": "doc.node.attrs",
"description": "A section has no level.", "description": "A section has no level.",
@@ -330,7 +365,7 @@
}, },
{ {
"id": "doc.run.canonical", "id": "doc.run.canonical",
"description": "Runs are not canonical: an empty text run, or two adjacent text runs with the same styles.", "description": "Runs are not canonical: an empty text run, two adjacent text runs with the same styles and no `printed`, or a `printed` equal to its run's text.",
"chapter": "spec/22-conformance.md" "chapter": "spec/22-conformance.md"
}, },
{ {
@@ -363,6 +398,11 @@
"description": "A same-document xref names no node.", "description": "A same-document xref names no node.",
"chapter": "spec/22-conformance.md" "chapter": "spec/22-conformance.md"
}, },
{
"id": "doc.suspect.witness",
"description": "A suspect names a witness the package does not have.",
"chapter": "spec/22-conformance.md"
},
{ {
"id": "doc.table.header", "id": "doc.table.header",
"description": "A column or row header path names a node that is not a cell.", "description": "A column or row header path names a node that is not a cell.",
@@ -408,6 +448,16 @@
"description": "The exercise kind is unknown.", "description": "The exercise kind is unknown.",
"chapter": "spec/22-conformance.md" "chapter": "spec/22-conformance.md"
}, },
{
"id": "layer.trace.source",
"description": "A trace's passage is not in the document its source names, its source is the citing document, its selector has no AnchorSelector, or its TextQuoteSelector does not repeat the anchor's plain quote.",
"chapter": "spec/18-layers.md"
},
{
"id": "layer.trace.target",
"description": "A trace's target is not a leaf with runs of the citing document selected by an AnchorSelector, or its sentence does not cite the reference the trace names.",
"chapter": "spec/18-layers.md"
},
{ {
"id": "package.file.canonical", "id": "package.file.canonical",
"description": "A JSON or JSON Lines record is not in canonical JSON.", "description": "A JSON or JSON Lines record is not in canonical JSON.",
+4 -3
View File
@@ -1,6 +1,6 @@
# Schemas # Schemas
This folder holds the JSON (JavaScript Object Notation) Schemas (draft 2020-12) for every file and record that the paperspec formats (paperspec is the specification this repository holds) define: 42 schema files. This folder holds the JSON (JavaScript Object Notation) Schemas (draft 2020-12) for every file and record that the paperspec formats (paperspec is the specification this repository holds) define: 43 schema files.
A JSON Schema is a file, itself written in JSON, that states what a valid JSON file looks like. A JSON Schema is a file, itself written in JSON, that states what a valid JSON file looks like.
Newcomers can read it as a form: it lists the fields a record must have and what kind of value each field takes. Newcomers can read it as a form: it lists the fields a record must have and what kind of value each field takes.
Implementers will find the loading recipe and the traps under "Validating" and "Writing schemas". Implementers will find the loading recipe and the traps under "Validating" and "Writing schemas".
@@ -20,7 +20,7 @@ The number after each name is the chapter of `spec/` that defines the file.
| Topic | Schemas (chapter) | | Topic | Schemas (chapter) |
| --- | --- | | --- | --- |
| Shared definitions | `common.schema.json` (1): hashes, IDs, keys, addresses, times, decimals, boxes, licenses, signatures, evidence, quotes. | | Shared definitions | `common.schema.json` (1): hashes, IDs, keys, addresses, times, decimals, boxes, licenses, signatures, evidence, quotes. |
| A package | `manifest.schema.json` (12), `document.schema.json` (2, 12), `node.schema.json` (3), `runs.schema.json` (3), `witnesses.schema.json` (2), `provenance.schema.json` (12), `page.schema.json` (7), `location.schema.json` (7), `reference.schema.json` (10), `id-entry.schema.json` (4), `correction.schema.json` (11), `receipt.schema.json` (8), `revocation.schema.json` (8), `roster.schema.json` (8), `suspect.schema.json` (5), `mathml.schema.json` (12) | | A package | `manifest.schema.json` (12), `document.schema.json` (2, 12), `node.schema.json` (3), `runs.schema.json` (3), `witnesses.schema.json` (2), `provenance.schema.json` (12), `page.schema.json` (7), `location.schema.json` (7), `reference.schema.json` (10), `id-entry.schema.json` (4), `correction.schema.json` (11), `receipt.schema.json` (8), `revocation.schema.json` (8), `roster.schema.json` (8), `suspect.schema.json` (5), `mathml.schema.json` (12), `math.schema.json` (9, 12) |
| Pointing into documents | `anchor.schema.json` (6) | | Pointing into documents | `anchor.schema.json` (6) |
| Rights | `rights.schema.json` (14), `policy.schema.json` (14), `stages.schema.json` (14), `backend.schema.json` (14), `profile.schema.json` (14), `stamps.schema.json` (7) | | Rights | `rights.schema.json` (14), `policy.schema.json` (14), `stages.schema.json` (14), `backend.schema.json` (14), `profile.schema.json` (14), `stamps.schema.json` (7) |
| Review | `qa-report.schema.json` (8), `spot-check.schema.json` (8), `checklist.schema.json` (8), `proof.schema.json` (8, 11) | | Review | `qa-report.schema.json` (8), `spot-check.schema.json` (8), `checklist.schema.json` (8), `proof.schema.json` (8, 11) |
@@ -37,7 +37,8 @@ The Data schemas for datasets, digitizations and views, the Teams and drafts sch
The rest belong to `candidate` formats or to no format of their own. The rest belong to `candidate` formats or to no format of their own.
The bundle has no JSON Schema: its registry entry points to `sql/bundle-sqlite.sql`. The bundle has no JSON Schema: its registry entry points to `sql/bundle-sqlite.sql`.
Of the 42 schemas, 11 have no format of their own because each describes a line or part of a larger file: `common`, `node`, `runs`, `witnesses`, `provenance`, `location`, `reference`, `id-entry`, `mathml`, `annotation` and `value-anchor`. Of the 43 schemas, 12 have no format of their own because each describes a line or part of a larger file: `common`, `node`, `runs`, `witnesses`, `provenance`, `location`, `reference`, `id-entry`, `mathml`, `math`, `annotation` and `value-anchor`.
A line of `derived/math.jsonl` carries `form`, the math form `scienting-math/1` it reads the formula in; that names a spelling of TeX, which papermath implements ([spec/09 §9.4](../spec/09-figures-tables-equations.md#94-the-math-form)), not a file format, so the registry does not list it.
Of the schemas that do have one, 27 require a `format` property; `spot-check.schema.json` describes the input a VRF proof is made over rather than a file. Of the schemas that do have one, 27 require a `format` property; `spot-check.schema.json` describes the input a VRF proof is made over rather than a file.
The others (`page`, `draft-ids`, `view` and `log-entry`) describe a line of a file, a Vega-Lite specification (a JSON description of a chart) or an item of a tree, and the record itself does not need to carry the identifier. The others (`page`, `draft-ids`, `view` and `log-entry`) describe a line of a file, a Vega-Lite specification (a JSON description of a chart) or an item of a tree, and the record itself does not need to carry the identifier.
+190 -7
View File
@@ -3,6 +3,64 @@
"$id": "https://paperspec.scient.ing/schemas/annotation.schema.json", "$id": "https://paperspec.scient.ing/schemas/annotation.schema.json",
"title": "Annotation", "title": "Annotation",
"description": "One line of annotations.jsonl in scienting-layer/1: a W3C Web Annotation; spec/18-layers.md.", "description": "One line of annotations.jsonl in scienting-layer/1: a W3C Web Annotation; spec/18-layers.md.",
"$defs": {
"category": {
"description": "What a comment, caveat or question is about (spec/18 §18.4).",
"enum": [
"comment",
"context",
"critique",
"question",
"correction",
"feedback",
"resource"
]
},
"selector": {
"description": "A selector of a passage: the AnchorSelector, or the standard TextQuoteSelector that repeats the anchor's plain quote for tools that do not know ours (spec/18 §18.3).",
"oneOf": [
{
"type": "object",
"properties": {
"type": {
"const": "AnchorSelector"
},
"anchor": {
"$ref": "anchor.schema.json"
}
},
"required": [
"type",
"anchor"
],
"additionalProperties": false
},
{
"type": "object",
"properties": {
"type": {
"const": "TextQuoteSelector"
},
"exact": {
"type": "string",
"minLength": 1
},
"prefix": {
"type": "string"
},
"suffix": {
"type": "string"
}
},
"required": [
"type",
"exact"
],
"additionalProperties": false
}
]
}
},
"type": "object", "type": "object",
"properties": { "properties": {
"@context": { "@context": {
@@ -97,15 +155,13 @@
"const": "SpecificResource" "const": "SpecificResource"
}, },
"source": { "source": {
"type": "string", "$ref": "common.schema.json#/$defs/claimRef"
"minLength": 1
}, },
"kind": { "kind": {
"const": "claim-link" "const": "claim-link"
}, },
"pin": { "pin": {
"type": "string", "$ref": "common.schema.json#/$defs/claimPin"
"minLength": 1
}, },
"role": { "role": {
"enum": [ "enum": [
@@ -130,17 +186,21 @@
"const": "SpecificResource" "const": "SpecificResource"
}, },
"source": { "source": {
"type": "string", "$ref": "common.schema.json#/$defs/claimRef"
"minLength": 1
}, },
"kind": { "kind": {
"const": "symbol" "const": "symbol"
}, },
"pin": { "pin": {
"$ref": "common.schema.json#/$defs/claimPin"
},
"key": {
"description": "The symbol's scienting-math/1 key, which the symbol claim's notation has too (spec/09 §9.4, spec/18 §18.4).",
"type": "string", "type": "string",
"minLength": 1 "minLength": 1
}, },
"symbol": { "symbol": {
"description": "The symbol as the span writes it.",
"type": "string", "type": "string",
"minLength": 1 "minLength": 1
} }
@@ -148,7 +208,8 @@
"required": [ "required": [
"type", "type",
"kind", "kind",
"source" "source",
"key"
], ],
"additionalProperties": false "additionalProperties": false
}, },
@@ -173,6 +234,9 @@
}, },
"kind": { "kind": {
"const": "comment" "const": "comment"
},
"category": {
"$ref": "#/$defs/category"
} }
}, },
"required": [ "required": [
@@ -203,6 +267,9 @@
}, },
"kind": { "kind": {
"const": "caveat" "const": "caveat"
},
"category": {
"$ref": "#/$defs/category"
} }
}, },
"required": [ "required": [
@@ -240,6 +307,9 @@
"group", "group",
"authors" "authors"
] ]
},
"category": {
"$ref": "#/$defs/category"
} }
}, },
"required": [ "required": [
@@ -397,6 +467,79 @@
], ],
"additionalProperties": false "additionalProperties": false
}, },
{
"type": "object",
"properties": {
"type": {
"const": "SpecificResource"
},
"kind": {
"const": "trace"
},
"source": {
"description": "The cited document, as a target's source names a document.",
"type": "string",
"pattern": "^tag:scient\\.ing,2026:doc:[a-z0-9][a-z0-9._-]*/[a-z][a-z0-9]*-[0-9a-hjkmnp-tv-z]{4,51}(\\.[a-z0-9][a-z0-9-]*)*$"
},
"selector": {
"description": "The passage of the cited document: an AnchorSelector, then a TextQuoteSelector when the anchor's quote is plain.",
"type": "array",
"items": {
"$ref": "#/$defs/selector"
},
"minItems": 1
},
"reference": {
"description": "The reference node of the citing document that the target's sentence cites and the trace is about.",
"$ref": "common.schema.json#/$defs/nodeId"
},
"note": {
"type": "string",
"minLength": 1
},
"verdict": {
"enum": [
"supports",
"partly",
"does-not",
"cannot-tell"
]
},
"proposer": {
"description": "The tool that proposed the trace, required when the annotation's creator is Software (spec/18 §18.4).",
"type": "object",
"properties": {
"model": {
"$ref": "common.schema.json#/$defs/model"
},
"run": {
"type": "string",
"minLength": 1
},
"score": {
"$ref": "common.schema.json#/$defs/decimal"
},
"rank": {
"type": "integer",
"minimum": 1
}
},
"required": [
"model",
"run"
],
"additionalProperties": false
}
},
"required": [
"type",
"kind",
"source",
"selector",
"reference"
],
"additionalProperties": false
},
{ {
"type": "object", "type": "object",
"properties": { "properties": {
@@ -738,6 +881,46 @@
"receipt" "receipt"
] ]
} }
},
{
"description": "A tool's trace names the tool and the run that proposed it (spec/18 §18.4).",
"if": {
"properties": {
"creator": {
"properties": {
"type": {
"const": "Software"
}
},
"required": [
"type"
]
},
"body": {
"properties": {
"kind": {
"const": "trace"
}
},
"required": [
"kind"
]
}
},
"required": [
"creator",
"body"
]
},
"then": {
"properties": {
"body": {
"required": [
"proposer"
]
}
}
}
} }
] ]
} }
+16
View File
@@ -71,6 +71,22 @@
"type": "string", "type": "string",
"pattern": "^([a-z0-9][a-z0-9._-]*/)?[a-z][a-z0-9]*-[0-9a-hjkmnp-tv-z]{4,51}(\\.[a-z0-9][a-z0-9-]*)*#[a-z0-9][a-z0-9._-]*(@[0-9a-f]{6})?(\\[(0|[1-9][0-9]*):(0|[1-9][0-9]*)\\])?$" "pattern": "^([a-z0-9][a-z0-9._-]*/)?[a-z][a-z0-9]*-[0-9a-hjkmnp-tv-z]{4,51}(\\.[a-z0-9][a-z0-9-]*)*#[a-z0-9][a-z0-9._-]*(@[0-9a-f]{6})?(\\[(0|[1-9][0-9]*):(0|[1-9][0-9]*)\\])?$"
}, },
"claimRef": {
"type": "string",
"pattern": "^claim:([a-z0-9.-]+\\.[a-z]{2,}/)?[0-9A-HJKMNP-TV-Z]{8}$",
"description": "A claim in a paperclaim store: claim:TAG, or claim:host/TAG for another store, TAG eight Crockford base32 capitals (spec/18 §18.4)."
},
"claimPin": {
"type": "string",
"pattern": "^claim:([a-z0-9.-]+\\.[a-z]{2,}/)?[0-9A-HJKMNP-TV-Z]{8}@[0-9a-f]{6}$",
"description": "A claim pinned to its statement: the claim's reference, @ and the first six hex digits of its statement hash (spec/18 §18.4)."
},
"mathForm": {
"enum": [
"scienting-math/1"
],
"description": "The form a math source is spelled in; scienting-math/1 is canonical TeX (spec/03 §3.7, spec/09 §9.4)."
},
"time": { "time": {
"type": "string", "type": "string",
"pattern": "^[0-9]{4}-[0-1][0-9]-[0-3][0-9]T[0-2][0-9]:[0-5][0-9]:[0-6][0-9]Z$" "pattern": "^[0-9]{4}-[0-1][0-9]-[0-3][0-9]T[0-2][0-9]:[0-5][0-9]:[0-6][0-9]Z$"
+109 -1
View File
@@ -3,6 +3,18 @@
"$id": "https://paperspec.scient.ing/schemas/correction.schema.json", "$id": "https://paperspec.scient.ing/schemas/correction.schema.json",
"title": "Correction", "title": "Correction",
"description": "scienting-correction/1: a line of corrections.jsonl, or a proposal; spec/11-corrections.md.", "description": "scienting-correction/1: a line of corrections.jsonl, or a proposal; spec/11-corrections.md.",
"$defs": {
"emendKind": {
"enum": [
"typo",
"spelling",
"grammar",
"punctuation",
"wording",
"other"
]
}
},
"type": "object", "type": "object",
"properties": { "properties": {
"format": { "format": {
@@ -25,7 +37,10 @@
"move", "move",
"reclassify", "reclassify",
"relabel", "relabel",
"set" "set",
"emend",
"relink",
"resolve"
] ]
}, },
"target": { "target": {
@@ -71,8 +86,39 @@
"type": "string" "type": "string"
}, },
"kind": { "kind": {
"description": "A reclassify's new node kind, or what an emend corrects.",
"anyOf": [
{
"$ref": "common.schema.json#/$defs/nodeKind" "$ref": "common.schema.json#/$defs/nodeKind"
}, },
{
"$ref": "#/$defs/emendKind"
}
]
},
"note": {
"type": "string",
"minLength": 1
},
"refs": {
"description": "A relink's references: reference node IDs, or null to unlink.",
"anyOf": [
{
"type": "array",
"items": {
"$ref": "common.schema.json#/$defs/nodeId"
},
"minItems": 1,
"uniqueItems": true
},
{
"type": "null"
}
]
},
"resolution": {
"$ref": "reference.schema.json#/properties/resolution"
},
"label": { "label": {
"anyOf": [ "anyOf": [
{ {
@@ -287,12 +333,74 @@
} }
}, },
"then": { "then": {
"properties": {
"kind": {
"$ref": "common.schema.json#/$defs/nodeKind"
}
},
"required": [ "required": [
"target", "target",
"kind" "kind"
] ]
} }
}, },
{
"if": {
"properties": {
"op": {
"const": "emend"
}
}
},
"then": {
"properties": {
"replace": {
"type": "string",
"minLength": 1
},
"kind": {
"$ref": "#/$defs/emendKind"
}
},
"required": [
"target",
"find",
"replace",
"kind"
]
}
},
{
"if": {
"properties": {
"op": {
"const": "relink"
}
}
},
"then": {
"required": [
"target",
"run",
"refs"
]
}
},
{
"if": {
"properties": {
"op": {
"const": "resolve"
}
}
},
"then": {
"required": [
"target",
"resolution"
]
}
},
{ {
"if": { "if": {
"properties": { "properties": {
+8 -1
View File
@@ -47,8 +47,15 @@
"same_as": { "same_as": {
"type": "array", "type": "array",
"items": { "items": {
"anyOf": [
{
"type": "string", "type": "string",
"pattern": "^(doi|arxiv|isbn|pmid|pmcid|openalex|url|lode):[^ ]+$" "pattern": "^(doi|arxiv|isbn|pmid|pmcid|openalex|url):[^ ]+$"
},
{
"$ref": "common.schema.json#/$defs/claimRef"
}
]
}, },
"uniqueItems": true "uniqueItems": true
} }
+172
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,172 @@
{
"$schema": "https://json-schema.org/draft/2020-12/schema",
"$id": "https://paperspec.scient.ing/schemas/math.schema.json",
"title": "Derived math",
"description": "One line of derived/math.jsonl: a formula of the package read in the form scienting-math/1 by a pinned tool, its tree, symbol keys and issues; never authoritative; spec/09-figures-tables-equations.md §9.4, spec/12-package.md §12.7.",
"$defs": {
"kind": {
"description": "What a tree node is. The kinds of scienting-math/1 are num, sym, text, const, oper, dots, empty, add, neg, pm, mp, mul, times, div, op, frac, binom, sqrt, root, pow, sub, prime, fact, prescript, mark, apply, lim, sum, prod, coprod, int, iint, iiint, oint, bigcup, bigcap, abs, norm, angle, floor, ceil, braces, interval, rel, list, lines, cases, matrix and opaque (spec/09 §9.4). The schema takes any lowercase name, so that a later minor version of the form may add a kind; a consumer that meets a kind it does not know treats that node as it treats opaque.",
"type": "string",
"pattern": "^[a-z][a-z0-9-]*$",
"examples": [
"sym",
"frac",
"rel",
"opaque"
]
},
"node": {
"description": "A tree node: an array whose first item is its kind and whose other items are its parts.",
"type": "array",
"minItems": 1,
"prefixItems": [
{
"$ref": "#/$defs/kind"
}
],
"items": {
"$ref": "#/$defs/part"
}
},
"group": {
"description": "Parts that are not a node: a case's value and condition, or a matrix's rows and cells. Its first item, when it has one, is a node, a group or null, never a string, so it is never mistaken for a node.",
"type": "array",
"prefixItems": [
{
"anyOf": [
{
"type": "array"
},
{
"type": "null"
}
]
}
],
"items": {
"$ref": "#/$defs/part"
}
},
"part": {
"description": "A part of a node: a string (digits, a symbol key, words, a command, a relation such as =), null (a script or condition that is absent), a node, or a group.",
"anyOf": [
{
"type": "string"
},
{
"type": "null"
},
{
"$ref": "#/$defs/node"
},
{
"$ref": "#/$defs/group"
}
]
},
"issue": {
"description": "Something a reader of the formula should look at; the formula is read all the same.",
"type": "object",
"properties": {
"code": {
"description": "unbalanced, unknown-command, label-or-power, script-on-group, opaque or infix-fraction in scienting-math/1 (spec/09 §9.4); a later minor version may add a code.",
"type": "string",
"pattern": "^[a-z][a-z0-9-]*$"
},
"message": {
"type": "string",
"minLength": 1
},
"at": {
"description": "The TeX the issue is about, in canonical form; empty when it is about the whole formula.",
"type": "string"
}
},
"required": [
"code",
"message",
"at"
],
"additionalProperties": false
}
},
"type": "object",
"properties": {
"node": {
"$ref": "common.schema.json#/$defs/nodeId"
},
"run": {
"description": "The index of the math run in the node's runs, or null for an equation or equation-line node, as in derived/mathml.jsonl.",
"anyOf": [
{
"type": "integer",
"minimum": 0
},
{
"type": "null"
}
]
},
"tool": {
"type": "object",
"properties": {
"name": {
"type": "string",
"minLength": 1
},
"version": {
"type": "string",
"minLength": 1
}
},
"required": [
"name",
"version"
],
"additionalProperties": false
},
"form": {
"enum": [
"scienting-math/1"
]
},
"tree": {
"$ref": "#/$defs/node"
},
"symbols": {
"description": "The key of every symbol in the tree, each once, in the order the formula first writes it.",
"type": "array",
"items": {
"type": "string",
"minLength": 1
},
"uniqueItems": true
},
"complete": {
"description": "True exactly when the tree has no opaque node.",
"type": "boolean"
},
"issues": {
"type": "array",
"items": {
"$ref": "#/$defs/issue"
}
},
"label": {
"description": "The printed number the tool lifted out of a \\tag in the source; omitted when the source has none.",
"type": "string",
"minLength": 1
}
},
"required": [
"node",
"run",
"tool",
"form",
"tree",
"symbols",
"complete",
"issues"
],
"additionalProperties": false
}
+16 -1
View File
@@ -329,13 +329,28 @@
"source": { "source": {
"type": "string", "type": "string",
"minLength": 1 "minLength": 1
},
"form": {
"$ref": "common.schema.json#/$defs/mathForm"
} }
}, },
"required": [ "required": [
"notation", "notation",
"source" "source"
], ],
"additionalProperties": false "additionalProperties": false,
"if": {
"required": [
"form"
]
},
"then": {
"properties": {
"notation": {
"const": "tex"
}
}
}
} }
} }
} }
+17 -3
View File
@@ -131,7 +131,21 @@
"type", "type",
"ref" "ref"
], ],
"additionalProperties": false "additionalProperties": false,
"if": {
"properties": {
"type": {
"const": "claim"
}
}
},
"then": {
"properties": {
"ref": {
"$ref": "common.schema.json#/$defs/claimRef"
}
}
}
}, },
"minItems": 1 "minItems": 1
} }
@@ -172,13 +186,13 @@
"claims": { "claims": {
"type": "object", "type": "object",
"properties": { "properties": {
"lode": { "paperclaim": {
"type": "string", "type": "string",
"minLength": 1 "minLength": 1
} }
}, },
"required": [ "required": [
"lode" "paperclaim"
], ],
"additionalProperties": false "additionalProperties": false
}, },
+38 -1
View File
@@ -3,6 +3,13 @@
"$id": "https://paperspec.scient.ing/schemas/runs.schema.json", "$id": "https://paperspec.scient.ing/schemas/runs.schema.json",
"title": "Inline runs", "title": "Inline runs",
"description": "The runs of a sentence, cell, reference, authors or keywords node; spec/03-nodes.md.", "description": "The runs of a sentence, cell, reference, authors or keywords node; spec/03-nodes.md.",
"$defs": {
"printed": {
"description": "The run's text as the paper prints it, kept by an emend correction (spec/03 §3.5, spec/11 §11.1).",
"type": "string",
"minLength": 1
}
},
"type": "array", "type": "array",
"minItems": 1, "minItems": 1,
"items": { "items": {
@@ -31,6 +38,9 @@
}, },
"minItems": 1, "minItems": 1,
"uniqueItems": true "uniqueItems": true
},
"printed": {
"$ref": "#/$defs/printed"
} }
}, },
"required": [ "required": [
@@ -54,6 +64,9 @@
"source": { "source": {
"type": "string", "type": "string",
"minLength": 1 "minLength": 1
},
"form": {
"$ref": "common.schema.json#/$defs/mathForm"
} }
}, },
"required": [ "required": [
@@ -61,7 +74,19 @@
"notation", "notation",
"source" "source"
], ],
"additionalProperties": false "additionalProperties": false,
"if": {
"required": [
"form"
]
},
"then": {
"properties": {
"notation": {
"const": "tex"
}
}
}
}, },
{ {
"type": "object", "type": "object",
@@ -79,6 +104,9 @@
"text": { "text": {
"type": "string", "type": "string",
"minLength": 1 "minLength": 1
},
"printed": {
"$ref": "#/$defs/printed"
} }
}, },
"required": [ "required": [
@@ -110,6 +138,9 @@
"text": { "text": {
"type": "string", "type": "string",
"minLength": 1 "minLength": 1
},
"printed": {
"$ref": "#/$defs/printed"
} }
}, },
"required": [ "required": [
@@ -138,6 +169,9 @@
"text": { "text": {
"type": "string", "type": "string",
"minLength": 1 "minLength": 1
},
"printed": {
"$ref": "#/$defs/printed"
} }
}, },
"required": [ "required": [
@@ -159,6 +193,9 @@
"text": { "text": {
"type": "string", "type": "string",
"minLength": 1 "minLength": 1
},
"printed": {
"$ref": "#/$defs/printed"
} }
}, },
"required": [ "required": [
+3
View File
@@ -60,6 +60,9 @@
} }
] ]
}, },
"witness": {
"$ref": "common.schema.json#/$defs/nodeId"
},
"crop": { "crop": {
"$ref": "common.schema.json#/$defs/hash" "$ref": "common.schema.json#/$defs/hash"
}, },
+3 -2
View File
@@ -4,7 +4,7 @@
| Object | Is | Identified by | | Object | Is | Identified by |
| --- | --- | --- | | --- | --- | --- |
| Work | The intellectual work, across all its versions. | A work key ([2.4](#24-work-and-document-keys)), and `same_as` identifiers: `doi:`, `arxiv:`, `isbn:`, `pmid:`, `pmcid:`, `openalex:`, `url:` or `lode:`. | | Work | The intellectual work, across all its versions. | A work key ([2.4](#24-work-and-document-keys)), and `same_as` identifiers: `doi:`, `arxiv:`, `isbn:`, `pmid:`, `pmcid:`, `openalex:`, `url:` or `claim:`. |
| Version | One expression of the work: a preprint, an accepted manuscript, the version of record, an erratum, Supporting Information, a draft. | The work's key and a version type, with an optional sequence number and date. | | Version | One expression of the work: a preprint, an accepted manuscript, the version of record, an erratum, Supporting Information, a draft. | The work's key and a version type, with an optional sequence number and date. |
| Witness | One file of a version: a PDF, JATS XML, a LaTeX source archive, an HTML page, an EPUB, a Typst project. | The SHA-256 of its bytes. | | Witness | One file of a version: a PDF, JATS XML, a LaTeX source archive, an HTML page, an EPUB, a Typst project. | The SHA-256 of its bytes. |
| Document | The text established for one version from one or more witnesses. | A key, and a root hash per revision. | | Document | The text established for one version from one or more witnesses. | A key, and a root hash per revision. |
@@ -83,7 +83,8 @@ The stop words are `a an the of on in for to and or at by with from as into onto
**The identity** is the work's first identifier among `doi`, `arxiv`, `isbn`, `pmid`, `pmcid` and `openalex` in `same_as`, in that order, written `<kind>:<value>` with a DOI's ASCII letters lower-cased. **The identity** is the work's first identifier among `doi`, `arxiv`, `isbn`, `pmid`, `pmcid` and `openalex` in `same_as`, in that order, written `<kind>:<value>` with a DOI's ASCII letters lower-cased.
A work with none has the identity `meta:<title words>|<year>|<family>` from the same folded parts. A work with none has the identity `meta:<title words>|<year>|<family>` from the same folded parts.
`url:` and `lode:` identifiers name copies and claims, not the work, and never enter the identity. `url:` and `claim:` identifiers name copies and claims, not the work, and never enter the identity.
A `claim:` identifier is a claim reference as a layer writes one, `claim:<tag>` or `claim:<host>/<tag>` ([18.4](18-layers.md#184-bodies)).
**The hash part** is the leading bits of SHA-256 of `scienting-key/1:` followed by the identity, in UTF-8, written in lowercase Crockford base32, five bits a character: four characters, or, when another work in the store already holds that key, six, eight and so on until the key is free. **The hash part** is the leading bits of SHA-256 of `scienting-key/1:` followed by the identity, in UTF-8, written in lowercase Crockford base32, five bits a character: four characters, or, when another work in the store already holds that key, six, eight and so on until the key is free.
A key is minted once, when the work enters a store, and never recomputed: a corrected title or a year revised later leaves it alone, while the hash of an identifier still shows which work the key names. A key is minted once, when the work enters a store, and never recomputed: a corrected title or a year revised later leaves it alone, while the hash of an identifier still shows which work the key names.
+30 -4
View File
@@ -79,11 +79,11 @@ Page breaks, running heads and columns are not nodes: they are geometry ([7](07-
| Content | Kinds | Shape | | Content | Kinds | Shape |
| --- | --- | --- | | --- | --- | --- |
| Runs | `sentence`, `cell`, `reference`, `authors`, `keywords` | A non-empty list of inline runs ([3.5](#35-inline-runs)). | | Runs | `sentence`, `cell`, `reference`, `authors`, `keywords` | A non-empty list of inline runs ([3.5](#35-inline-runs)). |
| Math | `equation`, `equation-line` | `{notation, source}`: `tex` or `typst`, and the source as written. | | Math | `equation`, `equation-line` | `{notation, source, form?}`: `tex` or `typst`, the source as written or as a form spells it, and that form ([3.7](#37-math-forms)). |
| Verbatim | `code`, `algorithm` | `{language?, text}`. | | Verbatim | `code`, `algorithm` | `{language?, text}`. |
Other kinds have no `content`. Other kinds have no `content`.
Derived renderings, such as MathML, are not content; they live in `derived/` ([12.7](12-package.md#127-derived-files)). Derived renderings and readings, such as MathML and a formula's tree, are not content; they live in `derived/` ([12.7](12-package.md#127-derived-files)).
## 3.4 Attributes ## 3.4 Attributes
@@ -105,14 +105,17 @@ No other kind carries `attrs`, and each kind carries only its own attributes.
| Run | Properties | Plain projection | | Run | Properties | Plain projection |
| --- | --- | --- | | --- | --- | --- |
| `text` | `text`, and optional `style`: a sorted list of distinct values from `em`, `strong`, `sup`, `sub`, `sc`, `mono`, never both `sup` and `sub`. | The text. | | `text` | `text`, and optional `style`: a sorted list of distinct values from `em`, `strong`, `sup`, `sub`, `sc`, `mono`, never both `sup` and `sub`. | The text. |
| `math` | `notation` (`tex` or `typst`), `source`. | `$` + source + `$` | | `math` | `notation` (`tex` or `typst`), `source`, and optional `form` ([3.7](#37-math-forms)). | `$` + source + `$` |
| `cite` | `refs`: reference node IDs; `text`: the printed form, such as `23`, `[1,2]` or `(Smith, 2019)`. | The printed form. | | `cite` | `refs`: reference node IDs; `text`: the printed form, such as `23`, `[1,2]` or `(Smith, 2019)`. | The printed form. |
| `xref` | `target`: a node ID in this document, an address in another, or null when not yet resolved; `text`. | The printed form. | | `xref` | `target`: a node ID in this document, an address in another, or null when not yet resolved; `text`. | The printed form. |
| `fnmark` | `footnote`: a footnote's ID, or null; `text`: the mark. | The mark. | | `fnmark` | `footnote`: a footnote's ID, or null; `text`: the mark. | The mark. |
| `link` | `url`, `text`. | The text. | | `link` | `url`, `text`. | The text. |
| `equation` | `node`: the ID of an equation child of the sentence. | `$$` + that equation's source + `$$` | | `equation` | `node`: the ID of an equation child of the sentence. | `$$` + that equation's source + `$$` |
Runs are canonical: no `text` run is empty, and no two adjacent `text` runs have the same style list. A `text`, `link`, `cite`, `xref` or `fnmark` run MAY carry `printed`: its text as the paper prints it, where an `emend` corrected the authors ([11.6](11-corrections.md#116-emendations)).
The run's `text` is then the emended text, and only an emend writes `printed`.
Runs are canonical: no `text` run is empty, no two adjacent `text` runs have the same style list unless one of them carries `printed`, and no run's `printed` equals its `text`.
A sentence's `equation` runs name its `equation` children, each once, in the children's order, and a sentence has no other children. A sentence's `equation` runs name its `equation` children, each once, in the children's order, and a sentence has no other children.
A display equation the sentence runs through is thus part of the sentence, while keeping its own ID and hashes. A display equation the sentence runs through is thus part of the sentence, while keeping its own ID and hashes.
@@ -125,3 +128,26 @@ That of any other node is the plain projections of its text leaves joined with o
A node's text leaves are found by walking its subtree in document order and stopping at `sentence`, `cell`, `reference`, `authors`, `keywords`, `code` and `algorithm` nodes, and at `equation` nodes whose parent is not a sentence; an `equation-line` is never a text leaf. A node's text leaves are found by walking its subtree in document order and stopping at `sentence`, `cell`, `reference`, `authors`, `keywords`, `code` and `algorithm` nodes, and at `equation` nodes whose parent is not a sentence; an `equation-line` is never a text leaf.
Offsets, quotations and the text hash are all defined on the plain projection as stored, before normalization. Offsets, quotations and the text hash are all defined on the plain projection as stored, before normalization.
A node's runs as printed are its runs with each run's `printed` in place of its `text`, and each `text` run that carried one joined with the adjacent `text` runs of the same style list, as the run was before an emend split it.
Its projection as printed is the plain projection of its runs as printed; an equation's or a verbatim node's is its plain projection, and any other node's joins its text leaves' projections as printed with one U+0020.
It is the text a witness of the paper holds, recovered from `nodes.jsonl` alone; for a node no emend touched it is the plain projection.
The strict and lossy projections are taken over the runs as printed ([5.3](05-hashes.md#53-the-strict-projection)), and `projections.jsonl` gives an emended sentence's projections with its projection as printed.
## 3.7 Math forms
A math form is a standard spelling of formulas, so that one formula is written alike whichever paper, converter or claim it comes from.
An equation's or equation line's content and a `math` run MAY carry `form`, which names the form its `source` is written in; a source without `form` is as the witness wrote it.
The one form is `scienting-math/1`, canonical TeX, which [9.4](09-figures-tables-equations.md#94-the-math-form) describes; a node or run with `form` has the notation `tex`.
A consumer MAY rely on these properties of a source that carries `form`:
1. It is canonical: it is the form's own spelling of the formula the witness wrote, which renders as that formula did, apart from presentation such as spacing, `\displaystyle` and delimiter sizes.
2. It is idempotent: spelling it in the form again gives it back unchanged, so a tool that rewrites it to check it, or a converter run twice, changes nothing.
3. It carries no label: the form lifts a `\tag` out of the source, and an equation keeps it as its `label`; `\label`, `\nonumber` and `\notag` are gone.
4. Everything else is derived from it: the tree, the symbol keys and the issues of [9.4](09-figures-tables-equations.md#94-the-math-form) are read from the source by a pinned tool into `derived/math.jsonl` ([12.7](12-package.md#127-derived-files)), are never content, and are the same for the same source under the same form.
A producer writes `form` only on a source it has spelled in that form.
A correction that changes such a source writes the new source in the form too, since the gate does not implement the form and cannot check it.
A validator that implements the form reports a source with `form` that is not its own canonical spelling as `doc.math.form`.
`form` enters no content value, so adding it to a source already in the form changes no hash, ID or anchor, while respelling a source in the form changes them as any edit of the source does ([5.2](05-hashes.md#52-own-content)).
+27 -8
View File
@@ -17,6 +17,9 @@ In this chapter *H* is SHA-256 written as hexadecimal; under a keyed scheme, *H*
| `node_hash` | *H*(canonical JSON of `{"own": own_hash, "children": [each child's node_hash, in order]}`) | Pins on leaves; the root hash; knowing that something below has changed. | | `node_hash` | *H*(canonical JSON of `{"own": own_hash, "children": [each child's node_hash, in order]}`) | Pins on leaves; the root hash; knowing that something below has changed. |
Normalization is that of [1.4](01-conventions.md#14-text-normalization-for-hashing). Normalization is that of [1.4](01-conventions.md#14-text-normalization-for-hashing).
The plain projection is of the runs as stored, and the strict and lossy projections of the runs as printed ([3.6](03-nodes.md#36-the-plain-projection)).
So an `emend`, which corrects the authors' own slip ([11.6](11-corrections.md#116-emendations)), changes a leaf's `text_hash`, `own_hash` and `node_hash`, because the text that is read, quoted and pinned is the emended one.
It leaves the leaf's `match_hash` and `align_key` as they were, because the witnesses they compare the leaf with hold the printed text, and a value computed from the emended text would report every emendation as a disagreement.
Because each `node_hash` covers its children's, the root's `node_hash` covers the whole tree (it is a hash over canonical JSON of `{own, children}`, not an RFC 6962 Merkle root, which [8.5](08-fidelity.md#85-merkle-roots) defines for receipts): a correction to one sentence changes that sentence's values and the `node_hash` of each ancestor, and nothing else. Because each `node_hash` covers its children's, the root's `node_hash` covers the whole tree (it is a hash over canonical JSON of `{own, children}`, not an RFC 6962 Merkle root, which [8.5](08-fidelity.md#85-merkle-roots) defines for receipts): a correction to one sentence changes that sentence's values and the `node_hash` of each ancestor, and nothing else.
`hashes.jsonl` gives every value for every node of a small document, with each node's own content. `hashes.jsonl` gives every value for every node of a small document, with each node's own content.
@@ -27,8 +30,8 @@ A node's own content is an object with its `kind` and these members, and nothing
| Kinds | Members | | Kinds | Members |
| --- | --- | | --- | --- |
| Kinds that take a label | `label`: the label, or null. | | Kinds that take a label | `label`: the label, or null. |
| `sentence`, `cell`, `reference`, `authors`, `keywords` | `runs`: the runs as stored, except that each `equation` run is reduced to `{"kind": "equation"}`, since an ID is never content. | | `sentence`, `cell`, `reference`, `authors`, `keywords` | `runs`: the runs as stored, except that each `equation` run is reduced to `{"kind": "equation"}`, since an ID is never content, and each `math` run is without its `form`. |
| `equation`, `equation-line` | `notation`, `source`. | | `equation`, `equation-line` | `notation`, `source`; never `form`. |
| `code`, `algorithm` | `language` (or null), `text`. | | `code`, `algorithm` | `language` (or null), `text`. |
| `section` | `level`, and `heading`: the `text_hash` of its heading, or null. | | `section` | `level`, and `heading`: the `text_hash` of its heading, or null. |
| `table` | `columns`, as stored. | | `table` | `columns`, as stored. |
@@ -39,10 +42,18 @@ So paragraphs, rows, lists, items and the other containers without content have
Own content covers stored values exactly; it is not normalized. Own content covers stored values exactly; it is not normalized.
A table's columns name header cells by ID, so fixing a header cell changes that cell, not the table. A table's columns name header cells by ID, so fixing a header cell changes that cell, not the table.
A math form ([3.7](03-nodes.md#37-math-forms)) enters no content value.
`form` says how the source is spelled, which the source itself shows, so it is left out of own content, and no projection reads it: a source in canonical TeX is projected as the TeX it is, by the rules of [5.3](#53-the-strict-projection) and [5.4](#54-simple-notation).
So a producer that adds `form` to sources already in the form leaves every hash, ID, pin and anchor as it was, and a reading with `form` and one without agree whenever their sources do.
Respelling a source in the form is an edit of the source: it changes the `text_hash`, `own_hash` and `node_hash` of the node, and, for a complex source, its complex key ([5.3](#53-the-strict-projection)).
Simple sources such as `K_r` and `K_{r}` have one canonical linear form, so their `match_hash` and `align_key` stay; a respelling that turns a simple character into a command [5.4](#54-simple-notation) does not read, as `ħ` becomes `\hbar`, makes the source complex and changes them.
Because the complex key compares sources as stored, a producer that aligns a reading in a form with a second reading ([5.6](#56-alignment)) spells the second reading's math in the same form first, or each complex formula it respelled becomes an `equation` suspect.
`hashes.jsonl` gives the values of a small document whose equation and math runs carry `form`, which are those of the same document without it.
## 5.3 The strict projection ## 5.3 The strict projection
The strict projection folds notation to one canonical linear form and keeps structure, so that it can certify agreement. The strict projection folds notation to one canonical linear form and keeps structure, so that it can certify agreement.
It is computed over a node's runs, or its math, as follows; for other nodes it is the strict projections of the text leaves joined with U+0020, then step 3. It is computed over a node's runs as printed ([3.6](03-nodes.md#36-the-plain-projection)), or its math, as follows; for other nodes it is the strict projections of the text leaves joined with U+0020, then step 3.
1. Apply NFC to every string, then project each run: 1. Apply NFC to every string, then project each run:
@@ -142,25 +153,33 @@ A node's prose length is the number of code points in its lossy projection other
Two readings of a document are aligned as whole sentence sequences, never paragraph by paragraph, because backends disagree about paragraphs at page and column breaks. Two readings of a document are aligned as whole sentence sequences, never paragraph by paragraph, because backends disagree about paragraphs at page and column breaks.
Each reading is a list of sentences in document order, each with its strict projection, lossy projection, complex keys, container and context (the kind of its container: paragraph, heading, caption and so on). Each reading is a list of sentences in document order, each with its strict projection, lossy projection, complex keys, container and context (the kind of its container: paragraph, heading, caption and so on).
Those projections are of the runs as printed ([5.3](#53-the-strict-projection)), so a corrected document aligned with a witness again shows no emendation as a suspect.
1. **Anchors.** A sentence is a candidate when its lossy projection occurs exactly once in each reading and its prose length is at least 20. 1. **Anchors.** A sentence is a candidate when its lossy projection occurs exactly once in each reading and its prose length is at least 20.
Take the candidates in the order of the first reading, and choose the longest subsequence whose positions in the second reading increase; among equally long ones, the one whose sequence of positions in the first reading is lexicographically smallest. Take the candidates in the order of the first reading, and choose the longest subsequence whose positions in the second reading increase; among equally long ones, the one whose sequence of positions in the first reading is lexicographically smallest.
2. **Between anchors**, and before the first and after the last, align by the longest common subsequence of lossy projections. 2. **Between anchors**, and before the first and after the last, align by the longest common subsequence of lossy projections.
Ties are broken deterministically: walking both segments from their start, pair two sentences whose lossy projections are equal; otherwise skip the first reading's sentence when the remainder without it has a common subsequence at least as long as without the second's, and skip the second's otherwise. Ties are broken deterministically: walking both segments from their start, pair two sentences whose lossy projections are equal; otherwise skip the first reading's sentence when the remainder without it has a common subsequence at least as long as without the second's, and skip the second's otherwise.
3. **Compare** each pair. 3. **Substitutions.** A sentence one reading misread has a different lossy projection, so steps 1 and 2 leave it unpaired on both sides; this step pairs it with its other reading.
Steps 1 and 2 leave stretches between consecutive pairs, and before the first and after the last, with unpaired sentences on either side.
In each stretch, take the first reading's unpaired sentences in order, and pair each whose prose length is at least 20 with the first of the second reading's unpaired sentences in the same stretch that comes after the last one paired in this step, has a prose length of at least 20, and has a similarity to it of at least 0.8.
The similarity of two lossy projections *a* and *b* is 2*L* / (|*a*| + |*b*|), where *L* is the length of their longest common subsequence of code points and |*a*| and |*b*| are their lengths in code points.
A pair made here never agrees, since its lossy projections differ, so step 4 makes it a `number`, `equation` or `word` suspect rather than a `dropped` and an `added` one.
4. **Compare** each pair.
They agree when their strict projections and complex keys are equal. They agree when their strict projections and complex keys are equal.
Otherwise the pair is a suspect: of kind `number` when their numeric skeletons differ, else `equation` when their complex keys differ, else `word`. Otherwise the pair is a suspect: of kind `number` when their numeric skeletons differ, else `equation` when their complex keys differ, else `word`.
The numeric skeleton keeps only digits, U+2212, `.`, `,`, `+`, `_{`, `^{` and `}`. The numeric skeleton keeps only digits, U+2212, `.`, `,`, `+`, `_{`, `^{` and `}`.
4. **Structure.** A pair whose contexts differ is also a `structure` suspect; two consecutive pairs that share a container in one reading but not in the other are a `join` suspect. 5. **Structure.** A pair whose contexts differ is also a `structure` suspect; two consecutive pairs that share a container in one reading but not in the other are a `join` suspect.
5. **Unplaced** sentences are `dropped` (in the first reading only) or `added` (in the second only). 6. **Unplaced** sentences are `dropped` (in the first reading only) or `added` (in the second only).
Pairs are listed in the first reading's order, whichever step made them.
Paired sentences keep the first reading's ID even when they disagree, so a reading that lost a superscript is caught rather than accepted. Paired sentences keep the first reading's ID even when they disagree, so a reading that lost a superscript is caught rather than accepted.
`alignment.jsonl` aligns two readings that exercise every rule, including two prose-thin sentences aligned by their order. `alignment.jsonl` aligns two readings that exercise every rule, including two prose-thin sentences aligned by their order, and a second pair of readings with substitutions: a misread number, a misread word, a sentence too short to be paired this way, and two sentences too unlike to be one.
## 5.7 Suspects ## 5.7 Suspects
A suspect, `scienting-suspect/1`, records a doubtful reading for review: its `id`, its `kind` (`word`, `number`, `equation`, `structure`, `join`, `added`, `dropped`, `boundary` for an uncertain sentence boundary, or `reading` for anything else), the node, the readings compared, an optional crop by SHA-256 and a note. A suspect, `scienting-suspect/1`, records a doubtful reading for review: its `id`, its `kind` (`word`, `number`, `equation`, `structure`, `join`, `added`, `dropped`, `boundary` for an uncertain sentence boundary, or `reading` for anything else), the node, the readings compared, an optional crop by SHA-256 and a note.
Suspects may travel in a package's `suspects.jsonl`, sorted by ID, until they are resolved. When the second reading, `b`, is another witness's reading of the node (a PDF's text layer, a JATS file, a LaTeX source), `witness` names that witness by its ID in `witnesses.json`, so a reviewer knows what the node was compared with.
Suspects may travel in a package's `suspects.jsonl`, sorted by ID, until they are resolved; in a package, a suspect's `witness` is one of the package's witnesses.
## 5.8 Keyed hashes ## 5.8 Keyed hashes
+2
View File
@@ -105,6 +105,8 @@ The result is `{result, node, node_hash?, span?, drift?, via?, reason?}`: the ou
A `moved` or `reattached` anchor is re-pinned to the live node, and the move is recorded. A `moved` or `reattached` anchor is re-pinned to the live node, and the move is recorded.
Checks are stricter than readers: an extract is a span or leaf anchor and never accepts `changed-below`, because a check is about exact words. Checks are stricter than readers: an extract is a span or leaf anchor and never accepts `changed-below`, because a check is about exact words.
An `emend` changes a leaf's `node_hash` and plain projection as a `replace` does ([11.6](11-corrections.md#116-emendations)), so an anchor on the leaf is judged as after a replace: a quote outside the emended text that occurs once is `reattached` with its new position, and a quote that spans the emended text is `stale`.
A `relink` changes the leaf's `node_hash` but not its plain projection, so an anchor on it is `reattached` by its quote; a `resolve` changes no node, so an anchor on the reference stays `current`.
`resolve.jsonl` resolves seventeen anchors made at revision 0 against `fixtures/packages/hale2026harmonic-damb` at revision 12, with every outcome. `resolve.jsonl` resolves seventeen anchors made at revision 0 against `fixtures/packages/hale2026harmonic-damb` at revision 12, with every outcome.
## 6.6 Drift ## 6.6 Drift
+9 -2
View File
@@ -12,10 +12,16 @@
Levels apply to leaves. Levels apply to leaves.
The pipeline records F0, F1 or F2 in a leaf's `fidelity`; F3 comes only from receipts. The pipeline records F0, F1 or F2 in a leaf's `fidelity`; F3 comes only from receipts.
A correction that changes a leaf drops it back: the gate's crop evidence makes it F1 at most, until it is corroborated or proofread again. A correction that changes a leaf drops it back: the gate's crop evidence makes it F1 at most, until it is corroborated or proofread again.
An `emend`, `relink` or `resolve` ([11.1](11-corrections.md#111-operations)) never does, because a level measures the reading against its witnesses and the page.
An emend corrects the authors, not the reading, and leaves the leaf as printed ([3.6](03-nodes.md#36-the-plain-projection)) as it was; a relink or a resolve changes no text, and the references a citation names are not text a witness corroborates.
Whatever compares a leaf with a witness or with the page compares the leaf as printed: alignment and its suspects ([5.6](05-hashes.md#56-alignment)), corroboration by `match_hash`, a proofreader who signs a receipt, and a spot-check's `errors`.
So an emendation is never reported as a misreading.
## 8.2 Levels ## 8.2 Levels
A leaf's level is the highest of its recorded `fidelity` and the levels of every valid receipt ([8.6](#86-receipt-status)) that lists it at its current `node_hash`. A leaf's level is the highest of its recorded `fidelity` and the levels of every valid receipt ([8.6](#86-receipt-status)) that lists it at its current `node_hash`, or at a `node_hash` that only `emend`, `relink` and `resolve` corrections of the leaf have changed since.
To find those hashes, walk the document's corrections back from the last: one of those three that targets the leaf and whose `after` is the hash reached so far leads back to its `before`, and any other correction that names the leaf, as its `target` or in `touched`, `path`, `to_path`, `created` or `retired`, ends the walk.
A receipt at a lower level never lowers a node; only a revocation, a failed spot-check or a correction does. A receipt at a lower level never lowers a node; only a revocation, a failed spot-check or a correction does.
A spot-check's `qa:` receipt ([8.8](#88-spot-checks)) raises the nodes it sampled, except those its `errors` name. A spot-check's `qa:` receipt ([8.8](#88-spot-checks)) raises the nodes it sampled, except those its `errors` name.
A document reports, in `document.json`, the lowest level among its leaves and the count at each level. A document reports, in `document.json`, the lowest level among its leaves and the count at each level.
@@ -31,7 +37,7 @@ A paper has thousands of nodes, and nobody signs thousands of times, so people s
| `doc` | Yes | The document key. | | `doc` | Yes | The document key. |
| `rev` | Yes | The revision reviewed. | | `rev` | Yes | The revision reviewed. |
| `level` | Yes | `F1`, `F2` or `F3`. | | `level` | Yes | `F1`, `F2` or `F3`. |
| `scope` | Yes | `all`, `section:<id>`, `page:<n>`, `targeted:<name>` (such as `targeted:lode`), or `qa:<receipt id>` for a spot-check. | | `scope` | Yes | `all`, `section:<id>`, `page:<n>`, `targeted:<name>` (such as `targeted:paperclaim`), or `qa:<receipt id>` for a spot-check. |
| `nodes` | Yes | `[[id, node_hash], …]`, sorted by ID without repeats. | | `nodes` | Yes | `[[id, node_hash], …]`, sorted by ID without repeats. |
| `records` | No | `[[kind, id, hash], …]` for other things signed in the sitting: `annotation`, `digitization`, `correction`, `layer` or `checklist`. | | `records` | No | `[[kind, id, hash], …]` for other things signed in the sitting: `annotation`, `digitization`, `correction`, `layer` or `checklist`. |
| `root` | Yes | The Merkle root ([8.5](#85-merkle-roots)). | | `root` | Yes | The Merkle root ([8.5](#85-merkle-roots)). |
@@ -45,6 +51,7 @@ A paper has thousands of nodes, and nobody signs thousands of times, so people s
A receipt lists nodes, records, or both. A receipt lists nodes, records, or both.
A correction invalidates a receipt for the corrected node only, because the node's `node_hash` no longer matches; the rest still counts. A correction invalidates a receipt for the corrected node only, because the node's `node_hash` no longer matches; the rest still counts.
An emend, relink or resolve invalidates none ([8.2](#82-levels)).
A receipt shared outside the team cannot carry plain node hashes, which would leak short texts, and its signature covers them. A receipt shared outside the team cannot carry plain node hashes, which would leak short texts, and its signature covers them.
So an export re-issues it: a new receipt with `export_of`, values under the export's key, signed by the original reviewer or a team key with the `export` purpose. So an export re-issues it: a new receipt with `export_of`, values under the export's key, signed by the original reviewer or a team key with the `export` purpose.
+80 -1
View File
@@ -34,4 +34,83 @@ For people, a cell can be shown as "Table 2, row CT–CT, column K_r" from its h
An equation keeps its source as written, `tex` from a conversion or `typst` from a draft, and its printed number as its `label`, so numbering never collides with a renderer's own. An equation keeps its source as written, `tex` from a conversion or `typst` from a draft, and its printed number as its `label`, so numbering never collides with a renderer's own.
An equation that the source numbers line by line (Eq. 3a) has `equation-line` children, each with its own label and source. An equation that the source numbers line by line (Eq. 3a) has `equation-line` children, each with its own label and source.
MathML is derived by a pinned tool and recorded, with the tool's name and version, in `derived/mathml.jsonl`. A converter that respells TeX in the standard form of [9.4](#94-the-math-form) stores the respelled source and says so with `form` beside it ([3.7](03-nodes.md#37-math-forms)); the source as written stays in the witness.
MathML is derived by a pinned tool and recorded, with the tool's name and version, in `derived/mathml.jsonl`, and the form's reading of each formula in `derived/math.jsonl` ([12.7](12-package.md#127-derived-files)).
## 9.4 The math form
`scienting-math/1` is the standard form of a formula in a paper: one canonical TeX spelling, a tree read from it, a key for each symbol, and the issues a reader should look at.
A converter writes a package's equations and math runs in it, a reader renders and searches it, and a claim store reads a paper's equations and its own claims through it, so the two can be matched.
papermath is its reference implementation, and what papermath computes is what the form says; this section states what the specification relies on.
The identifier names a spelling of formulas, not a file format, so [registry/formats.json](../registry/formats.json) does not list it; its readings travel in a package's `derived/math.jsonl`.
The form reads TeX only.
**Canonical TeX** respells and never reinterprets, so it renders as the source did apart from presentation:
1. Unicode NFC, and a math character a converter handed over becomes its command: `−` is `-`, `≤` is `\leq`, `α` is `\alpha`.
2. Space is dropped, except inside text and where a command needs one before a letter (`\sin x`).
3. One spelling per meaning: `\le` is `\leq`, `\dfrac` and `\tfrac` are `\frac`, `\textrm` is `\text`, `x^{\prime}` is `x'`.
4. Presentation is dropped: `\displaystyle` and the other styles, `\big` and its sizes, `\color`, and `\left` and `\right` around ordinary delimiters.
5. Every argument and script is braced, and on one base the subscript comes first: `x_i^2` is `x_{i}^{2}`, `\frac12` is `\frac{1}{2}`.
6. `\tag` is lifted out as the label, and `\label`, `\nonumber` and `\notag` are dropped.
7. An environment goes by one name: `align`, `split` and `multline` are `aligned`, `equation` and `gather` are `gathered`.
8. A command outside the form's vocabulary is kept as written and reported.
Spelling a canonical source again gives it back unchanged.
**The tree** is the canonical TeX read as JSON.
A node is an array whose first item is a string, its kind; its other items are its parts: strings, null for a part that is absent, nodes, and groups, which are arrays whose first item is not a string.
Brackets group and leave no node.
| Kind | Parts | Is |
| --- | --- | --- |
| `num` | The digits | A number as printed, a decimal comma read as `.`. |
| `sym` | The key | A symbol. |
| `text` | The words | Words in the formula. |
| `const`, `oper` | The command | A constant, such as `\infty`, or an operator, such as `\partial`. |
| `dots`, `empty` | None | An ellipsis; nothing. |
| `add` | The terms | A sum, in which a subtracted term is a `neg` node, ± a `pm` and ∓ an `mp`, each with one part. |
| `mul` | The factors | A product, by juxtaposition or `\cdot`. |
| `times`, `div`, `op` | Two operands, after the operator's command for `op` | `\times`; `/` or `\div`; any other binary operator. |
| `frac`, `binom`, `sqrt`, `root` | Numerator and denominator; the radicand, after the index for `root` | Fractions, binomials and roots. |
| `pow`, `sub`, `prime`, `fact` | The base, and the script for `pow` and `sub` | Scripts, primes and factorials on what is not a symbol. |
| `prescript` | The lower script, the upper script, the base | Scripts before their base, as in the isotope `^{31}\text{P}`. |
| `mark` | The sign or operator | A sign or operator with no operand: a charge (`x^{+}`), the radical dot of `\cdot\text{OH}`, a formula cut by its converter. |
| `apply` | The function's command, its argument, and its subscript if any | A named function: `\cos(x)`, `\log_{2} n`, `\max_{i} x_{i}`. |
| `lim` | The command, what is under it, the body | `\lim`, `\liminf` and `\limsup`. |
| `sum`, `prod`, `coprod`, `int`, `iint`, `iiint`, `oint`, `bigcup`, `bigcap` | The lower limit, the upper limit, the body | A big operator, whose body runs to the next sign outside brackets. |
| `abs`, `norm`, `angle`, `floor`, `ceil`, `braces` | The inside | A fence. |
| `interval` | The opening and closing brackets, the inside | Brackets that do not match, as in `[0, 1)`. |
| `rel` | Operands with a relation between each two | A relation or a chain; a continued line starts with null. |
| `list` | The formulas | Formulas side by side, at `,`, `;`, `\quad` or `\qquad` outside brackets. |
| `lines` | The lines | The lines of an `aligned` or `gathered` block. |
| `cases` | A group of value and condition for each case | Cases, a condition being null when there is none. |
| `matrix` | The environment, then a group of rows, each a group of cells | A matrix or array. |
| `opaque` | Canonical TeX | What the tree does not read. |
A tree with no `opaque` node is complete.
A later minor version of the form may add a kind, and a consumer that meets a kind it does not know reads that node as it reads `opaque`; `math.schema.json` therefore takes any lowercase kind, and its description lists these.
**A symbol** is a base, which is a letter, a Greek letter, or a font or accent command on a group (`\mathbf{F}`, `\hat{H}`), with any subscript, any superscript that names rather than raises (`R^{*}`, `A^{\dagger}`, `E^{\text{LJ}}`), and primes.
A text group alone is a symbol too, unless it holds several words, is a condition in `cases`, or is the set under a big operator.
A symbol's key is its canonical TeX with `\mathrm` spelled `\text`, `\ast` spelled `*`, `\prime` spelled `'`, and no space inside text: `K_r` and `K_{r}` have the key `K_{r}`, and `r_{\mathrm{eq}}` has the key `r_{\text{eq}}`.
The key is the one a paperclaim claim store gives a symbol, so a symbol in a paper and the same symbol in a claim have one key, and a `symbol` annotation names its symbol by it ([18.4](18-layers.md#184-bodies)).
**Issues** never stop the reading; each is `{code, message, at}`, with `at` the canonical TeX it is about.
| Code | Means |
| --- | --- |
| `unbalanced` | A brace, bracket or fence does not close; with a brace, the whole formula is one `opaque` node. |
| `unknown-command` | A command outside the vocabulary, kept as written. |
| `label-or-power` | A superscript that may be a label written without `\text`, such as `E^{LJ}`, read as a power. |
| `script-on-group` | A script on a braced group rather than on a symbol. |
| `opaque` | A part the tree does not read. |
| `infix-fraction` | `\over`, `\choose` or `\atop`, rewritten as `\frac` or `\binom`. |
A later minor version may add a code.
**In a package**, the canonical source is the equation's or the math run's `source`, with `form` beside it ([3.7](03-nodes.md#37-math-forms)), and the rest is derived: one line of `derived/math.jsonl` per formula a pinned tool read, `{node, run, tool, form, tree, symbols, complete, issues, label?}`.
`run` is the index of the math run among the node's runs, or null for an equation or equation line, as in `derived/mathml.jsonl`; `symbols` lists the keys in the order the formula first writes them; `label` is the label the tool lifted from a `\tag`, omitted when the source has none, as a canonical source never does.
The schema is `math.schema.json`.
A validator checks what it can without implementing the form: that each line names a formula of the package (`doc.derived.node`), and that the formula is TeX, `complete` is true exactly when the tree has no `opaque` node, and `symbols` holds each `sym` key of the tree once (`doc.derived.math`).
`fixtures/packages/hale2026harmonic-damb/derived/math.jsonl` holds papermath's reading of the example's equation, of a math run that is one symbol, and of the run `_2` of "H₂O", which the tree cannot read alone.
+4
View File
@@ -9,7 +9,11 @@ Each reference is a `reference` node holding its printed runs, exactly as printe
| `{type: "document", doc}` | It names a document in the same store, by key. | | `{type: "document", doc}` | It names a document in the same store, by key. |
| `{type: "none"}` | Nothing yet. | | `{type: "none"}` | Nothing yet. |
A reference without a record has the resolution `none`.
A `resolve` correction sets a reference's resolution, and its record keeps the one before ([11.7](11-corrections.md#117-citations-and-references)).
Every `cite` run links a sentence to one or more references. Every `cite` run links a sentence to one or more references.
A `relink` correction changes the references a run names, makes a text run a cite run, or makes a cite run text again, without changing its text ([11.7](11-corrections.md#117-citations-and-references)).
The citation graph is therefore sentence-level: for any reference, the format gives every sentence that cites it, which is the citation's context. The citation graph is therefore sentence-level: for any reference, the format gives every sentence that cites it, which is the citation's context.
The database derives a `citations` table from the runs ([13](13-database.md)). The database derives a `citations` table from the runs ([13](13-database.md)).
An article's references and its Supporting Information's are separate documents' references and never mix. An article's references and its Supporting Information's are separate documents' references and never mix.
+62 -7
View File
@@ -18,9 +18,14 @@ Each has an `index`, counted from 1 in the order corrections are applied, and th
| `reclassify` | `target`, `kind` | Changes a node's kind, such as a paragraph that is really a caption, to a kind with the same content shape. | Unchanged. | | `reclassify` | `target`, `kind` | Changes a node's kind, such as a paragraph that is really a caption, to a kind with the same content shape. | Unchanged. |
| `relabel` | `target`, `label` | Changes a printed label. | Unchanged. | | `relabel` | `target`, `label` | Changes a printed label. | Unchanged. |
| `set` | `target`, `attr`, `value` | Sets one structural attribute: a section's `level`, a table's `columns`, a cell's `column`, `rowspan`, `colspan` or `role`, a row's `header_path`, a list's `ordered`, an item's `marker` or a theorem's `variant`. | Unchanged. | | `set` | `target`, `attr`, `value` | Sets one structural attribute: a section's `level`, a table's `columns`, a cell's `column`, `rowspan`, `colspan` or `role`, a row's `header_path`, a list's `ordered`, an item's `marker` or a theorem's `variant`. | Unchanged. |
| `emend` | `target`, `find`, `replace`, `kind`, optional `run` and `note` | Corrects the authors' own slip, where the reading matches the page and the page is wrong: replaces the one occurrence of `find` among the target's prose strings with `replace`, a non-empty string, and keeps what was printed ([11.6](#116-emendations)). `kind` is `typo`, `spelling`, `grammar`, `punctuation`, `wording` or `other`. | Unchanged. |
| `relink` | `target`, `run`, `refs` | Makes run `run` of the target a `cite` run naming `refs`, a non-empty list of reference nodes, or with `refs` null makes a `cite` run a `text` run, keeping its text ([11.7](#117-citations-and-references)). | Unchanged. |
| `resolve` | `target`, `resolution` | Sets a reference node's resolution in `references.jsonl` ([11.7](#117-citations-and-references)). | Unchanged. |
A leaf's editable strings are the `text` of its `text`, `link`, `cite`, `xref` and `fnmark` runs and the `source` of its `math` runs, each searched on its own; an equation's `source`; a verbatim node's `text`. A leaf's editable strings are the `text` of its `text`, `link`, `cite`, `xref` and `fnmark` runs and the `source` of its `math` runs, each searched on its own; an equation's `source`; a verbatim node's `text`.
Its prose strings, which an emend searches, are the `text` of those five run kinds alone: never a math or equation source, and never a verbatim node's text.
`set` exists because readings drop spans, roles and header paths; see the [rationale](../docs/rationale.md#corrections). `set` exists because readings drop spans, roles and header paths; see the [rationale](../docs/rationale.md#corrections).
`emend` exists because a faithful reading of a wrong page is not a misreading: it corrects the paper while keeping what was printed ([11.6](#116-emendations)).
Runs are made canonical after every operation, and the result MUST satisfy every rule of [3](03-nodes.md). Runs are made canonical after every operation, and the result MUST satisfy every rule of [3](03-nodes.md).
## 11.2 Every correction records ## 11.2 Every correction records
@@ -43,9 +48,9 @@ When a correction is applied, its record gains:
| `before`, `after` | The target's `node_hash` before and after, or null; for an inserted subtree, `target` is its root. | | `before`, `after` | The target's `node_hash` before and after, or null; for an inserted subtree, `target` is its root. |
| `path` | The target's ancestors when it was applied, root first; for an insert, the new subtree's. | | `path` | The target's ancestors when it was applied, root first; for an insert, the new subtree's. |
| `to_path` | For a move, the new ancestors. | | `to_path` | For a move, the new ancestors. |
| `touched` | The leaves whose content the correction changed, sorted: the target of a `replace`, text `insert`, `relabel` or `set` on a leaf; the new leaves of a node `insert`; the deleted leaves of a `delete`; both parts of a `split`; both nodes of a run `merge`, or the moved-in leaves of a container `merge`; the moved leaves of a `move`; the leaves of a reclassified node. | | `touched` | The leaves whose content the correction changed, sorted: the target of a `replace`, text `insert`, `relabel` or `set` on a leaf, and of an `emend` or `relink`; the new leaves of a node `insert`; the deleted leaves of a `delete`; both parts of a `split`; both nodes of a run `merge`, or the moved-in leaves of a container `merge`; the moved leaves of a `move`; the leaves of a reclassified node; none for a `resolve`. |
| `created`, `retired` | IDs minted or retired. | | `created`, `retired` | IDs minted or retired. |
| `from` | The label, kind or attribute value before a `relabel`, `reclassify` or `set`. | | `from` | The label, kind or attribute value before a `relabel`, `reclassify` or `set`; the references the run named before a `relink`, or null for a text run; the resolution before a `resolve`. |
Retirements are also entered in `ids.jsonl` with the correction's index as `rev`. Retirements are also entered in `ids.jsonl` with the correction's index as `rev`.
Drift ([6.6](06-anchors.md#66-drift)) is computed from `path`, `to_path` and `touched` alone, so it needs no replay. Drift ([6.6](06-anchors.md#66-drift)) is computed from `path`, `to_path` and `touched` alone, so it needs no replay.
@@ -58,19 +63,22 @@ A correction is refused, naming the rule ([22](22-conformance.md)), when:
2. a target, parent or sibling is not live, or the root would be deleted, moved, merged or reclassified; 2. a target, parent or sibling is not live, or the root would be deleted, moved, merged or reclassified;
3. `find` is empty or does not occur exactly once; 3. `find` is empty or does not occur exactly once;
4. an `insert` has no crop evidence, or names a run or offset its target does not have; 4. an `insert` has no crop evidence, or names a run or offset its target does not have;
5. a digit changes without crop evidence: in a `replace` whose `find` and replacement have different digits, a `delete` of leaves that hold digits, or a `relabel` whose labels have different digits; 5. a digit changes without crop evidence: in a `replace` whose `find` and replacement have different digits, a `delete` of leaves that hold digits, or a `relabel` whose labels have different digits; or an `emend` changes, adds or removes a digit, or edits beside one, whatever its evidence ([11.6](#116-emendations));
6. any leaf outside `touched` has different digits afterwards; 6. any leaf outside `touched` has different digits afterwards;
7. a `split` falls outside the sentence, inside a run other than text, or leaves a part empty; 7. a `split` falls outside the sentence, inside a run other than text or inside an emended run, or leaves a part empty;
8. a `merge` joins nodes that differ in kind, are not mergeable, or are not adjacent siblings; 8. a `merge` joins nodes that differ in kind, are not mergeable, or are not adjacent siblings;
9. a `move` would put a node inside itself; 9. a `move` would put a node inside itself;
10. a `reclassify` changes the content shape, or a `relabel` or `set` targets a kind that does not take it; or 10. a `reclassify` changes the content shape, or a `relabel` or `set` targets a kind that does not take it;
11. the result breaks a rule of [3](03-nodes.md). 11. the result breaks a rule of [3](03-nodes.md);
12. an `emend` targets a node without runs, or finds its text only in a math or equation source or only across runs; or a `replace` or text `insert` would change an emended run, or a correction other than an emend writes `printed`;
13. a `relink` names a run that is neither text nor a cite, or unlinks a run that is not a cite; or
14. a `resolve` names a node that is not a reference.
The gate needs only the document's current state, so a tool can run it on a proposal before applying anything, and get back the record the correction would append or the rule it breaks. The gate needs only the document's current state, so a tool can run it on a proposal before applying anything, and get back the record the correction would append or the rule it breaks.
`paperspec validate --correction` does this against a package. `paperspec validate --correction` does this against a package.
Digits are characters of General Category Nd in the plain projection. Digits are characters of General Category Nd in the plain projection.
A package's corrections are also checked as a whole: indexes run from 1 without gaps, each `id` derives from its record, `rev` equals their number, every retired ID is in `ids.jsonl`, and the last correction of each leaf ends at its current `node_hash`. A package's corrections are also checked as a whole: indexes run from 1 without gaps, each `id` derives from its record, `rev` equals their number, every retired ID is in `ids.jsonl`, the last correction of each leaf ends at its current `node_hash`, and the last `resolve` of each reference ends at its resolution in `references.jsonl`.
`corrections.jsonl` in the vectors applies each operation, and each refusal, to a small document. `corrections.jsonl` in the vectors applies each operation, and each refusal, to a small document.
## 11.5 The history root ## 11.5 The history root
@@ -80,3 +88,50 @@ Because corrections are only appended, a consistency proof (RFC 9162 §2.1.4) be
The proof is a `scienting-proof/1` with `kind` `consistency`, holding the `doc`, `from_rev`, `to_rev`, `from_root`, `to_root` and the `path` as hex hashes; a verifier applies RFC 9162 §2.1.4.2. The proof is a `scienting-proof/1` with `kind` `consistency`, holding the `doc`, `from_rev`, `to_rev`, `from_root`, `to_root` and the `path` as hex hashes; a verifier applies RFC 9162 §2.1.4.2.
A checks-only package carries no corrections, so its history is the empty root. A checks-only package carries no corrections, so its history is the empty root.
`proofs.jsonl` gives consistency proofs for every prefix of small trees and for the example paper between revisions 8 and 12; `fixtures/records/proof-consistency.json` is the latter. `proofs.jsonl` gives consistency proofs for every prefix of small trees and for the example paper between revisions 8 and 12; `fixtures/records/proof-consistency.json` is the latter.
## 11.6 Emendations
A `replace` fixes the reading: the converter misread the page, and the page is right.
An `emend` fixes the paper: the reading matches the page, and the authors printed a typo, a misspelling, a slip of grammar or punctuation, or a wording an editor corrects for readers.
The two claim different things, so different things follow from them.
**What is kept.**
In a `text` run, the found text becomes a run of its own, with the style of the run it was in, whose `text` is the replacement and whose `printed` is the found text.
In a `link`, `cite`, `xref` or `fnmark` run, or a text run emended before, the run's text changes and `printed` keeps its whole text as it was first printed.
The record keeps `find`, the printed string, and `replace`, the emended one, so the history says what each emendation was, while the runs say where it is after any later split, merge or move.
A leaf as printed ([3.6](03-nodes.md#36-the-plain-projection)) is therefore recovered from `nodes.jsonl` alone: each run's `printed` in place of its text.
**The gate.**
An emend searches the target's prose strings for exactly one occurrence, as a `replace` searches its editable strings, but never a math or equation source, which `replace` corrects.
The replacement is a string, never runs, and is not empty; to delete a word, an editor finds it with a neighbor and keeps the neighbor.
The edit stays inside one run, so a `find` that occurs only across runs is refused.
No digit may change, be added or removed, and the edit may not touch one: setting aside the longest common prefix of the run's string before and after, and then the longest common suffix of the rest, what remains holds no digit in either string, and the unchanged character on each side of it is not a digit.
So an emend never turns "3,5" into "3.5": a number is data, corrected by `replace` with crop evidence, even where the authors printed it wrong.
Only an emend writes `printed`.
A `replace` or text `insert` that would change an emended run, a `split` inside one, and replacement runs or inserted nodes that carry `printed` are refused, and a second emend of an emended run keeps what was first printed.
**What follows.**
1. The leaf keeps its level ([8.1](08-fidelity.md#81-levels-of-fidelity), [8.2](08-fidelity.md#82-levels)): a level measures the reading against its witnesses and the page, and the leaf as printed is what it was.
2. Whatever compares the leaf with a witness or the page compares it as printed, so an emendation is never reported as a misreading ([8.1](08-fidelity.md#81-levels-of-fidelity)).
3. The leaf's `text_hash`, `own_hash` and `node_hash` change, as for any change of text, because the text read, quoted and pinned is the emended one; its `match_hash` and `align_key`, which are of the runs as printed, do not ([5.1](05-hashes.md#51-the-five-values)).
4. Anchors on the leaf relocate by their quote, as after a `replace` ([6.5](06-anchors.md#65-resolution)).
`corrections.jsonl` emends a word and a cross-reference's printed form, and refuses a changed digit, a `find` across runs, a `find` in math, an emend of a node without runs and a `replace` of an emended run; each emend's expectation adds the leaf as printed.
## 11.7 Citations and references
A `relink` changes what a citation names, never its text, so it needs no crop.
With `refs` a non-empty list of reference nodes, run `run` becomes a `cite` run naming them, or stays one, and keeps its text: a text run's whole text becomes the cite's printed form, and its style is dropped, since a cite run has none ([3.5](03-nodes.md#35-inline-runs)).
With `refs` null, a cite run becomes a text run with the same text.
Anything an emend kept in `printed` stays.
Every reference must be a `reference` node, as for any cite run (rule 11 of [11.4](#114-the-gate)), and `from` keeps the references the run named before, or null for a text run.
A relink changes no plain projection, so the leaf keeps its level.
Turning a text run into a cite, or back, still changes the leaf's `match_hash` and `align_key`, because the strict projection marks a citation ([5.3](05-hashes.md#53-the-strict-projection)); changing only which references a cite run names changes neither.
To cite part of a text run, a `replace` gives that part as runs that include the cite run ([11.1](#111-operations)).
A `resolve` sets a reference node's resolution in `references.jsonl` ([10](10-references.md)) to any valid one: `doi`, `document` or `none`.
The record keeps the resolution before in `from`, which is `{type: "none"}` for a reference without a record; the resolve then adds the record, in document order.
No content value covers `references.jsonl`, so a resolve changes no node's values: its `before` and `after` are the reference's unchanged `node_hash`, and `touched` is empty.
It changes `references.jsonl`, that file's entry in the manifest, the revision and the history root, as every correction does ([11.5](#115-the-history-root)).
`corrections.jsonl` links a citation printed as a superscript, unlinks a cite run, resolves a reference to a DOI, and refuses a relink of a cross-reference, a cite of a node that is not a reference and a resolve of a sentence.
+13 -3
View File
@@ -32,6 +32,7 @@ Paths use `/`, are relative, have no empty, `.` or `..` segment, no backslash an
No two paths are the same once case-folded, so a package reads alike on every file system. No two paths are the same once case-folded, so a package reads alike on every file system.
A package folder carries no symbolic links, and a consumer refuses one that does, as it refuses a package whose files exceed its own size limit. A package folder carries no symbolic links, and a consumer refuses one that does, as it refuses a package whose files exceed its own size limit.
In a zip, entries are UTF-8 named, sit under one top-level folder named by the key, are stored or deflated, carry no symbolic links, and are unique; a consumer refuses an archive that breaks any of these, or whose expanded size exceeds its own limit. In a zip, entries are UTF-8 named, sit under one top-level folder named by the key, are stored or deflated, carry no symbolic links, and are unique; a consumer refuses an archive that breaks any of these, or whose expanded size exceeds its own limit.
It refuses in the same way (`package.zip.entry`) an archive it cannot read, such as one whose entries need a later version of the zip format than it implements, or whose deflated data does not inflate.
A producer that wants byte-identical archives writes entries sorted by path, dated 1980-01-01 00:00, with no extra fields; `fixtures/packages/tiny2026tiny-j4qm.sct.zip` is such an archive. A producer that wants byte-identical archives writes entries sorted by path, dated 1980-01-01 00:00, with no extra fields; `fixtures/packages/tiny2026tiny-j4qm.sct.zip` is such an archive.
## 12.3 The manifest ## 12.3 The manifest
@@ -50,7 +51,7 @@ Every stage that uses a model or an outside service records where it ran ([14](1
| Policy | Means | | Policy | Means |
| --- | --- | | --- | --- |
| `full` | Every leaf keeps its content. | | `full` | Every leaf keeps its content. |
| `checks-only` | Every leaf has `withheld: true` and no `content`; panels drop their figure text; references keep their resolution but no CSL; there are no corrections, suspects or datasets; and the hashing scheme is keyed: `hmac-team` between the team's machines and `hkdf-pages` outside the team ([5.8](05-hashes.md#58-keyed-hashes)). | | `checks-only` | Every leaf has `withheld: true` and no `content`; panels drop their figure text; references keep their resolution but no CSL; there are no corrections, suspects, datasets or derived files; and the hashing scheme is keyed: `hmac-team` between the team's machines and `hkdf-pages` outside the team ([5.8](05-hashes.md#58-keyed-hashes)). |
A checks-only package is how a team shares its annotations on a paywalled paper without sharing the paper. A checks-only package is how a team shares its annotations on a paywalled paper without sharing the paper.
Its text lives in the team's private asset store, and only key holders can check its values. Its text lives in the team's private asset store, and only key holders can check its values.
@@ -63,8 +64,17 @@ Bytes that live only in the asset store are listed in the manifest with `present
## 12.7 Derived files ## 12.7 Derived files
`derived/` holds what a pinned tool makes from the package, such as `derived/mathml.jsonl`, whose lines are `{node, run, tool, mathml}` with `run` null for an equation node. `derived/` holds what a pinned tool makes from the package.
Nothing derived is content, and a consumer may delete and rebuild it. Each line of a derived file names a formula by `node` and `run`, the index of a math run among the node's runs, or null for an equation or equation line, and the `tool` (`{name, version}`) that made it.
| Path | Lines | Schema |
| --- | --- | --- |
| `derived/mathml.jsonl` | `{node, run, tool, mathml}`: the formula rendered as MathML. | `mathml.schema.json` |
| `derived/math.jsonl` | `{node, run, tool, form, tree, symbols, complete, issues, label?}`: the formula read in a math form ([9.4](09-figures-tables-equations.md#94-the-math-form)). | `math.schema.json` |
Nothing derived is content, and a consumer may delete and rebuild it; a validator does not recompute a derived file, since it does not run the tool, but checks its lines against their schema and that each names a formula of the package (`doc.derived.node`), and that a math line's formula is TeX and its `complete` and `symbols` agree with its tree (`doc.derived.math`).
A derived file reads the text, so a checks-only package carries none ([12.5](#125-text-policies)).
A correction can delete a formula, change it or move its run, so a producer that applies one rebuilds the derived files or leaves them out.
## 12.8 Media type and extension ## 12.8 Media type and extension
+1 -1
View File
@@ -39,7 +39,7 @@ Unloading gives the package back byte for byte, and its manifest hash with it; t
## 13.4 The store tables ## 13.4 The store tables
`store.sql` adds what a team adds to its documents: `roster_keys`, `projects`, `members`, `project_documents`, `reading_paths`, `layers`, `annotations`, `annotation_targets` (derived, so a reader finds the annotations on a node), `datasets`, `dataset_values`, `digitizations`, `views`, `policies`, `submissions` and `grades`. `store.sql` adds what a team adds to its documents: `roster_keys`, `projects`, `members`, `project_documents`, `reading_paths`, `layers`, `annotations`, `annotation_targets` (derived, so a reader finds the annotations on a node), `datasets`, `dataset_values`, `digitizations`, `views`, `policies`, `submissions` and `grades`.
Each keeps its record whole in a `record` or `descriptor` column, with the columns a query needs beside it. Each keeps its record whole in a `record` or `descriptor` column, with the columns a query needs beside it, such as an annotation's `body_kind` and its `category`, which is NULL when the body has none.
## 13.5 The bundle ## 13.5 The bundle
+77 -6
View File
@@ -43,21 +43,92 @@ Replies are annotations that target annotations, so discussions are threads anch
| `kind` | W3C type | Adds | Says | | `kind` | W3C type | Adds | Says |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| `gloss` | `TextualBody` | `audience` | An explanation at `novice`, `student` or `expert` level. | | `gloss` | `TextualBody` | `audience` | An explanation at `novice`, `student` or `expert` level. |
| `claim-link` | `SpecificResource` | `source` (`lode:<tag>`), `pin`, `role` | That the span `states`, `uses` or `disputes` a claim. | | `claim-link` | `SpecificResource` | `source`, `pin`, `role` | That the span `states`, `uses` or `disputes` a claim. |
| `symbol` | `SpecificResource` | `source`, `pin`, `symbol` | That this occurrence of a symbol is a symbol claim. | | `symbol` | `SpecificResource` | `source`, `pin`, `key`, `symbol` | That this occurrence of a symbol, the one whose key is `key`, is the symbol a symbol claim defines. |
| `comment` | `TextualBody` | | A remark, opinion or interpretation. | | `comment` | `TextualBody` | `category` | A remark, opinion or interpretation. |
| `caveat` | `TextualBody` | | A warning a reader should see. | | `caveat` | `TextualBody` | `category` | A warning a reader should see. |
| `question` | `TextualBody` | `for` | A question for a `reader`, a `group` or the `authors`. | | `question` | `TextualBody` | `for`, `category` | A question for a `reader`, a `group` or the `authors`. |
| `exercise` | `TextualBody` | `exercise` | A task with a key and a rule ([19](19-exercises.md)). | | `exercise` | `TextualBody` | `exercise` | A task with a key and a rule ([19](19-exercises.md)). |
| `citation-context` | `TextualBody` | `reference`, `verdict`, `reason` | Why a sentence cites a reference, and whether it supports it. | | `citation-context` | `TextualBody` | `reference`, `verdict`, `reason` | Why a sentence cites a reference, and whether it supports it. |
| `prerequisite` | `SpecificResource` | `source` | What to read or know first. | | `prerequisite` | `SpecificResource` | `source` | What to read or know first. |
| `crosslink` | `SpecificResource` | `source`, `selector` | That the span corresponds to a span in another document. | | `crosslink` | `SpecificResource` | `source`, `selector` | That the span corresponds to a span in another document. |
| `trace` | `SpecificResource` | `source`, `selector`, `reference`, `note`, `verdict`, `proposer` | That the target's sentence cites `reference` on the strength of a passage of the cited document ([18.5](#185-traced-citations)). |
| `translation` | `TextualBody` | `language` | The span in another language. | | `translation` | `TextualBody` | `language` | The span in another language. |
| `description` | `TextualBody` | `role` | A description of a figure, panel or table for readers who cannot see it: `alt`, a short text equivalent, or `long`, a full description. | | `description` | `TextualBody` | `role` | A description of a figure, panel or table for readers who cannot see it: `alt`, a short text equivalent, or `long`, a full description. |
| `generated` | `TextualBody` | `generator` | Text a model wrote about the span; never mistaken for source. `generator` is `{model, run}` as a correction's model author is ([11.2](11-corrections.md#112-every-correction-records)). | | `generated` | `TextualBody` | `generator` | Text a model wrote about the span; never mistaken for source. `generator` is `{model, run}` as a correction's model author is ([11.2](11-corrections.md#112-every-correction-records)). |
A textual body has a `value`, and optionally a `format` (`text/plain` or `text/markdown`) and a `language`. A textual body has a `value`, and optionally a `format` (`text/plain` or `text/markdown`) and a `language`.
The `source` of a `claim-link` or `symbol` body is a claim in a paperclaim claim store, written as paperclaim writes a reference: `claim:` and the claim's tag, eight Crockford base32 capitals (the digits and the letters without I, L, O and U), as in `claim:272XTX7C`, or `claim:<host>/<tag>` for a claim in another store, `<host>` being a domain name.
A tag never changes, while a claim's slug, such as `amber/k-bond`, may be renamed, so a slug is never a reference.
The optional `pin` fixes the claim as the annotator read it: the same reference, `@`, and the first six lowercase hex digits of the claim's statement hash, as in `claim:272XTX7C@02f47b`.
`common.schema.json` defines both, as `claimRef` and `claimPin`.
A `symbol` body names its symbol twice, as the target's span and by `key`, the symbol's key in the math form `scienting-math/1` ([9.4](09-figures-tables-equations.md#94-the-math-form)), which a claim store gives the symbol a symbol claim defines: `K_{r}` for a span `$K_r$`.
So a reader finds every occurrence of a symbol across a library by its key, however its source spaced or braced it, and a claim store matches the annotation to its claim without parsing the span.
The span is still required, since the key says which symbol and the span says where; `symbol`, optional, is the symbol as the span writes it.
A `comment`, `caveat` or `question` body MAY carry a `category`, which says what it is about, from a fixed list:
| `category` | Says |
| --- | --- |
| `comment` | A general remark. |
| `context` | Background, related work, or what a reader should know to follow the span. |
| `critique` | A flaw in the method, the analysis or the argument. |
| `question` | A question. |
| `correction` | An error of fact, number, citation or reference in the paper. |
| `feedback` | A suggestion addressed to the authors. |
| `resource` | Data, code or a related paper. |
A producer that supports categories SHOULD set one on every comment, caveat and question; the property is optional only so that layers written before it stay valid.
The category is independent of the kind, so a caveat may be a `correction` and a question a `critique`.
A `correction` category says that a reader found an error in the paper; correcting the document's reading of it is a correction of [11](11-corrections.md).
The store's `annotations` table keeps the category beside the body's kind ([13.4](13-database.md#134-the-store-tables)).
Nothing a model writes is ever stored as source text. Nothing a model writes is ever stored as source text.
A model may propose a `description`, and like any annotation it stays `proposed` until a person confirms it; an accessible export uses confirmed descriptions only, and a figure with none has no description. A model may propose a `description`, and like any annotation it stays `proposed` until a person confirms it; an accessible export uses confirmed descriptions only, and a figure with none has no description.
Other text a model writes about a span, such as a summary, is a `generated` annotation, which names its `generator`. Other text a model writes about a span, such as a summary, is a `generated` annotation, which names its `generator`.
`fixtures/records/layer/` holds a layer with one annotation of each common kind and the receipt that confirms some of them. `fixtures/records/layer/` holds a layer with one annotation of each common kind, each comment, caveat and question with its category, a claim link and a symbol that reference a paperclaim claim and pin it, and the receipt that confirms some of them.
## 18.5 Traced citations
"As previously reported [12]": a reader who finds where the cited paper reports it marks the passage, and the `trace` body keeps the mark.
A `crosslink` says only that two spans correspond, in both directions, whereas a trace goes from one sentence's citation to one passage, and says which reference it follows, why, and who or what found it.
The annotation's target is a leaf or span anchor ([6.4](06-anchors.md#64-four-kinds-of-anchor)) on the citing sentence, which MUST be a leaf with runs, a sentence or a cell, and MUST cite the reference the body names: one of its `cite` runs lists `reference` ([3.5](03-nodes.md#35-inline-runs)).
`reference` is the ID of a `reference` node of the citing document, because a sentence may cite several references at once, as in `[3, 12]`, and the target says only which sentence.
`source` is the cited document, written as a target's source is, `tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:<store>/<key>`, and never the citing document itself.
`selector` selects the passage in it: an `AnchorSelector` whose anchor holds the passage's pin (its `node_hash`) and, for part of a leaf, its `span`, then a `TextQuoteSelector` when the anchor's quote is plain ([18.3](#183-the-annotation)).
The passage may be a container, such as a table, whose anchor has no quote.
| Property | Required | Holds |
| --- | --- | --- |
| `reference` | Yes | The reference node of the citing document that the sentence cites and the trace follows. |
| `source`, `selector` | Yes | The cited document and the passage in it. |
| `note` | No | What the passage reports, in a person's or a tool's words. |
| `verdict` | No | `supports`, `partly`, `does-not` or `cannot-tell`, as a `citation-context` body has it ([19.2](19-exercises.md#192-verdicts)). |
| `proposer` | When the creator is `Software` | `{model, run, score?, rank?}`: the model and run that found the passage as a candidate, as a `generated` body's `generator` names them, the candidate's `score` as a decimal string, and its `rank`, from 1, among the candidates the run proposed for this citation. |
The state of a trace is the annotation's `status`.
A trace a tool proposes is `proposed` until a person confirms it, and `rejected` when a person turns the candidate down; a rejected candidate is kept, so that the tool is not offered it again.
A trace is *disputed* while a reply to it, an annotation whose target is the trace and whose motivation is `assessing`, is `proposed` or `confirmed`.
The dispute is computed from the replies and never written on the trace, so a reply can be withdrawn.
Whether a trace still leads where it did is also computed, from the current state of both documents.
Resolve the target's anchor against the citing document and the body's anchor against the cited document ([6.5](06-anchors.md#65-resolution)).
The first row that applies gives the outcome:
| Outcome | When |
| --- | --- |
| `stale` | An anchor is stale, on the citing side, the cited side or both. |
| `unlinked` | The sentence no longer cites `reference`: a `relink` removed the citation ([11.7](11-corrections.md#117-citations-and-references)), or the reference was deleted. |
| `misresolved` | A `resolve` made the reference name a DOI or a document that is not the cited work. A resolution of `none` names nothing and contradicts nothing ([10](10-references.md)). |
| `changed` | Both anchors resolve and at least one is not `current`. |
| `current` | Both anchors are `current`, and the reference still resolves to the cited work or to nothing. |
A resolution names the cited work when its document is the cited document, another version of the same work (a key with the same work key, [2.4](02-model.md#24-work-and-document-keys)), or one the caller knows to be the work; and a `doi` resolution does when the work is known by that DOI (`same_as`, [2.4](02-model.md#24-work-and-document-keys)).
Besides the outcome, a resolution gives the passage's current address, `key#node@pin[start:end]`, while its anchor resolves, and the citations inside the passage.
A chain of "as previously reported" is then followed one trace at a time: the reader opens the passage, and a citation in it that has a trace of its own leads on.
A trace breaks `layer.trace.source` when its selector has no `AnchorSelector`, an anchor is in another document than `source` names, `source` is the citing document, or the `TextQuoteSelector` does not repeat the anchor's plain quote.
It breaks `layer.trace.target` when the target is not a leaf with runs of the citing document selected by an `AnchorSelector`, or the sentence does not cite `reference` ([22.4](22-conformance.md#224-rules)).
`vectors/traces.jsonl` resolves traces against the fixture packages after corrections, with every outcome and every refusal, and `fixtures/records/traces/` holds a layer of four annotations on `writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3` that cites `hale2026harmonic-damb`: a trace a model proposed to the paper's abstract and a person confirmed with a receipt, a candidate a person rejected, a person's trace to Table 1, and a reply that disputes the first.
+2 -2
View File
@@ -7,9 +7,9 @@ A project, `scienting-project/1`, is the unit a team works in.
| `key`, `store`, `name`, `description` | Its identity. | | `key`, `store`, `name`, `description` | Its identity. |
| `members` | People with a `role` (`owner`, `editor`, `reader` or `guest`) and the roster keys they sign with. | | `members` | People with a `role` (`owner`, `editor`, `reader` or `guest`) and the roster keys they sign with. |
| `documents` | The project's documents, each with the `reason` it is included, `tags`, and a reading `status` per member: `unread`, `reading` or `read`. | | `documents` | The project's documents, each with the `reason` it is included, `tags`, and a reading `status` per member: `unread`, `reading` or `read`. |
| `paths` | Reading paths: ordered steps through documents, nodes, claims and layers, for onboarding a student or preparing a reading group. | | `paths` | Reading paths: ordered steps through documents, nodes, claims and layers, for onboarding a student or preparing a reading group; a claim step's `ref` is a claim reference, `claim:<tag>` ([18.4](18-layers.md#184-bodies)). |
| `layers`, `datasets`, `views`, `drafts` | What the project holds. | | `layers`, `datasets`, `views`, `drafts` | What the project holds. |
| `claims` | The claim namespace or bundle it uses, as the `lode` setting. | | `claims` | The claim namespace or bundle it uses, as the `paperclaim` setting. |
| `settings` | The digit rule for targeted F3 ([8.10](08-fidelity.md#810-targeted-f3)), the drift threshold ([6.6](06-anchors.md#66-drift)), the spot-check rate and minimum ([8.8](08-fidelity.md#88-spot-checks)), what happens when a right is unknown (`refuse`, the default, or `warn`), the stage requirements in use, as the `id` of their stage file ([14](14-rights.md)), and the project's transparency `log`: its `origin`, the roster keys that `witness` it, and the `threshold` of witnesses a checkpoint needs ([23](23-log.md)). | | `settings` | The digit rule for targeted F3 ([8.10](08-fidelity.md#810-targeted-f3)), the drift threshold ([6.6](06-anchors.md#66-drift)), the spot-check rate and minimum ([8.8](08-fidelity.md#88-spot-checks)), what happens when a right is unknown (`refuse`, the default, or `warn`), the stage requirements in use, as the `id` of their stage file ([14](14-rights.md)), and the project's transparency `log`: its `origin`, the roster keys that `witness` it, and the `threshold` of witnesses a checkpoint needs ([23](23-log.md)). |
Projects are small on purpose: everything about them is designed for hundreds of documents, not millions. Projects are small on purpose: everything about them is designed for hundreds of documents, not millions.
+8 -3
View File
@@ -6,7 +6,7 @@
| --- | --- | --- | | --- | --- | --- |
| `vectors/*.jsonl` | Inputs and expected outputs, one case per line. | Computes every expected output from its input. | | `vectors/*.jsonl` | Inputs and expected outputs, one case per line. | Computes every expected output from its input. |
| `fixtures/packages/` | Valid packages: a converted chemistry paper with corrections, receipts, a multi-level-header table and a dataset; its checks-only export; an open-access paper with two witnesses; a Typst draft; a tiny document, as a folder and as the zip of [12.2](12-package.md#122-paths). | Accepts each, and recomputes every value it contains. | | `fixtures/packages/` | Valid packages: a converted chemistry paper with corrections, receipts, a multi-level-header table and a dataset; its checks-only export; an open-access paper with two witnesses; a Typst draft; a tiny document, as a folder and as the zip of [12.2](12-package.md#122-paths). | Accepts each, and recomputes every value it contains. |
| `fixtures/records/` | A valid record of every other format that is a JSON file of its own; the stage requirements and stamp rules are in `registry/`, and a bundle is built by `paperspec load --bundle`. | Accepts each. | | `fixtures/records/` | A valid record of every other format that is a JSON file of its own, and a second layer, of traced citations ([18.5](18-layers.md#185-traced-citations)), whose traces resolve as `vectors/traces.jsonl` says; the stage requirements and stamp rules are in `registry/`, and a bundle is built by `paperspec load --bundle`. | Accepts each. |
| `fixtures/invalid/` | Invalid packages, each with `expect.json` naming the rule it breaks. | Refuses each, and SHOULD name that rule. | | `fixtures/invalid/` | Invalid packages, each with `expect.json` naming the rule it breaks. | Refuses each, and SHOULD name that rule. |
| `fixtures/keys/` | The test keys that signed the fixtures and the team secret of the checks-only export. | Never uses them for anything else. | | `fixtures/keys/` | The test keys that signed the fixtures and the team secret of the checks-only export. | Never uses them for anything else. |
@@ -22,7 +22,7 @@ A validator checks, in order, and reports each failure as `path:line: rule: mess
3. The tree ([3](03-nodes.md)), runs and references between nodes, the counts, and the keys ([2.4](02-model.md#24-work-and-document-keys)). 3. The tree ([3](03-nodes.md)), runs and references between nodes, the counts, and the keys ([2.4](02-model.md#24-work-and-document-keys)).
4. The policy and hashing scheme ([12.5](12-package.md#125-text-policies)). 4. The policy and hashing scheme ([12.5](12-package.md#125-text-policies)).
5. The five values of every node, the root and `meta_hash`, when the text is present and the key, if any, is known. 5. The five values of every node, the root and `meta_hash`, when the text is present and the key, if any, is known.
6. The ID table, the corrections and the history root, the witnesses, pages, locations and references, and every file's order. 6. The ID table, the corrections and the history root, the witnesses, pages, locations and references, the formulas derived files name, and every file's order.
7. Receipts: IDs, roots, documents, node order, signatures against the package's roster, spot-check keys, seeds and samples, and the fidelity distribution. 7. Receipts: IDs, roots, documents, node order, signatures against the package's roster, spot-check keys, seeds and samples, and the fidelity distribution.
## 22.3 Schemas ## 22.3 Schemas
@@ -39,7 +39,8 @@ Rule IDs are stable: a rule's meaning never changes, and a retired rule's ID is
| Prefix | Covers | | Prefix | Covers |
| --- | --- | | --- | --- |
| `package.` | The manifest, paths, files and schemas. | | `package.` | The manifest, paths, files and schemas. |
| `doc.tree.`, `doc.node.`, `doc.run.`, `doc.table.` | The tree, node content and runs. | | `doc.tree.`, `doc.node.`, `doc.run.`, `doc.table.`, `doc.math.` | The tree, node content and runs. |
| `doc.derived.` | Derived files ([12.7](12-package.md#127-derived-files)). |
| `doc.hash.` | The five values, the root and the metadata hash. | | `doc.hash.` | The five values, the root and the metadata hash. |
| `doc.id.`, `doc.order.` | The ID table and file order. | | `doc.id.`, `doc.order.` | The ID table and file order. |
| `doc.policy.` | Text policies and keyed hashing. | | `doc.policy.` | Text policies and keyed hashing. |
@@ -48,6 +49,10 @@ Rule IDs are stable: a rule's meaning never changes, and a retired rule's ID is
| `doc.receipt.`, `doc.qa.`, `doc.fidelity.` | Receipts, spot-checks and levels. | | `doc.receipt.`, `doc.qa.`, `doc.fidelity.` | Receipts, spot-checks and levels. |
| `doc.witness.`, `doc.page.`, `doc.location.`, `doc.reference.` | Witnesses and geometry. | | `doc.witness.`, `doc.page.`, `doc.location.`, `doc.reference.` | Witnesses and geometry. |
| `grade.` | Grading. | | `grade.` | Grading. |
| `layer.` | Annotations that refer to documents: `layer.trace.source` and `layer.trace.target` ([18.5](18-layers.md#185-traced-citations)). |
A package is validated by [22.2](#222-validating-a-package), but a layer is not part of one.
The `layer.` rules are reported for an annotation, in the form `annotation: rule: message`, by a validator that has the annotation and the states of the documents it names; the reference implementation does so for traces in `paperspec.traces.problems`.
## 22.5 Stability ## 22.5 Stability
+1
View File
@@ -35,6 +35,7 @@ Q2xlYXIgdGV4dCBpcyBub3QgYSByb290IGhhc2guLi4uLi4uLi4=
The origin names the log, and a team's logs are named `scient.ing/log/<store>` or under a domain the team controls. The origin names the log, and a team's logs are named `scient.ing/log/<store>` or under a domain the team controls.
A signature line is an em dash (U+2014), a space, the signer's roster key, a space, and Base64 of the signer's four-byte key hash followed by the signature. A signature line is an em dash (U+2014), a space, the signer's roster key, a space, and Base64 of the signer's four-byte key hash followed by the signature.
The key hash is the first four bytes of SHA-256 of the signer's name, a newline, the byte 0x01 and the Ed25519 public key; the signature is Ed25519 over the note's first three lines, each ending in a newline. The key hash is the first four bytes of SHA-256 of the signer's name, a newline, the byte 0x01 and the Ed25519 public key; the signature is Ed25519 over the note's first three lines, each ending in a newline.
Every line of a note, the last signature line included, ends in one U+000A LINE FEED; a note that ends a line with anything else, such as U+000B, U+0085 or U+2028, which some libraries also take for line breaks, or that lacks its final U+000A, is malformed.
A note parsed into JSON has `format`, `origin`, `size`, `root` as hex, `signatures` as `{name, key_hash, value}` and the `note` text itself; the schema is `checkpoint.schema.json`. A note parsed into JSON has `format`, `origin`, `size`, `root` as hex, `signatures` as `{name, key_hash, value}` and the `note` text itself; the schema is `checkpoint.schema.json`.
`checkpoint.jsonl` gives a checkpoint over the example paper's receipts and its verification. `checkpoint.jsonl` gives a checkpoint over the example paper's receipts and its verification.
+1 -1
View File
@@ -128,7 +128,7 @@ CREATE TABLE corrections (
doc_key VARCHAR(128) NOT NULL, doc_key VARCHAR(128) NOT NULL,
idx INTEGER NOT NULL CHECK (idx >= 1), idx INTEGER NOT NULL CHECK (idx >= 1),
id VARCHAR(32) NOT NULL, id VARCHAR(32) NOT NULL,
op VARCHAR(16) NOT NULL CHECK (op IN ('replace', 'insert', 'delete', 'split', 'merge', 'move', 'reclassify', 'relabel', 'set')), op VARCHAR(16) NOT NULL CHECK (op IN ('replace', 'insert', 'delete', 'split', 'merge', 'move', 'reclassify', 'relabel', 'set', 'emend', 'relink', 'resolve')),
target VARCHAR(16), target VARCHAR(16),
evidence TEXT NOT NULL, evidence TEXT NOT NULL,
author TEXT NOT NULL, author TEXT NOT NULL,
+2 -1
View File
@@ -68,7 +68,8 @@ CREATE TABLE layers (
CREATE TABLE annotations ( CREATE TABLE annotations (
id VARCHAR(256) NOT NULL, id VARCHAR(256) NOT NULL,
layer VARCHAR(256) NOT NULL, layer VARCHAR(256) NOT NULL,
body_kind VARCHAR(24) NOT NULL CHECK (body_kind IN ('gloss', 'claim-link', 'symbol', 'comment', 'caveat', 'question', 'exercise', 'citation-context', 'prerequisite', 'crosslink', 'translation', 'description', 'generated')), body_kind VARCHAR(24) NOT NULL CHECK (body_kind IN ('gloss', 'claim-link', 'symbol', 'comment', 'caveat', 'question', 'exercise', 'citation-context', 'prerequisite', 'crosslink', 'trace', 'translation', 'description', 'generated')),
category VARCHAR(12) CHECK (category IN ('comment', 'context', 'critique', 'question', 'correction', 'feedback', 'resource')),
status VARCHAR(10) NOT NULL CHECK (status IN ('proposed', 'confirmed', 'rejected', 'withdrawn')), status VARCHAR(10) NOT NULL CHECK (status IN ('proposed', 'confirmed', 'rejected', 'withdrawn')),
receipt VARCHAR(32), receipt VARCHAR(32),
creator VARCHAR(256) NOT NULL, creator VARCHAR(256) NOT NULL,
+52
View File
@@ -9,6 +9,7 @@ import unicodedata
from .hashing import prose_length from .hashing import prose_length
MIN_PROSE = 20 MIN_PROSE = 20
MIN_SIMILAR = 0.8
def _numeric_skeleton(strict): def _numeric_skeleton(strict):
@@ -82,6 +83,56 @@ def _lcs(A, B, a0, a1, b0, b1):
return out return out
def lcs_length(a, b):
"""Length of the longest common subsequence of two strings' code points (bit-parallel, Hyyrö 2004)."""
if len(a) < len(b):
a, b = b, a
masks = {}
for i, ch in enumerate(a):
masks[ch] = masks.get(ch, 0) | (1 << i)
full = (1 << len(a)) - 1
v = full
for ch in b:
u = v & masks.get(ch, 0)
v = ((v + u) | (v - u)) & full
return len(a) - v.bit_count()
def similarity(a, b):
"""2L / (|a| + |b|) over code points, L the longest common subsequence; 1 for two empty strings."""
if not a and not b:
return 1.0
return 2 * lcs_length(a, b) / (len(a) + len(b))
def _similar(a, b):
"""Whether two lossy projections are at least MIN_SIMILAR alike; exact, with two cheap upper bounds first."""
total = len(a) + len(b)
if 2 * min(len(a), len(b)) < MIN_SIMILAR * total:
return False
common = sum(min(n, b.count(ch)) for ch, n in {ch: a.count(ch) for ch in set(a)}.items())
if 2 * common < MIN_SIMILAR * total:
return False
return 2 * lcs_length(a, b) >= MIN_SIMILAR * total
def _substitutions(A, B, pairs):
"""Step 3: in each stretch between pairs, an unpaired sentence beside a nearly equal one is paired with it."""
out = []
bounds = [(-1, -1)] + pairs + [(len(A), len(B))]
for (a0, b0), (a1, b1) in zip(bounds, bounds[1:]):
nxt = b0 + 1
for i in range(a0 + 1, a1):
if prose_length(A[i]["lossy"]) < MIN_PROSE:
continue
for j in range(nxt, b1):
if prose_length(B[j]["lossy"]) >= MIN_PROSE and _similar(A[i]["lossy"], B[j]["lossy"]):
out.append((i, j))
nxt = j + 1
break
return out
def align(A, B): def align(A, B):
"""Align reading B to reading A. Returns {"pairs": [...], "suspects": [...]}.""" """Align reading B to reading A. Returns {"pairs": [...], "suspects": [...]}."""
count_a, count_b = {}, {} count_a, count_b = {}, {}
@@ -102,6 +153,7 @@ def align(A, B):
if ai < len(A): if ai < len(A):
pairs.append((ai, bi)) pairs.append((ai, bi))
prev_a, prev_b = ai + 1, bi + 1 prev_a, prev_b = ai + 1, bi + 1
pairs = sorted(pairs + _substitutions(A, B, pairs))
out_pairs, suspects = [], [] out_pairs, suspects = [], []
for ai, bi in pairs: for ai, bi in pairs:
kind = classify(A[ai], B[bi]) kind = classify(A[ai], B[bi])
+364 -34
View File
@@ -26,10 +26,10 @@ from paperspec import align as AL # noqa: E402
from paperspec import anchors as AN # noqa: E402 from paperspec import anchors as AN # noqa: E402
from paperspec import corrections as CO # noqa: E402 from paperspec import corrections as CO # noqa: E402
from paperspec import crypto, fingerprint as FP, grade as GR, hashing, jcs, receipts as RC, rights as RI # noqa: E402 from paperspec import crypto, fingerprint as FP, grade as GR, hashing, jcs, receipts as RC, rights as RI # noqa: E402
from paperspec import keys as K, log as LG, mldsa, targets as TG, vrf # noqa: E402 from paperspec import keys as K, log as LG, mldsa, targets as TG, traces as TR, vrf # noqa: E402
from paperspec.model import LEAVES, MATH_KINDS, RUN_KINDS, VERBATIM_KINDS, Doc # noqa: E402 from paperspec.model import LEAVES, MATH_KINDS, RUN_KINDS, VERBATIM_KINDS, Doc # noqa: E402
from paperspec.notation import fold_math # noqa: E402 from paperspec.notation import fold_math # noqa: E402
from paperspec.package import ZIP_EXTENSION, history_items, jsonl, line, witness_id, write, write_zip # noqa: E402 from paperspec.package import ZIP_EXTENSION, history_items, jsonl, line, read_state, witness_id, write, write_zip # noqa: E402
from paperspec.schema import Store # noqa: E402 from paperspec.schema import Store # noqa: E402
from paperspec.text import letter_first, mint_node_id, norm, record_id, sha256_hex # noqa: E402 from paperspec.text import letter_first, mint_node_id, norm, record_id, sha256_hex # noqa: E402
from paperspec.tree import Refusal, _flatten, mint_ids, validate_structure # noqa: E402 from paperspec.tree import Refusal, _flatten, mint_ids, validate_structure # noqa: E402
@@ -448,7 +448,7 @@ def build_document(src, used=None, extra_files=None):
nodes, side = establish(key, spec, names, used) nodes, side = establish(key, spec, names, used)
aliases = [{"id": a, "kind": "alias", "successor": names.ids[t]} aliases = [{"id": a, "kind": "alias", "successor": names.ids[t]}
for a, t in sorted(src.get("legacy_aliases", {}).items())] for a, t in sorted(src.get("legacy_aliases", {}).items())]
state = CO.State(key, nodes, aliases) state = CO.State(key, nodes, aliases, references=reference_records(Doc(key, nodes), side, names))
states = {0: state} states = {0: state}
records = [] records = []
for c in src.get("corrections", []): for c in src.get("corrections", []):
@@ -478,11 +478,12 @@ def build_document(src, used=None, extra_files=None):
names.ids[new_name] = rec["created"][0] names.ids[new_name] = rec["created"][0]
records.append(rec) records.append(rec)
states[state.rev] = state states[state.rev] = state
# A corrected leaf was checked against the page image: it is F1 at most until corroborated again. # A corrected leaf was checked against the page image: it is F1 at most until corroborated again. An emend,
# relink or resolve leaves what the witness read as it was, so it keeps the leaf's level (spec/08 §8.1).
final = state final = state
touched = set() touched = set()
for rec in records: for rec in records:
if any(e["kind"] == "crop" for e in rec["evidence"]): if any(e["kind"] == "crop" for e in rec["evidence"]) and rec["op"] not in CO.KEEPS_LEVEL:
touched |= set(rec["touched"]) | set(rec.get("created", [])) touched |= set(rec["touched"]) | set(rec.get("created", []))
for n in final.nodes: for n in final.nodes:
if n["id"] in touched and n["kind"] in LEAVES: if n["id"] in touched and n["kind"] in LEAVES:
@@ -504,6 +505,22 @@ def _strip_private(spec, names):
return out return out
def reference_records(doc, side, names, resolved=None):
"""The records of references.jsonl: each reference node in document order, with its label, its parsed CSL and
its resolution, which is the source's unless a resolve correction set it (`resolved`, by node)."""
refs = []
for nid in doc.preorder():
s = side.get(nid, {})
if doc.nodes[nid]["kind"] == "reference":
r = {"node": nid, "label": doc.nodes[nid].get("label")}
if "_csl" in s:
r["csl"] = s["_csl"]
res = s.get("_resolution", {"type": "none"})
r["resolution"] = (resolved or {}).get(nid) or {k: names.resolve(v) for k, v in res.items()}
refs.append({k: v for k, v in r.items() if v is not None})
return refs
def package_files(src, key, names, side, final, records, receipts=None, roster_rec=None, witnesses=None, def package_files(src, key, names, side, final, records, receipts=None, roster_rec=None, witnesses=None,
pages=None, boxes=None, extra=None, absent=()): pages=None, boxes=None, extra=None, absent=()):
doc = final.doc() doc = final.doc()
@@ -523,16 +540,7 @@ def package_files(src, key, names, side, final, records, receipts=None, roster_r
locs.sort(key=lambda l: (pos[l["node"]], l["page"], l["page_fp"])) locs.sort(key=lambda l: (pos[l["node"]], l["page"], l["page_fp"]))
if locs: if locs:
files["locations.jsonl"] = jsonl(locs) files["locations.jsonl"] = jsonl(locs)
refs = [] refs = reference_records(doc, side, names, {r["node"]: r["resolution"] for r in final.references})
for nid in doc.preorder():
s = side.get(nid, {})
if doc.nodes[nid]["kind"] == "reference":
r = {"node": nid, "label": doc.nodes[nid].get("label")}
if "_csl" in s:
r["csl"] = s["_csl"]
res = s.get("_resolution", {"type": "none"})
r["resolution"] = {k: names.resolve(v) for k, v in res.items()}
refs.append({k: v for k, v in r.items() if v is not None})
if refs: if refs:
files["references.jsonl"] = jsonl(refs) files["references.jsonl"] = jsonl(refs)
if records: if records:
@@ -551,7 +559,7 @@ def package_files(src, key, names, side, final, records, receipts=None, roster_r
"tools": [{"name": "paperspec tools/build.py", "version": VERSION}], "tools": [{"name": "paperspec tools/build.py", "version": VERSION}],
"stages": [{"stage": "hand", "processor": "local", "tool": "paperspec tools/build.py"}], "stages": [{"stage": "hand", "processor": "local", "tool": "paperspec tools/build.py"}],
"note": "Built by hand for the conformance suite; every reading is synthetic."}) + "\n").encode() "note": "Built by hand for the conformance suite; every reading is synthetic."}) + "\n").encode()
levels = RC.effective_levels(nodes, vals, receipts or [], ROSTER_BY_ID if roster_rec else {}) levels = RC.effective_levels(nodes, vals, receipts or [], ROSTER_BY_ID if roster_rec else {}, records or [])
d = dict(src["document"]) d = dict(src["document"])
d = {"format": "scienting-doc/1", **d} d = {"format": "scienting-doc/1", **d}
d.update({"hashing": {"scheme": "plain", "algorithm": "sha-256"}, "root": vals[doc.root]["node_hash"], "rev": final.rev, d.update({"hashing": {"scheme": "plain", "algorithm": "sha-256"}, "root": vals[doc.root]["node_hash"], "rev": final.rev,
@@ -625,11 +633,29 @@ def build_hale(out):
mathml = ('<math display="block"><msub><mi>E</mi><mtext>bond</mtext></msub><mo>=</mo><mfrac><mn>1</mn><mn>2' mathml = ('<math display="block"><msub><mi>E</mi><mtext>bond</mtext></msub><mo>=</mo><mfrac><mn>1</mn><mn>2'
'</mn></mfrac><msub><mi>K</mi><mi>r</mi></msub><msup><mrow><mo>(</mo><mi>r</mi><mo>−</mo><msub><mi>r' '</mn></mfrac><msub><mi>K</mi><mi>r</mi></msub><msup><mrow><mo>(</mo><mi>r</mi><mo>−</mo><msub><mi>r'
'</mi><mtext>eq</mtext></msub><mo>)</mo></mrow><mn>2</mn></msup></math>') '</mi><mtext>eq</mtext></msub><mo>)</mo></mrow><mn>2</mn></msup></math>')
# The scienting-math/1 reading of three formulas (spec/09 §9.4): what papermath 0.1.0 prints for each source,
# copied here because the oracle does not implement the form, and checked by the validator only for what it
# can check without it (spec/12 §12.7). The run `_2` of "H₂O" has no base, so its tree is one opaque node.
math_tool = {"name": "papermath", "version": "0.1.0"}
s2_runs, s3_runs = final_doc.nodes[names.ids["@s2"]]["content"], final_doc.nodes[names.ids["@s3"]]["content"]
math = [
{"node": eq, "run": None, "tree": [
"rel", ["sym", "E_{\\text{bond}}"], "=",
["mul", ["frac", ["num", "1"], ["num", "2"]], ["sym", "K_{r}"],
["pow", ["add", ["sym", "r"], ["neg", ["sym", "r_{\\text{eq}}"]]], ["num", "2"]]]],
"symbols": ["E_{\\text{bond}}", "K_{r}", "r", "r_{\\text{eq}}"], "complete": True, "issues": []},
{"node": names.ids["@s2"], "run": next(i for i, r in enumerate(s2_runs) if r.get("source") == "K_r"),
"tree": ["sym", "K_{r}"], "symbols": ["K_{r}"], "complete": True, "issues": []},
{"node": names.ids["@s3"], "run": next(i for i, r in enumerate(s3_runs) if r.get("source") == "_2"),
"tree": ["opaque", "_{2}"], "symbols": [], "complete": False,
"issues": [{"code": "opaque", "message": "a part after the formula's end", "at": "_{2}"}]},
]
extra = { extra = {
"assets/%s.png" % image_sha: image, "assets/%s.png" % image_sha: image,
"datasets/%s/datapackage.json" % ds_id: (jcs.dumps(datapackage) + "\n").encode(), "datasets/%s/datapackage.json" % ds_id: (jcs.dumps(datapackage) + "\n").encode(),
"datasets/%s/data.csv" % ds_id: ("\n".join(csv) + "\n").encode(), "datasets/%s/data.csv" % ds_id: ("\n".join(csv) + "\n").encode(),
"datasets/%s/anchors.jsonl" % ds_id: jsonl(anchors), "datasets/%s/anchors.jsonl" % ds_id: jsonl(anchors),
"derived/math.jsonl": jsonl([dict(m, tool=math_tool, form="scienting-math/1") for m in math]),
"derived/mathml.jsonl": jsonl([{"node": eq, "run": None, "tool": {"name": "hand", "version": "0"}, "derived/mathml.jsonl": jsonl([{"node": eq, "run": None, "tool": {"name": "hand", "version": "0"},
"mathml": mathml}]), "mathml": mathml}]),
} }
@@ -659,7 +685,7 @@ def build_checks_only(out, hale):
n["attrs"].pop("figure_text", None) n["attrs"].pop("figure_text", None)
nodes.append(node_record(n, keyed)) nodes.append(node_record(n, keyed))
f = dict(hale["files"]) f = dict(hale["files"])
for p in ("corrections.jsonl", "receipts.jsonl", "roster.json", "derived/mathml.jsonl"): for p in ("corrections.jsonl", "receipts.jsonl", "roster.json", "derived/math.jsonl", "derived/mathml.jsonl"):
f.pop(p, None) f.pop(p, None)
for p in [p for p in f if p.startswith("datasets/")]: for p in [p for p in f if p.startswith("datasets/")]:
f.pop(p) f.pop(p)
@@ -786,6 +812,9 @@ def projection_case(cid, runs, note=None):
plain = hashing.plain(doc, s) plain = hashing.plain(doc, s)
c = {"id": cid, "runs": runs, "plain": plain, "normalized": norm(plain), "strict": strict, "lossy": lossy, c = {"id": cid, "runs": runs, "plain": plain, "normalized": norm(plain), "strict": strict, "lossy": lossy,
"complex": cx, "text_hash": H(norm(plain)), "match_hash": H(strict), "align_key": H(lossy)} "complex": cx, "text_hash": H(norm(plain)), "match_hash": H(strict), "align_key": H(lossy)}
printed = hashing.printed(doc, s)
if printed != plain: # runs an emend touched: the projection as printed, which the strict one is made from
c["printed"] = printed
if note: if note:
c["note"] = note c["note"] = note
return c return c
@@ -878,6 +907,11 @@ def vectors(out, hale, tiny):
projection_case("hyphen-before-digit", [T("pages 10-20 and CT\u2013CT with 6-31G*")]), projection_case("hyphen-before-digit", [T("pages 10-20 and CT\u2013CT with 6-31G*")]),
projection_case("en-dash-before-digit", [T("pages 10\u201320 and CT-CT with 6\u201331G*")]), projection_case("en-dash-before-digit", [T("pages 10\u201320 and CT-CT with 6\u201331G*")]),
projection_case("astral", [T("Let "), M("\U0001d465"), T(" vary.")]), projection_case("astral", [T("Let "), M("\U0001d465"), T(" vary.")]),
# An emend keeps what was printed (spec/03 §3.5): the plain projection reads the emended text, the strict
# and lossy ones the printed text, so the emended sentence still agrees with a witness that prints the slip.
projection_case("emended", [T("The "), dict(T("bond", style=["em"]), printed="bnod"), T(" was rigid.")],
"The authors printed 'bnod'; an emend reads 'bond'."),
projection_case("as-printed", [T("The "), T("bnod", style=["em"]), T(" was rigid.")]),
] ]
groups = [ groups = [
{"id": "h2o", "same": "match_hash", {"id": "h2o", "same": "match_hash",
@@ -893,6 +927,8 @@ def vectors(out, hale, tiny):
{"id": "cite-structure", "differ": "match_hash", "cases": ["cite-mark", "cite-as-text"]}, {"id": "cite-structure", "differ": "match_hash", "cases": ["cite-mark", "cite-as-text"]},
{"id": "dashes-align", "same": "align_key", "cases": ["hyphen-before-digit", "en-dash-before-digit"]}, {"id": "dashes-align", "same": "align_key", "cases": ["hyphen-before-digit", "en-dash-before-digit"]},
{"id": "dashes-text", "differ": "text_hash", "cases": ["hyphen-before-digit", "en-dash-before-digit"]}, {"id": "dashes-text", "differ": "text_hash", "cases": ["hyphen-before-digit", "en-dash-before-digit"]},
{"id": "emended-match", "same": "match_hash", "cases": ["emended", "as-printed"]},
{"id": "emended-text", "differ": "text_hash", "cases": ["emended", "as-printed"]},
] ]
byid = {c["id"]: c for c in pc} byid = {c["id"]: c for c in pc}
for g in groups: for g in groups:
@@ -917,8 +953,23 @@ def vectors(out, hale, tiny):
tdoc = Doc(tiny["key"], tnodes) tdoc = Doc(tiny["key"], tnodes)
tv = hashing.compute(tdoc) tv = hashing.compute(tdoc)
own = {nid: hashing.own_content(tdoc, nid, lambda x: tv[x]["text_hash"]) for nid in tdoc.order} own = {nid: hashing.own_content(tdoc, nid, lambda x: tv[x]["text_hash"]) for nid in tdoc.order}
# A sentence whose display equation and math run carry the form their canonical TeX is spelled in (spec/03 §3.7):
# `form` is in no own content and no projection, so the values are those of the same nodes without it.
form = "scienting-math/1"
fnodes = [{"id": "aaaaaaa", "kind": "document", "parent": None, "ord": 0},
{"id": "bbbbbbb", "kind": "section", "parent": "aaaaaaa", "ord": 0, "attrs": {"level": 1}},
{"id": "ccccccc", "kind": "paragraph", "parent": "bbbbbbb", "ord": 0},
{"id": "ddddddd", "kind": "sentence", "parent": "ccccccc", "ord": 0, "content": [
T("The energy is "), {"kind": "equation", "node": "eeeeeee"}, T(" where "),
dict(M("K_{r}"), form=form), T(" is the force constant.")]},
{"id": "eeeeeee", "kind": "equation", "parent": "ddddddd", "ord": 0,
"content": {"notation": "tex", "source": "E=\\frac{1}{2}K_{r}x^{2}", "form": form}}]
fdoc = Doc("vectors", fnodes)
fv = hashing.compute(fdoc)
fown = {nid: hashing.own_content(fdoc, nid, lambda x: fv[x]["text_hash"]) for nid in fdoc.order}
wv(out, "hashes.jsonl", [{"id": "tiny2026example", "doc": tiny["key"], "nodes": tnodes, wv(out, "hashes.jsonl", [{"id": "tiny2026example", "doc": tiny["key"], "nodes": tnodes,
"own_content": own, "values": tv}]) "own_content": own, "values": tv},
{"id": "math-form", "doc": "vectors", "nodes": fnodes, "own_content": fown, "values": fv}])
# Addresses. The example keys are real work keys: Cornell et al. (1995) by its DOI, a fictional preprint. # Addresses. The example keys are real work keys: Cornell et al. (1995) by its DOI, a fictional preprint.
cornell = "cornell1995second-" + K.suffix("doi:10.1021/ja00124a002") cornell = "cornell1995second-" + K.suffix("doi:10.1021/ja00124a002")
dong = "dong2026machine-" + K.suffix("doi:10.5555/example.dong.2026") dong = "dong2026machine-" + K.suffix("doi:10.5555/example.dong.2026")
@@ -1126,7 +1177,22 @@ def vectors(out, hale, tiny):
item("b5", [T("where "), M("\\frac{c}{e}"), T(" is the bond length.")], "q2"), item("b5", [T("where "), M("\\frac{c}{e}"), T(" is the bond length.")], "q2"),
item("b6", [T("A sentence only the second reading has, also long.")], "q2"), item("b6", [T("A sentence only the second reading has, also long.")], "q2"),
item("b7", [T("The last sentence of the section is unique and long enough.")], "q2")] item("b7", [T("The last sentence of the section is unique and long enough.")], "q2")]
wv(out, "alignment.jsonl", [{"id": "two-readings", "a": A, "b": B, "expect": AL.align(A, B)}]) # Substitutions (step 3): a misread number and a misread word pair with their other readings; a short
# sentence and two sentences too unlike to be one stay dropped and added.
SA = [item("c1", [T("The force constants were fitted to ab initio scans of every bond.")], "p1"),
item("c2", [T("The bond constant was 310.0 kcal/mol for every aliphatic carbon.")], "p1"),
item("c3", [T("This prototypal set was later extended to nucleic acids.")], "p1"),
item("c4", [T("See below.")], "p1"),
item("c5", [T("Torsions were refit against a second, larger set of conformers.")], "p1"),
item("c6", [T("The charges came from a two-stage restrained fit to the potential.")], "p2")]
SB = [item("d1", [T("The force constants were fitted to ab initio scans of every bond.")], "q1"),
item("d2", [T("The bond constant was 3l0.0 kcal/mol for every aliphatic carbon.")], "q1"),
item("d3", [T("This prototypical set was later extended to nucleic acids.")], "q1"),
item("d4", [T("See bclow.")], "q1"),
item("d5", [T("Only the second reading prints this line about water models.")], "q1"),
item("d6", [T("The charges came from a two-stage restrained fit to the potential.")], "q2")]
wv(out, "alignment.jsonl", [{"id": "two-readings", "a": A, "b": B, "expect": AL.align(A, B)},
{"id": "substitutions", "a": SA, "b": SB, "expect": AL.align(SA, SB)}])
# Corrections, op by op, on the tiny document. # Corrections, op by op, on the tiny document.
wv(out, "corrections.jsonl", corrections_vectors()) wv(out, "corrections.jsonl", corrections_vectors())
# Anchor resolution against the hale package. # Anchor resolution against the hale package.
@@ -1182,23 +1248,73 @@ def corrections_vectors():
# A model proposed this one, so its author names the model, by weights and prompt, and the run. # A model proposed this one, so its author names the model, by weights and prompt, and the run.
("replace-by-model", {"op": "replace", "target": nm["@c"], "find": "second", "replace": "later", "evidence": person, ("replace-by-model", {"op": "replace", "target": nm["@c"], "find": "second", "replace": "later", "evidence": person,
"author": {"model": MODEL, "run": "illustrative-run-7"}}), "author": {"model": MODEL, "run": "illustrative-run-7"}}),
# Emend (spec/11 §11.1): the authors' own slips. The found text becomes a run that keeps what was printed, so
# the match_hash and align_key stay those of the printed text, and the expectation adds the leaf as printed.
("emend", {"op": "emend", "target": nm["@b"], "find": "the note", "replace": "the notes", "kind": "grammar",
"note": "The sentence points at two notes below the table.", "evidence": person}),
("emend-xref", {"op": "emend", "target": nm["@b"], "find": "Table 1", "replace": "Tab. 1", "kind": "wording",
"evidence": person}),
("emend-digit", {"op": "emend", "target": nm["@a"], "find": "42.0", "replace": "42,0", "kind": "punctuation",
"evidence": crop}),
("emend-across-runs", {"op": "emend", "target": nm["@b"], "find": "1 and", "replace": "1, and",
"kind": "punctuation", "evidence": person}),
("emend-not-runs", {"op": "emend", "target": nm["@t"], "find": "x", "replace": "X", "kind": "typo",
"evidence": person}),
# Relink (spec/11 §11.1): the cite run becomes text with the same text, which joins the text before it.
("relink-unlink", {"op": "relink", "target": nm["@b"], "run": 3, "refs": None, "evidence": person}),
("relink-xref", {"op": "relink", "target": nm["@b"], "run": 1, "refs": [nm["@r"]], "evidence": person}),
("relink-not-reference", {"op": "relink", "target": nm["@b"], "run": 3, "refs": [nm["@a"]], "evidence": person}),
# Resolve (spec/11 §11.1): the reference's record in references.jsonl, which the state before and after holds.
("resolve-doi", {"op": "resolve", "target": nm["@r"], "resolution": {"type": "doi", "doi": "10.5555/example.ref.2020"},
"evidence": [{"kind": "person", "by": "ana", "note": "Matched by title and year."}]}),
("resolve-not-reference", {"op": "resolve", "target": nm["@a"], "resolution": {"type": "none"},
"evidence": person}),
] ]
# Cases on other states: a math run, a citation read as a superscript, and a run already emended.
st_math, _ = CO.apply(st0, dict(base, **dict(cases)["replace-runs"]), store=SCHEMAS)
st_emended, _ = CO.apply(st0, dict(base, **dict(cases)["emend"]), store=SCHEMAS)
sup = [dict(n, content=[T("The value is 42.0 at 300 K."), T("1", style=["sup"])]) if n["id"] == nm["@a"] else n
for n in st0.nodes]
others = {
"emend-math": (CO.State(st0.key, st_math.nodes), {"op": "emend", "target": nm["@a"], "find": "mathrm",
"replace": "mathup", "kind": "typo", "evidence": person}),
"relink-superscript": (CO.State(st0.key, sup), {"op": "relink", "target": nm["@a"], "run": 1, "refs": [nm["@r"]],
"evidence": person}),
"replace-emended": (CO.State(st0.key, st_emended.nodes), {"op": "replace", "target": nm["@b"], "find": "notes",
"replace": "note", "evidence": crop}),
}
out = [] out = []
vals0 = hashing.compute(st0.doc()) for cid, c in cases + [(cid, c) for cid, (_, c) in others.items()]:
before = [dict(n, **vals0[n["id"]]) for n in st0.nodes] st = others[cid][0] if cid in others else st0
for cid, c in cases: vals0 = hashing.compute(st.doc())
c = dict(base, **c) c = dict(base, **c)
case = {"id": cid, "doc": st0.key, "before": {"nodes": before, "ids": [], "rev": 0}, "correction": c} before = {"nodes": [dict(n, **vals0[n["id"]]) for n in st.nodes], "ids": [], "rev": 0}
if c["op"] == "resolve":
st = CO.State(st.key, st.nodes, references=st0.references)
before["references"] = st.references
case = {"id": cid, "doc": st0.key, "before": before, "correction": c}
try: try:
st1, rec = CO.apply(st0, c, store=SCHEMAS) st1, rec = CO.apply(st, c, store=SCHEMAS)
v1 = hashing.compute(st1.doc()) case["expect"] = correction_expect(st1, rec, "references" in before)
case["expect"] = {"record": rec, "nodes": [dict(n, **v1[n["id"]]) for n in st1.nodes], "ids": st1.ids}
except Refusal as e: except Refusal as e:
case["expect"] = {"refusal": e.rule} case["expect"] = {"refusal": e.rule}
out.append(case) out.append(case)
return out return out
def correction_expect(st1, rec, references=False):
"""What a correction vector expects: the record, the nodes with their values and the ID table; the reference
records too when the case gives them; and for an emend, its leaf as printed (spec/03 §3.6)."""
d1 = st1.doc()
v1 = hashing.compute(d1)
out = {"record": rec, "nodes": [dict(n, **v1[n["id"]]) for n in st1.nodes], "ids": st1.ids}
if references:
out["references"] = st1.references
if rec["op"] == "emend":
out["printed"] = {nid: hashing.printed(d1, nid) for nid in rec["touched"]}
return out
def resolve_vectors(hale): def resolve_vectors(hale):
src, names, states, final = hale["src"], hale["names"], hale["states"], hale["final"] src, names, states, final = hale["src"], hale["names"], hale["states"], hale["final"]
s0 = states[0] s0 = states[0]
@@ -1276,6 +1392,10 @@ def ann_hash(a):
TAG = "tag:scient.ing,2026:" TAG = "tag:scient.ing,2026:"
# The claim amber/k-bond of paperclaim's example store, by its tag; paperclaim prints its pin as claim:272XTX7C@02f47b.
CLAIM_K_BOND = "claim:272XTX7C"
# The layer of traced citations on the draft (spec/18 §18.5), which the project holds beside the example layer.
TRACE_LAYER = TAG + "layer:smithlab/tr6c3q8m"
# A model's provenance: enough to name the weights and the instructions it ran with (all illustrative). # A model's provenance: enough to name the weights and the instructions it ran with (all illustrative).
MODEL = {"name": "example-model", "provider": "Example Models (illustrative)", "version": "2026-09", MODEL = {"name": "example-model", "provider": "Example Models (illustrative)", "version": "2026-09",
"weights": sha256_hex("illustrative weights"), "prompt": sha256_hex("illustrative review prompt"), "weights": sha256_hex("illustrative weights"), "prompt": sha256_hex("illustrative review prompt"),
@@ -1394,11 +1514,15 @@ def records(out, hale):
ann({"type": "TextualBody", "kind": "gloss", "audience": "novice", "format": "text/markdown", "language": "en", ann({"type": "TextualBody", "kind": "gloss", "audience": "novice", "format": "text/markdown", "language": "en",
"value": "A *harmonic* term treats a bond like a spring: the energy grows with the square of the stretch."}, "value": "A *harmonic* term treats a bond like a spring: the energy grows with the square of the stretch."},
target(anchor("@s2", "bond force constant")), "describing", "confirmed"), target(anchor("@s2", "bond force constant")), "describing", "confirmed"),
ann({"type": "SpecificResource", "kind": "claim-link", "source": "lode:amber/k-bond", "pin": "illustrative-pin", # paperclaim's references (spec/18 §18.4): the claim amber/k-bond by its tag, pinned to its statement hash.
ann({"type": "SpecificResource", "kind": "claim-link", "source": CLAIM_K_BOND, "pin": CLAIM_K_BOND + "@02f47b",
"role": "states"}, target(anchor("@s2")), "linking", "confirmed"), "role": "states"}, target(anchor("@s2")), "linking", "confirmed"),
ann({"type": "TextualBody", "kind": "comment", "value": "The step size matters more than the text admits."}, # Comments, caveats and questions carry the category a producer that supports categories always sets
# (spec/18 §18.4).
ann({"type": "TextualBody", "kind": "comment", "category": "critique",
"value": "The step size matters more than the text admits."},
target(anchor("@s6a", "steps of 0.01")), "commenting"), target(anchor("@s6a", "steps of 0.01")), "commenting"),
ann({"type": "TextualBody", "kind": "question", "for": "group", ann({"type": "TextualBody", "kind": "question", "category": "question", "for": "group",
"value": "Why fit to a scan first and to frequencies second?"}, "value": "Why fit to a scan first and to frequencies second?"},
target(AN.make_anchor(doc, vals, I["@sec2"], rev, store=STORE)), "questioning"), target(AN.make_anchor(doc, vals, I["@sec2"], rev, store=STORE)), "questioning"),
ann({"type": "TextualBody", "kind": "citation-context", "reference": I["@r2"], "verdict": "cannot-tell", ann({"type": "TextualBody", "kind": "citation-context", "reference": I["@r2"], "verdict": "cannot-tell",
@@ -1416,8 +1540,16 @@ def records(out, hale):
"value": "Energy along the C–C bond stretch (panel a) and the fit residual (panel b)."}, "value": "Energy along the C–C bond stretch (panel a) and the fit residual (panel b)."},
target(AN.make_anchor(doc, vals, I["@fig1"], rev, store=STORE)), "describing", "confirmed"), target(AN.make_anchor(doc, vals, I["@fig1"], rev, store=STORE)), "describing", "confirmed"),
] ]
anns.append(ann({"type": "TextualBody", "kind": "comment", "value": "Agreed; see the residual panel."}, anns.append(ann({"type": "TextualBody", "kind": "comment", "category": "comment",
"value": "Agreed; see the residual panel."},
{"type": "SpecificResource", "source": anns[2]["id"]}, "replying", created="2026-10-11T19:05:00Z")) {"type": "SpecificResource", "source": anns[2]["id"]}, "replying", created="2026-10-11T19:05:00Z"))
anns.append(ann({"type": "TextualBody", "kind": "caveat", "category": "context",
"value": "The band position is cited, not measured here; reference 2 is not in the library."},
target(anchor("@s3", "1595")), "commenting", created="2026-10-11T19:10:00Z"))
# A symbol: the span $K_r$ is the symbol the claim defines, named by its scienting-math/1 key (spec/09 §9.4).
anns.append(ann({"type": "SpecificResource", "kind": "symbol", "source": CLAIM_K_BOND, "pin": CLAIM_K_BOND + "@02f47b",
"key": "K_{r}", "symbol": "K_r"},
target(anchor("@s2", "$K_r$")), "identifying", created="2026-10-11T19:15:00Z"))
confirmed = [a for a in anns if a["status"] == "confirmed"] confirmed = [a for a in anns if a["status"] == "confirmed"]
lr = RC.seal({"format": "scienting-receipt/1", "doc": HALE, "rev": rev, "level": "F3", lr = RC.seal({"format": "scienting-receipt/1", "doc": HALE, "rev": rev, "level": "F3",
"scope": "targeted:layer", "nodes": [], "scope": "targeted:layer", "nodes": [],
@@ -1469,9 +1601,9 @@ def records(out, hale):
"paths": [{"id": "onboarding", "title": "First week", "steps": [ "paths": [{"id": "onboarding", "title": "First week", "steps": [
{"type": "document", "ref": QHALE, "note": "Read the introduction."}, {"type": "document", "ref": QHALE, "note": "Read the introduction."},
{"type": "node", "ref": QHALE + "#" + I["@tab1"], "note": "Then the table."}, {"type": "node", "ref": QHALE + "#" + I["@tab1"], "note": "Then the table."},
{"type": "claim", "ref": "lode:amber/k-bond"}]}], {"type": "claim", "ref": CLAIM_K_BOND, "note": "The bond force constant, amber/k-bond."}]}],
"layers": [layer_id], "datasets": ["ds-hale-bond-params", "ds-hale-ctct-scan"], "views": ["ctct-scan"], "layers": [layer_id, TRACE_LAYER], "datasets": ["ds-hale-bond-params", "ds-hale-ctct-scan"], "views": ["ctct-scan"],
"drafts": [STORE + "/" + DRAFT], "claims": {"lode": "amber"}, "drafts": [STORE + "/" + DRAFT], "claims": {"paperclaim": "amber"},
"settings": {"digit_rule": "anchored-sections", "drift_threshold": "0.25", "settings": {"digit_rule": "anchored-sections", "drift_threshold": "0.25",
"spot_check": {"rate": "0.05", "minimum": 10}, "rights_unknown": "refuse", "spot_check": {"rate": "0.05", "minimum": 10}, "rights_unknown": "refuse",
"stages": "scienting-stages-default", "stages": "scienting-stages-default",
@@ -1631,6 +1763,203 @@ def records(out, hale):
wr(out, "draft-ids.jsonl", jsonl(lines)) wr(out, "draft-ids.jsonl", jsonl(lines))
# --- traced citations ---------------------------------------------------------------
def traces(out, hale, draft):
"""The layer of traced citations on the draft, which cites the main example (spec/18 §18.5), and
vectors/traces.jsonl: each trace resolved against the two packages, after corrections that make it current,
changed, stale, unlinked or misresolved, and the traces that break `layer.trace.source` or `layer.trace.target`."""
HALE, WRITER = hale["key"], draft["key"]
QHALE, QWRITER = STORE + "/" + HALE, STORE + "/" + WRITER
OKAFOR = Names.registry["okafor2025open"].key
pkgs = os.path.join(out, "fixtures", "packages")
cited = read_state(os.path.join(pkgs, HALE))
citing = read_state(os.path.join(pkgs, WRITER))
hdoc, wdoc = cited.doc(), citing.doc()
hvals, wvals = hashing.compute(hdoc), hashing.compute(wdoc)
sentences = {hashing.plain(hdoc, n): n for n in hdoc.order if hdoc.nodes[n]["kind"] == "sentence"}
sentence = next(n for t, n in sentences.items() if t.startswith("We fit harmonic bond constants"))
intro = next(n for t, n in sentences.items() if t.startswith("Harmonic bond terms remain"))
table = hale["names"].ids["@tab1"]
cell = hale["names"].ids["@ow_ak"]
sentence_citing = draft["names"].ids["@d2"]
reference = draft["names"].ids["@dr1"]
other_sentence = draft["names"].ids["@d1"]
def anchor(doc, vals, rev, nid, quote=None):
span = None
if quote:
t = hashing.plain(doc, nid)
i = t.index(quote)
span = [i, i + len(quote)]
return AN.make_anchor(doc, vals, nid, rev, span=span, store=STORE)
def selector(a):
return [{"type": "AnchorSelector", "anchor": a}] + (
[{"type": "TextQuoteSelector", "exact": a["quote"]["exact"], "prefix": a["quote"].get("prefix", ""),
"suffix": a["quote"].get("suffix", "")}] if "quote" in a and "exact" in a["quote"] else [])
def target(a):
return {"type": "SpecificResource", "source": TAG + "doc:" + QWRITER, "selector": selector(a)}
def body(passage, note=None, verdict=None, proposer=None):
b = {"type": "SpecificResource", "kind": "trace", "source": TAG + "doc:" + QHALE, "selector": selector(passage),
"reference": reference}
for k, v in (("note", note), ("verdict", verdict), ("proposer", proposer)):
if v is not None:
b[k] = v
return b
ana = {"id": TAG + "key:ana", "type": "Person", "name": "Ana Example"}
ben = {"id": TAG + "key:ben", "type": "Person", "name": "Ben Example"}
model = {"id": TAG + "software:example-model", "type": "Software", "name": "A model (illustrative)"}
def ann(b, tgt, status, who, created, motivation="linking"):
a = {"@context": CTX, "type": "Annotation", "layer": TRACE_LAYER, "motivation": motivation, "creator": who,
"created": created, "body": b, "target": tgt}
a["id"] = TAG + "annotation:smithlab/" + record_id(H(jcs.dumpb(a)))
a["status"] = status
return a
span_citing = anchor(wdoc, wvals, citing.rev, sentence_citing, "two-step fit")
whole_citing = anchor(wdoc, wvals, citing.rev, sentence_citing)
hrev = cited.rev
run = "illustrative-run-2"
# A model found the abstract for the citation of "a two-step fit" and a person confirmed it; its second candidate,
# the introduction's sentence with a citation of its own, a person turned down.
best = ann(body(anchor(hdoc, hvals, hrev, sentence, "in two steps"),
note="The abstract states the two steps: a scan first, then vibrational frequencies.",
verdict="supports", proposer={"model": MODEL, "run": run, "score": "0.8731", "rank": 1}),
target(span_citing), "confirmed", model, "2026-10-12T09:00:00Z")
second = ann(body(anchor(hdoc, hvals, hrev, intro, "classical force fields.1"),
note="Says harmonic terms are common, not how the constants were fitted.",
proposer={"model": MODEL, "run": run, "score": "0.6410", "rank": 2}),
target(span_citing), "rejected", model, "2026-10-12T09:00:00Z")
# A person's trace for the same sentence as a whole: the table it points at.
person = ann(body(anchor(hdoc, hvals, hrev, table), note="Table 1 lists the fitted constants of both parameter sets.",
verdict="supports"),
target(whole_citing), "confirmed", ana, "2026-10-12T09:10:00Z")
reply = ann({"type": "TextualBody", "kind": "comment", "category": "critique",
"value": "The abstract names the two steps but not the constants; the table is the better passage."},
{"type": "SpecificResource", "source": best["id"]}, "proposed", ben, "2026-10-12T10:00:00Z", "assessing")
anns = [best, second, person, reply]
confirmed = [a for a in anns if a["status"] == "confirmed"]
lr = RC.seal({"format": "scienting-receipt/1", "doc": WRITER, "rev": citing.rev, "level": "F3",
"scope": "targeted:traces", "nodes": [],
"records": sorted([["annotation", a["id"].rsplit("/", 1)[1], ann_hash(a)] for a in confirmed]),
"evidence": [], "by": "ana", "at": "2026-10-12T09:30:00Z"}, secret("ana"), "ana")
for a in confirmed:
a["receipt"] = lr["id"]
wr(out, "traces/layer.json", {"@context": CTX, "format": "scienting-layer/1", "id": TRACE_LAYER,
"type": "AnnotationCollection", "label": "Where the draft's citations lead",
"purpose": "Traces from the draft's citations of Hale and Osei to the passages they rest on.",
"audience": "expert", "visibility": "team", "license": {"spdx": "CC-BY-4.0"},
"creator": ana, "created": "2026-10-12T09:00:00Z", "project": "smithlab-charges",
"docs": [QWRITER], "total": len(anns)})
wr(out, "traces/annotations.jsonl", jsonl(anns))
wr(out, "traces/receipt.json", lr)
# The vectors. A case names the two packages, the corrections that bring each to the state to judge, and the
# annotation; the expected outcome is computed here, never typed.
base = {"author": {"key": "ana"}, "reason": "Vector.", "at": "2026-10-13T12:00:00Z"}
person_ev = [{"kind": "person", "by": "ana"}]
crop_ev = [{"kind": "crop", "sha256": crop_sha(cell)}]
def corr(c):
return dict(base, **c)
def evolve(state, corrections):
for c in corrections:
state, _ = CO.apply(state, c, store=SCHEMAS)
return state
def case(cid, a, citing_c=(), cited_c=(), same_as=()):
cc, dc = [corr(c) for c in citing_c], [corr(c) for c in cited_c]
res = TR.resolve(a, evolve(citing, cc), evolve(cited, dc), same_as)
return {"id": cid, "op": "resolve", "citing": "fixtures/packages/" + WRITER, "cited": "fixtures/packages/" + HALE,
"citing_corrections": cc, "cited_corrections": dc, "same_as": list(same_as), "annotation": a,
"expect": res}
def broken(cid, a):
# The cited state is given when the passage is in the cited package; a trace that names the draft itself
# is checked without it.
passage = _anchors_of(a["body"])
use = cited if passage and passage[0]["doc"] == HALE else None
return {"id": cid, "op": "problems", "citing": "fixtures/packages/" + WRITER,
"cited": "fixtures/packages/" + HALE if use else None, "annotation": a,
"expect": TR.problems(a, citing, use)}
unlink = {"op": "relink", "target": sentence_citing, "run": 3, "refs": None, "evidence": person_ev}
def resolve_to(res):
return {"op": "resolve", "target": reference, "resolution": res, "evidence": person_ev}
def replace(target_id, find, new, ev=person_ev):
return {"op": "replace", "target": target_id, "find": find, "replace": new, "evidence": ev}
hale_doi = "doi:10.5555/example.hale.2026"
stale_cited = replace(sentence, "in two steps", "in three stages")
stale_citing = replace(sentence_citing, "two-step", "two-stage")
cases = [
case("current-abstract", best),
case("current-table", person),
case("current-candidate-with-citation", second),
case("changed-passage-moved", best, cited_c=[replace(sentence, "twelve bonds", "all bonds")]),
case("changed-sentence", best, citing_c=[replace(sentence_citing, "Its constants", "The constants")]),
case("changed-table", person, cited_c=[replace(cell, "553.0", "552.0", crop_ev)]),
case("stale-cited", best, cited_c=[stale_cited]),
case("stale-citing", best, citing_c=[stale_citing]),
case("stale-both", best, citing_c=[stale_citing], cited_c=[stale_cited]),
case("stale-citing-whole-sentence", person, citing_c=[stale_citing]),
case("unlinked", best, citing_c=[unlink]),
case("misresolved-doi", best, citing_c=[resolve_to({"type": "doi", "doi": "10.5555/example.other.2020"})],
same_as=[hale_doi]),
case("misresolved-document", best, citing_c=[resolve_to({"type": "document", "doc": STORE + "/" + OKAFOR})],
same_as=[hale_doi]),
case("misresolved-doi-without-same-as", best, citing_c=[resolve_to({"type": "doi", "doi": "10.5555/example.hale.2026"})]),
case("current-doi-in-same-as", best, citing_c=[resolve_to({"type": "doi", "doi": "10.5555/Example.Hale.2026"})],
same_as=[hale_doi]),
case("current-another-version", best, citing_c=[resolve_to({"type": "document", "doc": QHALE + ".v2"})]),
case("current-reference-unresolved", best, citing_c=[resolve_to({"type": "none"})]),
case("unlinked-before-misresolved", best, citing_c=[unlink, resolve_to({"type": "doi", "doi": "10.5555/example.other.2020"})]),
]
# Traces that break a rule: each is the confirmed model trace changed in one way.
tag_okafor = TAG + "doc:" + STORE + "/" + OKAFOR
plain_anchor = _anchors_of(best["body"])[0]
cites_nothing = anchor(wdoc, wvals, citing.rev, other_sentence)
paragraph = anchor(wdoc, wvals, citing.rev, wdoc.nodes[sentence_citing]["parent"])
def edited(body_edit=None, target_edit=None):
a = copy.deepcopy(best)
a["body"].update(body_edit or {})
a["target"] = target_edit if target_edit is not None else a["target"]
return a
quote_differs = copy.deepcopy(best["body"]["selector"])
quote_differs[1]["exact"] = "in three steps"
unknown_node = copy.deepcopy(plain_anchor)
unknown_node["node"] = "zzzzzzz"
broken_cases = [
broken("problems-none", best),
broken("problems-table", person),
broken("source-is-another-document", edited({"source": tag_okafor})),
broken("source-is-the-citing-document", edited({"source": TAG + "doc:" + QWRITER, "selector": selector(span_citing)})),
broken("source-without-anchor", edited({"selector": [best["body"]["selector"][1]]})),
broken("source-quote-differs", edited({"selector": [best["body"]["selector"][0], quote_differs[1]]})),
broken("source-node-unknown", edited({"selector": [{"type": "AnchorSelector", "anchor": unknown_node}]})),
broken("target-is-a-paragraph", edited(target_edit=target(paragraph))),
broken("target-cites-nothing", edited(target_edit=target(cites_nothing))),
broken("target-reference-is-a-sentence", edited({"reference": sentence_citing})),
broken("target-is-a-reply", edited(target_edit={"type": "SpecificResource", "source": second["id"]})),
]
wv(out, "traces.jsonl", cases + broken_cases)
def _anchors_of(body):
return [s["anchor"] for s in body["selector"] if s["type"] == "AnchorSelector"]
# --- invalid packages --------------------------------------------------------------- # --- invalid packages ---------------------------------------------------------------
@@ -1841,13 +2170,14 @@ def main(out):
hale = build_hale(out) hale = build_hale(out)
build_checks_only(out, hale) build_checks_only(out, hale)
build_simple(out, "okafor2025open") build_simple(out, "okafor2025open")
build_simple(out, "smithlab2027charges") draft = build_simple(out, "smithlab2027charges")
tiny = tiny_package(None) tiny = tiny_package(None)
tiny_dir = os.path.join(out, "fixtures", "packages", tiny["key"]) tiny_dir = os.path.join(out, "fixtures", "packages", tiny["key"])
write(tiny_dir, tiny["files"]) write(tiny_dir, tiny["files"])
# The same package zipped as spec/12 §12.2 says a producer writes a byte-identical archive. # The same package zipped as spec/12 §12.2 says a producer writes a byte-identical archive.
write_zip(tiny_dir, tiny_dir + ZIP_EXTENSION) write_zip(tiny_dir, tiny_dir + ZIP_EXTENSION)
records(out, hale) records(out, hale)
traces(out, hale, draft)
vectors(out, hale, tiny) vectors(out, hale, tiny)
invalid(out, tiny) invalid(out, tiny)
+279 -13
View File
@@ -27,7 +27,7 @@ from paperspec import anchors as AN # noqa: E402
from paperspec import corrections as CO # noqa: E402 from paperspec import corrections as CO # noqa: E402
from paperspec import crypto, db, fingerprint as FP, grade as GR, hashing, jcs, receipts as RC, rights as RI # noqa: E402 from paperspec import crypto, db, fingerprint as FP, grade as GR, hashing, jcs, receipts as RC, rights as RI # noqa: E402
from paperspec import package as PK # noqa: E402 from paperspec import package as PK # noqa: E402
from paperspec import keys as K, log as LG, mldsa, targets as TG, vrf # noqa: E402 from paperspec import keys as K, log as LG, mldsa, targets as TG, traces as TR, vrf # noqa: E402
import unicodedata # noqa: E402 import unicodedata # noqa: E402
from paperspec.model import Doc # noqa: E402 from paperspec.model import Doc # noqa: E402
from paperspec.notation import fold_math # noqa: E402 from paperspec.notation import fold_math # noqa: E402
@@ -77,6 +77,7 @@ def fixture_key(stem):
HALE = fixture_key("hale2026harmonic") HALE = fixture_key("hale2026harmonic")
DRAFT = fixture_key("smithlab2027charges")
TINY_KEY = fixture_key("tiny2026example") TINY_KEY = fixture_key("tiny2026example")
SCHEMA_FILES = sorted(f for f in os.listdir(p("schemas")) if f.endswith(".schema.json")) SCHEMA_FILES = sorted(f for f in os.listdir(p("schemas")) if f.endswith(".schema.json"))
FORMAT_SCHEMA = {f["format"]: f["schema"] for f in js(p("registry", "formats.json"))["formats"]} FORMAT_SCHEMA = {f["format"]: f["schema"] for f in js(p("registry", "formats.json"))["formats"]}
@@ -194,10 +195,18 @@ def check_records():
stage_ids = {js(p("registry", "stages", f))["id"] for f in os.listdir(p("registry", "stages")) if f.endswith(".json")} stage_ids = {js(p("registry", "stages", f))["id"] for f in os.listdir(p("registry", "stages")) if f.endswith(".json")}
stages = js(os.path.join(R, "project.json")).get("settings", {}).get("stages") stages = js(os.path.join(R, "project.json")).get("settings", {}).get("stages")
ok("records", stages is None or stages in stage_ids, "project settings.stages names no stage file: %s" % stages) ok("records", stages is None or stages in stage_ids, "project settings.stages names no stage file: %s" % stages)
# Confirmed annotations are covered by the layer receipt at their content hash. # Confirmed annotations are covered by the layer receipt at their content hash, in both layers: the example
lr = js(os.path.join(R, "layer", "receipt.json")) # layer on the main example and the layer of traces on the draft.
for layer in ("layer", "traces"):
lj = js(os.path.join(R, layer, "layer.json"))
lr = js(os.path.join(R, layer, "receipt.json"))
items = {(k, i): h for k, i, h in lr["records"]} items = {(k, i): h for k, i, h in lr["records"]}
for a in jl(os.path.join(R, "layer", "annotations.jsonl")): lines = jl(os.path.join(R, layer, "annotations.jsonl"))
ok("records", lj["total"] == len(lines) and all(a["layer"] == lj["id"] for a in lines),
"%s: the layer's total or an annotation's layer differs" % layer)
ok("records", any(d.endswith("/" + lr["doc"]) for d in lj["docs"]),
"%s: the receipt is for a document the layer does not annotate" % layer)
for a in lines:
sel = a["target"].get("selector", []) sel = a["target"].get("selector", [])
anchors = [x["anchor"] for x in sel if x.get("type") == "AnchorSelector"] anchors = [x["anchor"] for x in sel if x.get("type") == "AnchorSelector"]
for x in sel: for x in sel:
@@ -212,7 +221,7 @@ def check_records():
if a["status"] == "confirmed": if a["status"] == "confirmed":
ok("records", items.get(("annotation", a["id"].rsplit("/", 1)[1])) == sha256_hex(jcs.dumpb(body)), ok("records", items.get(("annotation", a["id"].rsplit("/", 1)[1])) == sha256_hex(jcs.dumpb(body)),
"a confirmed annotation is not covered at its hash: " + a["id"]) "a confirmed annotation is not covered at its hash: " + a["id"])
ok("records", lr["root"] == crypto.merkle_root(crypto.receipt_items(lr)), "layer receipt root") ok("records", lr["root"] == crypto.merkle_root(crypto.receipt_items(lr)), "%s: layer receipt root" % layer)
# Every figure of the main example has a confirmed description, which is what an accessible export needs. # Every figure of the main example has a confirmed description, which is what an accessible export needs.
anns = jl(os.path.join(R, "layer", "annotations.jsonl")) anns = jl(os.path.join(R, "layer", "annotations.jsonl"))
described = {x["anchor"]["node"] for a in anns if a["body"]["kind"] == "description" and a["status"] == "confirmed" described = {x["anchor"]["node"] for a in anns if a["body"]["kind"] == "description" and a["status"] == "confirmed"
@@ -222,6 +231,27 @@ def check_records():
% sorted(figures - described)) % sorted(figures - described))
ok("records", any(a["body"]["kind"] == "generated" and a["status"] == "proposed" for a in anns), ok("records", any(a["body"]["kind"] == "generated" and a["status"] == "proposed" for a in anns),
"the layer has no proposed generated annotation to contrast with the confirmed description") "the layer has no proposed generated annotation to contrast with the confirmed description")
# The fixtures' producer supports categories, so it sets one on every comment, caveat and question (spec/18 §18.4).
ok("records", all("category" in a["body"] for a in anns if a["body"]["kind"] in ("comment", "caveat", "question")),
"a comment, caveat or question of the layer has no category")
# A claim's pin names the claim its source does (spec/18 §18.4), and a symbol names its symbol by its key.
claims = [a["body"] for a in anns if a["body"]["kind"] in ("claim-link", "symbol")]
ok("records", {b["kind"] for b in claims} == {"claim-link", "symbol"}, "the layer lacks a claim link or a symbol")
for b in claims:
ok("records", "pin" not in b or b["pin"].startswith(b["source"] + "@"),
"a %s pins another claim than its source: %s, %s" % (b["kind"], b["source"], b.get("pin")))
common = STORE.load("common.schema.json")["$id"]
def errors(defn, value):
return list(Draft202012Validator({"$ref": common + "#/$defs/" + defn}, registry=STORE.registry()).iter_errors(value))
for bad in ("claim:amber/k-bond", "claim:272xtx7c", "claim:272XTXIC", "claim:example/272XTX7C", "claim:272XTX7C@02f47b",
"pcl:272XTX7C", "272XTX7C"):
ok("records", errors("claimRef", bad) != [], "%s is taken for a claim reference" % bad)
for bad in ("illustrative-pin", "claim:272XTX7C", "claim:272XTX7C@02F47B", "claim:272XTX7C@02f47"):
ok("records", errors("claimPin", bad) != [], "%s is taken for a claim pin" % bad)
for good in ("claim:272XTX7C", "claim:claims.example.org/272XTX7C"):
ok("records", errors("claimRef", good) == [] and errors("claimPin", good + "@02f47b") == [],
"%s is refused as a claim reference" % good)
def state_of(pkg): def state_of(pkg):
@@ -262,6 +292,63 @@ def check_packages():
"CSV value differs from its cell: %s/%s" % (va["row"], va["field"])) "CSV value differs from its cell: %s/%s" % (va["row"], va["field"]))
for m in jl(os.path.join(hp, "derived", "mathml.jsonl")): for m in jl(os.path.join(hp, "derived", "mathml.jsonl")):
valid("packages", "mathml.schema.json", m, "derived/mathml.jsonl") valid("packages", "mathml.schema.json", m, "derived/mathml.jsonl")
for m in jl(os.path.join(hp, "derived", "math.jsonl")):
valid("packages", "math.schema.json", m, "derived/math.jsonl")
def check_derived():
"""Derived files are checked, never recomputed (spec/12 §12.7): a line names a formula of the package, and a math
line's formula is TeX and its `complete` and `symbols` agree with its tree (spec/09 §9.4); a tree kind the
schema does not list is accepted, so the form can add kinds; a checks-only package carries no derived file.
No broken package carries these, so each is a variant of the main example's derived/math.jsonl.
"""
hp = p("fixtures", "packages", HALE)
manifest = js(os.path.join(hp, "MANIFEST.json"))
files, absent = {}, [f for f in manifest["files"] if f.get("present", True) is False]
for f in manifest["files"]:
if f.get("present", True):
with open(os.path.join(hp, f["path"]), "rb") as fh:
files[f["path"]] = fh.read()
math = jl(os.path.join(hp, "derived", "math.jsonl"))
eq, run, opaque = math[0], next(m for m in math if m["run"] is not None), next(m for m in math if not m["complete"])
sentence = next(n for n in jl(os.path.join(hp, "nodes.jsonl")) if n["kind"] == "sentence")
cases = [
("as built", math, set()),
("a new tree kind", [dict(eq, tree=["rel", ["sym", "x"], "=", ["tensor", ["sym", "y"]]], symbols=["x", "y"])]
+ math[1:], set()),
("unknown node", [dict(eq, node="zzzzzzz")], {"doc.derived.node"}),
("not a math run", [dict(run, run=0)], {"doc.derived.node"}),
("run past the end", [dict(run, run=99)], {"doc.derived.node"}),
("run null on a sentence", [dict(run, node=sentence["id"], run=None)], {"doc.derived.node"}),
("complete with an opaque node", [dict(opaque, complete=True)], {"doc.derived.math"}),
("incomplete without one", [dict(eq, complete=False)], {"doc.derived.math"}),
("a symbol missing", [dict(eq, symbols=eq["symbols"][1:])], {"doc.derived.math"}),
("a symbol not in the tree", [dict(eq, symbols=eq["symbols"] + ["q"])], {"doc.derived.math"}),
("a tree that is not a node", [dict(eq, tree=[["sym", "x"]])], {"package.schema"}),
("a kind that is not a name", [dict(eq, tree=["Sym", "x"])], {"package.schema"}),
("another form", [dict(eq, form="scienting-math/2")], {"package.schema"}),
("an issue without its text", [dict(opaque, issues=[{"code": "opaque", "message": "x"}])], {"package.schema"}),
]
for name, lines, want in cases:
files["derived/math.jsonl"] = PK.jsonl(lines)
with tempfile.TemporaryDirectory() as tmp:
PK.write(tmp, files, absent)
rules = {e["rule"] for e in PK.validate(tmp, STORE).errors}
ok("packages", rules == want, "derived math, %s: expected %s, got %s" % (name, sorted(want), sorted(rules)))
# A checks-only package withholds the text, and a derived file reads it (spec/12 §12.5).
co = p("fixtures", "packages", HALE + ".checks-only")
team_key = crypto.team_key(bytes.fromhex(open(p("fixtures", "keys", "smithlab-team-secret.hex")).read().strip()))
with tempfile.TemporaryDirectory() as tmp:
pkg = os.path.join(tmp, "pkg")
shutil.copytree(co, pkg)
cm = js(os.path.join(pkg, "MANIFEST.json"))
cfiles = {f["path"]: open(os.path.join(pkg, f["path"]), "rb").read() for f in cm["files"] if f.get("present", True)}
cfiles["derived/math.jsonl"] = PK.jsonl([math[0]])
shutil.rmtree(pkg)
PK.write(pkg, cfiles, [f for f in cm["files"] if f.get("present", True) is False])
rules = {e["rule"] for e in PK.validate(pkg, STORE, team_key).errors}
ok("packages", "doc.policy.withheld" in rules, "a checks-only package with a derived file: %s" % sorted(rules))
def _zip(path, entries): def _zip(path, entries):
@@ -339,6 +426,29 @@ def check_zips():
_zip(os.path.join(tmp, "empty.zip"), []) _zip(os.path.join(tmp, "empty.zip"), [])
ok("zips", {e["rule"] for e in PK.validate_zip(os.path.join(tmp, "empty.zip"), STORE).errors} ok("zips", {e["rule"] for e in PK.validate_zip(os.path.join(tmp, "empty.zip"), STORE).errors}
== {"package.zip.entry"}, "an empty archive is refused") == {"package.zip.entry"}, "an empty archive is refused")
# Archives the reader cannot read are refused with the rule, never with the zipfile module's own error: an
# entry that needs a later zip version (NotImplementedError), and deflated bytes that do not inflate
# (zlib.error), as `paperspec stress --seed 1` found.
with zipfile.ZipFile(os.path.join(tmp, "zip-version.zip"), "w") as zf:
for name, data, _ in entries:
zi = zipfile.ZipInfo(name, date_time=(1980, 1, 1, 0, 0, 0))
zi.extract_version = 98
zf.writestr(zi, data)
with zipfile.ZipFile(os.path.join(tmp, "bad-deflate.zip"), "w", zipfile.ZIP_DEFLATED) as zf:
for name, data, _ in entries:
zf.writestr(zipfile.ZipInfo(name, date_time=(1980, 1, 1, 0, 0, 0)), data, zipfile.ZIP_DEFLATED)
with zipfile.ZipFile(os.path.join(tmp, "bad-deflate.zip")) as zf:
zi = next(i for i in zf.infolist() if i.compress_size > 8)
start = zi.header_offset + 30 + len(zi.filename.encode("utf-8")) + len(zi.extra)
with open(os.path.join(tmp, "bad-deflate.zip"), "r+b") as fh:
fh.seek(start)
fh.write(b"\xff" * 8)
for name in ("zip-version", "bad-deflate"):
try:
rules = {e["rule"] for e in PK.validate_zip(os.path.join(tmp, name + ".zip"), STORE).errors}
except Exception as e: # noqa: BLE001
rules = {"raised %r" % e}
ok("zips", rules == {"package.zip.entry"}, "%s: expected package.zip.entry, got %s" % (name, sorted(rules)))
outside = [f for f in os.listdir(tmp) if not f.endswith(".zip")] outside = [f for f in os.listdir(tmp) if not f.endswith(".zip")]
ok("zips", not outside, "reading archives wrote outside their folders: %s" % outside) ok("zips", not outside, "reading archives wrote outside their folders: %s" % outside)
@@ -550,6 +660,24 @@ def check_vectors():
ok("vectors", vals == c["values"], "hashes " + c["id"]) ok("vectors", vals == c["values"], "hashes " + c["id"])
for nid, o in c["own_content"].items(): for nid, o in c["own_content"].items():
ok("vectors", sha256_hex(jcs.dumpb(o)) == vals[nid]["own_hash"], "own content " + nid) ok("vectors", sha256_hex(jcs.dumpb(o)) == vals[nid]["own_hash"], "own content " + nid)
# A math form enters no content value (spec/05 §5.2): the values of the nodes with `form` are those without it,
# and the nodes validate; the schema takes `form` only beside the notation tex.
fc = next(c for c in V("hashes.jsonl") if c["id"] == "math-form")
def unformed(n):
c = n.get("content")
if isinstance(c, dict):
c = {k: v for k, v in c.items() if k != "form"}
elif isinstance(c, list):
c = [{k: v for k, v in r.items() if k != "form"} for r in c]
return dict(n, content=c) if "content" in n else n
formed = sum(json.dumps(n).count('"form"') for n in fc["nodes"])
ok("vectors", formed == 2 and hashing.compute(Doc(fc["doc"], [unformed(n) for n in fc["nodes"]])) == fc["values"],
"a math form changes a content value")
for n in fc["nodes"]:
valid("vectors", "node.schema.json", dict(n, **fc["values"][n["id"]]), "hashes math-form " + n["id"])
eq = next(n for n in fc["nodes"] if n["kind"] == "equation")
typst = dict(eq, content=dict(eq["content"], notation="typst"), **fc["values"][eq["id"]])
ok("vectors", schema_errors("node.schema.json", typst) != [], "the schema takes a form beside the notation typst")
for c in V("addresses.jsonl"): for c in V("addresses.jsonl"):
ok("vectors", AN.parse_address(c["address"]) == c["parsed"], "address " + c["id"]) ok("vectors", AN.parse_address(c["address"]) == c["parsed"], "address " + c["id"])
if c["parsed"]: if c["parsed"]:
@@ -610,18 +738,27 @@ def check_vectors():
"zero errors in 300 bounds the rate below 1%") "zero errors in 300 bounds the rate below 1%")
for c in V("alignment.jsonl"): for c in V("alignment.jsonl"):
ok("vectors", AL.align(c["a"], c["b"]) == c["expect"], "alignment " + c["id"]) ok("vectors", AL.align(c["a"], c["b"]) == c["expect"], "alignment " + c["id"])
from paperspec.cli.build import correction_expect
for c in V("corrections.jsonl"): for c in V("corrections.jsonl"):
st = CO.State(c["doc"], [{k: v for k, v in n.items() if k not in ( st = CO.State(c["doc"], [{k: v for k, v in n.items() if k not in (
"text_hash", "match_hash", "align_key", "own_hash", "node_hash")} for n in c["before"]["nodes"]]) "text_hash", "match_hash", "align_key", "own_hash", "node_hash")} for n in c["before"]["nodes"]],
references=c["before"].get("references"))
try: try:
st1, rec = CO.apply(st, c["correction"], store=STORE) st1, rec = CO.apply(st, c["correction"], store=STORE)
v1 = hashing.compute(st1.doc())
ok("vectors", st1.index().values == reference_values(st1.doc()), ok("vectors", st1.index().values == reference_values(st1.doc()),
"correction %s: incremental values differ from the full computation" % c["id"]) "correction %s: incremental values differ from the full computation" % c["id"])
got = {"record": rec, "nodes": [dict(n, **v1[n["id"]]) for n in st1.nodes], "ids": st1.ids} got = correction_expect(st1, rec, "references" in c["before"])
except Refusal as e: except Refusal as e:
got = {"refusal": e.rule} got = {"refusal": e.rule}
ok("vectors", got == c["expect"], "correction " + c["id"]) ok("vectors", got == c["expect"], "correction " + c["id"])
if c["correction"]["op"] == "emend" and "record" in c["expect"]:
# An emend leaves the leaf as printed, and so its match_hash and align_key, as they were (spec/11 §11.3).
nid = c["correction"]["target"]
before = {n["id"]: n for n in c["before"]["nodes"]}[nid]
after = {n["id"]: n for n in c["expect"]["nodes"]}[nid]
ok("vectors", c["expect"]["printed"][nid] == hashing.plain(st.doc(), nid)
and all(before[k] == after[k] for k in ("match_hash", "align_key")) and before["text_hash"] != after["text_hash"],
"correction %s: the emend changed the leaf as printed" % c["id"])
states = {} states = {}
for c in V("resolve.jsonl"): for c in V("resolve.jsonl"):
st = states.setdefault(c["package"], state_of(p(c["package"]))) st = states.setdefault(c["package"], state_of(p(c["package"])))
@@ -710,6 +847,116 @@ def check_vectors():
ok("vectors", sorted(LG.tiles(c["entries"])) == c["tiles"], "checkpoint %s: tile paths" % c["id"]) ok("vectors", sorted(LG.tiles(c["entries"])) == c["tiles"], "checkpoint %s: tile paths" % c["id"])
def check_traces():
"""Traced citations (spec/18 §18.5): the layer of traces on the draft, resolved against the two packages, and
the vectors, which resolve and check traces after corrections that bring every outcome and every refusal."""
R = p("fixtures", "records", "traces")
states = {}
def st(path):
return states.setdefault(path, state_of(p(path)))
def evolve(state, corrections):
for c in corrections:
state, _ = CO.apply(state, c, store=STORE)
return state
rules = {r["id"]: r for r in js(p("registry", "rules.json"))["rules"]}
for rule in ("layer.trace.source", "layer.trace.target"):
ok("traces", rule in rules and rules[rule]["chapter"] == "spec/18-layers.md", "%s is not registered" % rule)
# The fixture layer: a model's confirmed trace to the abstract, a candidate a person rejected, a person's trace to
# Table 1 and a reply that disputes the first. Every trace is current, and breaks no rule alone or with the states.
citing, cited = st("fixtures/packages/" + DRAFT), st("fixtures/packages/" + HALE)
same_as = js(p("fixtures", "packages", HALE, "document.json"))["work"]["same_as"]
anns = jl(os.path.join(R, "annotations.jsonl"))
mine = [a for a in anns if a["body"]["kind"] == "trace"]
ok("traces", len(mine) == 3 and len(anns) == 4, "the layer holds three traces and a reply")
refs = {r["node"]: r["resolution"] for r in citing.references}
for a in mine:
b = a["body"]
ok("traces", TR.problems(a) == [] and TR.problems(a, citing, cited) == [], "a trace breaks a rule: " + a["id"])
got = TR.resolve(a, citing, cited, same_as)
ok("traces", got["result"] == "current" and got["open"] is not None, "a fixture trace is not current: " + a["id"])
ok("traces", ("proposer" in b) == (a["creator"]["type"] == "Software"), "proposer iff Software: " + a["id"])
ok("traces", refs[b["reference"]] == {"type": "document", "doc": b["source"].split("doc:", 1)[1]},
"the reference does not resolve to the trace's source: " + a["id"])
tool = next(a for a in mine if a["creator"]["type"] == "Software" and a["status"] == "confirmed")
ok("traces", {a["status"] for a in mine} == {"confirmed", "rejected"}
and [a["status"] for a in mine if a["creator"]["type"] == "Software"].count("rejected") == 1
and any(a["creator"]["type"] == "Person" and a["status"] == "confirmed"
and TR._anchors(a["body"])[0]["kind"] == "table" for a in mine),
"the layer lacks a confirmed model trace, a rejected candidate or a person's trace to a table")
ok("traces", [a["id"] for a in mine if TR.disputed(a["id"], anns)] == [tool["id"]]
and len(TR.disputes(tool["id"], anns)) == 1, "only the model's confirmed trace is disputed")
reply = TR.disputes(tool["id"], anns)[0]
ok("traces", reply["motivation"] == "assessing" and reply["creator"] != tool["creator"] and reply not in mine,
"the dispute is not an assessing reply by another")
for edit in ({"status": "withdrawn"}, {"status": "rejected"}, {"motivation": "replying"}):
ok("traces", not TR.disputed(tool["id"], [dict(reply, **edit)]), "a reply with %s disputes" % edit)
ok("traces", TR.replies(tool["id"], anns) == [reply] and TR.replies(reply["id"], anns) == [], "replies are found by target")
# A model's trace names its proposer; a person's may too; the shapes are closed (spec/18 §18.4).
bare = {k: v for k, v in tool["body"].items() if k != "proposer"}
person = next(a for a in mine if a["creator"]["type"] == "Person")
for name, a, good in (
("a model's trace without a proposer", dict(tool, body=bare), False),
("a person's trace with one", dict(person, body=dict(person["body"], proposer=tool["body"]["proposer"])), True),
("a rank below 1", dict(tool, body=dict(tool["body"], proposer=dict(tool["body"]["proposer"], rank=0))), False),
("a score that is no decimal", dict(tool, body=dict(tool["body"], proposer=dict(tool["body"]["proposer"], score="high"))), False),
("an unknown verdict", dict(person, body=dict(person["body"], verdict="agrees")), False),
("no reference", dict(person, body={k: v for k, v in person["body"].items() if k != "reference"}), False),
("a source that is no document tag", dict(person, body=dict(person["body"], source="hale2026harmonic-damb")), False),
("an empty note", dict(person, body=dict(person["body"], note="")), False),
("an extra property", dict(person, body=dict(person["body"], language="en")), False)):
ok("traces", (schema_errors("annotation.schema.json", a) == []) == good, "schema, %s" % name)
# The states must be those of the documents the trace names.
for call in (lambda: TR.resolve(tool, cited, citing), lambda: TR.problems(tool, cited), lambda: TR.problems(tool, citing, citing),
lambda: TR.resolve(next(a for a in jl(os.path.join(ROOT, "fixtures", "records", "layer", "annotations.jsonl"))), citing, cited)):
try:
call()
raised = False
except ValueError:
raised = True
ok("traces", raised, "a call with the wrong states or a body that is no trace did not raise")
# The vocabulary and the store know the kind (spec/18 §18.4, sql/store.sql).
ctx = js(p("context", "scienting-1.jsonld"))["@context"]
ok("traces", ctx["note"] == "sct:note" and ctx["proposer"] == {"@id": "sct:proposedBy", "@type": "@json"},
"the context lacks the terms note and proposer")
# The vectors.
outcomes, broken = set(), set()
ids = set()
for c in V("traces.jsonl"):
ids.add(c["id"])
valid("traces", "annotation.schema.json", c["annotation"], "vector " + c["id"])
a_citing = st(c["citing"])
snapshot = json.dumps([a_citing.nodes, a_citing.references], sort_keys=True)
if c["op"] == "resolve":
got = TR.resolve(c["annotation"], evolve(a_citing, c["citing_corrections"]),
evolve(st(c["cited"]), c["cited_corrections"]), c["same_as"])
ok("traces", got == c["expect"], "traces " + c["id"])
ok("traces", got["result"] in TR.RESULTS and ("side" in got) == (got["result"] == "stale")
and ("reason" in got) == (got["result"] != "current")
and (got["open"] is None) == (got["cited"]["result"] == "stale") and (got["cites"] == [] or got["open"]),
"traces %s: the result is not shaped as traces.resolve says" % c["id"])
outcomes.add(got["result"])
# Correcting a state to judge a trace leaves the state it started from as it was.
ok("traces", json.dumps([a_citing.nodes, a_citing.references], sort_keys=True) == snapshot,
"traces %s: the state changed" % c["id"])
else:
got = TR.problems(c["annotation"], a_citing, st(c["cited"]) if c["cited"] else None)
ok("traces", got == c["expect"], "traces " + c["id"])
broken |= {x["rule"] for x in got}
ok("traces", all(x["rule"] in rules for x in got), "traces %s: an unregistered rule" % c["id"])
ok("traces", outcomes == set(TR.RESULTS), "every outcome occurs: %s" % sorted(outcomes))
ok("traces", broken == {"layer.trace.source", "layer.trace.target"}, "both rules are broken by some case")
ok("traces", {"changed-passage-moved", "stale-both", "unlinked", "misresolved-doi-without-same-as",
"current-doi-in-same-as"} <= ids, "the vectors lack a case they are known for")
cites = [c for c in V("traces.jsonl") if c["op"] == "resolve" and c["expect"]["cites"]]
ok("traces", len(cites) == 1 and cites[0]["expect"]["cites"][0]["refs"][0]["resolution"]["type"] == "doi",
"one case follows a citation inside the passage")
def check_determinism(): def check_determinism():
with tempfile.TemporaryDirectory() as tmp: with tempfile.TemporaryDirectory() as tmp:
subprocess.run([sys.executable, "-m", "paperspec", "build", "--out", tmp], check=True) subprocess.run([sys.executable, "-m", "paperspec", "build", "--out", tmp], check=True)
@@ -767,6 +1014,10 @@ def check_sql():
for m in re.finditer(r"CREATE INDEX (\w+) ON", ddl): for m in re.finditer(r"CREATE INDEX (\w+) ON", ddl):
ok("sql", m.group(1).upper() not in RESERVED, "index name " + m.group(1)) ok("sql", m.group(1).upper() not in RESERVED, "index name " + m.group(1))
ok("sql", "FOREIGN KEY" not in ddl and "REFERENCES" not in ddl, "no foreign keys") ok("sql", "FOREIGN KEY" not in ddl and "REFERENCES" not in ddl, "no foreign keys")
# The store accepts exactly the body kinds the annotation schema has.
sql_kinds = set(re.findall(r"'([a-z-]+)'", re.search(r"body_kind VARCHAR\(24\) NOT NULL CHECK \(body_kind IN \((.*?)\)\)", ddl).group(1)))
schema_kinds = {b["properties"]["kind"]["const"] for b in STORE.load("annotation.schema.json")["properties"]["body"]["oneOf"]}
ok("sql", sql_kinds == schema_kinds, "body_kind differs from the schema's body kinds: %s" % sorted(sql_kinds ^ schema_kinds))
with tempfile.TemporaryDirectory() as tmp: with tempfile.TemporaryDirectory() as tmp:
conn = sqlite3.connect(os.path.join(tmp, "bundle.db")) conn = sqlite3.connect(os.path.join(tmp, "bundle.db"))
db.create_bundle(conn, p("sql")) db.create_bundle(conn, p("sql"))
@@ -793,14 +1044,17 @@ def check_sql():
check_bundle(conn) check_bundle(conn)
# Store records satisfy the store tables' CHECK constraints. # Store records satisfy the store tables' CHECK constraints.
R = p("fixtures", "records") R = p("fixtures", "records")
lay = js(os.path.join(R, "layer", "layer.json")) for layer in ("layer", "traces"):
lay = js(os.path.join(R, layer, "layer.json"))
conn.execute("INSERT INTO layers VALUES (?,?,?,?,?,?,?,?)", conn.execute("INSERT INTO layers VALUES (?,?,?,?,?,?,?,?)",
(lay["id"], lay.get("project"), lay["label"], lay["purpose"], lay.get("audience"), (lay["id"], lay.get("project"), lay["label"], lay["purpose"], lay.get("audience"),
lay["visibility"], jcs.dumps(lay["license"]), jcs.dumps(lay))) lay["visibility"], jcs.dumps(lay["license"]), jcs.dumps(lay)))
for a in jl(os.path.join(R, "layer", "annotations.jsonl")): for a in jl(os.path.join(R, layer, "annotations.jsonl")):
conn.execute("INSERT INTO annotations VALUES (?,?,?,?,?,?,?,?)", conn.execute("INSERT INTO annotations VALUES (?,?,?,?,?,?,?,?,?)",
(a["id"], a["layer"], a["body"]["kind"], a["status"], a.get("receipt"), a["creator"]["id"], (a["id"], a["layer"], a["body"]["kind"], a["body"].get("category"), a["status"],
a["created"], jcs.dumps(a))) a.get("receipt"), a["creator"]["id"], a["created"], jcs.dumps(a)))
kinds = {k for (k,) in conn.execute("SELECT DISTINCT body_kind FROM annotations")}
ok("sql", "trace" in kinds, "the store holds no trace annotation")
prj = js(os.path.join(R, "project.json")) prj = js(os.path.join(R, "project.json"))
conn.execute("INSERT INTO projects VALUES (?,?,?,?,?,?,?)", conn.execute("INSERT INTO projects VALUES (?,?,?,?,?,?,?)",
(prj["key"], prj.get("store"), prj["name"], prj.get("description"), jcs.dumps(prj.get("claims")), (prj["key"], prj.get("store"), prj["name"], prj.get("description"), jcs.dumps(prj.get("claims")),
@@ -1043,6 +1297,16 @@ def check_log():
ok("log", not LG.accept_checkpoint(note, roster, dict(settings, origin="other"))[0], "another origin was accepted") ok("log", not LG.accept_checkpoint(note, roster, dict(settings, origin="other"))[0], "another origin was accepted")
alone = LG.sign_checkpoint(settings["origin"], entries, [("wit", __import__("paperspec.cli.build", fromlist=["secret"]).secret("wit"))]) alone = LG.sign_checkpoint(settings["origin"], entries, [("wit", __import__("paperspec.cli.build", fromlist=["secret"]).secret("wit"))])
ok("log", not LG.accept_checkpoint(alone, roster, settings)[0], "a checkpoint without the team's key was accepted") ok("log", not LG.accept_checkpoint(alone, roster, settings)[0], "a checkpoint without the team's key was accepted")
# Every line of a note ends in U+000A and nothing else (spec/23 §23.2): a note whose last line break, or the break
# between its signature lines, is another line separator is malformed, as `paperspec stress --seed 2` found.
head, _, sigs = note.partition("\n\n")
lines = sigs.split("\n")[:-1]
ok("log", len(lines) >= 2 and LG.parse_checkpoint(head + "\n\n" + "\n".join(lines) + "\n") is not None,
"the checkpoint does not have two signature lines to separate")
for sep in ("\x0b", "\x0c", "\x1c", "\x1d", "\x1e", "\x85", "
", "
", "\r", ""):
ok("log", LG.parse_checkpoint(note[:-1] + sep) is None, "a note ending in %r instead of a newline parses" % sep)
ok("log", LG.parse_checkpoint(head + "\n\n" + sep.join(lines) + "\n") is None,
"a note whose signature lines are separated by %r parses" % sep)
# The ML-DSA-65 receipt verifies under dana's key, and fails under a tampered payload. # The ML-DSA-65 receipt verifies under dana's key, and fails under a tampered payload.
rec = js(os.path.join(R, "receipt-ml-dsa.json")) rec = js(os.path.join(R, "receipt-ml-dsa.json"))
ok("log", rec["signature"]["scheme"] == "ml-dsa-65" and RC.verify_signature(rec, roster), "the ML-DSA receipt does not verify") ok("log", rec["signature"]["scheme"] == "ml-dsa-65" and RC.verify_signature(rec, roster), "the ML-DSA receipt does not verify")
@@ -1175,11 +1439,13 @@ def run(args):
check_packages() check_packages()
check_zips() check_zips()
check_owner_revocation() check_owner_revocation()
check_derived()
check_unsafe_paths() check_unsafe_paths()
check_incremental() check_incremental()
check_gate() check_gate()
check_invalid() check_invalid()
check_vectors() check_vectors()
check_traces()
if not args.quick: if not args.quick:
check_determinism() check_determinism()
check_sql() check_sql()
+50 -4
View File
@@ -5,7 +5,8 @@ Usage: paperspec stress [--seed N] [--rounds N]
The vectors pin values; this program checks the invariants the chapters state, over inputs drawn from a seeded The vectors pin values; this program checks the invariants the chapters state, over inputs drawn from a seeded
random generator, so a failure is reproducible from the seed it prints. Canonical JSON round-trips and sorts keys random generator, so a failure is reproducible from the seed it prints. Canonical JSON round-trips and sorts keys
by UTF-16 units; normalization is idempotent; notation folding never raises; random corrections keep the five by UTF-16 units; normalization is idempotent; notation folding never raises; random corrections keep the five
values equal to a full recomputation, never reuse an ID and apply deterministically; anchors made before those values equal to a full recomputation, never reuse an ID and apply deterministically, and an emend, relink or
resolve leaves what a witness read, and the receipts on it, as they were; anchors made before those
corrections always resolve to one of the five outcomes; Merkle roots agree with a second implementation; corrections always resolve to one of the five outcomes; Merkle roots agree with a second implementation;
spot-check samples do not depend on input order; error bounds are the least six-decimal value with the stated tail; spot-check samples do not depend on input order; error bounds are the least six-decimal value with the stated tail;
differently stamped pages share a fingerprint; the zip reader and the package validator refuse or accept mutated differently stamped pages share a fingerprint; the zip reader and the package validator refuse or accept mutated
@@ -154,7 +155,7 @@ def random_correction(rng, st, doc):
sentences = _leaf_ids(doc, {"sentence"}) sentences = _leaf_ids(doc, {"sentence"})
cells = _leaf_ids(doc, {"cell"}) cells = _leaf_ids(doc, {"cell"})
op = rng.choice(["replace", "replace", "split", "merge", "move", "relabel", "set", "delete", "reclassify", op = rng.choice(["replace", "replace", "split", "merge", "move", "relabel", "set", "delete", "reclassify",
"insert-text", "insert-node"]) "insert-text", "insert-node", "emend", "emend", "relink", "resolve"])
evidence = [{"kind": "crop", "sha256": "0" * 64}] if rng.random() < 0.8 else [{"kind": "person", "by": "ana"}] evidence = [{"kind": "crop", "sha256": "0" * 64}] if rng.random() < 0.8 else [{"kind": "person", "by": "ana"}]
c = {"op": op.split("-")[0], "evidence": evidence} c = {"op": op.split("-")[0], "evidence": evidence}
if op == "replace" and (sentences or cells): if op == "replace" and (sentences or cells):
@@ -188,7 +189,12 @@ def random_correction(rng, st, doc):
c.update(target=rng.choice(cells), attr=rng.choice(["colspan", "rowspan", "role", "column", "level"]), c.update(target=rng.choice(cells), attr=rng.choice(["colspan", "rowspan", "role", "column", "level"]),
value=rng.choice([1, 2, 3, "2", -1, "data", "row-header", "boss", None])) value=rng.choice([1, 2, 3, "2", -1, "data", "row-header", "boss", None]))
elif op == "delete" and len(doc.order) > 8: elif op == "delete" and len(doc.order) > 8:
c.update(target=rng.choice(doc.order[1:])) # Never below eight nodes: deleting the body section would leave a document with nothing to correct, and the
# rest of the walk would only be refused.
targets = [nid for nid in doc.order[1:] if len(doc.order) - len(doc.preorder(nid)) >= 8]
if not targets:
return None
c.update(target=rng.choice(targets))
elif op == "reclassify": elif op == "reclassify":
c.update(target=rng.choice(doc.order), kind=rng.choice(["footnote", "quote", "paragraph", "caption", "section"])) c.update(target=rng.choice(doc.order), kind=rng.choice(["footnote", "quote", "paragraph", "caption", "section"]))
elif op == "insert-text" and sentences: elif op == "insert-text" and sentences:
@@ -205,6 +211,25 @@ def random_correction(rng, st, doc):
if rng.random() < 0.2: if rng.random() < 0.2:
node["foo"] = 1 node["foo"] = 1
c.update(parent=parent, place_after=rng.choice(kids + [None]), node=node) c.update(parent=parent, place_after=rng.choice(kids + [None]), node=node)
elif op == "emend" and (sentences or cells):
nid = rng.choice(sentences + cells)
texts = [r.get("text") or r.get("source", "") for r in doc.nodes[nid]["content"]]
text = rng.choice(texts + [hashing.plain(doc, nid)])
if not text:
return None
i = rng.randrange(len(text))
j = min(len(text), i + rng.randint(1, 6))
c.update(target=nid, find=text[i:j], replace=rand_text(rng, 1, 8),
kind=rng.choice(["typo", "spelling", "grammar", "punctuation", "wording", "other"]))
elif op == "relink" and sentences:
nid = rng.choice(sentences)
refs = _leaf_ids(doc, {"reference"})
c.update(target=nid, run=rng.randint(0, len(doc.nodes[nid]["content"])),
refs=rng.choice([None, refs[:1] or None, [rng.choice(doc.order)]]))
elif op == "resolve":
c.update(target=rng.choice(_leaf_ids(doc, {"reference"}) + [rng.choice(doc.order)]),
resolution=rng.choice([{"type": "none"}, {"type": "doi", "doi": "10.5555/stress.%d" % rng.randint(0, 9)},
{"type": "document", "doc": "smithlab/" + TINY_KEY}]))
else: else:
return None return None
return c return c
@@ -247,6 +272,24 @@ def stress_corrections(rng, rounds):
ok("corrections", rec["id"] == record_id(sha256_hex(jcs.dumpb({k: v for k, v in rec.items() if k != "id"}))), ok("corrections", rec["id"] == record_id(sha256_hex(jcs.dumpb({k: v for k, v in rec.items() if k != "id"}))),
"the record's id does not derive from its content") "the record's id does not derive from its content")
ok("corrections", rec["index"] == st.rev + 1 == st1.rev, "the record's index is not the next revision") ok("corrections", rec["index"] == st.rev + 1 == st1.rev, "the record's index is not the next revision")
# Emend, relink and resolve leave what a witness read as it was (spec/11 §11.3): an emend keeps the leaf as
# printed, and so its match_hash and align_key; a relink keeps its plain projection; a resolve its node_hash.
t = c.get("target")
d0, d1 = st.doc(), st1.doc()
if c["op"] == "emend":
v0, v1 = st.index().values[t], st1.index().values[t]
ok("corrections", hashing.printed(d0, t) == hashing.printed(d1, t) and v0["match_hash"] == v1["match_hash"]
and v0["align_key"] == v1["align_key"], "an emend changed the leaf as printed: %s" % json.dumps(c)[:160])
elif c["op"] == "relink":
ok("corrections", hashing.plain(d0, t) == hashing.plain(d1, t), "a relink changed the text")
elif c["op"] == "resolve":
ok("corrections", st.index().values == st1.index().values
and {r["node"]: r["resolution"] for r in st1.references}.get(t) == c["resolution"],
"a resolve changed a node or did not record its resolution")
if c["op"] in CO.KEEPS_LEVEL:
carried = RC.carried_hashes(st1.index().values, st1.corrections)
ok("corrections", st.index().values[t]["node_hash"] in carried[t],
"a receipt at the hash before an %s would no longer count" % c["op"])
st2, rec2 = CO.apply(st, copy.deepcopy(c), store=SCHEMAS) st2, rec2 = CO.apply(st, copy.deepcopy(c), store=SCHEMAS)
ok("corrections", rec2 == rec and st2.nodes == st1.nodes and st2.ids == st1.ids, "apply is not deterministic") ok("corrections", rec2 == rec and st2.nodes == st1.nodes and st2.ids == st1.ids, "apply is not deterministic")
try: try:
@@ -443,8 +486,11 @@ def stress_packages(rng, rounds):
data[k] = (data[k] + rng.randrange(1, 256)) % 256 data[k] = (data[k] + rng.randrange(1, 256)) % 256
open(full, "wb").write(data) open(full, "wb").write(data)
elif mode == "truncate": elif mode == "truncate":
# Strictly shorter: a cut at the full length would leave the file as it was, and the package valid.
data = open(full, "rb").read() data = open(full, "rb").read()
open(full, "wb").write(data[:rng.randrange(len(data) + 1)]) if not data:
continue
open(full, "wb").write(data[:rng.randrange(len(data))])
elif mode == "delete": elif mode == "delete":
os.remove(full) os.remove(full)
elif mode == "add": elif mode == "add":
+140 -6
View File
@@ -23,17 +23,23 @@ SETTABLE = {
"theorem": {"variant"}, "theorem": {"variant"},
} }
EDITABLE_RUN_FIELD = {"text": "text", "link": "text", "cite": "text", "xref": "text", "fnmark": "text", "math": "source"} EDITABLE_RUN_FIELD = {"text": "text", "link": "text", "cite": "text", "xref": "text", "fnmark": "text", "math": "source"}
# The runs an emend searches: prose, never a math or equation source (spec/11 §11.1).
PROSE_RUNS = frozenset(["text", "link", "cite", "xref", "fnmark"])
# The operations that never lower a leaf's level: what a witness read stays what it was (spec/08 §8.1-8.2).
KEEPS_LEVEL = frozenset(["emend", "relink", "resolve"])
class State: class State:
"""The current state of a document: nodes, the ID table and the corrections applied.""" """The current state of a document: nodes, the ID table, the corrections applied and the reference records."""
def __init__(self, key, nodes, ids=None, corrections=None, indexes=None): def __init__(self, key, nodes, ids=None, corrections=None, indexes=None, references=None):
self.key = key self.key = key
self.nodes = [dict(n) for n in nodes] self.nodes = [dict(n) for n in nodes]
self.ids = [dict(e) for e in (ids or [])] self.ids = [dict(e) for e in (ids or [])]
self.corrections = [dict(c) for c in (corrections or [])] self.corrections = [dict(c) for c in (corrections or [])]
self._indexes = dict(indexes or {}) self._indexes = dict(indexes or {})
# The records of references.jsonl, which a resolve rewrites (spec/10, spec/11 §11.1).
self.references = [dict(r) for r in (references or [])]
@property @property
def rev(self): def rev(self):
@@ -85,6 +91,34 @@ def _has_crop(c):
return any(e.get("kind") == "crop" for e in c.get("evidence", [])) return any(e.get("kind") == "crop" for e in c.get("evidence", []))
def _carries_printed(v):
"""Whether runs, or a subtree to insert, carry `printed`, which only an emend writes (spec/11 §11.4)."""
if isinstance(v, list):
return any(_carries_printed(x) for x in v)
if isinstance(v, dict):
return "printed" in v or any(_carries_printed(x) for x in v.values())
return False
def _edits_by_digit(old, new):
"""Whether turning `old` into `new` changes, adds or removes a digit, or edits beside one (spec/11 §11.4).
The edit is what is left once the longest common prefix, and then the longest common suffix of the rest, are
set aside; its characters in both strings, and the unchanged character on each side of it, are checked.
"""
if old == new:
return False
p = 0
while p < len(old) and p < len(new) and old[p] == new[p]:
p += 1
s = 0
while s < len(old) - p and s < len(new) - p and old[-1 - s] == new[-1 - s]:
s += 1
edit = old[p:len(old) - s] + new[p:len(new) - s]
beside = old[max(p - 1, 0):p] + old[len(old) - s:len(old) - s + 1]
return bool(digits(edit + beside))
def _rebuild(nodes): def _rebuild(nodes):
"""Recompute document order and `ord` from parent links, keeping sibling order as listed.""" """Recompute document order and `ord` from parent links, keeping sibling order as listed."""
by_id = {n["id"]: n for n in nodes} by_id = {n["id"]: n for n in nodes}
@@ -181,6 +215,7 @@ def apply(state, c, hasher=hashing.PLAIN, store=None):
retired, created = [], [] retired, created = [], []
path = doc.ancestors(target) if target in by_id else None path = doc.ancestors(target) if target in by_id else None
touched = [] touched = []
references = state.references
if op == "replace": if op == "replace":
node = by_id[target] node = by_id[target]
@@ -195,6 +230,11 @@ def apply(state, c, hasher=hashing.PLAIN, store=None):
if len(hits) != 1: if len(hits) != 1:
raise Refusal("correction.find", "find occurs %d times, not exactly once" % len(hits), target) raise Refusal("correction.find", "find occurs %d times, not exactly once" % len(hits), target)
pth, s, i = hits[0] pth, s, i = hits[0]
# An emended run's text is the editor's, not a reading, so only another emend changes it.
if len(pth) == 2 and "printed" in node["content"][pth[0]]:
raise Refusal("correction.emend", "the run was emended; only another emend changes its text", target)
if _carries_printed(repl):
raise Refusal("correction.emend", "only an emend records what was printed", target)
if isinstance(repl, str): if isinstance(repl, str):
_set_string(node, pth, s[:i] + repl + s[i + len(find):]) _set_string(node, pth, s[:i] + repl + s[i + len(find):])
else: else:
@@ -215,6 +255,8 @@ def apply(state, c, hasher=hashing.PLAIN, store=None):
elif op == "insert" and "node" in c: elif op == "insert" and "node" in c:
if not _has_crop(c): if not _has_crop(c):
raise Refusal("correction.evidence", "an insert needs crop evidence") raise Refusal("correction.evidence", "an insert needs crop evidence")
if _carries_printed(c["node"]):
raise Refusal("correction.emend", "only an emend records what was printed")
parent = c["parent"] parent = c["parent"]
if parent not in by_id: if parent not in by_id:
raise Refusal("correction.target", "no live parent %s" % parent) raise Refusal("correction.target", "no live parent %s" % parent)
@@ -244,6 +286,8 @@ def apply(state, c, hasher=hashing.PLAIN, store=None):
f = EDITABLE_RUN_FIELD.get(r["kind"]) f = EDITABLE_RUN_FIELD.get(r["kind"])
if not f or offset > len(r[f]) or not isinstance(c.get("text"), str): if not f or offset > len(r[f]) or not isinstance(c.get("text"), str):
raise Refusal("correction.insert", "bad run or offset", target) raise Refusal("correction.insert", "bad run or offset", target)
if "printed" in r:
raise Refusal("correction.emend", "the run was emended; only another emend changes its text", target)
node["content"][run] = dict(r, **{f: r[f][:offset] + c["text"] + r[f][offset:]}) node["content"][run] = dict(r, **{f: r[f][:offset] + c["text"] + r[f][offset:]})
node["content"] = canonical_runs(node["content"]) node["content"] = canonical_runs(node["content"])
touched = [target] touched = [target]
@@ -269,12 +313,13 @@ def apply(state, c, hasher=hashing.PLAIN, store=None):
first.append(r) first.append(r)
elif pos >= k: elif pos >= k:
second.append(r) second.append(r)
elif r["kind"] == "text": elif r["kind"] == "text" and "printed" not in r:
cut = k - pos cut = k - pos
first.append(dict(r, text=r["text"][:cut])) first.append(dict(r, text=r["text"][:cut]))
second.append(dict(r, text=r["text"][cut:])) second.append(dict(r, text=r["text"][cut:]))
else: else:
raise Refusal("correction.split", "the offset falls inside a %s run" % r["kind"], target) where = "an emended run" if "printed" in r else "a %s run" % r["kind"]
raise Refusal("correction.split", "the offset falls inside " + where, target)
pos += ln pos += ln
_strip_edge(first, end=True) _strip_edge(first, end=True)
_strip_edge(second, end=False) _strip_edge(second, end=False)
@@ -375,6 +420,88 @@ def apply(state, c, hasher=hashing.PLAIN, store=None):
node["attrs"] = attrs node["attrs"] = attrs
touched = [target] if node["kind"] in LEAVES else [] touched = [target] if node["kind"] in LEAVES else []
elif op == "emend":
node = by_id[target]
if node["kind"] not in RUN_KINDS:
raise Refusal("correction.emend", "emend corrects the prose of runs; a %s is corrected by replace"
% node["kind"], target)
find, repl = c.get("find", ""), c["replace"]
if not find:
raise Refusal("correction.find", "find must not be empty")
runs = node["content"]
# `run`, when given, narrows the search to one run, as for replace.
mine = [i for i in range(len(runs)) if c.get("run", i) == i]
hits = [(i, j) for i in mine if runs[i]["kind"] in PROSE_RUNS for j in _occurrences(runs[i]["text"], find)]
if not hits:
sources = [runs[i]["source"] if runs[i]["kind"] == "math"
else doc.nodes[runs[i]["node"]]["content"]["source"]
for i in mine if runs[i]["kind"] in ("math", "equation")]
if any(find in s for s in sources) or ("run" in c and len(mine) == 1 and sources):
raise Refusal("correction.emend", "emend corrects prose, not math; a source is corrected by replace",
target)
if "run" not in c and find in hashing.plain_runs(runs, doc):
raise Refusal("correction.emend", "find crosses a run boundary; an emend stays inside one run", target)
if len(hits) != 1:
raise Refusal("correction.find", "find occurs %d times, not exactly once" % len(hits), target)
i, j = hits[0]
r = runs[i]
old = r["text"]
new = old[:j] + repl + old[j + len(find):]
if _edits_by_digit(old, new):
raise Refusal("correction.digits", "an emend changes no digit and edits beside none; a number is "
"corrected by replace, with crop evidence", target)
if r["kind"] == "text" and "printed" not in r:
# The found text becomes a run of its own, styled as before, that keeps what was printed.
style = {"style": r["style"]} if "style" in r else {}
mid = [dict({"kind": "text", "text": old[:j]}, **style),
dict({"kind": "text", "text": repl, "printed": find}, **style),
dict({"kind": "text", "text": old[j + len(find):]}, **style)]
node["content"] = runs[:i] + mid + runs[i + 1:]
else:
# Any other run, or one emended before, keeps its whole printed text, from the first emend.
node["content"][i] = dict(r, text=new, printed=r.get("printed", old))
node["content"] = canonical_runs(node["content"])
touched = [target]
elif op == "relink":
node = by_id[target]
run, refs = c.get("run"), c.get("refs")
if node["kind"] not in RUN_KINDS or not _is_index(run) or run >= len(node["content"]):
raise Refusal("correction.relink", "relink names a run of a node with runs", target)
r = node["content"][run]
if r["kind"] not in ("text", "cite") or (refs is None and r["kind"] != "cite"):
raise Refusal("correction.relink", "relink links a text or cite run, and unlinks a cite run", target)
if refs is not None and (not isinstance(refs, list) or not refs):
raise Refusal("correction.relink", "refs is a non-empty list of references, or null", target)
record["from"] = r["refs"] if r["kind"] == "cite" else None
# The printed form and anything an emend kept stay; a cite run takes no style (spec/03 §3.5).
keep = {"printed": r["printed"]} if "printed" in r else {}
if refs is None:
new_run = dict({"kind": "text", "text": r["text"]}, **keep)
else:
new_run = dict({"kind": "cite", "refs": list(refs), "text": r["text"]}, **keep)
node["content"] = canonical_runs(node["content"][:run] + [new_run] + node["content"][run + 1:])
touched = [target]
elif op == "resolve":
node = by_id[target]
if node["kind"] != "reference":
raise Refusal("correction.resolve", "resolve names a reference node, not a %s" % node["kind"], target)
res = c.get("resolution")
if not isinstance(res, dict) or res.get("type") not in ("doi", "document", "none"):
raise Refusal("correction.resolve", "the resolution is doi, document or none (spec/10)", target)
references = [dict(x) for x in state.references]
held = next((x for x in references if x["node"] == target), None)
# A reference without a record has not been resolved yet.
record["from"] = held["resolution"] if held else {"type": "none"}
if held:
held["resolution"] = res
else:
pos = {nid: k for k, nid in enumerate(doc.order)}
references.append(dict({"node": target}, **({"label": node["label"]} if "label" in node else {}),
resolution=res))
references.sort(key=lambda x: pos.get(x["node"], len(pos)))
else: else:
raise Refusal("correction.op", "unknown operation " + op) raise Refusal("correction.op", "unknown operation " + op)
@@ -407,7 +534,8 @@ def apply(state, c, hasher=hashing.PLAIN, store=None):
raise Refusal("correction.digits", "an undeclared digit change", nid) raise Refusal("correction.digits", "an undeclared digit change", nid)
for k in ("op", "target", "find", "replace", "run", "offset", "text", "parent", "place_after", "node", "with", for k in ("op", "target", "find", "replace", "run", "offset", "text", "parent", "place_after", "node", "with",
"joiner", "kind", "label", "attr", "value", "evidence", "author", "reason", "at"): "joiner", "kind", "label", "attr", "value", "refs", "resolution", "note", "evidence", "author", "reason",
"at"):
if k in c: if k in c:
record[k] = c[k] record[k] = c[k]
if op == "insert" and "node" in c: if op == "insert" and "node" in c:
@@ -429,7 +557,7 @@ def apply(state, c, hasher=hashing.PLAIN, store=None):
"rev": record["index"]}) "rev": record["index"]})
new_ids.sort(key=id_order) new_ids.sort(key=id_order)
new_state = State(state.key, [after_doc.nodes[x] for x in after_doc.preorder()], new_ids, new_state = State(state.key, [after_doc.nodes[x] for x in after_doc.preorder()], new_ids,
state.corrections + [record], {hasher.key: after_ix}) state.corrections + [record], {hasher.key: after_ix}, references)
return new_state, record return new_state, record
@@ -450,5 +578,11 @@ def _strip_edge(runs, end):
t = t[1:] t = t[1:]
if t: if t:
runs[i] = dict(r, text=t) runs[i] = dict(r, text=t)
# What an emended run printed loses the same edge whitespace, so the parts read as printed split alike.
if "printed" in r:
p = r["printed"]
while p and is_ws(p[-1 if end else 0]):
p = p[:-1] if end else p[1:]
runs[i] = dict(runs[i], printed=p) if p else {k: v for k, v in runs[i].items() if k != "printed"}
return return
del runs[i] del runs[i]
+40 -1
View File
@@ -58,6 +58,28 @@ def plain_runs(runs, doc=None):
return "".join(out) return "".join(out)
def as_printed(runs):
"""The runs as the paper prints them (spec/03 §3.6): each run's `printed` in place of its text, and a text run
that carried one joined with an adjacent text run of the same style, as the run was before an emend split it.
Only an emend sets `printed` (spec/11 §11.1), so these are the runs with every emendation undone and every
other correction kept; runs without one are returned as they are.
"""
out, last = [], False
for r in runs:
mark = "printed" in r
if mark:
r = dict(r)
r["text"] = r.pop("printed")
if (mark or last) and out and r["kind"] == "text" and out[-1]["kind"] == "text" \
and out[-1].get("style") == r.get("style"):
out[-1] = dict(out[-1], text=out[-1]["text"] + r["text"])
else:
out.append(r)
last = mark
return out
def _strict_math(notation, source, complexes): def _strict_math(notation, source, complexes):
folded = fold_math(notation, source) folded = fold_math(notation, source)
if folded is None: if folded is None:
@@ -72,8 +94,9 @@ def _finish_strict(s):
def strict_runs_raw(runs, doc, complexes): def strict_runs_raw(runs, doc, complexes):
"""The strict projection of runs before NFKC and whitespace, over the runs as printed (spec/05 §5.3)."""
out = [] out = []
for r in runs: for r in as_printed(runs):
k = r["kind"] k = r["kind"]
if k == "text": if k == "text":
st = r.get("style", []) st = r.get("style", [])
@@ -148,6 +171,18 @@ def plain(doc, nid):
return " ".join(plain(doc, x) for x in doc.text_leaves(nid)) return " ".join(plain(doc, x) for x in doc.text_leaves(nid))
def printed(doc, nid):
"""The plain projection as printed (spec/03 §3.6): the plain projection of the runs as printed, so the text a
witness of the paper holds even where an emend corrected the authors. Equal to `plain` for a node no emend
touched; equations and verbatim text are never emended."""
n = doc.nodes[nid]
if n["kind"] in RUN_KINDS:
return plain_runs(as_printed(n["content"]), doc)
if n["kind"] in MATH_KINDS or n["kind"] in VERBATIM_KINDS:
return plain(doc, nid)
return " ".join(printed(doc, x) for x in doc.text_leaves(nid))
def strict(doc, nid): def strict(doc, nid):
"""The strict canonical projection and the node's complex math keys, in order.""" """The strict canonical projection and the node's complex math keys, in order."""
n = doc.nodes[nid] n = doc.nodes[nid]
@@ -174,10 +209,14 @@ def lossy(doc, nid):
def _runs_for_own(runs): def _runs_for_own(runs):
"""The runs as own content (spec/05 §5.2): an equation run without the ID it names, a math run without its
`form`, which says how the source is spelled and adds nothing to it (spec/03 §3.7)."""
out = [] out = []
for r in runs: for r in runs:
if r["kind"] == "equation": if r["kind"] == "equation":
out.append({"kind": "equation"}) out.append({"kind": "equation"})
elif r["kind"] == "math" and "form" in r:
out.append({k: v for k, v in r.items() if k != "form"})
else: else:
out.append(r) out.append(r)
return out return out
+9 -2
View File
@@ -63,15 +63,22 @@ def sign_checkpoint(origin, entries, signers):
def parse_checkpoint(text): def parse_checkpoint(text):
"""The origin, size, root (hex) and [(name, key hash, signature)] of a note, or None when malformed.""" """The origin, size, root (hex) and [(name, key hash, signature)] of a note, or None when malformed.
Every line ends in one U+000A and nothing else (spec/23 §23.2): a note is split on U+000A alone, never with
`str.splitlines`, which also ends a line at U+000B, U+000C, U+001C to U+001E, U+0085, U+2028 and U+2029 and
would accept a note whose last line break was replaced by one of them.
"""
try: try:
body, _, sigs = text.partition("\n\n") body, _, sigs = text.partition("\n\n")
origin, size, root_b64 = body.split("\n") origin, size, root_b64 = body.split("\n")
rt = _b64(root_b64) rt = _b64(root_b64)
if rt is None or len(rt) != 32 or not size.isdigit() or str(int(size)) != size or not origin: if rt is None or len(rt) != 32 or not size.isdigit() or str(int(size)) != size or not origin:
return None return None
if sigs and not sigs.endswith("\n"):
return None
out = [] out = []
for ln in sigs.splitlines(): for ln in sigs.split("\n")[:-1]:
if not ln.startswith("— "): if not ln.startswith("— "):
return None return None
_, name, blob = ln.split(" ", 2) _, name, blob = ln.split(" ", 2)
+96 -5
View File
@@ -11,9 +11,11 @@ import os
import posixpath import posixpath
import re import re
import stat import stat
import struct
import tempfile import tempfile
import unicodedata import unicodedata
import zipfile import zipfile
import zlib
from . import crypto, hashing, jcs, keys as K, receipts as R, vrf from . import crypto, hashing, jcs, keys as K, receipts as R, vrf
from .anchors import ADDRESS_RE from .anchors import ADDRESS_RE
@@ -42,6 +44,11 @@ JSON = {
"roster.json": "roster.schema.json", "roster.json": "roster.schema.json",
} }
REQUIRED = ["document.json", "nodes.jsonl", "witnesses.json", "provenance.json"] REQUIRED = ["document.json", "nodes.jsonl", "witnesses.json", "provenance.json"]
# Derived files (spec/12 §12.7): checked against their schemas and the formulas they name, never recomputed.
DERIVED = {
"derived/math.jsonl": "math.schema.json",
"derived/mathml.jsonl": "mathml.schema.json",
}
def line(rec): def line(rec):
@@ -253,6 +260,13 @@ def _validate(root, store, key, rep, limit=SIZE_LIMIT):
rep.add("package.file.empty", p, "an optional JSONL file with no records is omitted") rep.add("package.file.empty", p, "an optional JSONL file with no records is omitted")
else: else:
data[p] = [] data[p] = []
for p, sch in DERIVED.items():
data[p] = read_jsonl(os.path.join(root, p)) if p in listed else []
for i, rec in enumerate(data[p], 1):
for e in schema_validate(store, sch, rec):
rep.add("package.schema", "%s:%d" % (p, i), e)
if p in listed and not data[p]:
rep.add("package.file.empty", p, "an optional JSONL file with no records is omitted")
if not rep: if not rep:
return return
@@ -290,6 +304,8 @@ def _validate(root, store, key, rep, limit=SIZE_LIMIT):
rep.add("doc.policy.withheld", "nodes.jsonl", "a checks-only package withholds every leaf's content") rep.add("doc.policy.withheld", "nodes.jsonl", "a checks-only package withholds every leaf's content")
if scheme == "plain": if scheme == "plain":
rep.add("doc.policy.keyed", "document.json", "a checks-only package carries keyed hashes") rep.add("doc.policy.keyed", "document.json", "a checks-only package carries keyed hashes")
for p in sorted(x for x in listed if x.startswith("derived/")):
rep.add("doc.policy.withheld", p, "a checks-only package carries no derived files, which read the text")
if scheme == "hmac-team" and key is not None and document["hashing"]["key_id"] != crypto.key_id(key): if scheme == "hmac-team" and key is not None and document["hashing"]["key_id"] != crypto.key_id(key):
rep.add("doc.hash.key", "document.json", "key_id does not match the key supplied") rep.add("doc.hash.key", "document.json", "key_id does not match the key supplied")
@@ -302,6 +318,8 @@ def _validate(root, store, key, rep, limit=SIZE_LIMIT):
leaves_n = sum(1 for n in nodes if n["kind"] in LEAVES) leaves_n = sum(1 for n in nodes if n["kind"] in LEAVES)
if document.get("counts") != {"nodes": len(nodes), "leaves": leaves_n}: if document.get("counts") != {"nodes": len(nodes), "leaves": leaves_n}:
rep.add("doc.counts", "document.json", "counts do not recompute") rep.add("doc.counts", "document.json", "counts do not recompute")
for p in DERIVED:
_check_derived(doc, p, data[p], rep)
# Hashes. # Hashes.
hasher = hashing.PLAIN if scheme == "plain" else (hashing.Hasher(key) if key else None) hasher = hashing.PLAIN if scheme == "plain" else (hashing.Hasher(key) if key else None)
@@ -394,6 +412,14 @@ def _validate(root, store, key, rep, limit=SIZE_LIMIT):
for i, ref in enumerate(data["references.jsonl"], 1): for i, ref in enumerate(data["references.jsonl"], 1):
if kinds.get(ref["node"]) != "reference": if kinds.get(ref["node"]) != "reference":
rep.add("doc.reference.node", "references.jsonl:%d" % i, "names no reference node") rep.add("doc.reference.node", "references.jsonl:%d" % i, "names no reference node")
# The last resolve of each live reference ends at its resolution in references.jsonl (spec/11 §11.3), which is
# none for a reference without a record.
held = {r["node"]: r["resolution"] for r in data["references.jsonl"]}
resolved = {c["target"]: c for c in cors if c["op"] == "resolve"}
for nid, c in resolved.items():
if nid in live and held.get(nid, {"type": "none"}) != c["resolution"]:
rep.add("doc.correction.resolution", c["id"], "the last resolve of %s is not its resolution in "
"references.jsonl" % nid)
rorder = sorted(data["references.jsonl"], key=lambda r: pos.get(r["node"], -1)) rorder = sorted(data["references.jsonl"], key=lambda r: pos.get(r["node"], -1))
if rorder != data["references.jsonl"]: if rorder != data["references.jsonl"]:
rep.add("doc.order.references", "references.jsonl", "references follow document order") rep.add("doc.order.references", "references.jsonl", "references follow document order")
@@ -401,6 +427,9 @@ def _validate(root, store, key, rep, limit=SIZE_LIMIT):
sorder = sorted(data["suspects.jsonl"], key=lambda x: x["id"]) sorder = sorted(data["suspects.jsonl"], key=lambda x: x["id"])
if sorder != data["suspects.jsonl"]: if sorder != data["suspects.jsonl"]:
rep.add("doc.order.suspects", "suspects.jsonl", "suspects sort by ID") rep.add("doc.order.suspects", "suspects.jsonl", "suspects sort by ID")
for s in data["suspects.jsonl"]:
if "witness" in s and s["witness"] not in wits:
rep.add("doc.suspect.witness", s["id"], "a suspect's witness is one of the package's witnesses")
# Receipts and fidelity. # Receipts and fidelity.
roster = {k["id"]: k for k in data.get("roster.json", {}).get("keys", [])} roster = {k["id"]: k for k in data.get("roster.json", {}).get("keys", [])}
@@ -467,10 +496,66 @@ def _validate(root, store, key, rep, limit=SIZE_LIMIT):
if not withheld and (roster or not recs): if not withheld and (roster or not recs):
# Without a roster no receipt can be judged valid, so a package that carries receipts but no roster is # Without a roster no receipt can be judged valid, so a package that carries receipts but no roster is
# checked against its store instead; one with neither reports the leaves' own levels. # checked against its store instead; one with neither reports the leaves' own levels.
if R.distribution(R.effective_levels(nodes, vals, recs, roster)) != document["fidelity"]: if R.distribution(R.effective_levels(nodes, vals, recs, roster, cors)) != document["fidelity"]:
rep.add("doc.fidelity.report", "document.json", "the fidelity distribution does not recompute") rep.add("doc.fidelity.report", "document.json", "the fidelity distribution does not recompute")
def derived_formula(doc, node, run):
"""The formula a derived line names (spec/12 §12.7), as `{notation, source, form?}`, or None when it names none:
the content of an equation or equation line when `run` is null, else the math run at index `run` of a node
with runs."""
n = doc.nodes.get(node)
if n is None or n.get("withheld"):
return None
if run is None:
return n.get("content") if n["kind"] in MATH_KINDS else None
runs = n.get("content") if n["kind"] in RUN_KINDS else None
if not isinstance(runs, list) or run >= len(runs) or runs[run]["kind"] != "math":
return None
return runs[run]
def tree_facts(tree):
"""The `sym` keys of a scienting-math/1 tree in document order, and whether it has an `opaque` node (spec/09
§9.4). A node is an array whose first item is its kind; an array whose first item is not a string is a group of
parts. Walked without recursion, so a deep tree cannot exhaust the stack."""
keys, opaque, stack = [], False, [tree]
while stack:
x = stack.pop()
if not isinstance(x, list) or not x:
continue
if isinstance(x[0], str):
if x[0] == "opaque":
opaque = True
elif x[0] == "sym" and len(x) > 1 and isinstance(x[1], str):
keys.append(x[1])
stack.extend(reversed(x[1:]))
else:
stack.extend(reversed(x))
return keys, opaque
def _check_derived(doc, path, lines, rep):
"""Each line of a derived file names a formula of the package; a math line's formula is TeX, and its `complete`
and `symbols` agree with its tree (spec/12 §12.7, spec/09 §9.4). The tree itself is the tool's and not
recomputed."""
for i, rec in enumerate(lines, 1):
where = "%s:%d" % (path, i)
formula = derived_formula(doc, rec["node"], rec["run"])
if formula is None:
rep.add("doc.derived.node", where, "names no equation, equation line or math run of the package")
continue
if path != "derived/math.jsonl":
continue
if formula["notation"] != "tex":
rep.add("doc.derived.math", where, "the math form reads TeX, and the formula is %s" % formula["notation"])
keys, opaque = tree_facts(rec["tree"])
if rec["complete"] == opaque:
rep.add("doc.derived.math", where, "complete is true exactly when the tree has no opaque node")
if sorted(set(keys)) != sorted(rec["symbols"]):
rep.add("doc.derived.math", where, "symbols are not the sym keys of the tree, each once")
def read_state(root): def read_state(root):
"""The current state of the package at `root`, for the gate (spec/11 §11.4): nodes without their values, """The current state of the package at `root`, for the gate (spec/11 §11.4): nodes without their values,
the ID table and the corrections applied so far. Validate the package first.""" the ID table and the corrections applied so far. Validate the package first."""
@@ -482,7 +567,8 @@ def read_state(root):
values = ("text_hash", "match_hash", "align_key", "own_hash", "node_hash") values = ("text_hash", "match_hash", "align_key", "own_hash", "node_hash")
nodes = [{k: v for k, v in n.items() if k not in values} for n in jl("nodes.jsonl")] nodes = [{k: v for k, v in n.items() if k not in values} for n in jl("nodes.jsonl")]
return State(read_json(os.path.join(root, "document.json"))["key"], nodes, jl("ids.jsonl"), jl("corrections.jsonl")) return State(read_json(os.path.join(root, "document.json"))["key"], nodes, jl("ids.jsonl"), jl("corrections.jsonl"),
references=jl("references.jsonl"))
def n_root_hash(nodes, doc): def n_root_hash(nodes, doc):
@@ -502,6 +588,11 @@ ZIP_LIMIT = 1 << 30
_ZIP_DATE = (1980, 1, 1, 0, 0, 0) _ZIP_DATE = (1980, 1, 1, 0, 0, 0)
_FLAG_ENCRYPTED = 0x1 _FLAG_ENCRYPTED = 0x1
_FLAG_UTF8 = 0x800 _FLAG_UTF8 = 0x800
# What `zipfile` raises on an archive it cannot read: a damaged structure (BadZipFile, struct.error, EOFError), a
# version or feature it does not implement (NotImplementedError, as for "zip file version 9.8"), a name that is not
# the UTF-8 its flag claims (UnicodeDecodeError, a ValueError), or deflated bytes that do not inflate (zlib.error).
_ZIP_ERRORS = (zipfile.BadZipFile, NotImplementedError, EOFError, ValueError, RuntimeError, OSError, struct.error,
zlib.error)
def is_zip(path): def is_zip(path):
@@ -577,8 +668,8 @@ def read_zip(path, dest, limit=ZIP_LIMIT):
""" """
try: try:
zf = zipfile.ZipFile(path) zf = zipfile.ZipFile(path)
except (zipfile.BadZipFile, OSError) as e: except _ZIP_ERRORS as e:
raise Refusal("package.zip.entry", "not a zip archive: %s" % e) raise Refusal("package.zip.entry", "not a zip archive this reader can open: %s" % e)
with zf: with zf:
folder = _zip_entries(zf, limit) folder = _zip_entries(zf, limit)
root = os.path.join(dest, folder) root = os.path.join(dest, folder)
@@ -602,7 +693,7 @@ def read_zip(path, dest, limit=ZIP_LIMIT):
if n > zi.file_size or written > limit: if n > zi.file_size or written > limit:
raise Refusal("package.zip.size", "%s: holds more than its header declares" % zi.filename) raise Refusal("package.zip.size", "%s: holds more than its header declares" % zi.filename)
dst.write(chunk) dst.write(chunk)
except (zipfile.BadZipFile, RuntimeError, OSError) as e: except _ZIP_ERRORS as e:
raise Refusal("package.zip.entry", "%s: %s" % (zi.filename, e)) raise Refusal("package.zip.entry", "%s: %s" % (zi.filename, e))
return root return root
+27 -3
View File
@@ -256,13 +256,37 @@ def receipt_status(rec, records, roster):
return statuses(records, roster).get(rec.get("id"), "invalid") return statuses(records, roster).get(rec.get("id"), "invalid")
def effective_levels(nodes, values, records, roster): def carried_hashes(values, corrections):
"""Every leaf's level: its recorded level, raised by valid receipts that list it at its current hash. """For each node, the node_hashes at which a receipt still counts for it (spec/08 §8.2): its current one, and
each earlier one that only emend, relink and resolve corrections of the node itself have changed since.
Walking the corrections back from the last, one that names the node in any way ends its chain, unless it is
one of those three, targets the node, and ends at the hash reached so far; then its `before` is reached.
"""
from .corrections import KEEPS_LEVEL
out = {nid: {v["node_hash"]} for nid, v in values.items()}
reached = {nid: v["node_hash"] for nid, v in values.items()}
for c in reversed(corrections):
named = ({c.get("target")} | set(c.get("touched", [])) | set(c.get("path") or []) | set(c.get("to_path") or [])
| set(c.get("created", [])) | set(c.get("retired", [])))
for nid in named & set(reached):
if c["op"] in KEEPS_LEVEL and c.get("target") == nid and c.get("after") == reached[nid] and c.get("before"):
reached[nid] = c["before"]
out[nid].add(c["before"])
else:
del reached[nid]
return out
def effective_levels(nodes, values, records, roster, corrections=()):
"""Every leaf's level: its recorded level, raised by valid receipts that list it at its current hash, or at a
hash only emend, relink and resolve corrections have changed since, given the document's `corrections`.
A spot-check's `qa:` receipt does not raise the nodes it found in error (spec/08 §8.2). A spot-check's `qa:` receipt does not raise the nodes it found in error (spec/08 §8.2).
""" """
level = {n["id"]: n.get("fidelity") for n in nodes if "fidelity" in n} level = {n["id"]: n.get("fidelity") for n in nodes if "fidelity" in n}
status = statuses(records, roster) status = statuses(records, roster)
carried = carried_hashes(values, corrections)
for rec in records: for rec in records:
if rec["format"] != "scienting-receipt/1": if rec["format"] != "scienting-receipt/1":
continue continue
@@ -270,7 +294,7 @@ def effective_levels(nodes, values, records, roster):
continue continue
wrong = {e["node"] for e in (rec.get("qa") or {}).get("errors", [])} wrong = {e["node"] for e in (rec.get("qa") or {}).get("errors", [])}
for nid, h in rec.get("nodes", []): for nid, h in rec.get("nodes", []):
if nid in level and nid not in wrong and values[nid]["node_hash"] == h: if nid in level and nid not in wrong and h in carried[nid]:
if LEVELS.index(rec["level"]) > LEVELS.index(level[nid]): if LEVELS.index(rec["level"]) > LEVELS.index(level[nid]):
level[nid] = rec["level"] level[nid] = rec["level"]
return level return level
+268
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,268 @@
"""Traced citations: where a citation leads, and whether it still does.
A trace is an annotation whose body has the kind `trace`: its target is a sentence of the citing document, and its
body names the reference the sentence cites and a passage of the cited document. Non-normative; see
spec/18-layers.md §18.4 for the body and spec/22-conformance.md §22.4 for the rules `layer.trace.source` and
`layer.trace.target`.
`resolve` judges a trace against the current states of both documents, `problems` checks a trace when it is
written, and `disputes` finds the replies that dispute it. Nothing here needs more than the standard library.
"""
import re
from . import anchors as AN
from . import hashing
from .model import RUN_KINDS
RESULTS = ("current", "changed", "stale", "unlinked", "misresolved")
DOC_TAG = re.compile(r"^tag:scient\.ing,2026:doc:(?P<store>[a-z0-9][a-z0-9._-]*)/(?P<key>[a-z][a-z0-9]*-[0-9a-hjkmnp-tv-z]{4,51}"
r"(?:\.[a-z0-9][a-z0-9-]*)*)$")
# The statuses of a reply that still stands: a withdrawn or rejected reply disputes nothing.
LIVE = ("proposed", "confirmed")
def doc_tag(store, key):
"""The tag of a document of a store, as `source` and a target's source write it."""
return "tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:%s/%s" % (store, key)
def _anchors(holder):
"""The anchors of the `AnchorSelector`s of a body or a target, in order."""
sel = holder.get("selector") if isinstance(holder, dict) else None
return [s["anchor"] for s in sel or [] if isinstance(s, dict) and s.get("type") == "AnchorSelector"]
def _bare(doc):
"""A document key without its store: `smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb` and `hale2026harmonic-damb` agree."""
return doc.rsplit("/", 1)[-1]
def _work(doc):
"""The work key of a document key: the key before the first dot of its version suffix (spec/02 §2.4)."""
return _bare(doc).split(".", 1)[0]
def _live(state, nid):
"""The live node an ID leads to, following aliases and retirements; None when it was deleted or never was."""
return AN._follow(state, nid)[0]
def _record(state, nid):
"""The resolution of a reference: the record of references.jsonl for the node, else `none` (spec/10)."""
for r in state.references:
if r["node"] == nid:
return r["resolution"]
return {"type": "none"}
def _cites(state, nid, reference):
"""Whether the leaf `nid` has a cite run that names the reference `reference`, however either was renamed."""
n = {x["id"]: x for x in state.nodes}.get(nid)
if n is None or n["kind"] not in RUN_KINDS:
return False
want = _live(state, reference)
return want is not None and any(_live(state, x) == want for r in n["content"] if r["kind"] == "cite"
for x in r["refs"])
def _agrees(resolution, cited_key, same_as):
"""Whether a reference's resolution still names the cited work.
`none` names nothing, so it contradicts nothing. A `document` resolution agrees when its key is the cited
document's, another version of the same work (the key before the first dot), or one of `same_as`; a `doi`
resolution agrees when `doi:` and the DOI, in lower case, is one of `same_as`.
"""
known = {x.lower() for x in same_as}
kind = resolution.get("type")
if kind == "document":
doc = resolution["doc"]
return _work(doc) == _work(cited_key) or _bare(doc) in known or doc in known
if kind == "doi":
return "doi:" + resolution["doi"].lower() in known
return True
def _passage_cites(state, node, span):
"""The citations inside a passage, so a chain of 'as previously reported' can be followed one trace at a time.
One item for each `cite` run of the passage's leaves (those that overlap `span`, for a span of a leaf), in
document order: the leaf, the run's index and span in the leaf's plain projection, its printed text, and each
reference it names with that reference's resolution in the cited document.
"""
doc = state.doc()
leaves = doc.leaves(node)
out = []
for leaf in leaves:
n = doc.nodes[leaf]
if n["kind"] not in RUN_KINDS:
continue
pos = 0
for i, r in enumerate(n["content"]):
end = pos + len(hashing.plain_runs([r], doc))
if r["kind"] == "cite" and (span is None or (pos < span[1] and end > span[0])):
out.append({"node": leaf, "run": i, "span": [pos, end], "text": r["text"],
"refs": [{"node": x, "resolution": _record(state, _live(state, x) or x)} for x in r["refs"]]})
pos = end
return out
def _sides(annotation, citing_state, cited_state):
"""The citing anchor and the passage anchor of a trace, after checking that the states are those documents'."""
body = annotation.get("body", {})
if body.get("kind") != "trace":
raise ValueError("the annotation is not a trace")
mine, theirs = _anchors(annotation["target"]), _anchors(body)
if not mine or not theirs:
raise ValueError("a trace needs an AnchorSelector on its target and one in its body")
if mine[0]["doc"] != citing_state.key:
raise ValueError("citing_state is %s, but the trace's target is on %s" % (citing_state.key, mine[0]["doc"]))
if theirs[0]["doc"] != cited_state.key:
raise ValueError("cited_state is %s, but the trace's passage is in %s" % (cited_state.key, theirs[0]["doc"]))
return mine[0], theirs[0]
def resolve(annotation, citing_state, cited_state, same_as=()):
"""Judge a trace against the current state of the citing document and of the cited document.
`annotation` is the trace, an annotation with a `trace` body; `citing_state` and `cited_state` are the
`corrections.State` of the document its target is on and of the document its body's `source` names (for a
package, `package.read_state`); `same_as` is everything the cited work is known by, the `work.same_as` of its
`document.json` (`doi:…`) and the keys of its other versions, and decides whether a `doi` resolution of the
reference still names the cited work. Both anchors are resolved by spec/06 §6.5.
Returns a dict. `result` is the first that applies of:
- `stale`: an anchor does not resolve; `side` is `citing`, `cited` or `both`.
- `unlinked`: the sentence no longer cites the reference (a `relink` removed the citation, or the reference
was deleted).
- `misresolved`: the reference now resolves to a `doi` or a `document` that is not the cited work (a `resolve`).
- `changed`: both anchors resolve, and at least one is not `current`, so the passage or the sentence is not as
it was when the trace was made; a reader shows the trace with its new address and offers a review.
- `current`: both anchors are `current` and the citation links the reference to the cited work.
`citing` and `cited` are the two anchor resolutions (spec/06 §6.5). `open` is the current address of the
cited passage, `store/key#node@pin[start:end]`, whenever its anchor still resolves, whatever `result` says;
`None` when it is stale. `cites` lists the citations inside the passage, `[]` when it is stale: one item
`{node, run, span, text, refs}` for each `cite` run of the passage's leaves, in document order, where `node`
and `run` find the run in the cited document, `span` is its place in the leaf's plain projection, `text` is
what the paper prints, and `refs` lists `{node, resolution}` for each reference it names, so a chain of "as
previously reported" is followed by looking for a trace on that leaf and reference. `reference` is the live
node of the reference in the citing document, or None when it was deleted, and `resolution` the one its
record holds. `reason` says why for every result but `current`.
The annotation's `status` and its replies are not read here: a rejected candidate resolves like any other
trace, and `disputed` says whether a reply disputes it. A `ValueError` means the call is wrong, not the trace:
the annotation has no trace body, or a state is not that of the document the annotation names.
"""
body = annotation["body"]
mine, theirs = _sides(annotation, citing_state, cited_state)
citing, cited = AN.resolve(citing_state, mine), AN.resolve(cited_state, theirs)
reference = _live(citing_state, body["reference"])
resolution = _record(citing_state, reference) if reference else _record(citing_state, body["reference"])
out = {"citing": citing, "cited": cited, "reference": reference, "resolution": resolution}
if cited["result"] != "stale":
m = DOC_TAG.match(body["source"])
store = m.group("store") if m else theirs.get("store")
out["open"] = AN.format_address(store, cited_state.key, cited["node"], cited["node_hash"][:6], cited.get("span"))
out["cites"] = _passage_cites(cited_state, cited["node"], cited.get("span"))
else:
out["open"], out["cites"] = None, []
stale = [s for s, r in (("citing", citing), ("cited", cited)) if r["result"] == "stale"]
if stale:
out.update(result="stale", side="both" if len(stale) == 2 else stale[0],
reason="; ".join("the %s anchor is stale: %s" % (s, (citing if s == "citing" else cited).get("reason", ""))
for s in stale))
elif reference is None or not _cites(citing_state, citing["node"], reference):
out.update(result="unlinked", reason="the sentence no longer cites the reference")
elif not _agrees(resolution, cited_state.key, same_as):
out.update(result="misresolved", reason="the reference resolves to %s, not to the cited work"
% (resolution.get("doc") or "doi:" + resolution.get("doi", "")))
elif citing["result"] != "current" or cited["result"] != "current":
out.update(result="changed", reason="; ".join("the %s anchor is %s" % (s, r["result"]) for s, r in (
("citing", citing), ("cited", cited)) if r["result"] != "current"))
else:
out["result"] = "current"
return out
def problems(annotation, citing_state=None, cited_state=None):
"""The rules a trace breaks, as `[{"rule", "message"}]` in the order checked; empty when it breaks none.
Without states the trace is checked alone; with them, against the documents it was made on, which is how a
producer checks a trace it writes or imports. A trace later made `unlinked` by a correction breaks
`layer.trace.target` here, since the sentence it names no longer cites the reference; `resolve` is the judgment
of a trace over time. `layer.trace.source` covers the body, `layer.trace.target` the target and the reference.
"""
found = []
def add(rule, message):
found.append({"rule": rule, "message": message})
body, target = annotation["body"], annotation["target"]
mine, passage = _anchors(target), _anchors(body)
if citing_state is not None and mine and mine[0]["doc"] != citing_state.key:
raise ValueError("citing_state is not the document the trace's target is on")
if cited_state is not None and passage and passage[0]["doc"] != cited_state.key:
raise ValueError("cited_state is not the document the trace's passage is in")
# The source: a document of a store, named by its tag, and the passage inside it.
m = DOC_TAG.match(body.get("source", ""))
if not m:
add("layer.trace.source", "the source is not a document tag")
if not passage:
add("layer.trace.source", "the body's selector has no AnchorSelector")
elif m:
for a in passage:
if a["doc"] != m.group("key") or ("store" in a and a["store"] != m.group("store")):
add("layer.trace.source", "an anchor of the selector is in %s, not in the source %s/%s"
% (a["doc"], m.group("store"), m.group("key")))
break
citing_doc = target.get("source", "") if isinstance(target, dict) else ""
if citing_doc == body["source"]:
add("layer.trace.source", "the source is the citing document itself; a trace leads to another paper")
quote = passage[0].get("quote", {}) if passage else {}
for s in body.get("selector", []) if passage else []:
if isinstance(s, dict) and s.get("type") == "TextQuoteSelector":
if "exact" not in quote or any(s.get(k, "") != quote.get(k, "") for k in ("exact", "prefix", "suffix")):
add("layer.trace.source", "the TextQuoteSelector does not repeat the anchor's plain quote")
break
if cited_state is not None and passage:
node = passage[0]["node"]
if node not in {n["id"] for n in cited_state.nodes} | {e["id"] for e in cited_state.ids}:
add("layer.trace.source", "the passage's node %s is not in the cited document" % node)
# The target: a leaf with runs of the citing document, which cites the reference.
if not mine:
add("layer.trace.target", "the target is not a document selected by an AnchorSelector")
else:
a = mine[0]
kind = a.get("kind")
if (kind is not None and kind not in RUN_KINDS) or "quote" not in a:
add("layer.trace.target", "the target anchor is not on a leaf with runs, whole or in part")
elif citing_state is not None:
live = _live(citing_state, a["node"])
nodes = {n["id"]: n for n in citing_state.nodes}
ref = nodes.get(_live(citing_state, body["reference"]) or "")
if ref is None or ref["kind"] != "reference":
add("layer.trace.target", "the reference %s is not a reference node of the citing document" % body["reference"])
elif live is None or not _cites(citing_state, live, body["reference"]):
add("layer.trace.target", "the sentence does not cite the reference %s" % body["reference"])
return found
def replies(annotation_id, annotations):
"""The annotations among `annotations` that reply to the annotation `annotation_id`: those whose target is it."""
return [a for a in annotations if isinstance(a.get("target"), dict) and "selector" not in a["target"]
and a["target"].get("source") == annotation_id]
def disputes(annotation_id, annotations):
"""The replies that dispute a trace: those with the motivation `assessing` that are `proposed` or `confirmed`."""
return [a for a in replies(annotation_id, annotations) if a.get("motivation") == "assessing"
and a.get("status") in LIVE]
def disputed(annotation_id, annotations):
"""Whether a trace is disputed; a dispute is computed from the replies, never stored on the trace."""
return bool(disputes(annotation_id, annotations))
+9 -2
View File
@@ -24,10 +24,16 @@ class Refusal(Exception):
def canonical_runs(runs): def canonical_runs(runs):
"""Drop empty text runs and join adjacent text runs with the same styles.""" """Drop empty text runs and join adjacent text runs with the same styles.
A run that keeps what was printed (`printed`, spec/03 §3.5) is never joined, so the emendation stays where it
was made; a `printed` equal to the run's text records nothing and is dropped.
"""
out = [] out = []
for r in runs: for r in runs:
r = dict(r) r = dict(r)
if "printed" in r and r["printed"] == r.get("text"):
del r["printed"]
if r["kind"] == "text": if r["kind"] == "text":
if "style" in r: if "style" in r:
r["style"] = sorted(set(r["style"])) r["style"] = sorted(set(r["style"]))
@@ -35,7 +41,8 @@ def canonical_runs(runs):
del r["style"] del r["style"]
if r["text"] == "": if r["text"] == "":
continue continue
if out and out[-1]["kind"] == "text" and out[-1].get("style") == r.get("style"): if (out and out[-1]["kind"] == "text" and out[-1].get("style") == r.get("style")
and "printed" not in out[-1] and "printed" not in r):
out[-1] = dict(out[-1], text=out[-1]["text"] + r["text"]) out[-1] = dict(out[-1], text=out[-1]["text"] + r["text"])
continue continue
out.append(r) out.append(r)
+2 -2
View File
@@ -75,8 +75,8 @@ A node's five values depend only on its own subtree, so after a correction the o
`paperspec check` compares the result after every correction with a slow computation that projects each node from its whole subtree. `paperspec check` compares the result after every correction with a slow computation that projects each node from its whole subtree.
Other repositories of the project do not reimplement the specification: they install this repository as the Python package `paperspec`, from the Gitea package registry or as a git pin ([deploy/](../deploy/README.md#install-from-the-registry)), and import the oracle from it, so that every key, identifier, canonical JSON string, package check and database form comes from one piece of code. Other repositories of the project do not reimplement the specification: they install this repository as the Python package `paperspec`, from the Gitea package registry or as a git pin ([deploy/](../deploy/README.md#install-from-the-registry)), and import the oracle from it, so that every key, identifier, canonical JSON string, package check and database form comes from one piece of code.
The library surface they use is `keys`, `text`, `jcs`, `package`, `db`, `schema` and `rights`, with the schemas, SQL and vectors as package data: `paperspec.resources.path("sql")` finds a folder in an installed wheel and in an editable install alike. The library surface they use is `keys`, `text`, `jcs`, `package`, `db`, `schema`, `rights` and `traces`, with the schemas, SQL and vectors as package data: `paperspec.resources.path("sql")` finds a folder in an installed wheel and in an editable install alike.
The vectors travel with the package, but `resolve.jsonl`, `grading.jsonl` and `targets.jsonl` name a fixture package, and the fixtures stay in the repository. The vectors travel with the package, but `resolve.jsonl`, `grading.jsonl`, `targets.jsonl` and `traces.jsonl` name a fixture package, and the fixtures stay in the repository.
The package needs Python 3.14, the only version with the Unicode 16.0 character data the specification pins, and refuses to import on any other. The package needs Python 3.14, the only version with the Unicode 16.0 character data the specification pins, and refuses to import on any other.
Importing any of its modules needs only the standard library. Importing any of its modules needs only the standard library.
Schema validation (`schema`, and with it `package.validate` and `corrections.gate`) needs `paperspec[schema]` (`jsonschema` and `referencing`), and HKDF and Ed25519 in `crypto`, which the signature and receipt checks use, need `paperspec[crypto]`. Schema validation (`schema`, and with it `package.validate` and `corrections.gate`) needs `paperspec[schema]` (`jsonschema` and `referencing`), and HKDF and Ed25519 in `crypto`, which the signature and receipt checks use, need `paperspec[crypto]`.
+11 -7
View File
@@ -52,7 +52,7 @@ The procedure is the same for every file:
3. 3.
Find the inputs and the expected outputs of the case. Find the inputs and the expected outputs of the case.
The table below says which fields are which, and the chapter it links defines the rule. The table below says which fields are which, and the chapter it links defines the rule.
Only six files, `alignment`, `corrections`, `grading`, `resolve`, `rights` and `targets`, put the expected outputs under `expect`. Only seven files, `alignment`, `corrections`, `grading`, `resolve`, `rights`, `targets` and `traces`, put the expected outputs under `expect`.
In the other nineteen the expected outputs are fields beside the inputs, such as `output`, `sha256`, `canonical` or `parsed`. In the other nineteen the expected outputs are fields beside the inputs, such as `output`, `sha256`, `canonical` or `parsed`.
4. 4.
Compute each output from the inputs with your implementation. Compute each output from the inputs with your implementation.
@@ -74,11 +74,14 @@ Some files change the procedure:
- `fingerprints.jsonl` needs the download-stamp rules in [registry/stamps/scienting-stamps-1.json](../registry/stamps/scienting-stamps-1.json), which each case names in `rules`. - `fingerprints.jsonl` needs the download-stamp rules in [registry/stamps/scienting-stamps-1.json](../registry/stamps/scienting-stamps-1.json), which each case names in `rules`.
- `resolve.jsonl`, `grading.jsonl` and `targets.jsonl` name a package by a path from the repository root. - `resolve.jsonl`, `grading.jsonl` and `targets.jsonl` name a package by a path from the repository root.
All three use `fixtures/packages/hale2026harmonic-damb`. All three use `fixtures/packages/hale2026harmonic-damb`.
- `traces.jsonl` names two packages, `citing` (the draft) and `cited` (the main example), and for a `resolve` case lists the corrections to apply to each, in order, before judging the trace, and the `same_as` identifiers of the cited work.
Apply them with the gate ([11.4](../spec/11-corrections.md#114-the-gate)) to the package's state at its own revision.
A `problems` case gives the packages' states as they are, and `cited` is null when the trace names no passage in the main example.
Several files also mix more than one kind of case, told apart by their fields. Several files also mix more than one kind of case, told apart by their fields.
`ids.jsonl` has minting cases and letter-first cases, `keyed.jsonl` and `signatures.jsonl` have a case for each derivation or record, `spotcheck.jsonl` has sample-size cases and one full sample, and `rights.jsonl` has stage checks (a `stage` field), backend checks (a `backend` field) and one combining case (neither). `ids.jsonl` has minting cases and letter-first cases, `keyed.jsonl` and `signatures.jsonl` have a case for each derivation or record, `spotcheck.jsonl` has sample-size cases and one full sample, and `rights.jsonl` has stage checks (a `stage` field), backend checks (a `backend` field) and one combining case (neither).
The reference checker, `paperspec check` ([tools/](../tools/README.md)), runs all twenty-five files, together with the rest of the repository's checks: The reference checker, `paperspec check` ([tools/](../tools/README.md)), runs all twenty-six files, together with the rest of the repository's checks:
```sh ```sh
paperspec check --quick paperspec check --quick
@@ -106,10 +109,10 @@ The table below uses a few terms that the chapters define:
| `normalize.jsonl` | Normalization for hashing, and the SHA-256 of the result. | [1.4](../spec/01-conventions.md#14-text-normalization-for-hashing) | | `normalize.jsonl` | Normalization for hashing, and the SHA-256 of the result. | [1.4](../spec/01-conventions.md#14-text-normalization-for-hashing) |
| `ids.jsonl` | Minting payloads and node IDs, and letter-first encodings of digests. | [4](../spec/04-identity.md) | | `ids.jsonl` | Minting payloads and node IDs, and letter-first encodings of digests. | [4](../spec/04-identity.md) |
| `notation.jsonl` | Each math source's canonical linear form, or null when it is complex. | [5.4](../spec/05-hashes.md#54-simple-notation) | | `notation.jsonl` | Each math source's canonical linear form, or null when it is complex. | [5.4](../spec/05-hashes.md#54-simple-notation) |
| `projections.jsonl` | One-sentence runs: plain, normalized, strict and lossy projections, complex keys and the three text values. | [5.3](../spec/05-hashes.md#53-the-strict-projection) | | `projections.jsonl` | One-sentence runs: plain, normalized, strict and lossy projections, complex keys and the three text values, and the projection as printed (`printed`) of an emended sentence. | [5.3](../spec/05-hashes.md#53-the-strict-projection), [3.6](../spec/03-nodes.md#36-the-plain-projection) |
| `projection-groups.jsonl` | Which cases must share, or must differ in, a value: H₂O in six spellings, cm⁻¹, 10⁻³, K_r, ligatures, the micro sign, "103" against 10³. | [5.3](../spec/05-hashes.md#53-the-strict-projection) | | `projection-groups.jsonl` | Which cases must share, or must differ in, a value: H₂O in six spellings, cm⁻¹, 10⁻³, K_r, ligatures, the micro sign, "103" against 10³, and an emended sentence against its printed text. | [5.3](../spec/05-hashes.md#53-the-strict-projection) |
| `offsets.jsonl` | Code-point spans and their UTF-16 equivalents. | [1.5](../spec/01-conventions.md#15-character-offsets) | | `offsets.jsonl` | Code-point spans and their UTF-16 equivalents. | [1.5](../spec/01-conventions.md#15-character-offsets) |
| `hashes.jsonl` | Every node of a small document, its own content and its five values. | [5.1](../spec/05-hashes.md#51-the-five-values) | | `hashes.jsonl` | Every node of a small document, its own content and its five values; and of a sentence whose equation and math run carry a math form, which enters no value. | [5.1](../spec/05-hashes.md#51-the-five-values), [5.2](../spec/05-hashes.md#52-own-content) |
| `addresses.jsonl` | How addresses parse; null for invalid ones. | [6.1](../spec/06-anchors.md#61-addresses) | | `addresses.jsonl` | How addresses parse; null for invalid ones. | [6.1](../spec/06-anchors.md#61-addresses) |
| `keyed.jsonl` | The team key and its ID, an HMAC, page hashes, a page-derived key, and what someone without the paper cannot check. | [5.8](../spec/05-hashes.md#58-keyed-hashes) | | `keyed.jsonl` | The team key and its ID, an HMAC, page hashes, a page-derived key, and what someone without the paper cannot check. | [5.8](../spec/05-hashes.md#58-keyed-hashes) |
| `fingerprints.jsonl` | Pages as text lines, the stamp rules that fired, and the fingerprint; two downloads that must agree, and a change that must not. | [7.1](../spec/07-geometry.md#71-page-fingerprints) | | `fingerprints.jsonl` | Pages as text lines, the stamp rules that fired, and the fingerprint; two downloads that must agree, and a change that must not. | [7.1](../spec/07-geometry.md#71-page-fingerprints) |
@@ -118,8 +121,9 @@ The table below uses a few terms that the chapters define:
| `spotcheck.jsonl` | Seed payloads, seeds, sample sizes and samples. | [8.8](../spec/08-fidelity.md#88-spot-checks) | | `spotcheck.jsonl` | Seed payloads, seeds, sample sizes and samples. | [8.8](../spec/08-fidelity.md#88-spot-checks) |
| `bounds.jsonl` | Reviewer error bounds as reported. | [8.9](../spec/08-fidelity.md#89-reviewer-error-bounds) | | `bounds.jsonl` | Reviewer error bounds as reported. | [8.9](../spec/08-fidelity.md#89-reviewer-error-bounds) |
| `alignment.jsonl` | Two readings of a document, their pairs and their suspects. | [5.6](../spec/05-hashes.md#56-alignment) | | `alignment.jsonl` | Two readings of a document, their pairs and their suspects. | [5.6](../spec/05-hashes.md#56-alignment) |
| `corrections.jsonl` | Each operation and refusal on a small document: the state before, the correction, and the record and state after, or the rule broken. | [11](../spec/11-corrections.md) | | `corrections.jsonl` | Each operation and refusal on a small document: the state before, the correction, and the record and state after, or the rule broken; with the reference records for a `resolve`, and the leaf as printed for an `emend`. | [11](../spec/11-corrections.md) |
| `resolve.jsonl` | Anchors made on the example paper's first reading, and how each resolves after its corrections. | [6.5](../spec/06-anchors.md#65-resolution) | | `resolve.jsonl` | Anchors made on the example paper's first reading, and how each resolves after its corrections. | [6.5](../spec/06-anchors.md#65-resolution) |
| `traces.jsonl` | Traced citations: a trace on the draft's sentence that cites the main example, with the corrections that make it current, changed, stale, unlinked or misresolved, the passage's current address and the citations inside it (`op` `resolve`); and traces that break `layer.trace.source` or `layer.trace.target` (`op` `problems`). | [18.5](../spec/18-layers.md#185-traced-citations) |
| `rights.jsonl` | Stage checks with policies and expiry, the combining rule, and backend conditions. | [14](../spec/14-rights.md) | | `rights.jsonl` | Stage checks with policies and expiry, the combining rule, and backend conditions. | [14](../spec/14-rights.md) |
| `grading.jsonl` | Exercises, submissions and the grades they earn. | [19.4](../spec/19-exercises.md#194-grading) | | `grading.jsonl` | Exercises, submissions and the grades they earn. | [19.4](../spec/19-exercises.md#194-grading) |
| `targets.jsonl` | The target set of targeted F3 for the example paper under each digit rule, given the anchored nodes. | [8.10](../spec/08-fidelity.md#810-targeted-f3) | | `targets.jsonl` | The target set of targeted F3 for the example paper under each digit rule, given the anchored nodes. | [8.10](../spec/08-fidelity.md#810-targeted-f3) |
@@ -138,7 +142,7 @@ A candidate format changes only with a recorded reason and a new or changed vect
A passing run shows one thing: for these inputs, your implementation computes the same values as the reference implementation in `src/paperspec/`. A passing run shows one thing: for these inputs, your implementation computes the same values as the reference implementation in `src/paperspec/`.
That code computed the expected outputs, and `pixi run build` regenerates them ([tools/](../tools/README.md)). That code computed the expected outputs, and `pixi run build` regenerates them ([tools/](../tools/README.md)).
The vectors hold 311 cases in all, some of them small: `hashes.jsonl` has one document, `alignment.jsonl` one pair of readings, `offsets.jsonl` two cases. The vectors hold 359 cases in all, some of them small: `hashes.jsonl` has two documents, `alignment.jsonl` two pairs of readings, `offsets.jsonl` two cases.
The vectors do not show the following. The vectors do not show the following.
+1
View File
@@ -1 +1,2 @@
{"a":[{"complex":[],"container":"h","context":"heading","id":"a1","lossy":"methods","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"Methods"}],"strict":"Methods"},{"complex":[],"container":"p1","context":"paragraph","id":"a2","lossy":"everybondwasscannedinstepsof0.01åarounditsminimum.","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"Every bond was scanned in steps of 0.01 Å around its minimum."}],"strict":"Every bond was scanned in steps of 0.01 Å around its minimum."},{"complex":["tex:\\frac{a}{b}"],"container":"p1","context":"paragraph","id":"a3","lossy":"whereisthebondlength.","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"where "},{"kind":"math","notation":"tex","source":"\\frac{a}{b}"},{"kind":"text","text":" is the bond length."}],"strict":"where  is the bond length."},{"complex":[],"container":"p1","context":"paragraph","id":"a4","lossy":"thefittedrateis103persecondatroomtemperature.","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"The fitted rate is 10³ per second at room temperature."}],"strict":"The fitted rate is 10^{3} per second at room temperature."},{"complex":["tex:\\frac{c}{d}"],"container":"p2","context":"paragraph","id":"a5","lossy":"whereisthebondlength.","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"where "},{"kind":"math","notation":"tex","source":"\\frac{c}{d}"},{"kind":"text","text":" is the bond length."}],"strict":"where  is the bond length."},{"complex":[],"container":"p2","context":"paragraph","id":"a6","lossy":"thissentencewasdroppedbythesecondreadingentirely.","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"This sentence was dropped by the second reading entirely."}],"strict":"This sentence was dropped by the second reading entirely."},{"complex":[],"container":"p2","context":"paragraph","id":"a7","lossy":"thelastsentenceofthesectionisuniqueandlongenough.","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"The last sentence of the section is unique and long enough."}],"strict":"The last sentence of the section is unique and long enough."}],"b":[{"complex":[],"container":"x","context":"paragraph","id":"b1","lossy":"methods","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"Methods"}],"strict":"Methods"},{"complex":[],"container":"q1","context":"paragraph","id":"b2","lossy":"everybondwasscannedinstepsof0.01åarounditsminimum.","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"Every bond was scanned in steps of 0.01 Å around its minimum."}],"strict":"Every bond was scanned in steps of 0.01 Å around its minimum."},{"complex":["tex:\\frac{a}{b}"],"container":"q1","context":"paragraph","id":"b3","lossy":"whereisthebondlength.","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"where "},{"kind":"math","notation":"tex","source":"\\frac{a}{b}"},{"kind":"text","text":" is the bond length."}],"strict":"where  is the bond length."},{"complex":[],"container":"q2","context":"paragraph","id":"b4","lossy":"thefittedrateis103persecondatroomtemperature.","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"The fitted rate is 103 per second at room temperature."}],"strict":"The fitted rate is 103 per second at room temperature."},{"complex":["tex:\\frac{c}{e}"],"container":"q2","context":"paragraph","id":"b5","lossy":"whereisthebondlength.","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"where "},{"kind":"math","notation":"tex","source":"\\frac{c}{e}"},{"kind":"text","text":" is the bond length."}],"strict":"where  is the bond length."},{"complex":[],"container":"q2","context":"paragraph","id":"b6","lossy":"asentenceonlythesecondreadinghas,alsolong.","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"A sentence only the second reading has, also long."}],"strict":"A sentence only the second reading has, also long."},{"complex":[],"container":"q2","context":"paragraph","id":"b7","lossy":"thelastsentenceofthesectionisuniqueandlongenough.","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"The last sentence of the section is unique and long enough."}],"strict":"The last sentence of the section is unique and long enough."}],"expect":{"pairs":[{"a":"a1","agree":true,"b":"b1"},{"a":"a2","agree":true,"b":"b2"},{"a":"a3","agree":true,"b":"b3"},{"a":"a4","agree":false,"b":"b4"},{"a":"a5","agree":false,"b":"b5"},{"a":"a7","agree":true,"b":"b7"}],"suspects":[{"a":"a1","b":"b1","kind":"structure"},{"a":"a4","b":"b4","kind":"number"},{"a":"a5","b":"b5","kind":"equation"},{"a":"a4","b":"b4","kind":"join"},{"a":"a5","b":"b5","kind":"join"},{"a":"a6","b":null,"kind":"dropped"},{"a":null,"b":"b6","kind":"added"}]},"id":"two-readings"} {"a":[{"complex":[],"container":"h","context":"heading","id":"a1","lossy":"methods","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"Methods"}],"strict":"Methods"},{"complex":[],"container":"p1","context":"paragraph","id":"a2","lossy":"everybondwasscannedinstepsof0.01åarounditsminimum.","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"Every bond was scanned in steps of 0.01 Å around its minimum."}],"strict":"Every bond was scanned in steps of 0.01 Å around its minimum."},{"complex":["tex:\\frac{a}{b}"],"container":"p1","context":"paragraph","id":"a3","lossy":"whereisthebondlength.","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"where "},{"kind":"math","notation":"tex","source":"\\frac{a}{b}"},{"kind":"text","text":" is the bond length."}],"strict":"where  is the bond length."},{"complex":[],"container":"p1","context":"paragraph","id":"a4","lossy":"thefittedrateis103persecondatroomtemperature.","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"The fitted rate is 10³ per second at room temperature."}],"strict":"The fitted rate is 10^{3} per second at room temperature."},{"complex":["tex:\\frac{c}{d}"],"container":"p2","context":"paragraph","id":"a5","lossy":"whereisthebondlength.","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"where "},{"kind":"math","notation":"tex","source":"\\frac{c}{d}"},{"kind":"text","text":" is the bond length."}],"strict":"where  is the bond length."},{"complex":[],"container":"p2","context":"paragraph","id":"a6","lossy":"thissentencewasdroppedbythesecondreadingentirely.","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"This sentence was dropped by the second reading entirely."}],"strict":"This sentence was dropped by the second reading entirely."},{"complex":[],"container":"p2","context":"paragraph","id":"a7","lossy":"thelastsentenceofthesectionisuniqueandlongenough.","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"The last sentence of the section is unique and long enough."}],"strict":"The last sentence of the section is unique and long enough."}],"b":[{"complex":[],"container":"x","context":"paragraph","id":"b1","lossy":"methods","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"Methods"}],"strict":"Methods"},{"complex":[],"container":"q1","context":"paragraph","id":"b2","lossy":"everybondwasscannedinstepsof0.01åarounditsminimum.","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"Every bond was scanned in steps of 0.01 Å around its minimum."}],"strict":"Every bond was scanned in steps of 0.01 Å around its minimum."},{"complex":["tex:\\frac{a}{b}"],"container":"q1","context":"paragraph","id":"b3","lossy":"whereisthebondlength.","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"where "},{"kind":"math","notation":"tex","source":"\\frac{a}{b}"},{"kind":"text","text":" is the bond length."}],"strict":"where  is the bond length."},{"complex":[],"container":"q2","context":"paragraph","id":"b4","lossy":"thefittedrateis103persecondatroomtemperature.","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"The fitted rate is 103 per second at room temperature."}],"strict":"The fitted rate is 103 per second at room temperature."},{"complex":["tex:\\frac{c}{e}"],"container":"q2","context":"paragraph","id":"b5","lossy":"whereisthebondlength.","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"where "},{"kind":"math","notation":"tex","source":"\\frac{c}{e}"},{"kind":"text","text":" is the bond length."}],"strict":"where  is the bond length."},{"complex":[],"container":"q2","context":"paragraph","id":"b6","lossy":"asentenceonlythesecondreadinghas,alsolong.","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"A sentence only the second reading has, also long."}],"strict":"A sentence only the second reading has, also long."},{"complex":[],"container":"q2","context":"paragraph","id":"b7","lossy":"thelastsentenceofthesectionisuniqueandlongenough.","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"The last sentence of the section is unique and long enough."}],"strict":"The last sentence of the section is unique and long enough."}],"expect":{"pairs":[{"a":"a1","agree":true,"b":"b1"},{"a":"a2","agree":true,"b":"b2"},{"a":"a3","agree":true,"b":"b3"},{"a":"a4","agree":false,"b":"b4"},{"a":"a5","agree":false,"b":"b5"},{"a":"a7","agree":true,"b":"b7"}],"suspects":[{"a":"a1","b":"b1","kind":"structure"},{"a":"a4","b":"b4","kind":"number"},{"a":"a5","b":"b5","kind":"equation"},{"a":"a4","b":"b4","kind":"join"},{"a":"a5","b":"b5","kind":"join"},{"a":"a6","b":null,"kind":"dropped"},{"a":null,"b":"b6","kind":"added"}]},"id":"two-readings"}
{"a":[{"complex":[],"container":"p1","context":"paragraph","id":"c1","lossy":"theforceconstantswerefittedtoabinitioscansofeverybond.","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"The force constants were fitted to ab initio scans of every bond."}],"strict":"The force constants were fitted to ab initio scans of every bond."},{"complex":[],"container":"p1","context":"paragraph","id":"c2","lossy":"thebondconstantwas310.0kcal/molforeveryaliphaticcarbon.","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"The bond constant was 310.0 kcal/mol for every aliphatic carbon."}],"strict":"The bond constant was 310.0 kcal/mol for every aliphatic carbon."},{"complex":[],"container":"p1","context":"paragraph","id":"c3","lossy":"thisprototypalsetwaslaterextendedtonucleicacids.","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"This prototypal set was later extended to nucleic acids."}],"strict":"This prototypal set was later extended to nucleic acids."},{"complex":[],"container":"p1","context":"paragraph","id":"c4","lossy":"seebelow.","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"See below."}],"strict":"See below."},{"complex":[],"container":"p1","context":"paragraph","id":"c5","lossy":"torsionswererefitagainstasecond,largersetofconformers.","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"Torsions were refit against a second, larger set of conformers."}],"strict":"Torsions were refit against a second, larger set of conformers."},{"complex":[],"container":"p2","context":"paragraph","id":"c6","lossy":"thechargescamefromatwostagerestrainedfittothepotential.","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"The charges came from a two-stage restrained fit to the potential."}],"strict":"The charges came from a two-stage restrained fit to the potential."}],"b":[{"complex":[],"container":"q1","context":"paragraph","id":"d1","lossy":"theforceconstantswerefittedtoabinitioscansofeverybond.","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"The force constants were fitted to ab initio scans of every bond."}],"strict":"The force constants were fitted to ab initio scans of every bond."},{"complex":[],"container":"q1","context":"paragraph","id":"d2","lossy":"thebondconstantwas3l0.0kcal/molforeveryaliphaticcarbon.","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"The bond constant was 3l0.0 kcal/mol for every aliphatic carbon."}],"strict":"The bond constant was 3l0.0 kcal/mol for every aliphatic carbon."},{"complex":[],"container":"q1","context":"paragraph","id":"d3","lossy":"thisprototypicalsetwaslaterextendedtonucleicacids.","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"This prototypical set was later extended to nucleic acids."}],"strict":"This prototypical set was later extended to nucleic acids."},{"complex":[],"container":"q1","context":"paragraph","id":"d4","lossy":"seebclow.","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"See bclow."}],"strict":"See bclow."},{"complex":[],"container":"q1","context":"paragraph","id":"d5","lossy":"onlythesecondreadingprintsthislineaboutwatermodels.","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"Only the second reading prints this line about water models."}],"strict":"Only the second reading prints this line about water models."},{"complex":[],"container":"q2","context":"paragraph","id":"d6","lossy":"thechargescamefromatwostagerestrainedfittothepotential.","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"The charges came from a two-stage restrained fit to the potential."}],"strict":"The charges came from a two-stage restrained fit to the potential."}],"expect":{"pairs":[{"a":"c1","agree":true,"b":"d1"},{"a":"c2","agree":false,"b":"d2"},{"a":"c3","agree":false,"b":"d3"},{"a":"c6","agree":true,"b":"d6"}],"suspects":[{"a":"c2","b":"d2","kind":"number"},{"a":"c3","b":"d3","kind":"word"},{"a":"c4","b":null,"kind":"dropped"},{"a":"c5","b":null,"kind":"dropped"},{"a":null,"b":"d4","kind":"added"},{"a":null,"b":"d5","kind":"added"}]},"id":"substitutions"}
+1 -1
View File
@@ -1 +1 @@
{"entries":[["receipt","npc15pn6675z5","37b3025b54c6397e5f8d400912b5788cd6ce203059cd9143e7d521c2cdbf2917"],["receipt","y2zw8ctg5s8dp","ae17f8866a05ca1b671d96b7758984e11ac694acd6743835f107cb513c7cc600"],["receipt","mvjmb94nz7rdh","a4dca8b492bf3e1b190f22e09de77713523e345526fd1b01c1186d0fe80d1cf4"],["receipt","q465jpwz8afhe","39218b2b73e853e2e66d8d4ce68cf7e155ca001f05ee4da5942a8d9b63b216bc"],["revocation","pcbhtpwvysgq6","9062e3ab737ecc2e6d487d2076ee27f764be60f06ad01f1ad103d708d466e56a"],["receipt","gx2s84z9jf9xv","5ee8b2827d327a7bbcacb08fd19b9523fad83ebf6c29350d5ce7ca30bf5ce388"],["receipt","mg18668nzxvap","4c80506322bfeed5649cfab303959e4ccf0aa0e594995ee6fd5ad59f9d3ee6a7"],["receipt","yt70fcc3qm0xb","2ad1c0f63077a03ab1cce01e6235734577d0b072b90ebab2f7db7fd481ccee2c"],["roster","smithlab","782c5e68f4e4f9918e69b7a44b108d9d70c89a289981acff3d25300ec8373c15"]],"id":"smithlab","note":"scient.ing/log/smithlab\n9\nGa0n103p3Gl136z6XWmM92kGvsvMYGXlk+ijjX4KWiA=\n\n— ana dBv7wtCAdNnczkCO5KwtrmDvtWUVPRusBSuLPeBDQoLZi9Hm34IHuNjvnjyPEar5afNf7xqcDtokk2XZEP31uJMVuwE=\n— wit h7ghDsJGkhWLaPO7+TIZQUenslhiQh/E/TKWU4ddphpFcuylQBZM2kG/o8H1nyPfUT0MkbvnFqPFfHPH3OaN5W1EwAI=\n","origin":"scient.ing/log/smithlab","root":"19ad27d74de9dc6975dfacfa5d698cf76906becbcc6065e593e8a38d7e0a5a20","signers":["ana","wit"],"tiles":["tile/0/000.p/9","tile/entries/000.p/9"]} {"entries":[["receipt","vskq18t5sxydz","7fccee1468b9ef9bf712279f10d13f5544abb79db03e33b122a2504a3cf25789"],["receipt","fhhvg9qrzqp0n","f78c7704df1fbd815ac3ccf9114c82a189f9032ffcd75023e10b27b924f406b5"],["receipt","mvjmb94nz7rdh","a4dca8b492bf3e1b190f22e09de77713523e345526fd1b01c1186d0fe80d1cf4"],["receipt","q465jpwz8afhe","39218b2b73e853e2e66d8d4ce68cf7e155ca001f05ee4da5942a8d9b63b216bc"],["revocation","pcbhtpwvysgq6","9062e3ab737ecc2e6d487d2076ee27f764be60f06ad01f1ad103d708d466e56a"],["receipt","gx2s84z9jf9xv","5ee8b2827d327a7bbcacb08fd19b9523fad83ebf6c29350d5ce7ca30bf5ce388"],["receipt","ksx5sc327xp97","1fcf4b960c47ed927b2f9599bc7e54221e35b2e1c001d46d92fc18505f219395"],["receipt","yt70fcc3qm0xb","2ad1c0f63077a03ab1cce01e6235734577d0b072b90ebab2f7db7fd481ccee2c"],["roster","smithlab","782c5e68f4e4f9918e69b7a44b108d9d70c89a289981acff3d25300ec8373c15"]],"id":"smithlab","note":"scient.ing/log/smithlab\n9\nWQxnIeoDxqOJ/rIz5b0uJ3pfpq4S1kUQMNvbG55bPEM=\n\n— ana dBv7wrLxQN8XFJOwKZO4L98UosXwyw3jVbYTM3a+dZWQdtZkPqd6fM8LHwgbIyBT+OEq18meE0JkqJKoYeZ2DMP7eAo=\n— wit h7ghDsbQuWAI5VIGw+jiEAMHeSpDVlubOR46YIEuxL5TWkxU1xAtrp4gwgKxCV+q72A9mZC6APgyaCAUi78euiV/SA8=\n","origin":"scient.ing/log/smithlab","root":"590c6721ea03c6a389feb233e5bd2e277a5fa6ae12d6451030dbdb1b9e5b3c43","signers":["ana","wit"],"tiles":["tile/0/000.p/9","tile/entries/000.p/9"]}
+13
View File
@@ -27,3 +27,16 @@
{"before":{"ids":[],"nodes":[{"align_key":"b3108c22ec836d883e5116f7ed8546fa75390eb4aa960d78f2936115f69b6826","id":"s0fn2fj","kind":"document","match_hash":"b6a4e12f700a6214bf02c9a437559e82fccdbecea7b575fa438a7d2e8c33071a","node_hash":"a05328e6d13edba652599aceb58c018dbccf54abd1f878c9f61623017960e1fe","ord":0,"own_hash":"34444fe0e6bdbf3927a579fe3286859d204ea0882a381b7769ffd4905551d24f","parent":null,"text_hash":"bd2abc746d51cf52d57a18632383245d585e29e265426967894eed99bc937561"},{"align_key":"caf6aee3882b3890996037e35d0ffdfe30b5e66653d45321d7ea0fa9135f1ee9","attrs":{"level":1},"id":"b9wp3tt","kind":"section","label":"1","match_hash":"5a96c01f314c4d8a22fd5e105bebef45df4301886cccbc2538ecefddfcb1d405","node_hash":"ea9a1409bbf0f0f7bd8d508bfdbbf7d14a22ab1e3da011eafbfcd4e14ae7e4fd","ord":0,"own_hash":"65da097b48f8237e8d171bfbd0053ff0e3795c0532d5522d23a92b53430956f4","parent":"s0fn2fj","text_hash":"7a97628fe9643c0fca3614a077e2e631c3fee81d3733ba1564292df65a294573"},{"align_key":"c099142bc3186ded72786ba27e9ea6d2da240fb9fd3fe79b479ecf8e734b2850","id":"vet7k0e","kind":"heading","match_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd","node_hash":"a3c82ab1e44bf4cffa1a59507f8bddc39a1ad191321ee803d0d60d96609a44c7","ord":0,"own_hash":"e813ff86a8920cef741e548eb5df545774b520d2fadbdda6e2b872a6729b9d26","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd"},{"align_key":"c099142bc3186ded72786ba27e9ea6d2da240fb9fd3fe79b479ecf8e734b2850","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"Results"}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"em5pd9v","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd","node_hash":"293fc03ff4e39d7532467e4417ffcdb15f470f0bd3658dc1c021645ad53c9bef","ord":0,"own_hash":"c55f401232b19ff1133d77eac6c72868975064f177fc2d31ab8a181303c30599","parent":"vet7k0e","text_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd"},{"align_key":"610c235321e38145abff21e31eaab303d85a6ce0d1b9340a599dc821a04922f6","id":"ytp1e5n","kind":"paragraph","match_hash":"bcb4902ec69f2a7a724384f561ee9aa0e214c824c5882c1ad92777bee680aad4","node_hash":"7667a3a4bc2e8fec1dc7af53e19c414952f9ce926b1e37e8d9adca66dd8f8d1d","ord":1,"own_hash":"494e069be36a18ecaabf5a63be7c31617ade7a5460218ca83a2de3d8d8f964e0","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"f589ee914c46c4aea7ce2de49d925c433c914121f576b81a3eab692f17f179a3"},{"align_key":"8f21603c39df123eb8680362184274aac9bdf1dbd485b3bba230960179071c95","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"The value is 42.0 at 300 K."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"jvnys4s","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"3bcf9fa8412dca28be91d6423460233ddedd7add6c324d8a0f2b26038567d3d3","node_hash":"f5761f338b2878dff39a6ee724a75b13626dd625a0df96cf1cc6f9e8258cb7cc","ord":0,"own_hash":"7f0b9190d076cf01b51a8be863a51e9a8eeaab5d3ec8656202ff4d41578d4d82","parent":"ytp1e5n","text_hash":"3bcf9fa8412dca28be91d6423460233ddedd7add6c324d8a0f2b26038567d3d3"},{"align_key":"8e7fe271cd1bab88d86c8900fe3ffae0ce95c55af6659df1fca278d359296e2d","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"See "},{"kind":"xref","target":"tb49qpc","text":"Table 1"},{"kind":"text","text":" and the note."},{"kind":"cite","refs":["r3e21zr"],"text":"1"}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"mzwwhxj","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"9894a48790a8561966e68672fa13da20541d25a5178653720648f62cbc9ad36b","node_hash":"8f3e5338ba3c97efca4cef5c60d849757aed6334ee27ab807fa71d969089e46e","ord":1,"own_hash":"02ed6d50b8ac607b59e3f7b5116ee6143ed7e69af25b19c4037aa799bc330a88","parent":"ytp1e5n","text_hash":"5b1de19c9eb1399e54bde7e96f051cac8b337be1f307fac320292b8db7e39da7"},{"align_key":"282eea00b316a6950fb7179f6289a8b98359019e11cb23a3ff426cdecad90165","id":"exq1ter","kind":"paragraph","match_hash":"da88f35d24faf0099610c720953c4919647a5dfb9003889a15c464cd9c540fb1","node_hash":"062dd26bfb226ca9811d0dfb013df211cb201dfe7b4b25f9aba000f3212298d5","ord":2,"own_hash":"494e069be36a18ecaabf5a63be7c31617ade7a5460218ca83a2de3d8d8f964e0","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"da88f35d24faf0099610c720953c4919647a5dfb9003889a15c464cd9c540fb1"},{"align_key":"b8074a8bc013aa007023c4cce7334f1e1f22384d57a526ca22fd2f5589d5ab17","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"A second paragraph."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"j663d4h","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"2e8313b033de5e17878ae778d6293bbd6e197a072f36acf7fe0840a690a7f31e","node_hash":"443539440dca73149ca75276492334ce9a5a6c50070137e8dc7bf414b75a27ab","ord":0,"own_hash":"acee4b6b1399bfde1dc67dea8d8c86b0db961d2af516ae4aaee26f294261456f","parent":"exq1ter","text_hash":"2e8313b033de5e17878ae778d6293bbd6e197a072f36acf7fe0840a690a7f31e"},{"align_key":"437c101749b0481e615fc7eed8dcacb536b65400c7e0695ad4cbb2bf2dae488c","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"It ends here."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"rsw24qc","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"2888dbfa0c08fd65c58c923b920860c76e13913d9fa93b03eccbbf7bdf53b882","node_hash":"caeb3ae57d0821b8ac961c9507debbcda2b118b16cdc010b83a143a782058d57","ord":1,"own_hash":"705f77e8520c8c5ce3a7a495a20d8a9c55baa9801e49a55c341f5de79eeeLine truncated {"before":{"ids":[],"nodes":[{"align_key":"b3108c22ec836d883e5116f7ed8546fa75390eb4aa960d78f2936115f69b6826","id":"s0fn2fj","kind":"document","match_hash":"b6a4e12f700a6214bf02c9a437559e82fccdbecea7b575fa438a7d2e8c33071a","node_hash":"a05328e6d13edba652599aceb58c018dbccf54abd1f878c9f61623017960e1fe","ord":0,"own_hash":"34444fe0e6bdbf3927a579fe3286859d204ea0882a381b7769ffd4905551d24f","parent":null,"text_hash":"bd2abc746d51cf52d57a18632383245d585e29e265426967894eed99bc937561"},{"align_key":"caf6aee3882b3890996037e35d0ffdfe30b5e66653d45321d7ea0fa9135f1ee9","attrs":{"level":1},"id":"b9wp3tt","kind":"section","label":"1","match_hash":"5a96c01f314c4d8a22fd5e105bebef45df4301886cccbc2538ecefddfcb1d405","node_hash":"ea9a1409bbf0f0f7bd8d508bfdbbf7d14a22ab1e3da011eafbfcd4e14ae7e4fd","ord":0,"own_hash":"65da097b48f8237e8d171bfbd0053ff0e3795c0532d5522d23a92b53430956f4","parent":"s0fn2fj","text_hash":"7a97628fe9643c0fca3614a077e2e631c3fee81d3733ba1564292df65a294573"},{"align_key":"c099142bc3186ded72786ba27e9ea6d2da240fb9fd3fe79b479ecf8e734b2850","id":"vet7k0e","kind":"heading","match_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd","node_hash":"a3c82ab1e44bf4cffa1a59507f8bddc39a1ad191321ee803d0d60d96609a44c7","ord":0,"own_hash":"e813ff86a8920cef741e548eb5df545774b520d2fadbdda6e2b872a6729b9d26","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd"},{"align_key":"c099142bc3186ded72786ba27e9ea6d2da240fb9fd3fe79b479ecf8e734b2850","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"Results"}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"em5pd9v","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd","node_hash":"293fc03ff4e39d7532467e4417ffcdb15f470f0bd3658dc1c021645ad53c9bef","ord":0,"own_hash":"c55f401232b19ff1133d77eac6c72868975064f177fc2d31ab8a181303c30599","parent":"vet7k0e","text_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd"},{"align_key":"610c235321e38145abff21e31eaab303d85a6ce0d1b9340a599dc821a04922f6","id":"ytp1e5n","kind":"paragraph","match_hash":"bcb4902ec69f2a7a724384f561ee9aa0e214c824c5882c1ad92777bee680aad4","node_hash":"7667a3a4bc2e8fec1dc7af53e19c414952f9ce926b1e37e8d9adca66dd8f8d1d","ord":1,"own_hash":"494e069be36a18ecaabf5a63be7c31617ade7a5460218ca83a2de3d8d8f964e0","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"f589ee914c46c4aea7ce2de49d925c433c914121f576b81a3eab692f17f179a3"},{"align_key":"8f21603c39df123eb8680362184274aac9bdf1dbd485b3bba230960179071c95","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"The value is 42.0 at 300 K."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"jvnys4s","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"3bcf9fa8412dca28be91d6423460233ddedd7add6c324d8a0f2b26038567d3d3","node_hash":"f5761f338b2878dff39a6ee724a75b13626dd625a0df96cf1cc6f9e8258cb7cc","ord":0,"own_hash":"7f0b9190d076cf01b51a8be863a51e9a8eeaab5d3ec8656202ff4d41578d4d82","parent":"ytp1e5n","text_hash":"3bcf9fa8412dca28be91d6423460233ddedd7add6c324d8a0f2b26038567d3d3"},{"align_key":"8e7fe271cd1bab88d86c8900fe3ffae0ce95c55af6659df1fca278d359296e2d","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"See "},{"kind":"xref","target":"tb49qpc","text":"Table 1"},{"kind":"text","text":" and the note."},{"kind":"cite","refs":["r3e21zr"],"text":"1"}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"mzwwhxj","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"9894a48790a8561966e68672fa13da20541d25a5178653720648f62cbc9ad36b","node_hash":"8f3e5338ba3c97efca4cef5c60d849757aed6334ee27ab807fa71d969089e46e","ord":1,"own_hash":"02ed6d50b8ac607b59e3f7b5116ee6143ed7e69af25b19c4037aa799bc330a88","parent":"ytp1e5n","text_hash":"5b1de19c9eb1399e54bde7e96f051cac8b337be1f307fac320292b8db7e39da7"},{"align_key":"282eea00b316a6950fb7179f6289a8b98359019e11cb23a3ff426cdecad90165","id":"exq1ter","kind":"paragraph","match_hash":"da88f35d24faf0099610c720953c4919647a5dfb9003889a15c464cd9c540fb1","node_hash":"062dd26bfb226ca9811d0dfb013df211cb201dfe7b4b25f9aba000f3212298d5","ord":2,"own_hash":"494e069be36a18ecaabf5a63be7c31617ade7a5460218ca83a2de3d8d8f964e0","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"da88f35d24faf0099610c720953c4919647a5dfb9003889a15c464cd9c540fb1"},{"align_key":"b8074a8bc013aa007023c4cce7334f1e1f22384d57a526ca22fd2f5589d5ab17","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"A second paragraph."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"j663d4h","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"2e8313b033de5e17878ae778d6293bbd6e197a072f36acf7fe0840a690a7f31e","node_hash":"443539440dca73149ca75276492334ce9a5a6c50070137e8dc7bf414b75a27ab","ord":0,"own_hash":"acee4b6b1399bfde1dc67dea8d8c86b0db961d2af516ae4aaee26f294261456f","parent":"exq1ter","text_hash":"2e8313b033de5e17878ae778d6293bbd6e197a072f36acf7fe0840a690a7f31e"},{"align_key":"437c101749b0481e615fc7eed8dcacb536b65400c7e0695ad4cbb2bf2dae488c","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"It ends here."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"rsw24qc","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"2888dbfa0c08fd65c58c923b920860c76e13913d9fa93b03eccbbf7bdf53b882","node_hash":"caeb3ae57d0821b8ac961c9507debbcda2b118b16cdc010b83a143a782058d57","ord":1,"own_hash":"705f77e8520c8c5ce3a7a495a20d8a9c55baa9801e49a55c341f5de79eeeLine truncated
{"before":{"ids":[],"nodes":[{"align_key":"b3108c22ec836d883e5116f7ed8546fa75390eb4aa960d78f2936115f69b6826","id":"s0fn2fj","kind":"document","match_hash":"b6a4e12f700a6214bf02c9a437559e82fccdbecea7b575fa438a7d2e8c33071a","node_hash":"a05328e6d13edba652599aceb58c018dbccf54abd1f878c9f61623017960e1fe","ord":0,"own_hash":"34444fe0e6bdbf3927a579fe3286859d204ea0882a381b7769ffd4905551d24f","parent":null,"text_hash":"bd2abc746d51cf52d57a18632383245d585e29e265426967894eed99bc937561"},{"align_key":"caf6aee3882b3890996037e35d0ffdfe30b5e66653d45321d7ea0fa9135f1ee9","attrs":{"level":1},"id":"b9wp3tt","kind":"section","label":"1","match_hash":"5a96c01f314c4d8a22fd5e105bebef45df4301886cccbc2538ecefddfcb1d405","node_hash":"ea9a1409bbf0f0f7bd8d508bfdbbf7d14a22ab1e3da011eafbfcd4e14ae7e4fd","ord":0,"own_hash":"65da097b48f8237e8d171bfbd0053ff0e3795c0532d5522d23a92b53430956f4","parent":"s0fn2fj","text_hash":"7a97628fe9643c0fca3614a077e2e631c3fee81d3733ba1564292df65a294573"},{"align_key":"c099142bc3186ded72786ba27e9ea6d2da240fb9fd3fe79b479ecf8e734b2850","id":"vet7k0e","kind":"heading","match_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd","node_hash":"a3c82ab1e44bf4cffa1a59507f8bddc39a1ad191321ee803d0d60d96609a44c7","ord":0,"own_hash":"e813ff86a8920cef741e548eb5df545774b520d2fadbdda6e2b872a6729b9d26","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd"},{"align_key":"c099142bc3186ded72786ba27e9ea6d2da240fb9fd3fe79b479ecf8e734b2850","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"Results"}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"em5pd9v","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd","node_hash":"293fc03ff4e39d7532467e4417ffcdb15f470f0bd3658dc1c021645ad53c9bef","ord":0,"own_hash":"c55f401232b19ff1133d77eac6c72868975064f177fc2d31ab8a181303c30599","parent":"vet7k0e","text_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd"},{"align_key":"610c235321e38145abff21e31eaab303d85a6ce0d1b9340a599dc821a04922f6","id":"ytp1e5n","kind":"paragraph","match_hash":"bcb4902ec69f2a7a724384f561ee9aa0e214c824c5882c1ad92777bee680aad4","node_hash":"7667a3a4bc2e8fec1dc7af53e19c414952f9ce926b1e37e8d9adca66dd8f8d1d","ord":1,"own_hash":"494e069be36a18ecaabf5a63be7c31617ade7a5460218ca83a2de3d8d8f964e0","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"f589ee914c46c4aea7ce2de49d925c433c914121f576b81a3eab692f17f179a3"},{"align_key":"8f21603c39df123eb8680362184274aac9bdf1dbd485b3bba230960179071c95","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"The value is 42.0 at 300 K."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"jvnys4s","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"3bcf9fa8412dca28be91d6423460233ddedd7add6c324d8a0f2b26038567d3d3","node_hash":"f5761f338b2878dff39a6ee724a75b13626dd625a0df96cf1cc6f9e8258cb7cc","ord":0,"own_hash":"7f0b9190d076cf01b51a8be863a51e9a8eeaab5d3ec8656202ff4d41578d4d82","parent":"ytp1e5n","text_hash":"3bcf9fa8412dca28be91d6423460233ddedd7add6c324d8a0f2b26038567d3d3"},{"align_key":"8e7fe271cd1bab88d86c8900fe3ffae0ce95c55af6659df1fca278d359296e2d","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"See "},{"kind":"xref","target":"tb49qpc","text":"Table 1"},{"kind":"text","text":" and the note."},{"kind":"cite","refs":["r3e21zr"],"text":"1"}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"mzwwhxj","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"9894a48790a8561966e68672fa13da20541d25a5178653720648f62cbc9ad36b","node_hash":"8f3e5338ba3c97efca4cef5c60d849757aed6334ee27ab807fa71d969089e46e","ord":1,"own_hash":"02ed6d50b8ac607b59e3f7b5116ee6143ed7e69af25b19c4037aa799bc330a88","parent":"ytp1e5n","text_hash":"5b1de19c9eb1399e54bde7e96f051cac8b337be1f307fac320292b8db7e39da7"},{"align_key":"282eea00b316a6950fb7179f6289a8b98359019e11cb23a3ff426cdecad90165","id":"exq1ter","kind":"paragraph","match_hash":"da88f35d24faf0099610c720953c4919647a5dfb9003889a15c464cd9c540fb1","node_hash":"062dd26bfb226ca9811d0dfb013df211cb201dfe7b4b25f9aba000f3212298d5","ord":2,"own_hash":"494e069be36a18ecaabf5a63be7c31617ade7a5460218ca83a2de3d8d8f964e0","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"da88f35d24faf0099610c720953c4919647a5dfb9003889a15c464cd9c540fb1"},{"align_key":"b8074a8bc013aa007023c4cce7334f1e1f22384d57a526ca22fd2f5589d5ab17","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"A second paragraph."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"j663d4h","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"2e8313b033de5e17878ae778d6293bbd6e197a072f36acf7fe0840a690a7f31e","node_hash":"443539440dca73149ca75276492334ce9a5a6c50070137e8dc7bf414b75a27ab","ord":0,"own_hash":"acee4b6b1399bfde1dc67dea8d8c86b0db961d2af516ae4aaee26f294261456f","parent":"exq1ter","text_hash":"2e8313b033de5e17878ae778d6293bbd6e197a072f36acf7fe0840a690a7f31e"},{"align_key":"437c101749b0481e615fc7eed8dcacb536b65400c7e0695ad4cbb2bf2dae488c","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"It ends here."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"rsw24qc","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"2888dbfa0c08fd65c58c923b920860c76e13913d9fa93b03eccbbf7bdf53b882","node_hash":"caeb3ae57d0821b8ac961c9507debbcda2b118b16cdc010b83a143a782058d57","ord":1,"own_hash":"705f77e8520c8c5ce3a7a495a20d8a9c55baa9801e49a55c341f5de79eeeLine truncated {"before":{"ids":[],"nodes":[{"align_key":"b3108c22ec836d883e5116f7ed8546fa75390eb4aa960d78f2936115f69b6826","id":"s0fn2fj","kind":"document","match_hash":"b6a4e12f700a6214bf02c9a437559e82fccdbecea7b575fa438a7d2e8c33071a","node_hash":"a05328e6d13edba652599aceb58c018dbccf54abd1f878c9f61623017960e1fe","ord":0,"own_hash":"34444fe0e6bdbf3927a579fe3286859d204ea0882a381b7769ffd4905551d24f","parent":null,"text_hash":"bd2abc746d51cf52d57a18632383245d585e29e265426967894eed99bc937561"},{"align_key":"caf6aee3882b3890996037e35d0ffdfe30b5e66653d45321d7ea0fa9135f1ee9","attrs":{"level":1},"id":"b9wp3tt","kind":"section","label":"1","match_hash":"5a96c01f314c4d8a22fd5e105bebef45df4301886cccbc2538ecefddfcb1d405","node_hash":"ea9a1409bbf0f0f7bd8d508bfdbbf7d14a22ab1e3da011eafbfcd4e14ae7e4fd","ord":0,"own_hash":"65da097b48f8237e8d171bfbd0053ff0e3795c0532d5522d23a92b53430956f4","parent":"s0fn2fj","text_hash":"7a97628fe9643c0fca3614a077e2e631c3fee81d3733ba1564292df65a294573"},{"align_key":"c099142bc3186ded72786ba27e9ea6d2da240fb9fd3fe79b479ecf8e734b2850","id":"vet7k0e","kind":"heading","match_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd","node_hash":"a3c82ab1e44bf4cffa1a59507f8bddc39a1ad191321ee803d0d60d96609a44c7","ord":0,"own_hash":"e813ff86a8920cef741e548eb5df545774b520d2fadbdda6e2b872a6729b9d26","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd"},{"align_key":"c099142bc3186ded72786ba27e9ea6d2da240fb9fd3fe79b479ecf8e734b2850","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"Results"}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"em5pd9v","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd","node_hash":"293fc03ff4e39d7532467e4417ffcdb15f470f0bd3658dc1c021645ad53c9bef","ord":0,"own_hash":"c55f401232b19ff1133d77eac6c72868975064f177fc2d31ab8a181303c30599","parent":"vet7k0e","text_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd"},{"align_key":"610c235321e38145abff21e31eaab303d85a6ce0d1b9340a599dc821a04922f6","id":"ytp1e5n","kind":"paragraph","match_hash":"bcb4902ec69f2a7a724384f561ee9aa0e214c824c5882c1ad92777bee680aad4","node_hash":"7667a3a4bc2e8fec1dc7af53e19c414952f9ce926b1e37e8d9adca66dd8f8d1d","ord":1,"own_hash":"494e069be36a18ecaabf5a63be7c31617ade7a5460218ca83a2de3d8d8f964e0","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"f589ee914c46c4aea7ce2de49d925c433c914121f576b81a3eab692f17f179a3"},{"align_key":"8f21603c39df123eb8680362184274aac9bdf1dbd485b3bba230960179071c95","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"The value is 42.0 at 300 K."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"jvnys4s","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"3bcf9fa8412dca28be91d6423460233ddedd7add6c324d8a0f2b26038567d3d3","node_hash":"f5761f338b2878dff39a6ee724a75b13626dd625a0df96cf1cc6f9e8258cb7cc","ord":0,"own_hash":"7f0b9190d076cf01b51a8be863a51e9a8eeaab5d3ec8656202ff4d41578d4d82","parent":"ytp1e5n","text_hash":"3bcf9fa8412dca28be91d6423460233ddedd7add6c324d8a0f2b26038567d3d3"},{"align_key":"8e7fe271cd1bab88d86c8900fe3ffae0ce95c55af6659df1fca278d359296e2d","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"See "},{"kind":"xref","target":"tb49qpc","text":"Table 1"},{"kind":"text","text":" and the note."},{"kind":"cite","refs":["r3e21zr"],"text":"1"}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"mzwwhxj","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"9894a48790a8561966e68672fa13da20541d25a5178653720648f62cbc9ad36b","node_hash":"8f3e5338ba3c97efca4cef5c60d849757aed6334ee27ab807fa71d969089e46e","ord":1,"own_hash":"02ed6d50b8ac607b59e3f7b5116ee6143ed7e69af25b19c4037aa799bc330a88","parent":"ytp1e5n","text_hash":"5b1de19c9eb1399e54bde7e96f051cac8b337be1f307fac320292b8db7e39da7"},{"align_key":"282eea00b316a6950fb7179f6289a8b98359019e11cb23a3ff426cdecad90165","id":"exq1ter","kind":"paragraph","match_hash":"da88f35d24faf0099610c720953c4919647a5dfb9003889a15c464cd9c540fb1","node_hash":"062dd26bfb226ca9811d0dfb013df211cb201dfe7b4b25f9aba000f3212298d5","ord":2,"own_hash":"494e069be36a18ecaabf5a63be7c31617ade7a5460218ca83a2de3d8d8f964e0","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"da88f35d24faf0099610c720953c4919647a5dfb9003889a15c464cd9c540fb1"},{"align_key":"b8074a8bc013aa007023c4cce7334f1e1f22384d57a526ca22fd2f5589d5ab17","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"A second paragraph."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"j663d4h","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"2e8313b033de5e17878ae778d6293bbd6e197a072f36acf7fe0840a690a7f31e","node_hash":"443539440dca73149ca75276492334ce9a5a6c50070137e8dc7bf414b75a27ab","ord":0,"own_hash":"acee4b6b1399bfde1dc67dea8d8c86b0db961d2af516ae4aaee26f294261456f","parent":"exq1ter","text_hash":"2e8313b033de5e17878ae778d6293bbd6e197a072f36acf7fe0840a690a7f31e"},{"align_key":"437c101749b0481e615fc7eed8dcacb536b65400c7e0695ad4cbb2bf2dae488c","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"It ends here."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"rsw24qc","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"2888dbfa0c08fd65c58c923b920860c76e13913d9fa93b03eccbbf7bdf53b882","node_hash":"caeb3ae57d0821b8ac961c9507debbcda2b118b16cdc010b83a143a782058d57","ord":1,"own_hash":"705f77e8520c8c5ce3a7a495a20d8a9c55baa9801e49a55c341f5de79eeeLine truncated
{"before":{"ids":[],"nodes":[{"align_key":"b3108c22ec836d883e5116f7ed8546fa75390eb4aa960d78f2936115f69b6826","id":"s0fn2fj","kind":"document","match_hash":"b6a4e12f700a6214bf02c9a437559e82fccdbecea7b575fa438a7d2e8c33071a","node_hash":"a05328e6d13edba652599aceb58c018dbccf54abd1f878c9f61623017960e1fe","ord":0,"own_hash":"34444fe0e6bdbf3927a579fe3286859d204ea0882a381b7769ffd4905551d24f","parent":null,"text_hash":"bd2abc746d51cf52d57a18632383245d585e29e265426967894eed99bc937561"},{"align_key":"caf6aee3882b3890996037e35d0ffdfe30b5e66653d45321d7ea0fa9135f1ee9","attrs":{"level":1},"id":"b9wp3tt","kind":"section","label":"1","match_hash":"5a96c01f314c4d8a22fd5e105bebef45df4301886cccbc2538ecefddfcb1d405","node_hash":"ea9a1409bbf0f0f7bd8d508bfdbbf7d14a22ab1e3da011eafbfcd4e14ae7e4fd","ord":0,"own_hash":"65da097b48f8237e8d171bfbd0053ff0e3795c0532d5522d23a92b53430956f4","parent":"s0fn2fj","text_hash":"7a97628fe9643c0fca3614a077e2e631c3fee81d3733ba1564292df65a294573"},{"align_key":"c099142bc3186ded72786ba27e9ea6d2da240fb9fd3fe79b479ecf8e734b2850","id":"vet7k0e","kind":"heading","match_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd","node_hash":"a3c82ab1e44bf4cffa1a59507f8bddc39a1ad191321ee803d0d60d96609a44c7","ord":0,"own_hash":"e813ff86a8920cef741e548eb5df545774b520d2fadbdda6e2b872a6729b9d26","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd"},{"align_key":"c099142bc3186ded72786ba27e9ea6d2da240fb9fd3fe79b479ecf8e734b2850","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"Results"}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"em5pd9v","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd","node_hash":"293fc03ff4e39d7532467e4417ffcdb15f470f0bd3658dc1c021645ad53c9bef","ord":0,"own_hash":"c55f401232b19ff1133d77eac6c72868975064f177fc2d31ab8a181303c30599","parent":"vet7k0e","text_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd"},{"align_key":"610c235321e38145abff21e31eaab303d85a6ce0d1b9340a599dc821a04922f6","id":"ytp1e5n","kind":"paragraph","match_hash":"bcb4902ec69f2a7a724384f561ee9aa0e214c824c5882c1ad92777bee680aad4","node_hash":"7667a3a4bc2e8fec1dc7af53e19c414952f9ce926b1e37e8d9adca66dd8f8d1d","ord":1,"own_hash":"494e069be36a18ecaabf5a63be7c31617ade7a5460218ca83a2de3d8d8f964e0","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"f589ee914c46c4aea7ce2de49d925c433c914121f576b81a3eab692f17f179a3"},{"align_key":"8f21603c39df123eb8680362184274aac9bdf1dbd485b3bba230960179071c95","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"The value is 42.0 at 300 K."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"jvnys4s","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"3bcf9fa8412dca28be91d6423460233ddedd7add6c324d8a0f2b26038567d3d3","node_hash":"f5761f338b2878dff39a6ee724a75b13626dd625a0df96cf1cc6f9e8258cb7cc","ord":0,"own_hash":"7f0b9190d076cf01b51a8be863a51e9a8eeaab5d3ec8656202ff4d41578d4d82","parent":"ytp1e5n","text_hash":"3bcf9fa8412dca28be91d6423460233ddedd7add6c324d8a0f2b26038567d3d3"},{"align_key":"8e7fe271cd1bab88d86c8900fe3ffae0ce95c55af6659df1fca278d359296e2d","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"See "},{"kind":"xref","target":"tb49qpc","text":"Table 1"},{"kind":"text","text":" and the note."},{"kind":"cite","refs":["r3e21zr"],"text":"1"}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"mzwwhxj","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"9894a48790a8561966e68672fa13da20541d25a5178653720648f62cbc9ad36b","node_hash":"8f3e5338ba3c97efca4cef5c60d849757aed6334ee27ab807fa71d969089e46e","ord":1,"own_hash":"02ed6d50b8ac607b59e3f7b5116ee6143ed7e69af25b19c4037aa799bc330a88","parent":"ytp1e5n","text_hash":"5b1de19c9eb1399e54bde7e96f051cac8b337be1f307fac320292b8db7e39da7"},{"align_key":"282eea00b316a6950fb7179f6289a8b98359019e11cb23a3ff426cdecad90165","id":"exq1ter","kind":"paragraph","match_hash":"da88f35d24faf0099610c720953c4919647a5dfb9003889a15c464cd9c540fb1","node_hash":"062dd26bfb226ca9811d0dfb013df211cb201dfe7b4b25f9aba000f3212298d5","ord":2,"own_hash":"494e069be36a18ecaabf5a63be7c31617ade7a5460218ca83a2de3d8d8f964e0","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"da88f35d24faf0099610c720953c4919647a5dfb9003889a15c464cd9c540fb1"},{"align_key":"b8074a8bc013aa007023c4cce7334f1e1f22384d57a526ca22fd2f5589d5ab17","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"A second paragraph."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"j663d4h","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"2e8313b033de5e17878ae778d6293bbd6e197a072f36acf7fe0840a690a7f31e","node_hash":"443539440dca73149ca75276492334ce9a5a6c50070137e8dc7bf414b75a27ab","ord":0,"own_hash":"acee4b6b1399bfde1dc67dea8d8c86b0db961d2af516ae4aaee26f294261456f","parent":"exq1ter","text_hash":"2e8313b033de5e17878ae778d6293bbd6e197a072f36acf7fe0840a690a7f31e"},{"align_key":"437c101749b0481e615fc7eed8dcacb536b65400c7e0695ad4cbb2bf2dae488c","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"It ends here."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"rsw24qc","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"2888dbfa0c08fd65c58c923b920860c76e13913d9fa93b03eccbbf7bdf53b882","node_hash":"caeb3ae57d0821b8ac961c9507debbcda2b118b16cdc010b83a143a782058d57","ord":1,"own_hash":"705f77e8520c8c5ce3a7a495a20d8a9c55baa9801e49a55c341f5de79eeeLine truncated {"before":{"ids":[],"nodes":[{"align_key":"b3108c22ec836d883e5116f7ed8546fa75390eb4aa960d78f2936115f69b6826","id":"s0fn2fj","kind":"document","match_hash":"b6a4e12f700a6214bf02c9a437559e82fccdbecea7b575fa438a7d2e8c33071a","node_hash":"a05328e6d13edba652599aceb58c018dbccf54abd1f878c9f61623017960e1fe","ord":0,"own_hash":"34444fe0e6bdbf3927a579fe3286859d204ea0882a381b7769ffd4905551d24f","parent":null,"text_hash":"bd2abc746d51cf52d57a18632383245d585e29e265426967894eed99bc937561"},{"align_key":"caf6aee3882b3890996037e35d0ffdfe30b5e66653d45321d7ea0fa9135f1ee9","attrs":{"level":1},"id":"b9wp3tt","kind":"section","label":"1","match_hash":"5a96c01f314c4d8a22fd5e105bebef45df4301886cccbc2538ecefddfcb1d405","node_hash":"ea9a1409bbf0f0f7bd8d508bfdbbf7d14a22ab1e3da011eafbfcd4e14ae7e4fd","ord":0,"own_hash":"65da097b48f8237e8d171bfbd0053ff0e3795c0532d5522d23a92b53430956f4","parent":"s0fn2fj","text_hash":"7a97628fe9643c0fca3614a077e2e631c3fee81d3733ba1564292df65a294573"},{"align_key":"c099142bc3186ded72786ba27e9ea6d2da240fb9fd3fe79b479ecf8e734b2850","id":"vet7k0e","kind":"heading","match_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd","node_hash":"a3c82ab1e44bf4cffa1a59507f8bddc39a1ad191321ee803d0d60d96609a44c7","ord":0,"own_hash":"e813ff86a8920cef741e548eb5df545774b520d2fadbdda6e2b872a6729b9d26","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd"},{"align_key":"c099142bc3186ded72786ba27e9ea6d2da240fb9fd3fe79b479ecf8e734b2850","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"Results"}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"em5pd9v","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd","node_hash":"293fc03ff4e39d7532467e4417ffcdb15f470f0bd3658dc1c021645ad53c9bef","ord":0,"own_hash":"c55f401232b19ff1133d77eac6c72868975064f177fc2d31ab8a181303c30599","parent":"vet7k0e","text_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd"},{"align_key":"610c235321e38145abff21e31eaab303d85a6ce0d1b9340a599dc821a04922f6","id":"ytp1e5n","kind":"paragraph","match_hash":"bcb4902ec69f2a7a724384f561ee9aa0e214c824c5882c1ad92777bee680aad4","node_hash":"7667a3a4bc2e8fec1dc7af53e19c414952f9ce926b1e37e8d9adca66dd8f8d1d","ord":1,"own_hash":"494e069be36a18ecaabf5a63be7c31617ade7a5460218ca83a2de3d8d8f964e0","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"f589ee914c46c4aea7ce2de49d925c433c914121f576b81a3eab692f17f179a3"},{"align_key":"8f21603c39df123eb8680362184274aac9bdf1dbd485b3bba230960179071c95","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"The value is 42.0 at 300 K."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"jvnys4s","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"3bcf9fa8412dca28be91d6423460233ddedd7add6c324d8a0f2b26038567d3d3","node_hash":"f5761f338b2878dff39a6ee724a75b13626dd625a0df96cf1cc6f9e8258cb7cc","ord":0,"own_hash":"7f0b9190d076cf01b51a8be863a51e9a8eeaab5d3ec8656202ff4d41578d4d82","parent":"ytp1e5n","text_hash":"3bcf9fa8412dca28be91d6423460233ddedd7add6c324d8a0f2b26038567d3d3"},{"align_key":"8e7fe271cd1bab88d86c8900fe3ffae0ce95c55af6659df1fca278d359296e2d","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"See "},{"kind":"xref","target":"tb49qpc","text":"Table 1"},{"kind":"text","text":" and the note."},{"kind":"cite","refs":["r3e21zr"],"text":"1"}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"mzwwhxj","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"9894a48790a8561966e68672fa13da20541d25a5178653720648f62cbc9ad36b","node_hash":"8f3e5338ba3c97efca4cef5c60d849757aed6334ee27ab807fa71d969089e46e","ord":1,"own_hash":"02ed6d50b8ac607b59e3f7b5116ee6143ed7e69af25b19c4037aa799bc330a88","parent":"ytp1e5n","text_hash":"5b1de19c9eb1399e54bde7e96f051cac8b337be1f307fac320292b8db7e39da7"},{"align_key":"282eea00b316a6950fb7179f6289a8b98359019e11cb23a3ff426cdecad90165","id":"exq1ter","kind":"paragraph","match_hash":"da88f35d24faf0099610c720953c4919647a5dfb9003889a15c464cd9c540fb1","node_hash":"062dd26bfb226ca9811d0dfb013df211cb201dfe7b4b25f9aba000f3212298d5","ord":2,"own_hash":"494e069be36a18ecaabf5a63be7c31617ade7a5460218ca83a2de3d8d8f964e0","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"da88f35d24faf0099610c720953c4919647a5dfb9003889a15c464cd9c540fb1"},{"align_key":"b8074a8bc013aa007023c4cce7334f1e1f22384d57a526ca22fd2f5589d5ab17","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"A second paragraph."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"j663d4h","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"2e8313b033de5e17878ae778d6293bbd6e197a072f36acf7fe0840a690a7f31e","node_hash":"443539440dca73149ca75276492334ce9a5a6c50070137e8dc7bf414b75a27ab","ord":0,"own_hash":"acee4b6b1399bfde1dc67dea8d8c86b0db961d2af516ae4aaee26f294261456f","parent":"exq1ter","text_hash":"2e8313b033de5e17878ae778d6293bbd6e197a072f36acf7fe0840a690a7f31e"},{"align_key":"437c101749b0481e615fc7eed8dcacb536b65400c7e0695ad4cbb2bf2dae488c","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"It ends here."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"rsw24qc","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"2888dbfa0c08fd65c58c923b920860c76e13913d9fa93b03eccbbf7bdf53b882","node_hash":"caeb3ae57d0821b8ac961c9507debbcda2b118b16cdc010b83a143a782058d57","ord":1,"own_hash":"705f77e8520c8c5ce3a7a495a20d8a9c55baa9801e49a55c341f5de79eeeLine truncated
{"before":{"ids":[],"nodes":[{"align_key":"b3108c22ec836d883e5116f7ed8546fa75390eb4aa960d78f2936115f69b6826","id":"s0fn2fj","kind":"document","match_hash":"b6a4e12f700a6214bf02c9a437559e82fccdbecea7b575fa438a7d2e8c33071a","node_hash":"a05328e6d13edba652599aceb58c018dbccf54abd1f878c9f61623017960e1fe","ord":0,"own_hash":"34444fe0e6bdbf3927a579fe3286859d204ea0882a381b7769ffd4905551d24f","parent":null,"text_hash":"bd2abc746d51cf52d57a18632383245d585e29e265426967894eed99bc937561"},{"align_key":"caf6aee3882b3890996037e35d0ffdfe30b5e66653d45321d7ea0fa9135f1ee9","attrs":{"level":1},"id":"b9wp3tt","kind":"section","label":"1","match_hash":"5a96c01f314c4d8a22fd5e105bebef45df4301886cccbc2538ecefddfcb1d405","node_hash":"ea9a1409bbf0f0f7bd8d508bfdbbf7d14a22ab1e3da011eafbfcd4e14ae7e4fd","ord":0,"own_hash":"65da097b48f8237e8d171bfbd0053ff0e3795c0532d5522d23a92b53430956f4","parent":"s0fn2fj","text_hash":"7a97628fe9643c0fca3614a077e2e631c3fee81d3733ba1564292df65a294573"},{"align_key":"c099142bc3186ded72786ba27e9ea6d2da240fb9fd3fe79b479ecf8e734b2850","id":"vet7k0e","kind":"heading","match_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd","node_hash":"a3c82ab1e44bf4cffa1a59507f8bddc39a1ad191321ee803d0d60d96609a44c7","ord":0,"own_hash":"e813ff86a8920cef741e548eb5df545774b520d2fadbdda6e2b872a6729b9d26","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd"},{"align_key":"c099142bc3186ded72786ba27e9ea6d2da240fb9fd3fe79b479ecf8e734b2850","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"Results"}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"em5pd9v","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd","node_hash":"293fc03ff4e39d7532467e4417ffcdb15f470f0bd3658dc1c021645ad53c9bef","ord":0,"own_hash":"c55f401232b19ff1133d77eac6c72868975064f177fc2d31ab8a181303c30599","parent":"vet7k0e","text_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd"},{"align_key":"610c235321e38145abff21e31eaab303d85a6ce0d1b9340a599dc821a04922f6","id":"ytp1e5n","kind":"paragraph","match_hash":"bcb4902ec69f2a7a724384f561ee9aa0e214c824c5882c1ad92777bee680aad4","node_hash":"7667a3a4bc2e8fec1dc7af53e19c414952f9ce926b1e37e8d9adca66dd8f8d1d","ord":1,"own_hash":"494e069be36a18ecaabf5a63be7c31617ade7a5460218ca83a2de3d8d8f964e0","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"f589ee914c46c4aea7ce2de49d925c433c914121f576b81a3eab692f17f179a3"},{"align_key":"8f21603c39df123eb8680362184274aac9bdf1dbd485b3bba230960179071c95","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"The value is 42.0 at 300 K."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"jvnys4s","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"3bcf9fa8412dca28be91d6423460233ddedd7add6c324d8a0f2b26038567d3d3","node_hash":"f5761f338b2878dff39a6ee724a75b13626dd625a0df96cf1cc6f9e8258cb7cc","ord":0,"own_hash":"7f0b9190d076cf01b51a8be863a51e9a8eeaab5d3ec8656202ff4d41578d4d82","parent":"ytp1e5n","text_hash":"3bcf9fa8412dca28be91d6423460233ddedd7add6c324d8a0f2b26038567d3d3"},{"align_key":"8e7fe271cd1bab88d86c8900fe3ffae0ce95c55af6659df1fca278d359296e2d","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"See "},{"kind":"xref","target":"tb49qpc","text":"Table 1"},{"kind":"text","text":" and the note."},{"kind":"cite","refs":["r3e21zr"],"text":"1"}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"mzwwhxj","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"9894a48790a8561966e68672fa13da20541d25a5178653720648f62cbc9ad36b","node_hash":"8f3e5338ba3c97efca4cef5c60d849757aed6334ee27ab807fa71d969089e46e","ord":1,"own_hash":"02ed6d50b8ac607b59e3f7b5116ee6143ed7e69af25b19c4037aa799bc330a88","parent":"ytp1e5n","text_hash":"5b1de19c9eb1399e54bde7e96f051cac8b337be1f307fac320292b8db7e39da7"},{"align_key":"282eea00b316a6950fb7179f6289a8b98359019e11cb23a3ff426cdecad90165","id":"exq1ter","kind":"paragraph","match_hash":"da88f35d24faf0099610c720953c4919647a5dfb9003889a15c464cd9c540fb1","node_hash":"062dd26bfb226ca9811d0dfb013df211cb201dfe7b4b25f9aba000f3212298d5","ord":2,"own_hash":"494e069be36a18ecaabf5a63be7c31617ade7a5460218ca83a2de3d8d8f964e0","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"da88f35d24faf0099610c720953c4919647a5dfb9003889a15c464cd9c540fb1"},{"align_key":"b8074a8bc013aa007023c4cce7334f1e1f22384d57a526ca22fd2f5589d5ab17","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"A second paragraph."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"j663d4h","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"2e8313b033de5e17878ae778d6293bbd6e197a072f36acf7fe0840a690a7f31e","node_hash":"443539440dca73149ca75276492334ce9a5a6c50070137e8dc7bf414b75a27ab","ord":0,"own_hash":"acee4b6b1399bfde1dc67dea8d8c86b0db961d2af516ae4aaee26f294261456f","parent":"exq1ter","text_hash":"2e8313b033de5e17878ae778d6293bbd6e197a072f36acf7fe0840a690a7f31e"},{"align_key":"437c101749b0481e615fc7eed8dcacb536b65400c7e0695ad4cbb2bf2dae488c","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"It ends here."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"rsw24qc","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"2888dbfa0c08fd65c58c923b920860c76e13913d9fa93b03eccbbf7bdf53b882","node_hash":"caeb3ae57d0821b8ac961c9507debbcda2b118b16cdc010b83a143a782058d57","ord":1,"own_hash":"705f77e8520c8c5ce3a7a495a20d8a9c55baa9801e49a55c341f5de79eeeLine truncated
{"before":{"ids":[],"nodes":[{"align_key":"b3108c22ec836d883e5116f7ed8546fa75390eb4aa960d78f2936115f69b6826","id":"s0fn2fj","kind":"document","match_hash":"b6a4e12f700a6214bf02c9a437559e82fccdbecea7b575fa438a7d2e8c33071a","node_hash":"a05328e6d13edba652599aceb58c018dbccf54abd1f878c9f61623017960e1fe","ord":0,"own_hash":"34444fe0e6bdbf3927a579fe3286859d204ea0882a381b7769ffd4905551d24f","parent":null,"text_hash":"bd2abc746d51cf52d57a18632383245d585e29e265426967894eed99bc937561"},{"align_key":"caf6aee3882b3890996037e35d0ffdfe30b5e66653d45321d7ea0fa9135f1ee9","attrs":{"level":1},"id":"b9wp3tt","kind":"section","label":"1","match_hash":"5a96c01f314c4d8a22fd5e105bebef45df4301886cccbc2538ecefddfcb1d405","node_hash":"ea9a1409bbf0f0f7bd8d508bfdbbf7d14a22ab1e3da011eafbfcd4e14ae7e4fd","ord":0,"own_hash":"65da097b48f8237e8d171bfbd0053ff0e3795c0532d5522d23a92b53430956f4","parent":"s0fn2fj","text_hash":"7a97628fe9643c0fca3614a077e2e631c3fee81d3733ba1564292df65a294573"},{"align_key":"c099142bc3186ded72786ba27e9ea6d2da240fb9fd3fe79b479ecf8e734b2850","id":"vet7k0e","kind":"heading","match_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd","node_hash":"a3c82ab1e44bf4cffa1a59507f8bddc39a1ad191321ee803d0d60d96609a44c7","ord":0,"own_hash":"e813ff86a8920cef741e548eb5df545774b520d2fadbdda6e2b872a6729b9d26","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd"},{"align_key":"c099142bc3186ded72786ba27e9ea6d2da240fb9fd3fe79b479ecf8e734b2850","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"Results"}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"em5pd9v","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd","node_hash":"293fc03ff4e39d7532467e4417ffcdb15f470f0bd3658dc1c021645ad53c9bef","ord":0,"own_hash":"c55f401232b19ff1133d77eac6c72868975064f177fc2d31ab8a181303c30599","parent":"vet7k0e","text_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd"},{"align_key":"610c235321e38145abff21e31eaab303d85a6ce0d1b9340a599dc821a04922f6","id":"ytp1e5n","kind":"paragraph","match_hash":"bcb4902ec69f2a7a724384f561ee9aa0e214c824c5882c1ad92777bee680aad4","node_hash":"7667a3a4bc2e8fec1dc7af53e19c414952f9ce926b1e37e8d9adca66dd8f8d1d","ord":1,"own_hash":"494e069be36a18ecaabf5a63be7c31617ade7a5460218ca83a2de3d8d8f964e0","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"f589ee914c46c4aea7ce2de49d925c433c914121f576b81a3eab692f17f179a3"},{"align_key":"8f21603c39df123eb8680362184274aac9bdf1dbd485b3bba230960179071c95","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"The value is 42.0 at 300 K."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"jvnys4s","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"3bcf9fa8412dca28be91d6423460233ddedd7add6c324d8a0f2b26038567d3d3","node_hash":"f5761f338b2878dff39a6ee724a75b13626dd625a0df96cf1cc6f9e8258cb7cc","ord":0,"own_hash":"7f0b9190d076cf01b51a8be863a51e9a8eeaab5d3ec8656202ff4d41578d4d82","parent":"ytp1e5n","text_hash":"3bcf9fa8412dca28be91d6423460233ddedd7add6c324d8a0f2b26038567d3d3"},{"align_key":"8e7fe271cd1bab88d86c8900fe3ffae0ce95c55af6659df1fca278d359296e2d","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"See "},{"kind":"xref","target":"tb49qpc","text":"Table 1"},{"kind":"text","text":" and the note."},{"kind":"cite","refs":["r3e21zr"],"text":"1"}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"mzwwhxj","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"9894a48790a8561966e68672fa13da20541d25a5178653720648f62cbc9ad36b","node_hash":"8f3e5338ba3c97efca4cef5c60d849757aed6334ee27ab807fa71d969089e46e","ord":1,"own_hash":"02ed6d50b8ac607b59e3f7b5116ee6143ed7e69af25b19c4037aa799bc330a88","parent":"ytp1e5n","text_hash":"5b1de19c9eb1399e54bde7e96f051cac8b337be1f307fac320292b8db7e39da7"},{"align_key":"282eea00b316a6950fb7179f6289a8b98359019e11cb23a3ff426cdecad90165","id":"exq1ter","kind":"paragraph","match_hash":"da88f35d24faf0099610c720953c4919647a5dfb9003889a15c464cd9c540fb1","node_hash":"062dd26bfb226ca9811d0dfb013df211cb201dfe7b4b25f9aba000f3212298d5","ord":2,"own_hash":"494e069be36a18ecaabf5a63be7c31617ade7a5460218ca83a2de3d8d8f964e0","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"da88f35d24faf0099610c720953c4919647a5dfb9003889a15c464cd9c540fb1"},{"align_key":"b8074a8bc013aa007023c4cce7334f1e1f22384d57a526ca22fd2f5589d5ab17","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"A second paragraph."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"j663d4h","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"2e8313b033de5e17878ae778d6293bbd6e197a072f36acf7fe0840a690a7f31e","node_hash":"443539440dca73149ca75276492334ce9a5a6c50070137e8dc7bf414b75a27ab","ord":0,"own_hash":"acee4b6b1399bfde1dc67dea8d8c86b0db961d2af516ae4aaee26f294261456f","parent":"exq1ter","text_hash":"2e8313b033de5e17878ae778d6293bbd6e197a072f36acf7fe0840a690a7f31e"},{"align_key":"437c101749b0481e615fc7eed8dcacb536b65400c7e0695ad4cbb2bf2dae488c","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"It ends here."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"rsw24qc","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"2888dbfa0c08fd65c58c923b920860c76e13913d9fa93b03eccbbf7bdf53b882","node_hash":"caeb3ae57d0821b8ac961c9507debbcda2b118b16cdc010b83a143a782058d57","ord":1,"own_hash":"705f77e8520c8c5ce3a7a495a20d8a9c55baa9801e49a55c341f5de79eeeLine truncated
{"before":{"ids":[],"nodes":[{"align_key":"b3108c22ec836d883e5116f7ed8546fa75390eb4aa960d78f2936115f69b6826","id":"s0fn2fj","kind":"document","match_hash":"b6a4e12f700a6214bf02c9a437559e82fccdbecea7b575fa438a7d2e8c33071a","node_hash":"a05328e6d13edba652599aceb58c018dbccf54abd1f878c9f61623017960e1fe","ord":0,"own_hash":"34444fe0e6bdbf3927a579fe3286859d204ea0882a381b7769ffd4905551d24f","parent":null,"text_hash":"bd2abc746d51cf52d57a18632383245d585e29e265426967894eed99bc937561"},{"align_key":"caf6aee3882b3890996037e35d0ffdfe30b5e66653d45321d7ea0fa9135f1ee9","attrs":{"level":1},"id":"b9wp3tt","kind":"section","label":"1","match_hash":"5a96c01f314c4d8a22fd5e105bebef45df4301886cccbc2538ecefddfcb1d405","node_hash":"ea9a1409bbf0f0f7bd8d508bfdbbf7d14a22ab1e3da011eafbfcd4e14ae7e4fd","ord":0,"own_hash":"65da097b48f8237e8d171bfbd0053ff0e3795c0532d5522d23a92b53430956f4","parent":"s0fn2fj","text_hash":"7a97628fe9643c0fca3614a077e2e631c3fee81d3733ba1564292df65a294573"},{"align_key":"c099142bc3186ded72786ba27e9ea6d2da240fb9fd3fe79b479ecf8e734b2850","id":"vet7k0e","kind":"heading","match_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd","node_hash":"a3c82ab1e44bf4cffa1a59507f8bddc39a1ad191321ee803d0d60d96609a44c7","ord":0,"own_hash":"e813ff86a8920cef741e548eb5df545774b520d2fadbdda6e2b872a6729b9d26","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd"},{"align_key":"c099142bc3186ded72786ba27e9ea6d2da240fb9fd3fe79b479ecf8e734b2850","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"Results"}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"em5pd9v","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd","node_hash":"293fc03ff4e39d7532467e4417ffcdb15f470f0bd3658dc1c021645ad53c9bef","ord":0,"own_hash":"c55f401232b19ff1133d77eac6c72868975064f177fc2d31ab8a181303c30599","parent":"vet7k0e","text_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd"},{"align_key":"610c235321e38145abff21e31eaab303d85a6ce0d1b9340a599dc821a04922f6","id":"ytp1e5n","kind":"paragraph","match_hash":"bcb4902ec69f2a7a724384f561ee9aa0e214c824c5882c1ad92777bee680aad4","node_hash":"7667a3a4bc2e8fec1dc7af53e19c414952f9ce926b1e37e8d9adca66dd8f8d1d","ord":1,"own_hash":"494e069be36a18ecaabf5a63be7c31617ade7a5460218ca83a2de3d8d8f964e0","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"f589ee914c46c4aea7ce2de49d925c433c914121f576b81a3eab692f17f179a3"},{"align_key":"8f21603c39df123eb8680362184274aac9bdf1dbd485b3bba230960179071c95","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"The value is 42.0 at 300 K."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"jvnys4s","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"3bcf9fa8412dca28be91d6423460233ddedd7add6c324d8a0f2b26038567d3d3","node_hash":"f5761f338b2878dff39a6ee724a75b13626dd625a0df96cf1cc6f9e8258cb7cc","ord":0,"own_hash":"7f0b9190d076cf01b51a8be863a51e9a8eeaab5d3ec8656202ff4d41578d4d82","parent":"ytp1e5n","text_hash":"3bcf9fa8412dca28be91d6423460233ddedd7add6c324d8a0f2b26038567d3d3"},{"align_key":"8e7fe271cd1bab88d86c8900fe3ffae0ce95c55af6659df1fca278d359296e2d","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"See "},{"kind":"xref","target":"tb49qpc","text":"Table 1"},{"kind":"text","text":" and the note."},{"kind":"cite","refs":["r3e21zr"],"text":"1"}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"mzwwhxj","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"9894a48790a8561966e68672fa13da20541d25a5178653720648f62cbc9ad36b","node_hash":"8f3e5338ba3c97efca4cef5c60d849757aed6334ee27ab807fa71d969089e46e","ord":1,"own_hash":"02ed6d50b8ac607b59e3f7b5116ee6143ed7e69af25b19c4037aa799bc330a88","parent":"ytp1e5n","text_hash":"5b1de19c9eb1399e54bde7e96f051cac8b337be1f307fac320292b8db7e39da7"},{"align_key":"282eea00b316a6950fb7179f6289a8b98359019e11cb23a3ff426cdecad90165","id":"exq1ter","kind":"paragraph","match_hash":"da88f35d24faf0099610c720953c4919647a5dfb9003889a15c464cd9c540fb1","node_hash":"062dd26bfb226ca9811d0dfb013df211cb201dfe7b4b25f9aba000f3212298d5","ord":2,"own_hash":"494e069be36a18ecaabf5a63be7c31617ade7a5460218ca83a2de3d8d8f964e0","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"da88f35d24faf0099610c720953c4919647a5dfb9003889a15c464cd9c540fb1"},{"align_key":"b8074a8bc013aa007023c4cce7334f1e1f22384d57a526ca22fd2f5589d5ab17","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"A second paragraph."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"j663d4h","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"2e8313b033de5e17878ae778d6293bbd6e197a072f36acf7fe0840a690a7f31e","node_hash":"443539440dca73149ca75276492334ce9a5a6c50070137e8dc7bf414b75a27ab","ord":0,"own_hash":"acee4b6b1399bfde1dc67dea8d8c86b0db961d2af516ae4aaee26f294261456f","parent":"exq1ter","text_hash":"2e8313b033de5e17878ae778d6293bbd6e197a072f36acf7fe0840a690a7f31e"},{"align_key":"437c101749b0481e615fc7eed8dcacb536b65400c7e0695ad4cbb2bf2dae488c","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"It ends here."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"rsw24qc","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"2888dbfa0c08fd65c58c923b920860c76e13913d9fa93b03eccbbf7bdf53b882","node_hash":"caeb3ae57d0821b8ac961c9507debbcda2b118b16cdc010b83a143a782058d57","ord":1,"own_hash":"705f77e8520c8c5ce3a7a495a20d8a9c55baa9801e49a55c341f5de79eeeLine truncated
{"before":{"ids":[],"nodes":[{"align_key":"b3108c22ec836d883e5116f7ed8546fa75390eb4aa960d78f2936115f69b6826","id":"s0fn2fj","kind":"document","match_hash":"b6a4e12f700a6214bf02c9a437559e82fccdbecea7b575fa438a7d2e8c33071a","node_hash":"a05328e6d13edba652599aceb58c018dbccf54abd1f878c9f61623017960e1fe","ord":0,"own_hash":"34444fe0e6bdbf3927a579fe3286859d204ea0882a381b7769ffd4905551d24f","parent":null,"text_hash":"bd2abc746d51cf52d57a18632383245d585e29e265426967894eed99bc937561"},{"align_key":"caf6aee3882b3890996037e35d0ffdfe30b5e66653d45321d7ea0fa9135f1ee9","attrs":{"level":1},"id":"b9wp3tt","kind":"section","label":"1","match_hash":"5a96c01f314c4d8a22fd5e105bebef45df4301886cccbc2538ecefddfcb1d405","node_hash":"ea9a1409bbf0f0f7bd8d508bfdbbf7d14a22ab1e3da011eafbfcd4e14ae7e4fd","ord":0,"own_hash":"65da097b48f8237e8d171bfbd0053ff0e3795c0532d5522d23a92b53430956f4","parent":"s0fn2fj","text_hash":"7a97628fe9643c0fca3614a077e2e631c3fee81d3733ba1564292df65a294573"},{"align_key":"c099142bc3186ded72786ba27e9ea6d2da240fb9fd3fe79b479ecf8e734b2850","id":"vet7k0e","kind":"heading","match_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd","node_hash":"a3c82ab1e44bf4cffa1a59507f8bddc39a1ad191321ee803d0d60d96609a44c7","ord":0,"own_hash":"e813ff86a8920cef741e548eb5df545774b520d2fadbdda6e2b872a6729b9d26","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd"},{"align_key":"c099142bc3186ded72786ba27e9ea6d2da240fb9fd3fe79b479ecf8e734b2850","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"Results"}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"em5pd9v","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd","node_hash":"293fc03ff4e39d7532467e4417ffcdb15f470f0bd3658dc1c021645ad53c9bef","ord":0,"own_hash":"c55f401232b19ff1133d77eac6c72868975064f177fc2d31ab8a181303c30599","parent":"vet7k0e","text_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd"},{"align_key":"610c235321e38145abff21e31eaab303d85a6ce0d1b9340a599dc821a04922f6","id":"ytp1e5n","kind":"paragraph","match_hash":"bcb4902ec69f2a7a724384f561ee9aa0e214c824c5882c1ad92777bee680aad4","node_hash":"7667a3a4bc2e8fec1dc7af53e19c414952f9ce926b1e37e8d9adca66dd8f8d1d","ord":1,"own_hash":"494e069be36a18ecaabf5a63be7c31617ade7a5460218ca83a2de3d8d8f964e0","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"f589ee914c46c4aea7ce2de49d925c433c914121f576b81a3eab692f17f179a3"},{"align_key":"8f21603c39df123eb8680362184274aac9bdf1dbd485b3bba230960179071c95","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"The value is 42.0 at 300 K."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"jvnys4s","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"3bcf9fa8412dca28be91d6423460233ddedd7add6c324d8a0f2b26038567d3d3","node_hash":"f5761f338b2878dff39a6ee724a75b13626dd625a0df96cf1cc6f9e8258cb7cc","ord":0,"own_hash":"7f0b9190d076cf01b51a8be863a51e9a8eeaab5d3ec8656202ff4d41578d4d82","parent":"ytp1e5n","text_hash":"3bcf9fa8412dca28be91d6423460233ddedd7add6c324d8a0f2b26038567d3d3"},{"align_key":"8e7fe271cd1bab88d86c8900fe3ffae0ce95c55af6659df1fca278d359296e2d","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"See "},{"kind":"xref","target":"tb49qpc","text":"Table 1"},{"kind":"text","text":" and the note."},{"kind":"cite","refs":["r3e21zr"],"text":"1"}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"mzwwhxj","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"9894a48790a8561966e68672fa13da20541d25a5178653720648f62cbc9ad36b","node_hash":"8f3e5338ba3c97efca4cef5c60d849757aed6334ee27ab807fa71d969089e46e","ord":1,"own_hash":"02ed6d50b8ac607b59e3f7b5116ee6143ed7e69af25b19c4037aa799bc330a88","parent":"ytp1e5n","text_hash":"5b1de19c9eb1399e54bde7e96f051cac8b337be1f307fac320292b8db7e39da7"},{"align_key":"282eea00b316a6950fb7179f6289a8b98359019e11cb23a3ff426cdecad90165","id":"exq1ter","kind":"paragraph","match_hash":"da88f35d24faf0099610c720953c4919647a5dfb9003889a15c464cd9c540fb1","node_hash":"062dd26bfb226ca9811d0dfb013df211cb201dfe7b4b25f9aba000f3212298d5","ord":2,"own_hash":"494e069be36a18ecaabf5a63be7c31617ade7a5460218ca83a2de3d8d8f964e0","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"da88f35d24faf0099610c720953c4919647a5dfb9003889a15c464cd9c540fb1"},{"align_key":"b8074a8bc013aa007023c4cce7334f1e1f22384d57a526ca22fd2f5589d5ab17","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"A second paragraph."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"j663d4h","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"2e8313b033de5e17878ae778d6293bbd6e197a072f36acf7fe0840a690a7f31e","node_hash":"443539440dca73149ca75276492334ce9a5a6c50070137e8dc7bf414b75a27ab","ord":0,"own_hash":"acee4b6b1399bfde1dc67dea8d8c86b0db961d2af516ae4aaee26f294261456f","parent":"exq1ter","text_hash":"2e8313b033de5e17878ae778d6293bbd6e197a072f36acf7fe0840a690a7f31e"},{"align_key":"437c101749b0481e615fc7eed8dcacb536b65400c7e0695ad4cbb2bf2dae488c","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"It ends here."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"rsw24qc","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"2888dbfa0c08fd65c58c923b920860c76e13913d9fa93b03eccbbf7bdf53b882","node_hash":"caeb3ae57d0821b8ac961c9507debbcda2b118b16cdc010b83a143a782058d57","ord":1,"own_hash":"705f77e8520c8c5ce3a7a495a20d8a9c55baa9801e49a55c341f5de79eeeLine truncated
{"before":{"ids":[],"nodes":[{"align_key":"b3108c22ec836d883e5116f7ed8546fa75390eb4aa960d78f2936115f69b6826","id":"s0fn2fj","kind":"document","match_hash":"b6a4e12f700a6214bf02c9a437559e82fccdbecea7b575fa438a7d2e8c33071a","node_hash":"a05328e6d13edba652599aceb58c018dbccf54abd1f878c9f61623017960e1fe","ord":0,"own_hash":"34444fe0e6bdbf3927a579fe3286859d204ea0882a381b7769ffd4905551d24f","parent":null,"text_hash":"bd2abc746d51cf52d57a18632383245d585e29e265426967894eed99bc937561"},{"align_key":"caf6aee3882b3890996037e35d0ffdfe30b5e66653d45321d7ea0fa9135f1ee9","attrs":{"level":1},"id":"b9wp3tt","kind":"section","label":"1","match_hash":"5a96c01f314c4d8a22fd5e105bebef45df4301886cccbc2538ecefddfcb1d405","node_hash":"ea9a1409bbf0f0f7bd8d508bfdbbf7d14a22ab1e3da011eafbfcd4e14ae7e4fd","ord":0,"own_hash":"65da097b48f8237e8d171bfbd0053ff0e3795c0532d5522d23a92b53430956f4","parent":"s0fn2fj","text_hash":"7a97628fe9643c0fca3614a077e2e631c3fee81d3733ba1564292df65a294573"},{"align_key":"c099142bc3186ded72786ba27e9ea6d2da240fb9fd3fe79b479ecf8e734b2850","id":"vet7k0e","kind":"heading","match_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd","node_hash":"a3c82ab1e44bf4cffa1a59507f8bddc39a1ad191321ee803d0d60d96609a44c7","ord":0,"own_hash":"e813ff86a8920cef741e548eb5df545774b520d2fadbdda6e2b872a6729b9d26","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd"},{"align_key":"c099142bc3186ded72786ba27e9ea6d2da240fb9fd3fe79b479ecf8e734b2850","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"Results"}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"em5pd9v","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd","node_hash":"293fc03ff4e39d7532467e4417ffcdb15f470f0bd3658dc1c021645ad53c9bef","ord":0,"own_hash":"c55f401232b19ff1133d77eac6c72868975064f177fc2d31ab8a181303c30599","parent":"vet7k0e","text_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd"},{"align_key":"610c235321e38145abff21e31eaab303d85a6ce0d1b9340a599dc821a04922f6","id":"ytp1e5n","kind":"paragraph","match_hash":"bcb4902ec69f2a7a724384f561ee9aa0e214c824c5882c1ad92777bee680aad4","node_hash":"7667a3a4bc2e8fec1dc7af53e19c414952f9ce926b1e37e8d9adca66dd8f8d1d","ord":1,"own_hash":"494e069be36a18ecaabf5a63be7c31617ade7a5460218ca83a2de3d8d8f964e0","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"f589ee914c46c4aea7ce2de49d925c433c914121f576b81a3eab692f17f179a3"},{"align_key":"8f21603c39df123eb8680362184274aac9bdf1dbd485b3bba230960179071c95","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"The value is 42.0 at 300 K."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"jvnys4s","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"3bcf9fa8412dca28be91d6423460233ddedd7add6c324d8a0f2b26038567d3d3","node_hash":"f5761f338b2878dff39a6ee724a75b13626dd625a0df96cf1cc6f9e8258cb7cc","ord":0,"own_hash":"7f0b9190d076cf01b51a8be863a51e9a8eeaab5d3ec8656202ff4d41578d4d82","parent":"ytp1e5n","text_hash":"3bcf9fa8412dca28be91d6423460233ddedd7add6c324d8a0f2b26038567d3d3"},{"align_key":"8e7fe271cd1bab88d86c8900fe3ffae0ce95c55af6659df1fca278d359296e2d","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"See "},{"kind":"xref","target":"tb49qpc","text":"Table 1"},{"kind":"text","text":" and the note."},{"kind":"cite","refs":["r3e21zr"],"text":"1"}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"mzwwhxj","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"9894a48790a8561966e68672fa13da20541d25a5178653720648f62cbc9ad36b","node_hash":"8f3e5338ba3c97efca4cef5c60d849757aed6334ee27ab807fa71d969089e46e","ord":1,"own_hash":"02ed6d50b8ac607b59e3f7b5116ee6143ed7e69af25b19c4037aa799bc330a88","parent":"ytp1e5n","text_hash":"5b1de19c9eb1399e54bde7e96f051cac8b337be1f307fac320292b8db7e39da7"},{"align_key":"282eea00b316a6950fb7179f6289a8b98359019e11cb23a3ff426cdecad90165","id":"exq1ter","kind":"paragraph","match_hash":"da88f35d24faf0099610c720953c4919647a5dfb9003889a15c464cd9c540fb1","node_hash":"062dd26bfb226ca9811d0dfb013df211cb201dfe7b4b25f9aba000f3212298d5","ord":2,"own_hash":"494e069be36a18ecaabf5a63be7c31617ade7a5460218ca83a2de3d8d8f964e0","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"da88f35d24faf0099610c720953c4919647a5dfb9003889a15c464cd9c540fb1"},{"align_key":"b8074a8bc013aa007023c4cce7334f1e1f22384d57a526ca22fd2f5589d5ab17","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"A second paragraph."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"j663d4h","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"2e8313b033de5e17878ae778d6293bbd6e197a072f36acf7fe0840a690a7f31e","node_hash":"443539440dca73149ca75276492334ce9a5a6c50070137e8dc7bf414b75a27ab","ord":0,"own_hash":"acee4b6b1399bfde1dc67dea8d8c86b0db961d2af516ae4aaee26f294261456f","parent":"exq1ter","text_hash":"2e8313b033de5e17878ae778d6293bbd6e197a072f36acf7fe0840a690a7f31e"},{"align_key":"437c101749b0481e615fc7eed8dcacb536b65400c7e0695ad4cbb2bf2dae488c","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"It ends here."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"rsw24qc","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"2888dbfa0c08fd65c58c923b920860c76e13913d9fa93b03eccbbf7bdf53b882","node_hash":"caeb3ae57d0821b8ac961c9507debbcda2b118b16cdc010b83a143a782058d57","ord":1,"own_hash":"705f77e8520c8c5ce3a7a495a20d8a9c55baa9801e49a55c341f5de79eeeLine truncated
{"before":{"ids":[],"nodes":[{"align_key":"b3108c22ec836d883e5116f7ed8546fa75390eb4aa960d78f2936115f69b6826","id":"s0fn2fj","kind":"document","match_hash":"b6a4e12f700a6214bf02c9a437559e82fccdbecea7b575fa438a7d2e8c33071a","node_hash":"a05328e6d13edba652599aceb58c018dbccf54abd1f878c9f61623017960e1fe","ord":0,"own_hash":"34444fe0e6bdbf3927a579fe3286859d204ea0882a381b7769ffd4905551d24f","parent":null,"text_hash":"bd2abc746d51cf52d57a18632383245d585e29e265426967894eed99bc937561"},{"align_key":"caf6aee3882b3890996037e35d0ffdfe30b5e66653d45321d7ea0fa9135f1ee9","attrs":{"level":1},"id":"b9wp3tt","kind":"section","label":"1","match_hash":"5a96c01f314c4d8a22fd5e105bebef45df4301886cccbc2538ecefddfcb1d405","node_hash":"ea9a1409bbf0f0f7bd8d508bfdbbf7d14a22ab1e3da011eafbfcd4e14ae7e4fd","ord":0,"own_hash":"65da097b48f8237e8d171bfbd0053ff0e3795c0532d5522d23a92b53430956f4","parent":"s0fn2fj","text_hash":"7a97628fe9643c0fca3614a077e2e631c3fee81d3733ba1564292df65a294573"},{"align_key":"c099142bc3186ded72786ba27e9ea6d2da240fb9fd3fe79b479ecf8e734b2850","id":"vet7k0e","kind":"heading","match_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd","node_hash":"a3c82ab1e44bf4cffa1a59507f8bddc39a1ad191321ee803d0d60d96609a44c7","ord":0,"own_hash":"e813ff86a8920cef741e548eb5df545774b520d2fadbdda6e2b872a6729b9d26","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd"},{"align_key":"c099142bc3186ded72786ba27e9ea6d2da240fb9fd3fe79b479ecf8e734b2850","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"Results"}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"em5pd9v","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd","node_hash":"293fc03ff4e39d7532467e4417ffcdb15f470f0bd3658dc1c021645ad53c9bef","ord":0,"own_hash":"c55f401232b19ff1133d77eac6c72868975064f177fc2d31ab8a181303c30599","parent":"vet7k0e","text_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd"},{"align_key":"610c235321e38145abff21e31eaab303d85a6ce0d1b9340a599dc821a04922f6","id":"ytp1e5n","kind":"paragraph","match_hash":"bcb4902ec69f2a7a724384f561ee9aa0e214c824c5882c1ad92777bee680aad4","node_hash":"7667a3a4bc2e8fec1dc7af53e19c414952f9ce926b1e37e8d9adca66dd8f8d1d","ord":1,"own_hash":"494e069be36a18ecaabf5a63be7c31617ade7a5460218ca83a2de3d8d8f964e0","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"f589ee914c46c4aea7ce2de49d925c433c914121f576b81a3eab692f17f179a3"},{"align_key":"8f21603c39df123eb8680362184274aac9bdf1dbd485b3bba230960179071c95","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"The value is 42.0 at 300 K."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"jvnys4s","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"3bcf9fa8412dca28be91d6423460233ddedd7add6c324d8a0f2b26038567d3d3","node_hash":"f5761f338b2878dff39a6ee724a75b13626dd625a0df96cf1cc6f9e8258cb7cc","ord":0,"own_hash":"7f0b9190d076cf01b51a8be863a51e9a8eeaab5d3ec8656202ff4d41578d4d82","parent":"ytp1e5n","text_hash":"3bcf9fa8412dca28be91d6423460233ddedd7add6c324d8a0f2b26038567d3d3"},{"align_key":"8e7fe271cd1bab88d86c8900fe3ffae0ce95c55af6659df1fca278d359296e2d","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"See "},{"kind":"xref","target":"tb49qpc","text":"Table 1"},{"kind":"text","text":" and the note."},{"kind":"cite","refs":["r3e21zr"],"text":"1"}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"mzwwhxj","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"9894a48790a8561966e68672fa13da20541d25a5178653720648f62cbc9ad36b","node_hash":"8f3e5338ba3c97efca4cef5c60d849757aed6334ee27ab807fa71d969089e46e","ord":1,"own_hash":"02ed6d50b8ac607b59e3f7b5116ee6143ed7e69af25b19c4037aa799bc330a88","parent":"ytp1e5n","text_hash":"5b1de19c9eb1399e54bde7e96f051cac8b337be1f307fac320292b8db7e39da7"},{"align_key":"282eea00b316a6950fb7179f6289a8b98359019e11cb23a3ff426cdecad90165","id":"exq1ter","kind":"paragraph","match_hash":"da88f35d24faf0099610c720953c4919647a5dfb9003889a15c464cd9c540fb1","node_hash":"062dd26bfb226ca9811d0dfb013df211cb201dfe7b4b25f9aba000f3212298d5","ord":2,"own_hash":"494e069be36a18ecaabf5a63be7c31617ade7a5460218ca83a2de3d8d8f964e0","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"da88f35d24faf0099610c720953c4919647a5dfb9003889a15c464cd9c540fb1"},{"align_key":"b8074a8bc013aa007023c4cce7334f1e1f22384d57a526ca22fd2f5589d5ab17","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"A second paragraph."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"j663d4h","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"2e8313b033de5e17878ae778d6293bbd6e197a072f36acf7fe0840a690a7f31e","node_hash":"443539440dca73149ca75276492334ce9a5a6c50070137e8dc7bf414b75a27ab","ord":0,"own_hash":"acee4b6b1399bfde1dc67dea8d8c86b0db961d2af516ae4aaee26f294261456f","parent":"exq1ter","text_hash":"2e8313b033de5e17878ae778d6293bbd6e197a072f36acf7fe0840a690a7f31e"},{"align_key":"437c101749b0481e615fc7eed8dcacb536b65400c7e0695ad4cbb2bf2dae488c","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"It ends here."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"rsw24qc","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"2888dbfa0c08fd65c58c923b920860c76e13913d9fa93b03eccbbf7bdf53b882","node_hash":"caeb3ae57d0821b8ac961c9507debbcda2b118b16cdc010b83a143a782058d57","ord":1,"own_hash":"705f77e8520c8c5ce3a7a495a20d8a9c55baa9801e49a55c341f5de79eeeLine truncated
{"before":{"ids":[],"nodes":[{"align_key":"b3108c22ec836d883e5116f7ed8546fa75390eb4aa960d78f2936115f69b6826","id":"s0fn2fj","kind":"document","match_hash":"b6a4e12f700a6214bf02c9a437559e82fccdbecea7b575fa438a7d2e8c33071a","node_hash":"a05328e6d13edba652599aceb58c018dbccf54abd1f878c9f61623017960e1fe","ord":0,"own_hash":"34444fe0e6bdbf3927a579fe3286859d204ea0882a381b7769ffd4905551d24f","parent":null,"text_hash":"bd2abc746d51cf52d57a18632383245d585e29e265426967894eed99bc937561"},{"align_key":"caf6aee3882b3890996037e35d0ffdfe30b5e66653d45321d7ea0fa9135f1ee9","attrs":{"level":1},"id":"b9wp3tt","kind":"section","label":"1","match_hash":"5a96c01f314c4d8a22fd5e105bebef45df4301886cccbc2538ecefddfcb1d405","node_hash":"ea9a1409bbf0f0f7bd8d508bfdbbf7d14a22ab1e3da011eafbfcd4e14ae7e4fd","ord":0,"own_hash":"65da097b48f8237e8d171bfbd0053ff0e3795c0532d5522d23a92b53430956f4","parent":"s0fn2fj","text_hash":"7a97628fe9643c0fca3614a077e2e631c3fee81d3733ba1564292df65a294573"},{"align_key":"c099142bc3186ded72786ba27e9ea6d2da240fb9fd3fe79b479ecf8e734b2850","id":"vet7k0e","kind":"heading","match_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd","node_hash":"a3c82ab1e44bf4cffa1a59507f8bddc39a1ad191321ee803d0d60d96609a44c7","ord":0,"own_hash":"e813ff86a8920cef741e548eb5df545774b520d2fadbdda6e2b872a6729b9d26","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd"},{"align_key":"c099142bc3186ded72786ba27e9ea6d2da240fb9fd3fe79b479ecf8e734b2850","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"Results"}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"em5pd9v","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd","node_hash":"293fc03ff4e39d7532467e4417ffcdb15f470f0bd3658dc1c021645ad53c9bef","ord":0,"own_hash":"c55f401232b19ff1133d77eac6c72868975064f177fc2d31ab8a181303c30599","parent":"vet7k0e","text_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd"},{"align_key":"610c235321e38145abff21e31eaab303d85a6ce0d1b9340a599dc821a04922f6","id":"ytp1e5n","kind":"paragraph","match_hash":"bcb4902ec69f2a7a724384f561ee9aa0e214c824c5882c1ad92777bee680aad4","node_hash":"7667a3a4bc2e8fec1dc7af53e19c414952f9ce926b1e37e8d9adca66dd8f8d1d","ord":1,"own_hash":"494e069be36a18ecaabf5a63be7c31617ade7a5460218ca83a2de3d8d8f964e0","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"f589ee914c46c4aea7ce2de49d925c433c914121f576b81a3eab692f17f179a3"},{"align_key":"8f21603c39df123eb8680362184274aac9bdf1dbd485b3bba230960179071c95","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"The value is 42.0 at 300 K."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"jvnys4s","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"3bcf9fa8412dca28be91d6423460233ddedd7add6c324d8a0f2b26038567d3d3","node_hash":"f5761f338b2878dff39a6ee724a75b13626dd625a0df96cf1cc6f9e8258cb7cc","ord":0,"own_hash":"7f0b9190d076cf01b51a8be863a51e9a8eeaab5d3ec8656202ff4d41578d4d82","parent":"ytp1e5n","text_hash":"3bcf9fa8412dca28be91d6423460233ddedd7add6c324d8a0f2b26038567d3d3"},{"align_key":"8e7fe271cd1bab88d86c8900fe3ffae0ce95c55af6659df1fca278d359296e2d","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"See "},{"kind":"xref","target":"tb49qpc","text":"Table 1"},{"kind":"text","text":" and the note."},{"kind":"cite","refs":["r3e21zr"],"text":"1"}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"mzwwhxj","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"9894a48790a8561966e68672fa13da20541d25a5178653720648f62cbc9ad36b","node_hash":"8f3e5338ba3c97efca4cef5c60d849757aed6334ee27ab807fa71d969089e46e","ord":1,"own_hash":"02ed6d50b8ac607b59e3f7b5116ee6143ed7e69af25b19c4037aa799bc330a88","parent":"ytp1e5n","text_hash":"5b1de19c9eb1399e54bde7e96f051cac8b337be1f307fac320292b8db7e39da7"},{"align_key":"282eea00b316a6950fb7179f6289a8b98359019e11cb23a3ff426cdecad90165","id":"exq1ter","kind":"paragraph","match_hash":"da88f35d24faf0099610c720953c4919647a5dfb9003889a15c464cd9c540fb1","node_hash":"062dd26bfb226ca9811d0dfb013df211cb201dfe7b4b25f9aba000f3212298d5","ord":2,"own_hash":"494e069be36a18ecaabf5a63be7c31617ade7a5460218ca83a2de3d8d8f964e0","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"da88f35d24faf0099610c720953c4919647a5dfb9003889a15c464cd9c540fb1"},{"align_key":"b8074a8bc013aa007023c4cce7334f1e1f22384d57a526ca22fd2f5589d5ab17","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"A second paragraph."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"j663d4h","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"2e8313b033de5e17878ae778d6293bbd6e197a072f36acf7fe0840a690a7f31e","node_hash":"443539440dca73149ca75276492334ce9a5a6c50070137e8dc7bf414b75a27ab","ord":0,"own_hash":"acee4b6b1399bfde1dc67dea8d8c86b0db961d2af516ae4aaee26f294261456f","parent":"exq1ter","text_hash":"2e8313b033de5e17878ae778d6293bbd6e197a072f36acf7fe0840a690a7f31e"},{"align_key":"437c101749b0481e615fc7eed8dcacb536b65400c7e0695ad4cbb2bf2dae488c","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"It ends here."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"rsw24qc","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"2888dbfa0c08fd65c58c923b920860c76e13913d9fa93b03eccbbf7bdf53b882","node_hash":"caeb3ae57d0821b8ac961c9507debbcda2b118b16cdc010b83a143a782058d57","ord":1,"own_hash":"705f77e8520c8c5ce3a7a495a20d8a9c55baa9801e49a55c341f5de79eeeLine truncated
{"before":{"ids":[],"nodes":[{"align_key":"b3108c22ec836d883e5116f7ed8546fa75390eb4aa960d78f2936115f69b6826","id":"s0fn2fj","kind":"document","match_hash":"b6a4e12f700a6214bf02c9a437559e82fccdbecea7b575fa438a7d2e8c33071a","node_hash":"a05328e6d13edba652599aceb58c018dbccf54abd1f878c9f61623017960e1fe","ord":0,"own_hash":"34444fe0e6bdbf3927a579fe3286859d204ea0882a381b7769ffd4905551d24f","parent":null,"text_hash":"bd2abc746d51cf52d57a18632383245d585e29e265426967894eed99bc937561"},{"align_key":"caf6aee3882b3890996037e35d0ffdfe30b5e66653d45321d7ea0fa9135f1ee9","attrs":{"level":1},"id":"b9wp3tt","kind":"section","label":"1","match_hash":"5a96c01f314c4d8a22fd5e105bebef45df4301886cccbc2538ecefddfcb1d405","node_hash":"ea9a1409bbf0f0f7bd8d508bfdbbf7d14a22ab1e3da011eafbfcd4e14ae7e4fd","ord":0,"own_hash":"65da097b48f8237e8d171bfbd0053ff0e3795c0532d5522d23a92b53430956f4","parent":"s0fn2fj","text_hash":"7a97628fe9643c0fca3614a077e2e631c3fee81d3733ba1564292df65a294573"},{"align_key":"c099142bc3186ded72786ba27e9ea6d2da240fb9fd3fe79b479ecf8e734b2850","id":"vet7k0e","kind":"heading","match_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd","node_hash":"a3c82ab1e44bf4cffa1a59507f8bddc39a1ad191321ee803d0d60d96609a44c7","ord":0,"own_hash":"e813ff86a8920cef741e548eb5df545774b520d2fadbdda6e2b872a6729b9d26","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd"},{"align_key":"c099142bc3186ded72786ba27e9ea6d2da240fb9fd3fe79b479ecf8e734b2850","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"Results"}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"em5pd9v","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd","node_hash":"293fc03ff4e39d7532467e4417ffcdb15f470f0bd3658dc1c021645ad53c9bef","ord":0,"own_hash":"c55f401232b19ff1133d77eac6c72868975064f177fc2d31ab8a181303c30599","parent":"vet7k0e","text_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd"},{"align_key":"610c235321e38145abff21e31eaab303d85a6ce0d1b9340a599dc821a04922f6","id":"ytp1e5n","kind":"paragraph","match_hash":"bcb4902ec69f2a7a724384f561ee9aa0e214c824c5882c1ad92777bee680aad4","node_hash":"7667a3a4bc2e8fec1dc7af53e19c414952f9ce926b1e37e8d9adca66dd8f8d1d","ord":1,"own_hash":"494e069be36a18ecaabf5a63be7c31617ade7a5460218ca83a2de3d8d8f964e0","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"f589ee914c46c4aea7ce2de49d925c433c914121f576b81a3eab692f17f179a3"},{"align_key":"8f21603c39df123eb8680362184274aac9bdf1dbd485b3bba230960179071c95","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"The value is 42.0 at 300 K."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"jvnys4s","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"3bcf9fa8412dca28be91d6423460233ddedd7add6c324d8a0f2b26038567d3d3","node_hash":"f5761f338b2878dff39a6ee724a75b13626dd625a0df96cf1cc6f9e8258cb7cc","ord":0,"own_hash":"7f0b9190d076cf01b51a8be863a51e9a8eeaab5d3ec8656202ff4d41578d4d82","parent":"ytp1e5n","text_hash":"3bcf9fa8412dca28be91d6423460233ddedd7add6c324d8a0f2b26038567d3d3"},{"align_key":"8e7fe271cd1bab88d86c8900fe3ffae0ce95c55af6659df1fca278d359296e2d","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"See "},{"kind":"xref","target":"tb49qpc","text":"Table 1"},{"kind":"text","text":" and the note."},{"kind":"cite","refs":["r3e21zr"],"text":"1"}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"mzwwhxj","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"9894a48790a8561966e68672fa13da20541d25a5178653720648f62cbc9ad36b","node_hash":"8f3e5338ba3c97efca4cef5c60d849757aed6334ee27ab807fa71d969089e46e","ord":1,"own_hash":"02ed6d50b8ac607b59e3f7b5116ee6143ed7e69af25b19c4037aa799bc330a88","parent":"ytp1e5n","text_hash":"5b1de19c9eb1399e54bde7e96f051cac8b337be1f307fac320292b8db7e39da7"},{"align_key":"282eea00b316a6950fb7179f6289a8b98359019e11cb23a3ff426cdecad90165","id":"exq1ter","kind":"paragraph","match_hash":"da88f35d24faf0099610c720953c4919647a5dfb9003889a15c464cd9c540fb1","node_hash":"062dd26bfb226ca9811d0dfb013df211cb201dfe7b4b25f9aba000f3212298d5","ord":2,"own_hash":"494e069be36a18ecaabf5a63be7c31617ade7a5460218ca83a2de3d8d8f964e0","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"da88f35d24faf0099610c720953c4919647a5dfb9003889a15c464cd9c540fb1"},{"align_key":"b8074a8bc013aa007023c4cce7334f1e1f22384d57a526ca22fd2f5589d5ab17","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"A second paragraph."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"j663d4h","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"2e8313b033de5e17878ae778d6293bbd6e197a072f36acf7fe0840a690a7f31e","node_hash":"443539440dca73149ca75276492334ce9a5a6c50070137e8dc7bf414b75a27ab","ord":0,"own_hash":"acee4b6b1399bfde1dc67dea8d8c86b0db961d2af516ae4aaee26f294261456f","parent":"exq1ter","text_hash":"2e8313b033de5e17878ae778d6293bbd6e197a072f36acf7fe0840a690a7f31e"},{"align_key":"437c101749b0481e615fc7eed8dcacb536b65400c7e0695ad4cbb2bf2dae488c","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"It ends here."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"rsw24qc","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"2888dbfa0c08fd65c58c923b920860c76e13913d9fa93b03eccbbf7bdf53b882","node_hash":"caeb3ae57d0821b8ac961c9507debbcda2b118b16cdc010b83a143a782058d57","ord":1,"own_hash":"705f77e8520c8c5ce3a7a495a20d8a9c55baa9801e49a55c341f5de79eeeLine truncated
{"before":{"ids":[],"nodes":[{"align_key":"b3108c22ec836d883e5116f7ed8546fa75390eb4aa960d78f2936115f69b6826","id":"s0fn2fj","kind":"document","match_hash":"b6a4e12f700a6214bf02c9a437559e82fccdbecea7b575fa438a7d2e8c33071a","node_hash":"a05328e6d13edba652599aceb58c018dbccf54abd1f878c9f61623017960e1fe","ord":0,"own_hash":"34444fe0e6bdbf3927a579fe3286859d204ea0882a381b7769ffd4905551d24f","parent":null,"text_hash":"bd2abc746d51cf52d57a18632383245d585e29e265426967894eed99bc937561"},{"align_key":"caf6aee3882b3890996037e35d0ffdfe30b5e66653d45321d7ea0fa9135f1ee9","attrs":{"level":1},"id":"b9wp3tt","kind":"section","label":"1","match_hash":"5a96c01f314c4d8a22fd5e105bebef45df4301886cccbc2538ecefddfcb1d405","node_hash":"ea9a1409bbf0f0f7bd8d508bfdbbf7d14a22ab1e3da011eafbfcd4e14ae7e4fd","ord":0,"own_hash":"65da097b48f8237e8d171bfbd0053ff0e3795c0532d5522d23a92b53430956f4","parent":"s0fn2fj","text_hash":"7a97628fe9643c0fca3614a077e2e631c3fee81d3733ba1564292df65a294573"},{"align_key":"c099142bc3186ded72786ba27e9ea6d2da240fb9fd3fe79b479ecf8e734b2850","id":"vet7k0e","kind":"heading","match_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd","node_hash":"a3c82ab1e44bf4cffa1a59507f8bddc39a1ad191321ee803d0d60d96609a44c7","ord":0,"own_hash":"e813ff86a8920cef741e548eb5df545774b520d2fadbdda6e2b872a6729b9d26","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd"},{"align_key":"c099142bc3186ded72786ba27e9ea6d2da240fb9fd3fe79b479ecf8e734b2850","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"Results"}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"em5pd9v","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd","node_hash":"293fc03ff4e39d7532467e4417ffcdb15f470f0bd3658dc1c021645ad53c9bef","ord":0,"own_hash":"c55f401232b19ff1133d77eac6c72868975064f177fc2d31ab8a181303c30599","parent":"vet7k0e","text_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd"},{"align_key":"610c235321e38145abff21e31eaab303d85a6ce0d1b9340a599dc821a04922f6","id":"ytp1e5n","kind":"paragraph","match_hash":"bcb4902ec69f2a7a724384f561ee9aa0e214c824c5882c1ad92777bee680aad4","node_hash":"7667a3a4bc2e8fec1dc7af53e19c414952f9ce926b1e37e8d9adca66dd8f8d1d","ord":1,"own_hash":"494e069be36a18ecaabf5a63be7c31617ade7a5460218ca83a2de3d8d8f964e0","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"f589ee914c46c4aea7ce2de49d925c433c914121f576b81a3eab692f17f179a3"},{"align_key":"8f21603c39df123eb8680362184274aac9bdf1dbd485b3bba230960179071c95","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"The value is 42.0 at 300 K."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"jvnys4s","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"3bcf9fa8412dca28be91d6423460233ddedd7add6c324d8a0f2b26038567d3d3","node_hash":"f5761f338b2878dff39a6ee724a75b13626dd625a0df96cf1cc6f9e8258cb7cc","ord":0,"own_hash":"7f0b9190d076cf01b51a8be863a51e9a8eeaab5d3ec8656202ff4d41578d4d82","parent":"ytp1e5n","text_hash":"3bcf9fa8412dca28be91d6423460233ddedd7add6c324d8a0f2b26038567d3d3"},{"align_key":"8e7fe271cd1bab88d86c8900fe3ffae0ce95c55af6659df1fca278d359296e2d","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"See "},{"kind":"xref","target":"tb49qpc","text":"Table 1"},{"kind":"text","text":" and the note."},{"kind":"cite","refs":["r3e21zr"],"text":"1"}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"mzwwhxj","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"9894a48790a8561966e68672fa13da20541d25a5178653720648f62cbc9ad36b","node_hash":"8f3e5338ba3c97efca4cef5c60d849757aed6334ee27ab807fa71d969089e46e","ord":1,"own_hash":"02ed6d50b8ac607b59e3f7b5116ee6143ed7e69af25b19c4037aa799bc330a88","parent":"ytp1e5n","text_hash":"5b1de19c9eb1399e54bde7e96f051cac8b337be1f307fac320292b8db7e39da7"},{"align_key":"282eea00b316a6950fb7179f6289a8b98359019e11cb23a3ff426cdecad90165","id":"exq1ter","kind":"paragraph","match_hash":"da88f35d24faf0099610c720953c4919647a5dfb9003889a15c464cd9c540fb1","node_hash":"062dd26bfb226ca9811d0dfb013df211cb201dfe7b4b25f9aba000f3212298d5","ord":2,"own_hash":"494e069be36a18ecaabf5a63be7c31617ade7a5460218ca83a2de3d8d8f964e0","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"da88f35d24faf0099610c720953c4919647a5dfb9003889a15c464cd9c540fb1"},{"align_key":"b8074a8bc013aa007023c4cce7334f1e1f22384d57a526ca22fd2f5589d5ab17","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"A second paragraph."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"j663d4h","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"2e8313b033de5e17878ae778d6293bbd6e197a072f36acf7fe0840a690a7f31e","node_hash":"443539440dca73149ca75276492334ce9a5a6c50070137e8dc7bf414b75a27ab","ord":0,"own_hash":"acee4b6b1399bfde1dc67dea8d8c86b0db961d2af516ae4aaee26f294261456f","parent":"exq1ter","text_hash":"2e8313b033de5e17878ae778d6293bbd6e197a072f36acf7fe0840a690a7f31e"},{"align_key":"437c101749b0481e615fc7eed8dcacb536b65400c7e0695ad4cbb2bf2dae488c","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"It ends here."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"rsw24qc","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"2888dbfa0c08fd65c58c923b920860c76e13913d9fa93b03eccbbf7bdf53b882","node_hash":"caeb3ae57d0821b8ac961c9507debbcda2b118b16cdc010b83a143a782058d57","ord":1,"own_hash":"705f77e8520c8c5ce3a7a495a20d8a9c55baa9801e49a55c341f5de79eeeLine truncated
{"before":{"ids":[],"nodes":[{"align_key":"b3108c22ec836d883e5116f7ed8546fa75390eb4aa960d78f2936115f69b6826","id":"s0fn2fj","kind":"document","match_hash":"b6a4e12f700a6214bf02c9a437559e82fccdbecea7b575fa438a7d2e8c33071a","node_hash":"a05328e6d13edba652599aceb58c018dbccf54abd1f878c9f61623017960e1fe","ord":0,"own_hash":"34444fe0e6bdbf3927a579fe3286859d204ea0882a381b7769ffd4905551d24f","parent":null,"text_hash":"bd2abc746d51cf52d57a18632383245d585e29e265426967894eed99bc937561"},{"align_key":"caf6aee3882b3890996037e35d0ffdfe30b5e66653d45321d7ea0fa9135f1ee9","attrs":{"level":1},"id":"b9wp3tt","kind":"section","label":"1","match_hash":"5a96c01f314c4d8a22fd5e105bebef45df4301886cccbc2538ecefddfcb1d405","node_hash":"ea9a1409bbf0f0f7bd8d508bfdbbf7d14a22ab1e3da011eafbfcd4e14ae7e4fd","ord":0,"own_hash":"65da097b48f8237e8d171bfbd0053ff0e3795c0532d5522d23a92b53430956f4","parent":"s0fn2fj","text_hash":"7a97628fe9643c0fca3614a077e2e631c3fee81d3733ba1564292df65a294573"},{"align_key":"c099142bc3186ded72786ba27e9ea6d2da240fb9fd3fe79b479ecf8e734b2850","id":"vet7k0e","kind":"heading","match_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd","node_hash":"a3c82ab1e44bf4cffa1a59507f8bddc39a1ad191321ee803d0d60d96609a44c7","ord":0,"own_hash":"e813ff86a8920cef741e548eb5df545774b520d2fadbdda6e2b872a6729b9d26","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd"},{"align_key":"c099142bc3186ded72786ba27e9ea6d2da240fb9fd3fe79b479ecf8e734b2850","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"Results"}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"em5pd9v","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd","node_hash":"293fc03ff4e39d7532467e4417ffcdb15f470f0bd3658dc1c021645ad53c9bef","ord":0,"own_hash":"c55f401232b19ff1133d77eac6c72868975064f177fc2d31ab8a181303c30599","parent":"vet7k0e","text_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd"},{"align_key":"610c235321e38145abff21e31eaab303d85a6ce0d1b9340a599dc821a04922f6","id":"ytp1e5n","kind":"paragraph","match_hash":"bcb4902ec69f2a7a724384f561ee9aa0e214c824c5882c1ad92777bee680aad4","node_hash":"7667a3a4bc2e8fec1dc7af53e19c414952f9ce926b1e37e8d9adca66dd8f8d1d","ord":1,"own_hash":"494e069be36a18ecaabf5a63be7c31617ade7a5460218ca83a2de3d8d8f964e0","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"f589ee914c46c4aea7ce2de49d925c433c914121f576b81a3eab692f17f179a3"},{"align_key":"8f21603c39df123eb8680362184274aac9bdf1dbd485b3bba230960179071c95","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"The value is 42.0 at 300 K."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"jvnys4s","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"3bcf9fa8412dca28be91d6423460233ddedd7add6c324d8a0f2b26038567d3d3","node_hash":"f5761f338b2878dff39a6ee724a75b13626dd625a0df96cf1cc6f9e8258cb7cc","ord":0,"own_hash":"7f0b9190d076cf01b51a8be863a51e9a8eeaab5d3ec8656202ff4d41578d4d82","parent":"ytp1e5n","text_hash":"3bcf9fa8412dca28be91d6423460233ddedd7add6c324d8a0f2b26038567d3d3"},{"align_key":"8e7fe271cd1bab88d86c8900fe3ffae0ce95c55af6659df1fca278d359296e2d","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"See "},{"kind":"xref","target":"tb49qpc","text":"Table 1"},{"kind":"text","text":" and the note."},{"kind":"cite","refs":["r3e21zr"],"text":"1"}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"mzwwhxj","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"9894a48790a8561966e68672fa13da20541d25a5178653720648f62cbc9ad36b","node_hash":"8f3e5338ba3c97efca4cef5c60d849757aed6334ee27ab807fa71d969089e46e","ord":1,"own_hash":"02ed6d50b8ac607b59e3f7b5116ee6143ed7e69af25b19c4037aa799bc330a88","parent":"ytp1e5n","text_hash":"5b1de19c9eb1399e54bde7e96f051cac8b337be1f307fac320292b8db7e39da7"},{"align_key":"282eea00b316a6950fb7179f6289a8b98359019e11cb23a3ff426cdecad90165","id":"exq1ter","kind":"paragraph","match_hash":"da88f35d24faf0099610c720953c4919647a5dfb9003889a15c464cd9c540fb1","node_hash":"062dd26bfb226ca9811d0dfb013df211cb201dfe7b4b25f9aba000f3212298d5","ord":2,"own_hash":"494e069be36a18ecaabf5a63be7c31617ade7a5460218ca83a2de3d8d8f964e0","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"da88f35d24faf0099610c720953c4919647a5dfb9003889a15c464cd9c540fb1"},{"align_key":"b8074a8bc013aa007023c4cce7334f1e1f22384d57a526ca22fd2f5589d5ab17","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"A second paragraph."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"j663d4h","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"2e8313b033de5e17878ae778d6293bbd6e197a072f36acf7fe0840a690a7f31e","node_hash":"443539440dca73149ca75276492334ce9a5a6c50070137e8dc7bf414b75a27ab","ord":0,"own_hash":"acee4b6b1399bfde1dc67dea8d8c86b0db961d2af516ae4aaee26f294261456f","parent":"exq1ter","text_hash":"2e8313b033de5e17878ae778d6293bbd6e197a072f36acf7fe0840a690a7f31e"},{"align_key":"437c101749b0481e615fc7eed8dcacb536b65400c7e0695ad4cbb2bf2dae488c","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"It ends here."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"rsw24qc","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"2888dbfa0c08fd65c58c923b920860c76e13913d9fa93b03eccbbf7bdf53b882","node_hash":"caeb3ae57d0821b8ac961c9507debbcda2b118b16cdc010b83a143a782058d57","ord":1,"own_hash":"705f77e8520c8c5ce3a7a495a20d8a9c55baa9801e49a55c341f5de79eeeLine truncated
{"before":{"ids":[],"nodes":[{"align_key":"b3108c22ec836d883e5116f7ed8546fa75390eb4aa960d78f2936115f69b6826","id":"s0fn2fj","kind":"document","match_hash":"e5c0a8bc46dcfaa863a8b1b8b47cf1ce17f92fbe843c24809efe7bc06c61dd36","node_hash":"5122d3f8f1b589e14b4530d46015d6855a3f2271a6beafe2c289f35fe88d08bc","ord":0,"own_hash":"34444fe0e6bdbf3927a579fe3286859d204ea0882a381b7769ffd4905551d24f","parent":null,"text_hash":"230751a057cfb05c90472d0519b1494bceb8e97935b0bb25d2c84f5df88d5bd3"},{"align_key":"caf6aee3882b3890996037e35d0ffdfe30b5e66653d45321d7ea0fa9135f1ee9","attrs":{"level":1},"id":"b9wp3tt","kind":"section","label":"1","match_hash":"6ed7a9811ba0ea36c025e36e27cb8217983db65052156998b8420fb7393e7676","node_hash":"58c71d717603ddfe949573ab616b9c58910e72632951f8d2485fa1212259500a","ord":0,"own_hash":"65da097b48f8237e8d171bfbd0053ff0e3795c0532d5522d23a92b53430956f4","parent":"s0fn2fj","text_hash":"9181fb7a9952168f1abc94771d7101fa4563403432448094f8f5f0532f093a9b"},{"align_key":"c099142bc3186ded72786ba27e9ea6d2da240fb9fd3fe79b479ecf8e734b2850","id":"vet7k0e","kind":"heading","match_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd","node_hash":"a3c82ab1e44bf4cffa1a59507f8bddc39a1ad191321ee803d0d60d96609a44c7","ord":0,"own_hash":"e813ff86a8920cef741e548eb5df545774b520d2fadbdda6e2b872a6729b9d26","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd"},{"align_key":"c099142bc3186ded72786ba27e9ea6d2da240fb9fd3fe79b479ecf8e734b2850","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"Results"}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"em5pd9v","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd","node_hash":"293fc03ff4e39d7532467e4417ffcdb15f470f0bd3658dc1c021645ad53c9bef","ord":0,"own_hash":"c55f401232b19ff1133d77eac6c72868975064f177fc2d31ab8a181303c30599","parent":"vet7k0e","text_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd"},{"align_key":"610c235321e38145abff21e31eaab303d85a6ce0d1b9340a599dc821a04922f6","id":"ytp1e5n","kind":"paragraph","match_hash":"780246e820ddb4784bee63ad5f3c049e9cfad6c761b7e75981826004bb3952b9","node_hash":"a5336a0ec43455f6077c8fa5d166240b79a677bd3fc8f12f2934ce43951c83e0","ord":1,"own_hash":"494e069be36a18ecaabf5a63be7c31617ade7a5460218ca83a2de3d8d8f964e0","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"ffcfd4089d7a6bf62d23c41c1e99db8a44a1e2f7c45c1af93986f55a5464afa9"},{"align_key":"8f21603c39df123eb8680362184274aac9bdf1dbd485b3bba230960179071c95","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"The value is 42.0 at "},{"kind":"math","notation":"tex","source":"300\\,\\mathrm{K}"},{"kind":"text","text":"."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"jvnys4s","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"f506115d79413340915fbd30daadfefe57d9e44e01ecb19401d78e8b77b04a13","node_hash":"f021a9d2435fcf11eb1babafeaec52991d37c997d4ca312d50a58bc18ab10d74","ord":0,"own_hash":"b4a20ac47e1a725076b316d9fb8822d09b6a0eabc1218eb2e826999ecbed53bb","parent":"ytp1e5n","text_hash":"f3ee4cc22182a9b3809ef1bf269dbad11ba7c93835503d96b2ed97cf9d142501"},{"align_key":"8e7fe271cd1bab88d86c8900fe3ffae0ce95c55af6659df1fca278d359296e2d","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"See "},{"kind":"xref","target":"tb49qpc","text":"Table 1"},{"kind":"text","text":" and the note."},{"kind":"cite","refs":["r3e21zr"],"text":"1"}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"mzwwhxj","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"9894a48790a8561966e68672fa13da20541d25a5178653720648f62cbc9ad36b","node_hash":"8f3e5338ba3c97efca4cef5c60d849757aed6334ee27ab807fa71d969089e46e","ord":1,"own_hash":"02ed6d50b8ac607b59e3f7b5116ee6143ed7e69af25b19c4037aa799bc330a88","parent":"ytp1e5n","text_hash":"5b1de19c9eb1399e54bde7e96f051cac8b337be1f307fac320292b8db7e39da7"},{"align_key":"282eea00b316a6950fb7179f6289a8b98359019e11cb23a3ff426cdecad90165","id":"exq1ter","kind":"paragraph","match_hash":"da88f35d24faf0099610c720953c4919647a5dfb9003889a15c464cd9c540fb1","node_hash":"062dd26bfb226ca9811d0dfb013df211cb201dfe7b4b25f9aba000f3212298d5","ord":2,"own_hash":"494e069be36a18ecaabf5a63be7c31617ade7a5460218ca83a2de3d8d8f964e0","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"da88f35d24faf0099610c720953c4919647a5dfb9003889a15c464cd9c540fb1"},{"align_key":"b8074a8bc013aa007023c4cce7334f1e1f22384d57a526ca22fd2f5589d5ab17","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"A second paragraph."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"j663d4h","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"2e8313b033de5e17878ae778d6293bbd6e197a072f36acf7fe0840a690a7f31e","node_hash":"443539440dca73149ca75276492334ce9a5a6c50070137e8dc7bf414b75a27ab","ord":0,"own_hash":"acee4b6b1399bfde1dc67dea8d8c86b0db961d2af516ae4aaee26f294261456f","parent":"exq1ter","text_hash":"2e8313b033de5e17878ae778d6293bbd6e197a072f36acf7fe0840a690a7f31e"},{"align_key":"437c101749b0481e615fc7eed8dcacb536b65400c7e0695ad4cbb2bf2dae488c","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"It ends here."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"rsw24qc","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"2888dbfa0c08fd65c58c923b920860c76e13913d9fa93b03eccbbf7bdf53b882","node_hash":"caeb3ae57d0821b8ac961c9507debbcda2b118b16cdc010b83a143a782058d5Line truncated
{"before":{"ids":[],"nodes":[{"align_key":"11eb11ac2d23695dca023e35025f59acb852174904364fb90cd4672fbfef374d","id":"s0fn2fj","kind":"document","match_hash":"4350229410af5761b6b1591853e92e45554cf68fe4c944829bd940bd32ac76df","node_hash":"2a48b6d579d3bdf928e7f941cdf38221b473fc28546a670d05dc63eecd71bfcf","ord":0,"own_hash":"34444fe0e6bdbf3927a579fe3286859d204ea0882a381b7769ffd4905551d24f","parent":null,"text_hash":"945ba1a25a52cb1770901c2057a949eee8d5f7ded4b8ad2c5c420f1f793578b4"},{"align_key":"ee038a9c75d18280999c0508755c8384044e115f66fddcf14f8f5a3948579145","attrs":{"level":1},"id":"b9wp3tt","kind":"section","label":"1","match_hash":"aaa6deb4d867035b0b647a335d75cdf1fca82ed2f4bc27ed9bf14b32bdfd064a","node_hash":"492693344303f7ad12326819797b1c15581fe17d5e3b81ec55ce0c7855eedb02","ord":0,"own_hash":"65da097b48f8237e8d171bfbd0053ff0e3795c0532d5522d23a92b53430956f4","parent":"s0fn2fj","text_hash":"2c147532ee174efc4c585df2dec1e4acf9a6d37c5df758db8edcd6c030b1961a"},{"align_key":"c099142bc3186ded72786ba27e9ea6d2da240fb9fd3fe79b479ecf8e734b2850","id":"vet7k0e","kind":"heading","match_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd","node_hash":"a3c82ab1e44bf4cffa1a59507f8bddc39a1ad191321ee803d0d60d96609a44c7","ord":0,"own_hash":"e813ff86a8920cef741e548eb5df545774b520d2fadbdda6e2b872a6729b9d26","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd"},{"align_key":"c099142bc3186ded72786ba27e9ea6d2da240fb9fd3fe79b479ecf8e734b2850","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"Results"}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"em5pd9v","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd","node_hash":"293fc03ff4e39d7532467e4417ffcdb15f470f0bd3658dc1c021645ad53c9bef","ord":0,"own_hash":"c55f401232b19ff1133d77eac6c72868975064f177fc2d31ab8a181303c30599","parent":"vet7k0e","text_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd"},{"align_key":"2fe6056823c87aea4e9638a2383985c945277290c6879c208e6b1081cfc260d6","id":"ytp1e5n","kind":"paragraph","match_hash":"11d1a247abea0f3a8d1c56b70584845a3276ec0a8bef8cb3c75efc56a4b3a559","node_hash":"284d314b4e4bfd001174c0e9e799a5d5cbc8094532227c284746d6f63dc05a06","ord":1,"own_hash":"494e069be36a18ecaabf5a63be7c31617ade7a5460218ca83a2de3d8d8f964e0","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"f5b3bc994139fc4ed899ad1672657f4a4717bc9ee7318ca51ec8ad1de835b3e4"},{"align_key":"0bc78bda8179e12373db6f92036ace49f2d4f28165be546d2f00871776ab6068","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"The value is 42.0 at 300 K."},{"kind":"text","style":["sup"],"text":"1"}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"jvnys4s","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"863796400802ab99888ed706bc895827e262075c9a04f06b5dee2df4b4293c30","node_hash":"017d8ae1e071c2edf742ec8dd4404422c6a069ba7724afd7a244d2c7665cb3e7","ord":0,"own_hash":"d47eaec1b67d582bbdfbdda564b2d948e37d644bc30958ce25176d986ce4d6b8","parent":"ytp1e5n","text_hash":"9315981cf22af97a60bef1e8d7e2249ae311fddebb784d9149b6cd868fad7762"},{"align_key":"8e7fe271cd1bab88d86c8900fe3ffae0ce95c55af6659df1fca278d359296e2d","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"See "},{"kind":"xref","target":"tb49qpc","text":"Table 1"},{"kind":"text","text":" and the note."},{"kind":"cite","refs":["r3e21zr"],"text":"1"}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"mzwwhxj","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"9894a48790a8561966e68672fa13da20541d25a5178653720648f62cbc9ad36b","node_hash":"8f3e5338ba3c97efca4cef5c60d849757aed6334ee27ab807fa71d969089e46e","ord":1,"own_hash":"02ed6d50b8ac607b59e3f7b5116ee6143ed7e69af25b19c4037aa799bc330a88","parent":"ytp1e5n","text_hash":"5b1de19c9eb1399e54bde7e96f051cac8b337be1f307fac320292b8db7e39da7"},{"align_key":"282eea00b316a6950fb7179f6289a8b98359019e11cb23a3ff426cdecad90165","id":"exq1ter","kind":"paragraph","match_hash":"da88f35d24faf0099610c720953c4919647a5dfb9003889a15c464cd9c540fb1","node_hash":"062dd26bfb226ca9811d0dfb013df211cb201dfe7b4b25f9aba000f3212298d5","ord":2,"own_hash":"494e069be36a18ecaabf5a63be7c31617ade7a5460218ca83a2de3d8d8f964e0","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"da88f35d24faf0099610c720953c4919647a5dfb9003889a15c464cd9c540fb1"},{"align_key":"b8074a8bc013aa007023c4cce7334f1e1f22384d57a526ca22fd2f5589d5ab17","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"A second paragraph."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"j663d4h","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"2e8313b033de5e17878ae778d6293bbd6e197a072f36acf7fe0840a690a7f31e","node_hash":"443539440dca73149ca75276492334ce9a5a6c50070137e8dc7bf414b75a27ab","ord":0,"own_hash":"acee4b6b1399bfde1dc67dea8d8c86b0db961d2af516ae4aaee26f294261456f","parent":"exq1ter","text_hash":"2e8313b033de5e17878ae778d6293bbd6e197a072f36acf7fe0840a690a7f31e"},{"align_key":"437c101749b0481e615fc7eed8dcacb536b65400c7e0695ad4cbb2bf2dae488c","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"It ends here."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"rsw24qc","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"2888dbfa0c08fd65c58c923b920860c76e13913d9fa93b03eccbbf7bdf53b882","node_hash":"caeb3ae57d0821b8ac961c9507debbcda2b118b16cdc010b83a143a782058d57","ord":1,"own_hash":"705f77e8520c8c5ceLine truncated
{"before":{"ids":[],"nodes":[{"align_key":"b3108c22ec836d883e5116f7ed8546fa75390eb4aa960d78f2936115f69b6826","id":"s0fn2fj","kind":"document","match_hash":"b6a4e12f700a6214bf02c9a437559e82fccdbecea7b575fa438a7d2e8c33071a","node_hash":"0e8aa6783398f823cfa0bb6a5e2cfdb477d34898ec26c8304e832bab48f9c5a2","ord":0,"own_hash":"34444fe0e6bdbf3927a579fe3286859d204ea0882a381b7769ffd4905551d24f","parent":null,"text_hash":"ea60d5078913fb304ea40102d1620ece2cd7f02a5f6fa35eebf408dec44f1d50"},{"align_key":"caf6aee3882b3890996037e35d0ffdfe30b5e66653d45321d7ea0fa9135f1ee9","attrs":{"level":1},"id":"b9wp3tt","kind":"section","label":"1","match_hash":"5a96c01f314c4d8a22fd5e105bebef45df4301886cccbc2538ecefddfcb1d405","node_hash":"dcc8a86f0d3e0e19559ef178b1e18960236dd0aa7e00b4b43d99210641bec856","ord":0,"own_hash":"65da097b48f8237e8d171bfbd0053ff0e3795c0532d5522d23a92b53430956f4","parent":"s0fn2fj","text_hash":"d2ae4e404ae4d37bec56ebc35d0bdf7d2ca9f06e08241206d4b6e0c493adab46"},{"align_key":"c099142bc3186ded72786ba27e9ea6d2da240fb9fd3fe79b479ecf8e734b2850","id":"vet7k0e","kind":"heading","match_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd","node_hash":"a3c82ab1e44bf4cffa1a59507f8bddc39a1ad191321ee803d0d60d96609a44c7","ord":0,"own_hash":"e813ff86a8920cef741e548eb5df545774b520d2fadbdda6e2b872a6729b9d26","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd"},{"align_key":"c099142bc3186ded72786ba27e9ea6d2da240fb9fd3fe79b479ecf8e734b2850","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"Results"}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"em5pd9v","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd","node_hash":"293fc03ff4e39d7532467e4417ffcdb15f470f0bd3658dc1c021645ad53c9bef","ord":0,"own_hash":"c55f401232b19ff1133d77eac6c72868975064f177fc2d31ab8a181303c30599","parent":"vet7k0e","text_hash":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd"},{"align_key":"610c235321e38145abff21e31eaab303d85a6ce0d1b9340a599dc821a04922f6","id":"ytp1e5n","kind":"paragraph","match_hash":"bcb4902ec69f2a7a724384f561ee9aa0e214c824c5882c1ad92777bee680aad4","node_hash":"07e5c84b755df3323b525a3d0619c73b2866bfbe1aa734076cbee2390ac10c21","ord":1,"own_hash":"494e069be36a18ecaabf5a63be7c31617ade7a5460218ca83a2de3d8d8f964e0","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"9f8d0d851f45cd9fa00f36f5ff388a4189109506b5cb3a461cf00619c2dade5b"},{"align_key":"8f21603c39df123eb8680362184274aac9bdf1dbd485b3bba230960179071c95","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"The value is 42.0 at 300 K."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"jvnys4s","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"3bcf9fa8412dca28be91d6423460233ddedd7add6c324d8a0f2b26038567d3d3","node_hash":"f5761f338b2878dff39a6ee724a75b13626dd625a0df96cf1cc6f9e8258cb7cc","ord":0,"own_hash":"7f0b9190d076cf01b51a8be863a51e9a8eeaab5d3ec8656202ff4d41578d4d82","parent":"ytp1e5n","text_hash":"3bcf9fa8412dca28be91d6423460233ddedd7add6c324d8a0f2b26038567d3d3"},{"align_key":"8e7fe271cd1bab88d86c8900fe3ffae0ce95c55af6659df1fca278d359296e2d","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"See "},{"kind":"xref","target":"tb49qpc","text":"Table 1"},{"kind":"text","text":" and "},{"kind":"text","printed":"the note","text":"the notes"},{"kind":"text","text":"."},{"kind":"cite","refs":["r3e21zr"],"text":"1"}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"mzwwhxj","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"9894a48790a8561966e68672fa13da20541d25a5178653720648f62cbc9ad36b","node_hash":"2f3fd0a30be375e5eeebfc445e673ffeeb4476b2271360a07d3aeb41a4459e8e","ord":1,"own_hash":"b218242ecf849bd9c494c6009def139e7426a55d7bc7f95a3ec5d7f05ed8eed2","parent":"ytp1e5n","text_hash":"4b221cb1e8bfe5197b1126ed2f716320e3b839bd58eeb4ba26d31d1a80b6362d"},{"align_key":"282eea00b316a6950fb7179f6289a8b98359019e11cb23a3ff426cdecad90165","id":"exq1ter","kind":"paragraph","match_hash":"da88f35d24faf0099610c720953c4919647a5dfb9003889a15c464cd9c540fb1","node_hash":"062dd26bfb226ca9811d0dfb013df211cb201dfe7b4b25f9aba000f3212298d5","ord":2,"own_hash":"494e069be36a18ecaabf5a63be7c31617ade7a5460218ca83a2de3d8d8f964e0","parent":"b9wp3tt","text_hash":"da88f35d24faf0099610c720953c4919647a5dfb9003889a15c464cd9c540fb1"},{"align_key":"b8074a8bc013aa007023c4cce7334f1e1f22384d57a526ca22fd2f5589d5ab17","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"A second paragraph."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"j663d4h","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"2e8313b033de5e17878ae778d6293bbd6e197a072f36acf7fe0840a690a7f31e","node_hash":"443539440dca73149ca75276492334ce9a5a6c50070137e8dc7bf414b75a27ab","ord":0,"own_hash":"acee4b6b1399bfde1dc67dea8d8c86b0db961d2af516ae4aaee26f294261456f","parent":"exq1ter","text_hash":"2e8313b033de5e17878ae778d6293bbd6e197a072f36acf7fe0840a690a7f31e"},{"align_key":"437c101749b0481e615fc7eed8dcacb536b65400c7e0695ad4cbb2bf2dae488c","content":[{"kind":"text","text":"It ends here."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"rsw24qc","kind":"sentence","match_hash":"2888dbfa0c08fd65c58c923b920860c76e13913d9fa93b03eccbbf7bdf53b882","node_hash":"caeb3ae57d0821b8ac961c9507debbcda2b118b16cdc010b83a143a782058d57","ord":Line truncated
+1
View File
@@ -1 +1,2 @@
{"doc":"tiny2026tiny-j4qm","id":"tiny2026example","nodes":[{"id":"s0fn2fj","kind":"document","ord":0,"parent":null},{"attrs":{"level":1},"id":"b9wp3tt","kind":"section","label":"1","ord":0,"parent":"s0fn2fj"},{"id":"vet7k0e","kind":"heading","ord":0,"parent":"b9wp3tt"},{"content":[{"kind":"text","text":"Results"}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"em5pd9v","kind":"sentence","ord":0,"parent":"vet7k0e"},{"id":"ytp1e5n","kind":"paragraph","ord":1,"parent":"b9wp3tt"},{"content":[{"kind":"text","text":"The value is 42.0 at 300 K."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"jvnys4s","kind":"sentence","ord":0,"parent":"ytp1e5n"},{"content":[{"kind":"text","text":"See "},{"kind":"xref","target":"tb49qpc","text":"Table 1"},{"kind":"text","text":" and the note."},{"kind":"cite","refs":["r3e21zr"],"text":"1"}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"mzwwhxj","kind":"sentence","ord":1,"parent":"ytp1e5n"},{"id":"exq1ter","kind":"paragraph","ord":2,"parent":"b9wp3tt"},{"content":[{"kind":"text","text":"A second paragraph."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"j663d4h","kind":"sentence","ord":0,"parent":"exq1ter"},{"content":[{"kind":"text","text":"It ends here."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"rsw24qc","kind":"sentence","ord":1,"parent":"exq1ter"},{"attrs":{"columns":[{"header_path":["af5b51r"],"id":"pj5sk05"},{"header_path":["ajqxkgh"],"id":"nymcs5q"}]},"id":"tb49qpc","kind":"table","label":"Table 1","ord":3,"parent":"b9wp3tt"},{"id":"t2ps2mp","kind":"table-head","ord":0,"parent":"tb49qpc"},{"id":"rr9rtf5","kind":"row","ord":0,"parent":"t2ps2mp"},{"attrs":{"colspan":1,"column":"pj5sk05","role":"column-header","rowspan":1},"content":[{"kind":"text","text":"x"}],"fidelity":"F1","id":"af5b51r","kind":"cell","ord":0,"parent":"rr9rtf5"},{"attrs":{"colspan":1,"column":"nymcs5q","role":"column-header","rowspan":1},"content":[{"kind":"text","text":"y"}],"fidelity":"F1","id":"ajqxkgh","kind":"cell","ord":1,"parent":"rr9rtf5"},{"id":"dmsstkg","kind":"table-body","ord":1,"parent":"tb49qpc"},{"attrs":{"header_path":["rdrqkv7"]},"id":"r3e7hfs","kind":"row","ord":0,"parent":"dmsstkg"},{"attrs":{"colspan":1,"column":"pj5sk05","role":"row-header","rowspan":1},"content":[{"kind":"text","text":"1"}],"fidelity":"F1","id":"rdrqkv7","kind":"cell","ord":0,"parent":"r3e7hfs"},{"attrs":{"colspan":1,"column":"nymcs5q","role":"data","rowspan":1},"content":[{"kind":"text","text":"2.5"}],"fidelity":"F1","id":"f463wj7","kind":"cell","ord":1,"parent":"r3e7hfs"},{"id":"aw97y35","kind":"back","ord":1,"parent":"s0fn2fj"},{"id":"yd513mw","kind":"references","ord":0,"parent":"aw97y35"},{"content":[{"kind":"text","text":"1. An Example, 2020."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"r3e21zr","kind":"reference","label":"1","ord":0,"parent":"yd513mw"}],"own_content":{"af5b51r":{"colspan":1,"column":"pj5sk05","kind":"cell","role":"column-header","rowspan":1,"runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"x"}]},"ajqxkgh":{"colspan":1,"column":"nymcs5q","kind":"cell","role":"column-header","rowspan":1,"runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"y"}]},"aw97y35":{"kind":"back"},"b9wp3tt":{"heading":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd","kind":"section","label":"1","level":1},"dmsstkg":{"kind":"table-body"},"em5pd9v":{"kind":"sentence","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"Results"}]},"exq1ter":{"kind":"paragraph"},"f463wj7":{"colspan":1,"column":"nymcs5q","kind":"cell","role":"data","rowspan":1,"runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"2.5"}]},"j663d4h":{"kind":"sentence","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"A second paragraph."}]},"jvnys4s":{"kind":"sentence","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"The value is 42.0 at 300 K."}]},"mzwwhxj":{"kind":"sentence","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"See "},{"kind":"xref","target":"tb49qpc","text":"Table 1"},{"kind":"text","text":" and the note."},{"kind":"cite","refs":["r3e21zr"],"text":"1"}]},"r3e21zr":{"kind":"reference","label":"1","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"1. An Example, 2020."}]},"r3e7hfs":{"kind":"row"},"rdrqkv7":{"colspan":1,"column":"pj5sk05","kind":"cell","role":"row-header","rowspan":1,"runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"1"}]},"rr9rtf5":{"kind":"row"},"rsw24qc":{"kind":"sentence","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"It ends here."}]},"s0fn2fj":{"kind":"document"},"t2ps2mp":{"kind":"table-head"},"tb49qpc":{"columns":[{"header_path":["af5b51r"],"id":"pj5sk05"},{"header_path":["ajqxkgh"],"id":"nymcs5q"}],"kind":"table","label":"Table 1"},"vet7k0e":{"kind":"heading"},"yd513mw":{"kind":"references"},"ytp1e5n":{"kind":"paragraph"}},"values":{"af5b51r":{"align_key":"2d711642b726b04401627ca9fbac32f5c8530fb1903cc4db02258717921a4881","match_hash":"2d711642b726b04401627ca9fbac32f5c8530fb1903cc4db02258717921a4881","node_hash":"59d1c20766a77bacde2aae80a134c7156fbcc708c140a3bb2d2a67f78bd9c6f5","own_hash":"c68933b07bc7c5b806892ae36b3e4c3205a0a2066fd6f8255578f7d1ca86dc10","text_hash":"2d711642b726b04401627ca9fbac32f5c8530fb1903cc4db02258717921a4881"},"ajqxkgh":{"align_key":"a1fce4363854ff888cff4b8e7875d600c2682390412a8cf79b37d0b11148b0fa","match_hash":"a1fce4363854ff888cff4b8e7875d600c2682390412a8cf79b37d0b11148b0fa","node_hash":"838e3fba38f0797d40522Line truncated {"doc":"tiny2026tiny-j4qm","id":"tiny2026example","nodes":[{"id":"s0fn2fj","kind":"document","ord":0,"parent":null},{"attrs":{"level":1},"id":"b9wp3tt","kind":"section","label":"1","ord":0,"parent":"s0fn2fj"},{"id":"vet7k0e","kind":"heading","ord":0,"parent":"b9wp3tt"},{"content":[{"kind":"text","text":"Results"}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"em5pd9v","kind":"sentence","ord":0,"parent":"vet7k0e"},{"id":"ytp1e5n","kind":"paragraph","ord":1,"parent":"b9wp3tt"},{"content":[{"kind":"text","text":"The value is 42.0 at 300 K."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"jvnys4s","kind":"sentence","ord":0,"parent":"ytp1e5n"},{"content":[{"kind":"text","text":"See "},{"kind":"xref","target":"tb49qpc","text":"Table 1"},{"kind":"text","text":" and the note."},{"kind":"cite","refs":["r3e21zr"],"text":"1"}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"mzwwhxj","kind":"sentence","ord":1,"parent":"ytp1e5n"},{"id":"exq1ter","kind":"paragraph","ord":2,"parent":"b9wp3tt"},{"content":[{"kind":"text","text":"A second paragraph."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"j663d4h","kind":"sentence","ord":0,"parent":"exq1ter"},{"content":[{"kind":"text","text":"It ends here."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"rsw24qc","kind":"sentence","ord":1,"parent":"exq1ter"},{"attrs":{"columns":[{"header_path":["af5b51r"],"id":"pj5sk05"},{"header_path":["ajqxkgh"],"id":"nymcs5q"}]},"id":"tb49qpc","kind":"table","label":"Table 1","ord":3,"parent":"b9wp3tt"},{"id":"t2ps2mp","kind":"table-head","ord":0,"parent":"tb49qpc"},{"id":"rr9rtf5","kind":"row","ord":0,"parent":"t2ps2mp"},{"attrs":{"colspan":1,"column":"pj5sk05","role":"column-header","rowspan":1},"content":[{"kind":"text","text":"x"}],"fidelity":"F1","id":"af5b51r","kind":"cell","ord":0,"parent":"rr9rtf5"},{"attrs":{"colspan":1,"column":"nymcs5q","role":"column-header","rowspan":1},"content":[{"kind":"text","text":"y"}],"fidelity":"F1","id":"ajqxkgh","kind":"cell","ord":1,"parent":"rr9rtf5"},{"id":"dmsstkg","kind":"table-body","ord":1,"parent":"tb49qpc"},{"attrs":{"header_path":["rdrqkv7"]},"id":"r3e7hfs","kind":"row","ord":0,"parent":"dmsstkg"},{"attrs":{"colspan":1,"column":"pj5sk05","role":"row-header","rowspan":1},"content":[{"kind":"text","text":"1"}],"fidelity":"F1","id":"rdrqkv7","kind":"cell","ord":0,"parent":"r3e7hfs"},{"attrs":{"colspan":1,"column":"nymcs5q","role":"data","rowspan":1},"content":[{"kind":"text","text":"2.5"}],"fidelity":"F1","id":"f463wj7","kind":"cell","ord":1,"parent":"r3e7hfs"},{"id":"aw97y35","kind":"back","ord":1,"parent":"s0fn2fj"},{"id":"yd513mw","kind":"references","ord":0,"parent":"aw97y35"},{"content":[{"kind":"text","text":"1. An Example, 2020."}],"fidelity":"F2","id":"r3e21zr","kind":"reference","label":"1","ord":0,"parent":"yd513mw"}],"own_content":{"af5b51r":{"colspan":1,"column":"pj5sk05","kind":"cell","role":"column-header","rowspan":1,"runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"x"}]},"ajqxkgh":{"colspan":1,"column":"nymcs5q","kind":"cell","role":"column-header","rowspan":1,"runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"y"}]},"aw97y35":{"kind":"back"},"b9wp3tt":{"heading":"219c4a6c86a716e99d5dc9611b61e584deb11b57e972d87d4b773387ebc3cadd","kind":"section","label":"1","level":1},"dmsstkg":{"kind":"table-body"},"em5pd9v":{"kind":"sentence","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"Results"}]},"exq1ter":{"kind":"paragraph"},"f463wj7":{"colspan":1,"column":"nymcs5q","kind":"cell","role":"data","rowspan":1,"runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"2.5"}]},"j663d4h":{"kind":"sentence","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"A second paragraph."}]},"jvnys4s":{"kind":"sentence","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"The value is 42.0 at 300 K."}]},"mzwwhxj":{"kind":"sentence","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"See "},{"kind":"xref","target":"tb49qpc","text":"Table 1"},{"kind":"text","text":" and the note."},{"kind":"cite","refs":["r3e21zr"],"text":"1"}]},"r3e21zr":{"kind":"reference","label":"1","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"1. An Example, 2020."}]},"r3e7hfs":{"kind":"row"},"rdrqkv7":{"colspan":1,"column":"pj5sk05","kind":"cell","role":"row-header","rowspan":1,"runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"1"}]},"rr9rtf5":{"kind":"row"},"rsw24qc":{"kind":"sentence","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"It ends here."}]},"s0fn2fj":{"kind":"document"},"t2ps2mp":{"kind":"table-head"},"tb49qpc":{"columns":[{"header_path":["af5b51r"],"id":"pj5sk05"},{"header_path":["ajqxkgh"],"id":"nymcs5q"}],"kind":"table","label":"Table 1"},"vet7k0e":{"kind":"heading"},"yd513mw":{"kind":"references"},"ytp1e5n":{"kind":"paragraph"}},"values":{"af5b51r":{"align_key":"2d711642b726b04401627ca9fbac32f5c8530fb1903cc4db02258717921a4881","match_hash":"2d711642b726b04401627ca9fbac32f5c8530fb1903cc4db02258717921a4881","node_hash":"59d1c20766a77bacde2aae80a134c7156fbcc708c140a3bb2d2a67f78bd9c6f5","own_hash":"c68933b07bc7c5b806892ae36b3e4c3205a0a2066fd6f8255578f7d1ca86dc10","text_hash":"2d711642b726b04401627ca9fbac32f5c8530fb1903cc4db02258717921a4881"},"ajqxkgh":{"align_key":"a1fce4363854ff888cff4b8e7875d600c2682390412a8cf79b37d0b11148b0fa","match_hash":"a1fce4363854ff888cff4b8e7875d600c2682390412a8cf79b37d0b11148b0fa","node_hash":"838e3fba38f0797d40522Line truncated
{"doc":"vectors","id":"math-form","nodes":[{"id":"aaaaaaa","kind":"document","ord":0,"parent":null},{"attrs":{"level":1},"id":"bbbbbbb","kind":"section","ord":0,"parent":"aaaaaaa"},{"id":"ccccccc","kind":"paragraph","ord":0,"parent":"bbbbbbb"},{"content":[{"kind":"text","text":"The energy is "},{"kind":"equation","node":"eeeeeee"},{"kind":"text","text":" where "},{"form":"scienting-math/1","kind":"math","notation":"tex","source":"K_{r}"},{"kind":"text","text":" is the force constant."}],"id":"ddddddd","kind":"sentence","ord":0,"parent":"ccccccc"},{"content":{"form":"scienting-math/1","notation":"tex","source":"E=\\frac{1}{2}K_{r}x^{2}"},"id":"eeeeeee","kind":"equation","ord":0,"parent":"ddddddd"}],"own_content":{"aaaaaaa":{"kind":"document"},"bbbbbbb":{"heading":null,"kind":"section","label":null,"level":1},"ccccccc":{"kind":"paragraph"},"ddddddd":{"kind":"sentence","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"The energy is "},{"kind":"equation"},{"kind":"text","text":" where "},{"kind":"math","notation":"tex","source":"K_{r}"},{"kind":"text","text":" is the force constant."}]},"eeeeeee":{"kind":"equation","label":null,"notation":"tex","source":"E=\\frac{1}{2}K_{r}x^{2}"}},"values":{"aaaaaaa":{"align_key":"0a0b7b0fad218642459f4be88e8a02e165b79eb087d7be0b33845f15d0dfc0b9","match_hash":"77244e317f4ace842f4027deb48c9063162f87b10a6d59cc18412945391f8b23","node_hash":"3d5c422271f7428e60428e337dc0bcb09d7f0a8ff77c309bdee3dfc277f8e83b","own_hash":"34444fe0e6bdbf3927a579fe3286859d204ea0882a381b7769ffd4905551d24f","text_hash":"06e060a25e16536e6d5f673d0d439ca35d5792f7b02ee57254a8932e5e691305"},"bbbbbbb":{"align_key":"0a0b7b0fad218642459f4be88e8a02e165b79eb087d7be0b33845f15d0dfc0b9","match_hash":"77244e317f4ace842f4027deb48c9063162f87b10a6d59cc18412945391f8b23","node_hash":"0dba0d12b31e1de737b37ededa816aa9ff8c864a04005c3f3ccaad1864a0fc5d","own_hash":"2e173cf74bdb3f542b050ad3556181eeebb58464a7a98765085b98ee7423227b","text_hash":"06e060a25e16536e6d5f673d0d439ca35d5792f7b02ee57254a8932e5e691305"},"ccccccc":{"align_key":"0a0b7b0fad218642459f4be88e8a02e165b79eb087d7be0b33845f15d0dfc0b9","match_hash":"77244e317f4ace842f4027deb48c9063162f87b10a6d59cc18412945391f8b23","node_hash":"87b388726c1ccd7b6f2f26db6912d261bc96ea8cd2d6a87e80e5bb7a3ca2a7f4","own_hash":"494e069be36a18ecaabf5a63be7c31617ade7a5460218ca83a2de3d8d8f964e0","text_hash":"06e060a25e16536e6d5f673d0d439ca35d5792f7b02ee57254a8932e5e691305"},"ddddddd":{"align_key":"0a0b7b0fad218642459f4be88e8a02e165b79eb087d7be0b33845f15d0dfc0b9","match_hash":"77244e317f4ace842f4027deb48c9063162f87b10a6d59cc18412945391f8b23","node_hash":"1282798a0fca7a4a61243a77a371bd9f2ca25868e85a4dc976db117082ce5139","own_hash":"bdf85965019bac6d61b8032a5caab32fdaf10fe912aa058e89ed93057a916788","text_hash":"06e060a25e16536e6d5f673d0d439ca35d5792f7b02ee57254a8932e5e691305"},"eeeeeee":{"align_key":"cd2822e88bcde089a4b8d4d60820a4c0c387d75c7fb1737b5e5ac93129194ff7","match_hash":"cd2822e88bcde089a4b8d4d60820a4c0c387d75c7fb1737b5e5ac93129194ff7","node_hash":"a0afe2c822540a5bdba87aab9459601f89624ee4a1192fcc7ea610646cea7804","own_hash":"453b9ae322705372c37ad8e1a30d712d037a1324c45d700f339229ae8b3013eb","text_hash":"4b8672dac603564cd19e17e0a59999e1eb9661d2179795992c3edeee9b094266"}}}
+2
View File
@@ -9,3 +9,5 @@
{"cases":["cite-mark","cite-as-text"],"differ":"match_hash","id":"cite-structure"} {"cases":["cite-mark","cite-as-text"],"differ":"match_hash","id":"cite-structure"}
{"cases":["hyphen-before-digit","en-dash-before-digit"],"id":"dashes-align","same":"align_key"} {"cases":["hyphen-before-digit","en-dash-before-digit"],"id":"dashes-align","same":"align_key"}
{"cases":["hyphen-before-digit","en-dash-before-digit"],"differ":"text_hash","id":"dashes-text"} {"cases":["hyphen-before-digit","en-dash-before-digit"],"differ":"text_hash","id":"dashes-text"}
{"cases":["emended","as-printed"],"id":"emended-match","same":"match_hash"}
{"cases":["emended","as-printed"],"differ":"text_hash","id":"emended-text"}
+2
View File
@@ -27,3 +27,5 @@
{"align_key":"156cc56f1b8c79722ce3db0aec57879a4b2f467fdb69d75ac6bdae01b7bd4433","complex":[],"id":"hyphen-before-digit","lossy":"pages10−20andctctwith6−31g*","match_hash":"86f127250e5076b9c8b9b5c189361aed13705d1ceb7600cbe2b7ed07597a2313","normalized":"pages 10-20 and CT–CT with 6-31G*","plain":"pages 10-20 and CT–CT with 6-31G*","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"pages 10-20 and CT–CT with 6-31G*"}],"strict":"pages 10−20 and CT–CT with 6−31G*","text_hash":"9dc7ad6bb0693572f0700420e1b2b1c723b39058784c76154e88fffa8fa0c8a8"} {"align_key":"156cc56f1b8c79722ce3db0aec57879a4b2f467fdb69d75ac6bdae01b7bd4433","complex":[],"id":"hyphen-before-digit","lossy":"pages10−20andctctwith6−31g*","match_hash":"86f127250e5076b9c8b9b5c189361aed13705d1ceb7600cbe2b7ed07597a2313","normalized":"pages 10-20 and CT–CT with 6-31G*","plain":"pages 10-20 and CT–CT with 6-31G*","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"pages 10-20 and CT–CT with 6-31G*"}],"strict":"pages 10−20 and CT–CT with 6−31G*","text_hash":"9dc7ad6bb0693572f0700420e1b2b1c723b39058784c76154e88fffa8fa0c8a8"}
{"align_key":"156cc56f1b8c79722ce3db0aec57879a4b2f467fdb69d75ac6bdae01b7bd4433","complex":[],"id":"en-dash-before-digit","lossy":"pages10−20andctctwith6−31g*","match_hash":"1d9c138f8b902b350a1f4477e8b84b6a0a87f35a1dd38486112b7291db3aa150","normalized":"pages 10–20 and CT-CT with 6–31G*","plain":"pages 10–20 and CT-CT with 6–31G*","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"pages 10–20 and CT-CT with 6–31G*"}],"strict":"pages 10−20 and CT-CT with 6−31G*","text_hash":"70b2e77b3966f2c506d87c12b13ebf7ae5193092f678eb101310f363d0ab605a"} {"align_key":"156cc56f1b8c79722ce3db0aec57879a4b2f467fdb69d75ac6bdae01b7bd4433","complex":[],"id":"en-dash-before-digit","lossy":"pages10−20andctctwith6−31g*","match_hash":"1d9c138f8b902b350a1f4477e8b84b6a0a87f35a1dd38486112b7291db3aa150","normalized":"pages 10–20 and CT-CT with 6–31G*","plain":"pages 10–20 and CT-CT with 6–31G*","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"pages 10–20 and CT-CT with 6–31G*"}],"strict":"pages 10−20 and CT-CT with 6−31G*","text_hash":"70b2e77b3966f2c506d87c12b13ebf7ae5193092f678eb101310f363d0ab605a"}
{"align_key":"89658229bf51901882aae4f9543338d4321e4b666a2c191bca749e384fd0a1cc","complex":["tex:𝑥"],"id":"astral","lossy":"letvary.","match_hash":"3b6c539092c6c721ee808437e208b31a1fab3407b43d85e60d29edb65762ac20","normalized":"Let $𝑥$ vary.","plain":"Let $𝑥$ vary.","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"Let "},{"kind":"math","notation":"tex","source":"𝑥"},{"kind":"text","text":" vary."}],"strict":"Let  vary.","text_hash":"43800bdb4e70f3613083dfe5ce728cf643a1d0d97d321f04cfbb4f9b2e56fc6f"} {"align_key":"89658229bf51901882aae4f9543338d4321e4b666a2c191bca749e384fd0a1cc","complex":["tex:𝑥"],"id":"astral","lossy":"letvary.","match_hash":"3b6c539092c6c721ee808437e208b31a1fab3407b43d85e60d29edb65762ac20","normalized":"Let $𝑥$ vary.","plain":"Let $𝑥$ vary.","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"Let "},{"kind":"math","notation":"tex","source":"𝑥"},{"kind":"text","text":" vary."}],"strict":"Let  vary.","text_hash":"43800bdb4e70f3613083dfe5ce728cf643a1d0d97d321f04cfbb4f9b2e56fc6f"}
{"align_key":"45c4f8f75d64dac18b12a35c97a437da5d34c633fae7e2e8c5c34dd1d1325fae","complex":[],"id":"emended","lossy":"thebnodwasrigid.","match_hash":"08468001288317b464726998c48c9aa7676f49742855422ff3db008ac761a278","normalized":"The bond was rigid.","note":"The authors printed 'bnod'; an emend reads 'bond'.","plain":"The bond was rigid.","printed":"The bnod was rigid.","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"The "},{"kind":"text","printed":"bnod","style":["em"],"text":"bond"},{"kind":"text","text":" was rigid."}],"strict":"The bnod was rigid.","text_hash":"9a28a35b7e63e521193b14c163c67e51d16d1dea2bcfe108f4540940f91d1058"}
{"align_key":"45c4f8f75d64dac18b12a35c97a437da5d34c633fae7e2e8c5c34dd1d1325fae","complex":[],"id":"as-printed","lossy":"thebnodwasrigid.","match_hash":"08468001288317b464726998c48c9aa7676f49742855422ff3db008ac761a278","normalized":"The bnod was rigid.","plain":"The bnod was rigid.","runs":[{"kind":"text","text":"The "},{"kind":"text","style":["em"],"text":"bnod"},{"kind":"text","text":" was rigid."}],"strict":"The bnod was rigid.","text_hash":"08468001288317b464726998c48c9aa7676f49742855422ff3db008ac761a278"}
+1 -1
View File
@@ -1,5 +1,5 @@
{"id":"rfc8032-test-1","message":"","public":"d75a980182b10ab7d54bfed3c964073a0ee172f3daa62325af021a68f707511a","secret":"9d61b19deffd5a60ba844af492ec2cc44449c5697b326919703bac031cae7f60","signature":"e5564300c360ac729086e2cc806e828a84877f1eb8e5d974d873e065224901555fb8821590a33bacc61e39701cf9b46bd25bf5f0595bbe24655141438e7a100b"} {"id":"rfc8032-test-1","message":"","public":"d75a980182b10ab7d54bfed3c964073a0ee172f3daa62325af021a68f707511a","secret":"9d61b19deffd5a60ba844af492ec2cc44449c5697b326919703bac031cae7f60","signature":"e5564300c360ac729086e2cc806e828a84877f1eb8e5d974d873e065224901555fb8821590a33bacc61e39701cf9b46bd25bf5f0595bbe24655141438e7a100b"}
{"id":"receipt-r1","payload":"{\"format\":\"scienting-receipt/1\",\"hash\":\"ae17f8866a05ca1b671d96b7758984e11ac694acd6743835f107cb513c7cc600\"}","public":"RUiz5j+y0QwgOtsQpqXrlq+gy3c/JFnkxwvlWUNX4Ao=","receipt":{"at":"2026-10-11T15:02:11Z","by":"ana","doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","evidence":[{"kind":"crop","node":"avbhhey","sha256":"942c23ea73a297e69c2ae8a82abe88d688de2532cb3f6d3543d1107c54f65b2e"},{"kind":"crop","node":"b5gd0h1","sha256":"a0b6f761fe95f8f29ef6dc37901fa85c7a62857b50b0163ca67b0aab048e4d17"},{"kind":"crop","node":"bnyvykm","sha256":"2c560caeaf914f3521fd0e3fca433922fcb9408c184c9b72bcfa869adf5ed409"},{"kind":"crop","node":"c20cna6","sha256":"bdbf7a4d9e86609675e3fc124c21ce808053a52d6bc0f35b15e1ba39027f13af"},{"kind":"crop","node":"d1mhw8b","sha256":"3104c57d9f8fb38302b057ead3bc44456da94f7c17d7c5c8f6db8732d4812c31"},{"kind":"crop","node":"ec5jc93","sha256":"321a926653b9e097987d255d9286880893d71abf895d73f1649403ed9ac0877d"},{"kind":"crop","node":"exms5gc","sha256":"cfc0e42e734470df5cfb741f92080526ef796bf48bcf05847d44f7091cfaaab1"},{"kind":"crop","node":"ganq1ns","sha256":"81d88697cd002fdfd770ee11413c550e4e4ffaa464d35841648311f278fc13bc"},{"kind":"crop","node":"hca6dc5","sha256":"a26619c3a9824bc19fddcf89ee618d9a4792d69110439f121eb717b6f98e88a6"},{"kind":"crop","node":"j6y45v6","sha256":"e689deda15dde9ad24433eb946200417473d273a1bf3136df67bf572256a483f"},{"kind":"crop","node":"jv1741a","sha256":"de60579bacfab769f614fa74d26d20c7b1aa02caf60af1479dc46b98ddcbc106"},{"kind":"crop","node":"k6a6616","sha256":"37b29d7ba293b27f913868690a785591d89ba9a4f47da8adaf764a4d5ae9675b"},{"kind":"crop","node":"m1p1n2g","sha256":"369c69758d2d09cc3d42b2424723c4fbc75f9ceb6817da81ce183be7d36f045f"},{"kind":"crop","node":"rr20tev","sha256":"f57e2cfe704d52c712b01e993e492b121ffe8c4d0174b11a0b0fa21fc5b9930b"},{"kind":"crop","node":"ryhrskg","sha256":"e6f816d93cfff8418dbb771ba03a09fb89a3b2438f97fabfc4ebef7f78af0dbf"},{"kind":"crop","node":"tkxsmts","sha256":"5d8e205660c2c59dcaff119b5671ac11650974b5287d7d7b239a9118e9171a85"},{"kind":"crop","node":"vd76637","sha256":"389742a44f1291e2dc7d7a69acd09410c92ed8a305718b2ab86b0b09b23253f4"},{"kind":"crop","node":"w0gr97q","sha256":"588a38407463e5674714899e6cf359810ccfed98fefdd2c1a90e8cb2ed0a9d64"},{"kind":"crop","node":"w264b74","sha256":"0babb0cef51933b8744f5b22d075069d51e431d3bdc08cb5e35d7822097b5953"},{"kind":"crop","node":"x3ns64d","sha256":"6bd7423a5933eb89572ded1d40d2f5baf6f6fa2f3c46791de8210f201a94b9d1"},{"kind":"crop","node":"ycwgbx1","sha256":"5ee72aca6b32e45f961f9cb2ff70408e71fc9ed7fccd28e91eb86e872041fed3"},{"kind":"crop","node":"yvkd7xr","sha256":"62fd5beecb3e76f430dfd142f443158b84657196af17173a976345a0cdd74449"},{"kind":"crop","node":"ztww0g8","sha256":"902e8ca35e1a313a81130c4c100aeb2233fd53854677b3a992fb16f744fe3151"},{"kind":"witness","sha256":"23b6b2aaece9cb0a828a2f0265539500fcf34d5195bf720b934b8bfdeccb9834"}],"format":"scienting-receipt/1","id":"y2zw8ctg5s8dp","level":"F3","nodes":[["avbhhey","c51730c0b1d7e11b51b317163ae42838f1be808b3690f196923482c9021f97c0"],["b5gd0h1","9635a750ac2acf526a4db28746fd3ed84659f4e384f5a73fef85d002b4e9308b"],["bnyvykm","13b0c5e01b52e467de5975acc898c2387fcc015d222517a865810a330a336c94"],["c20cna6","c8e6a553f5ae1377776e86dde6ee7d48a923dea7de417408841ea33b81563272"],["d1mhw8b","557a47334329925d191e772172fddbc1bd1a035eb2217240c476ee6bc43c92ab"],["ec5jc93","5421e9cf0ef3a995792963d0371b79e11a8efad519b02efb5cb88311a896d0cc"],["exms5gc","b7c47f8360eb7272d2ac0943e8bf1aec9d71cb4ea4e5e1d02f8acee5b430a038"],["ganq1ns","40d46db2088057debc3b1d5b4a3c972ff3a94fc3d5463565f98876d0927f1e67"],["hca6dc5","8cfed5a34aab28517e89e8a164f0f96c14361de83ebc800439116e83ef479f34"],["j6y45v6","00c4b92e220303ebc2bfb36aa557ac80ae4dba1675e9ed47adb82f6aeff10634"],["jv1741a","f644190803b5ea36aa24738e7f168a7fdf0d05cb5123c14a814b7628dab71f1e"],["k6a6616","90aa63a43587bdcee8e428c7dc7a95ac1502bdbcb9f49cae05c433db6d18348b"],["m1p1n2g","0847b5d75c2259257c3619e761c64d5571d3ca3932e96a96ee07e8ce68cc63be"],["rr20tev","76e06b4811a688357ac4b912172283463cfaf1b7a1f0795d274fc733a2309ba7"],["ryhrskg","525583990e7871a2ba55739e8206abac2df0f19d30c86ad74f6cafdd7c3cbe25"],["tkxsmts","cc0bf73dd84e298da0d36c4b363c8d2bdc9b6d5738d1923d14c4a9028dca08d6"],["vd76637","33810e4da42f8e65a224b5369c06fe8db254890294b7b6760808fe6e039da21a"],["w0gr97q","f738a008336ac59b2f1d45cda2f045dc96d34f0f1378c431ce6ff8e434feb8a7"],["w264b74","2ba9cea0f5c07ee9f7b47c5d541c85e92465709322869fb6c0d994ab61c56cad"],["x3ns64d","6bfc0a055148d877dbaf28b7f62565de7b6926137bf032c382282c39a4876797"],["ycwgbx1","167d1551ca64cad5b1143431c5af6d3fc24530887470b7fd265df88d1f54f267"],["yvkd7xr","aab8791a24bc4067c7e37fc5f0244d2128205e0a169e65c2c0fad977aabce313"],["ztww0g8","bda85639faacb77e504c891c035012602836171c009ecfd21584de4d6461ba93"]],"rev":12,"root":"373a7d860a14b58e5bfa9b9ad3bc916091bcb6db7556f0dbc9c71972a612494d","scope":"targeted:lode","signature":{"key":"ana","scheme":"ed25519","value":"2sraHCMlItocGta02EhvPlDW+F8rB1ZYMXBzA5lmNmtH0h+AlrLine truncated {"id":"receipt-r1","payload":"{\"format\":\"scienting-receipt/1\",\"hash\":\"f78c7704df1fbd815ac3ccf9114c82a189f9032ffcd75023e10b27b924f406b5\"}","public":"RUiz5j+y0QwgOtsQpqXrlq+gy3c/JFnkxwvlWUNX4Ao=","receipt":{"at":"2026-10-11T15:02:11Z","by":"ana","doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","evidence":[{"kind":"crop","node":"avbhhey","sha256":"942c23ea73a297e69c2ae8a82abe88d688de2532cb3f6d3543d1107c54f65b2e"},{"kind":"crop","node":"b5gd0h1","sha256":"a0b6f761fe95f8f29ef6dc37901fa85c7a62857b50b0163ca67b0aab048e4d17"},{"kind":"crop","node":"bnyvykm","sha256":"2c560caeaf914f3521fd0e3fca433922fcb9408c184c9b72bcfa869adf5ed409"},{"kind":"crop","node":"c20cna6","sha256":"bdbf7a4d9e86609675e3fc124c21ce808053a52d6bc0f35b15e1ba39027f13af"},{"kind":"crop","node":"d1mhw8b","sha256":"3104c57d9f8fb38302b057ead3bc44456da94f7c17d7c5c8f6db8732d4812c31"},{"kind":"crop","node":"ec5jc93","sha256":"321a926653b9e097987d255d9286880893d71abf895d73f1649403ed9ac0877d"},{"kind":"crop","node":"exms5gc","sha256":"cfc0e42e734470df5cfb741f92080526ef796bf48bcf05847d44f7091cfaaab1"},{"kind":"crop","node":"ganq1ns","sha256":"81d88697cd002fdfd770ee11413c550e4e4ffaa464d35841648311f278fc13bc"},{"kind":"crop","node":"hca6dc5","sha256":"a26619c3a9824bc19fddcf89ee618d9a4792d69110439f121eb717b6f98e88a6"},{"kind":"crop","node":"j6y45v6","sha256":"e689deda15dde9ad24433eb946200417473d273a1bf3136df67bf572256a483f"},{"kind":"crop","node":"jv1741a","sha256":"de60579bacfab769f614fa74d26d20c7b1aa02caf60af1479dc46b98ddcbc106"},{"kind":"crop","node":"k6a6616","sha256":"37b29d7ba293b27f913868690a785591d89ba9a4f47da8adaf764a4d5ae9675b"},{"kind":"crop","node":"m1p1n2g","sha256":"369c69758d2d09cc3d42b2424723c4fbc75f9ceb6817da81ce183be7d36f045f"},{"kind":"crop","node":"rr20tev","sha256":"f57e2cfe704d52c712b01e993e492b121ffe8c4d0174b11a0b0fa21fc5b9930b"},{"kind":"crop","node":"ryhrskg","sha256":"e6f816d93cfff8418dbb771ba03a09fb89a3b2438f97fabfc4ebef7f78af0dbf"},{"kind":"crop","node":"tkxsmts","sha256":"5d8e205660c2c59dcaff119b5671ac11650974b5287d7d7b239a9118e9171a85"},{"kind":"crop","node":"vd76637","sha256":"389742a44f1291e2dc7d7a69acd09410c92ed8a305718b2ab86b0b09b23253f4"},{"kind":"crop","node":"w0gr97q","sha256":"588a38407463e5674714899e6cf359810ccfed98fefdd2c1a90e8cb2ed0a9d64"},{"kind":"crop","node":"w264b74","sha256":"0babb0cef51933b8744f5b22d075069d51e431d3bdc08cb5e35d7822097b5953"},{"kind":"crop","node":"x3ns64d","sha256":"6bd7423a5933eb89572ded1d40d2f5baf6f6fa2f3c46791de8210f201a94b9d1"},{"kind":"crop","node":"ycwgbx1","sha256":"5ee72aca6b32e45f961f9cb2ff70408e71fc9ed7fccd28e91eb86e872041fed3"},{"kind":"crop","node":"yvkd7xr","sha256":"62fd5beecb3e76f430dfd142f443158b84657196af17173a976345a0cdd74449"},{"kind":"crop","node":"ztww0g8","sha256":"902e8ca35e1a313a81130c4c100aeb2233fd53854677b3a992fb16f744fe3151"},{"kind":"witness","sha256":"23b6b2aaece9cb0a828a2f0265539500fcf34d5195bf720b934b8bfdeccb9834"}],"format":"scienting-receipt/1","id":"fhhvg9qrzqp0n","level":"F3","nodes":[["avbhhey","c51730c0b1d7e11b51b317163ae42838f1be808b3690f196923482c9021f97c0"],["b5gd0h1","9635a750ac2acf526a4db28746fd3ed84659f4e384f5a73fef85d002b4e9308b"],["bnyvykm","13b0c5e01b52e467de5975acc898c2387fcc015d222517a865810a330a336c94"],["c20cna6","c8e6a553f5ae1377776e86dde6ee7d48a923dea7de417408841ea33b81563272"],["d1mhw8b","557a47334329925d191e772172fddbc1bd1a035eb2217240c476ee6bc43c92ab"],["ec5jc93","5421e9cf0ef3a995792963d0371b79e11a8efad519b02efb5cb88311a896d0cc"],["exms5gc","b7c47f8360eb7272d2ac0943e8bf1aec9d71cb4ea4e5e1d02f8acee5b430a038"],["ganq1ns","40d46db2088057debc3b1d5b4a3c972ff3a94fc3d5463565f98876d0927f1e67"],["hca6dc5","8cfed5a34aab28517e89e8a164f0f96c14361de83ebc800439116e83ef479f34"],["j6y45v6","00c4b92e220303ebc2bfb36aa557ac80ae4dba1675e9ed47adb82f6aeff10634"],["jv1741a","f644190803b5ea36aa24738e7f168a7fdf0d05cb5123c14a814b7628dab71f1e"],["k6a6616","90aa63a43587bdcee8e428c7dc7a95ac1502bdbcb9f49cae05c433db6d18348b"],["m1p1n2g","0847b5d75c2259257c3619e761c64d5571d3ca3932e96a96ee07e8ce68cc63be"],["rr20tev","76e06b4811a688357ac4b912172283463cfaf1b7a1f0795d274fc733a2309ba7"],["ryhrskg","525583990e7871a2ba55739e8206abac2df0f19d30c86ad74f6cafdd7c3cbe25"],["tkxsmts","cc0bf73dd84e298da0d36c4b363c8d2bdc9b6d5738d1923d14c4a9028dca08d6"],["vd76637","33810e4da42f8e65a224b5369c06fe8db254890294b7b6760808fe6e039da21a"],["w0gr97q","f738a008336ac59b2f1d45cda2f045dc96d34f0f1378c431ce6ff8e434feb8a7"],["w264b74","2ba9cea0f5c07ee9f7b47c5d541c85e92465709322869fb6c0d994ab61c56cad"],["x3ns64d","6bfc0a055148d877dbaf28b7f62565de7b6926137bf032c382282c39a4876797"],["ycwgbx1","167d1551ca64cad5b1143431c5af6d3fc24530887470b7fd265df88d1f54f267"],["yvkd7xr","aab8791a24bc4067c7e37fc5f0244d2128205e0a169e65c2c0fad977aabce313"],["ztww0g8","bda85639faacb77e504c891c035012602836171c009ecfd21584de4d6461ba93"]],"rev":12,"root":"373a7d860a14b58e5bfa9b9ad3bc916091bcb6db7556f0dbc9c71972a612494d","scope":"targeted:paperclaim","signature":{"key":"ana","scheme":"ed25519","value":"wTBxOxNPgseU/6ENyaRVcQKc6AChkmfqnkNbXfTEwQkILine truncated
{"did":"did:key:z6MktwupdmLXVVqTzCw4i46r4uGyosGXRnR3XjN4Zq7oMMsw","id":"did-key-ed25519","public":"d75a980182b10ab7d54bfed3c964073a0ee172f3daa62325af021a68f707511a","scheme":"ed25519"} {"did":"did:key:z6MktwupdmLXVVqTzCw4i46r4uGyosGXRnR3XjN4Zq7oMMsw","id":"did-key-ed25519","public":"d75a980182b10ab7d54bfed3c964073a0ee172f3daa62325af021a68f707511a","scheme":"ed25519"}
{"did":"did:key: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","id":"did-key-ml-dsa-65","public":"2841528a95e5cda35d99bc8d797774b577b254ca0680de5a07b0fdb75869b5a6a5b9f6e02cd0300fa485623ecc20ee4708a3d93fb4297a4fec246e170c6a5840b1dd6b6f01f138aa8045223d07a3ec11811f562fca76d59feb7a099015e9671acbbecab98c60cc8d1ea6aec39e54079504d970969ae75f028ee17678a528c3e245b2ab08fa54a3ab0f02d73d75c4911fc55c090086699fdc8a4dcd521dfbdc29e484534a9c0ac13984524aa714038d88bcdabb878785d3e7574d74be4339b44ce6c97bf1324a1053c30d1b5a8c1c84dd5d9b94cf7fd0c7e9310d57f0def75377d2ccbacf9c27b06ed27655f7203a16ec5d7995d9b9c202ea436100db185f9b9c4c64f310d177b12ddf5341afd5fa30d1601aff49e21640b99fbc36e6571e55d90d852fe59f7f3de92e8d3104cdeb6cb3b1451e7ea9efc341a0d090dc508bfce5fc2fc1f10afda7c7f5136fe7e668431b735f246a8ecd0e0ecbc39fc121496a31a4feb65cd618aaff9a993bcf99d7e21253af766be2255c7ae38365edb59ab155699016202a40331a7e5f3efa8552161534bd1430bdff1628083d091f8755e834dc869abc5697ae1c3edc6dfd75a85ed183f77b0749e3cb819ddc8975550274b267ffbfd0e2c17a948235f815e3154329e902391eab703f35eab756e398aeafb8419d757296600e6ef1f64601dd6907c6fece16c8221858dad70764f8d8fd5a8f031fc4167a1d6173ca99f415feb3ad26eb127667752503e245ff8247903b26b0000190de981c17a3fd9691a9e73777721b3c9818824378520c1088979a2e493a070998b7a988d2a58afb4273e43e3c33040c7eab4b2d4f28c164d31b2987b2e696a7e543f3468f1246ff2e50c95c5e353ce4c5f43c276c6d8099085131417cd3aa0be99a6f2b3429008a89ea75cd13dff6315080e0b2d38897bdaaf23b3a8d1194ef52fdc110aa0d18e5805126979e8e03dba6affb63ceb7532bfa99abc64b36ba7d71fed52a14cb5fd7ead8b1034195981dcbf039c8c91786f53b132929d79b8a379c8f0f9e4a55432cbbb546d8028d1ff9715db8ad0fc2ce510f24d0c99744297c5544b2d1dad0ef706cbb0b9023c0e28e057ef60ae0e25db530e1bd0de12e8db69d0b78c0579e2789756c88d6a60567750b0b80e0a2c6dc53ae7a002d612e589d068b11a17e1234cacfb34117e22eecc1695fc013d2919460ed5a64785a733d5f584775988c2aeada2ed3b0405d61b7189140f252cae3e4699a2b5b244eaa4fa454410899f46b6e594286d400a4d0e2adff96cf666f8ea43dbb7e9a16922dea32858396b7a270b9d9ee401c1df90676f1d1a92e23d50001613b6e6e048fd55a8c27d2ecdf29bade423614b86ce9fa74d63b9d369f0c6cb6e4e96fff3f954126d5a56719a6d497f1e8c816b4eda41d878ea6889682dd6e741cef545fd1a6677f9f94bafa6eb425e2a2c84c35afdaea590acb45f1cbe8dc73d05af78608ae81bea13efde522104245bd273729e93d650d1c3843e7011a25446d40f834ac32c7da33988291b343b510b5dd7ff1e3250b316e8e2be04839a728f471ce66602cd0b0e21a582e7b660680e2867fad602ba6cd4dLine truncated {"did":"did:key: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","id":"did-key-ml-dsa-65","public":"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 truncated
{"id":"ml-dsa-65-nist-keygen-26","public":"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","seed":"a991fd42b071d49c48ae3e75c647459e0daad1e1ba356a04801912d3294bcff8"} {"id":"ml-dsa-65-nist-keygen-26","public":"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","seed":"a991fd42b071d49c48ae3e75c647459e0daad1e1ba356a04801912d3294bcff8"}
+1 -1
View File
@@ -1,4 +1,4 @@
{"beta":"124417f3bbb8fcfaca31a6f3eb5c230a78db44a22502411f245d9fd088d911843d9efb674ffcf29df1cd0f0d8ea6d944bc37d765d45aed9fd64ebe7edc650784","checker_public":"rkzxigjCXg869PGSFAVr4EDXXRmwk+S/+wJ93lrG4dc=","id":"q1","minimum":10,"n":23,"rate":"0.05","receipt":{"at":"2026-10-11T15:02:11Z","by":"ana","doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","evidence":[{"kind":"crop","node":"avbhhey","sha256":"942c23ea73a297e69c2ae8a82abe88d688de2532cb3f6d3543d1107c54f65b2e"},{"kind":"crop","node":"b5gd0h1","sha256":"a0b6f761fe95f8f29ef6dc37901fa85c7a62857b50b0163ca67b0aab048e4d17"},{"kind":"crop","node":"bnyvykm","sha256":"2c560caeaf914f3521fd0e3fca433922fcb9408c184c9b72bcfa869adf5ed409"},{"kind":"crop","node":"c20cna6","sha256":"bdbf7a4d9e86609675e3fc124c21ce808053a52d6bc0f35b15e1ba39027f13af"},{"kind":"crop","node":"d1mhw8b","sha256":"3104c57d9f8fb38302b057ead3bc44456da94f7c17d7c5c8f6db8732d4812c31"},{"kind":"crop","node":"ec5jc93","sha256":"321a926653b9e097987d255d9286880893d71abf895d73f1649403ed9ac0877d"},{"kind":"crop","node":"exms5gc","sha256":"cfc0e42e734470df5cfb741f92080526ef796bf48bcf05847d44f7091cfaaab1"},{"kind":"crop","node":"ganq1ns","sha256":"81d88697cd002fdfd770ee11413c550e4e4ffaa464d35841648311f278fc13bc"},{"kind":"crop","node":"hca6dc5","sha256":"a26619c3a9824bc19fddcf89ee618d9a4792d69110439f121eb717b6f98e88a6"},{"kind":"crop","node":"j6y45v6","sha256":"e689deda15dde9ad24433eb946200417473d273a1bf3136df67bf572256a483f"},{"kind":"crop","node":"jv1741a","sha256":"de60579bacfab769f614fa74d26d20c7b1aa02caf60af1479dc46b98ddcbc106"},{"kind":"crop","node":"k6a6616","sha256":"37b29d7ba293b27f913868690a785591d89ba9a4f47da8adaf764a4d5ae9675b"},{"kind":"crop","node":"m1p1n2g","sha256":"369c69758d2d09cc3d42b2424723c4fbc75f9ceb6817da81ce183be7d36f045f"},{"kind":"crop","node":"rr20tev","sha256":"f57e2cfe704d52c712b01e993e492b121ffe8c4d0174b11a0b0fa21fc5b9930b"},{"kind":"crop","node":"ryhrskg","sha256":"e6f816d93cfff8418dbb771ba03a09fb89a3b2438f97fabfc4ebef7f78af0dbf"},{"kind":"crop","node":"tkxsmts","sha256":"5d8e205660c2c59dcaff119b5671ac11650974b5287d7d7b239a9118e9171a85"},{"kind":"crop","node":"vd76637","sha256":"389742a44f1291e2dc7d7a69acd09410c92ed8a305718b2ab86b0b09b23253f4"},{"kind":"crop","node":"w0gr97q","sha256":"588a38407463e5674714899e6cf359810ccfed98fefdd2c1a90e8cb2ed0a9d64"},{"kind":"crop","node":"w264b74","sha256":"0babb0cef51933b8744f5b22d075069d51e431d3bdc08cb5e35d7822097b5953"},{"kind":"crop","node":"x3ns64d","sha256":"6bd7423a5933eb89572ded1d40d2f5baf6f6fa2f3c46791de8210f201a94b9d1"},{"kind":"crop","node":"ycwgbx1","sha256":"5ee72aca6b32e45f961f9cb2ff70408e71fc9ed7fccd28e91eb86e872041fed3"},{"kind":"crop","node":"yvkd7xr","sha256":"62fd5beecb3e76f430dfd142f443158b84657196af17173a976345a0cdd74449"},{"kind":"crop","node":"ztww0g8","sha256":"902e8ca35e1a313a81130c4c100aeb2233fd53854677b3a992fb16f744fe3151"},{"kind":"witness","sha256":"23b6b2aaece9cb0a828a2f0265539500fcf34d5195bf720b934b8bfdeccb9834"}],"format":"scienting-receipt/1","id":"y2zw8ctg5s8dp","level":"F3","nodes":[["avbhhey","c51730c0b1d7e11b51b317163ae42838f1be808b3690f196923482c9021f97c0"],["b5gd0h1","9635a750ac2acf526a4db28746fd3ed84659f4e384f5a73fef85d002b4e9308b"],["bnyvykm","13b0c5e01b52e467de5975acc898c2387fcc015d222517a865810a330a336c94"],["c20cna6","c8e6a553f5ae1377776e86dde6ee7d48a923dea7de417408841ea33b81563272"],["d1mhw8b","557a47334329925d191e772172fddbc1bd1a035eb2217240c476ee6bc43c92ab"],["ec5jc93","5421e9cf0ef3a995792963d0371b79e11a8efad519b02efb5cb88311a896d0cc"],["exms5gc","b7c47f8360eb7272d2ac0943e8bf1aec9d71cb4ea4e5e1d02f8acee5b430a038"],["ganq1ns","40d46db2088057debc3b1d5b4a3c972ff3a94fc3d5463565f98876d0927f1e67"],["hca6dc5","8cfed5a34aab28517e89e8a164f0f96c14361de83ebc800439116e83ef479f34"],["j6y45v6","00c4b92e220303ebc2bfb36aa557ac80ae4dba1675e9ed47adb82f6aeff10634"],["jv1741a","f644190803b5ea36aa24738e7f168a7fdf0d05cb5123c14a814b7628dab71f1e"],["k6a6616","90aa63a43587bdcee8e428c7dc7a95ac1502bdbcb9f49cae05c433db6d18348b"],["m1p1n2g","0847b5d75c2259257c3619e761c64d5571d3ca3932e96a96ee07e8ce68cc63be"],["rr20tev","76e06b4811a688357ac4b912172283463cfaf1b7a1f0795d274fc733a2309ba7"],["ryhrskg","525583990e7871a2ba55739e8206abac2df0f19d30c86ad74f6cafdd7c3cbe25"],["tkxsmts","cc0bf73dd84e298da0d36c4b363c8d2bdc9b6d5738d1923d14c4a9028dca08d6"],["vd76637","33810e4da42f8e65a224b5369c06fe8db254890294b7b6760808fe6e039da21a"],["w0gr97q","f738a008336ac59b2f1d45cda2f045dc96d34f0f1378c431ce6ff8e434feb8a7"],["w264b74","2ba9cea0f5c07ee9f7b47c5d541c85e92465709322869fb6c0d994ab61c56cad"],["x3ns64d","6bfc0a055148d877dbaf28b7f62565de7b6926137bf032c382282c39a4876797"],["ycwgbx1","167d1551ca64cad5b1143431c5af6d3fc24530887470b7fd265df88d1f54f267"],["yvkd7xr","aab8791a24bc4067c7e37fc5f0244d2128205e0a169e65c2c0fad977aabce313"],["ztww0g8","bda85639faacb77e504c891c035012602836171c009ecfd21584de4d6461ba93"]],"rev":12,"root":"373a7d860a14b58e5bfa9b9ad3bc916091bcb6db7556f0dbc9c71972a612494d","scope":"targeted:lode","signature":{"key":"ana","scheme":"ed25519","value":"2sraHLine truncated {"beta":"38b48ed32447c1f7eb3171504e9bd3910e902cd9c096180f9d20a4579bddd87019f8469bf92774bbd98ee49f0e31578f0e7b690b84a31d448395b69b6fe2064d","checker_public":"rkzxigjCXg869PGSFAVr4EDXXRmwk+S/+wJ93lrG4dc=","id":"q1","minimum":10,"n":23,"rate":"0.05","receipt":{"at":"2026-10-11T15:02:11Z","by":"ana","doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","evidence":[{"kind":"crop","node":"avbhhey","sha256":"942c23ea73a297e69c2ae8a82abe88d688de2532cb3f6d3543d1107c54f65b2e"},{"kind":"crop","node":"b5gd0h1","sha256":"a0b6f761fe95f8f29ef6dc37901fa85c7a62857b50b0163ca67b0aab048e4d17"},{"kind":"crop","node":"bnyvykm","sha256":"2c560caeaf914f3521fd0e3fca433922fcb9408c184c9b72bcfa869adf5ed409"},{"kind":"crop","node":"c20cna6","sha256":"bdbf7a4d9e86609675e3fc124c21ce808053a52d6bc0f35b15e1ba39027f13af"},{"kind":"crop","node":"d1mhw8b","sha256":"3104c57d9f8fb38302b057ead3bc44456da94f7c17d7c5c8f6db8732d4812c31"},{"kind":"crop","node":"ec5jc93","sha256":"321a926653b9e097987d255d9286880893d71abf895d73f1649403ed9ac0877d"},{"kind":"crop","node":"exms5gc","sha256":"cfc0e42e734470df5cfb741f92080526ef796bf48bcf05847d44f7091cfaaab1"},{"kind":"crop","node":"ganq1ns","sha256":"81d88697cd002fdfd770ee11413c550e4e4ffaa464d35841648311f278fc13bc"},{"kind":"crop","node":"hca6dc5","sha256":"a26619c3a9824bc19fddcf89ee618d9a4792d69110439f121eb717b6f98e88a6"},{"kind":"crop","node":"j6y45v6","sha256":"e689deda15dde9ad24433eb946200417473d273a1bf3136df67bf572256a483f"},{"kind":"crop","node":"jv1741a","sha256":"de60579bacfab769f614fa74d26d20c7b1aa02caf60af1479dc46b98ddcbc106"},{"kind":"crop","node":"k6a6616","sha256":"37b29d7ba293b27f913868690a785591d89ba9a4f47da8adaf764a4d5ae9675b"},{"kind":"crop","node":"m1p1n2g","sha256":"369c69758d2d09cc3d42b2424723c4fbc75f9ceb6817da81ce183be7d36f045f"},{"kind":"crop","node":"rr20tev","sha256":"f57e2cfe704d52c712b01e993e492b121ffe8c4d0174b11a0b0fa21fc5b9930b"},{"kind":"crop","node":"ryhrskg","sha256":"e6f816d93cfff8418dbb771ba03a09fb89a3b2438f97fabfc4ebef7f78af0dbf"},{"kind":"crop","node":"tkxsmts","sha256":"5d8e205660c2c59dcaff119b5671ac11650974b5287d7d7b239a9118e9171a85"},{"kind":"crop","node":"vd76637","sha256":"389742a44f1291e2dc7d7a69acd09410c92ed8a305718b2ab86b0b09b23253f4"},{"kind":"crop","node":"w0gr97q","sha256":"588a38407463e5674714899e6cf359810ccfed98fefdd2c1a90e8cb2ed0a9d64"},{"kind":"crop","node":"w264b74","sha256":"0babb0cef51933b8744f5b22d075069d51e431d3bdc08cb5e35d7822097b5953"},{"kind":"crop","node":"x3ns64d","sha256":"6bd7423a5933eb89572ded1d40d2f5baf6f6fa2f3c46791de8210f201a94b9d1"},{"kind":"crop","node":"ycwgbx1","sha256":"5ee72aca6b32e45f961f9cb2ff70408e71fc9ed7fccd28e91eb86e872041fed3"},{"kind":"crop","node":"yvkd7xr","sha256":"62fd5beecb3e76f430dfd142f443158b84657196af17173a976345a0cdd74449"},{"kind":"crop","node":"ztww0g8","sha256":"902e8ca35e1a313a81130c4c100aeb2233fd53854677b3a992fb16f744fe3151"},{"kind":"witness","sha256":"23b6b2aaece9cb0a828a2f0265539500fcf34d5195bf720b934b8bfdeccb9834"}],"format":"scienting-receipt/1","id":"fhhvg9qrzqp0n","level":"F3","nodes":[["avbhhey","c51730c0b1d7e11b51b317163ae42838f1be808b3690f196923482c9021f97c0"],["b5gd0h1","9635a750ac2acf526a4db28746fd3ed84659f4e384f5a73fef85d002b4e9308b"],["bnyvykm","13b0c5e01b52e467de5975acc898c2387fcc015d222517a865810a330a336c94"],["c20cna6","c8e6a553f5ae1377776e86dde6ee7d48a923dea7de417408841ea33b81563272"],["d1mhw8b","557a47334329925d191e772172fddbc1bd1a035eb2217240c476ee6bc43c92ab"],["ec5jc93","5421e9cf0ef3a995792963d0371b79e11a8efad519b02efb5cb88311a896d0cc"],["exms5gc","b7c47f8360eb7272d2ac0943e8bf1aec9d71cb4ea4e5e1d02f8acee5b430a038"],["ganq1ns","40d46db2088057debc3b1d5b4a3c972ff3a94fc3d5463565f98876d0927f1e67"],["hca6dc5","8cfed5a34aab28517e89e8a164f0f96c14361de83ebc800439116e83ef479f34"],["j6y45v6","00c4b92e220303ebc2bfb36aa557ac80ae4dba1675e9ed47adb82f6aeff10634"],["jv1741a","f644190803b5ea36aa24738e7f168a7fdf0d05cb5123c14a814b7628dab71f1e"],["k6a6616","90aa63a43587bdcee8e428c7dc7a95ac1502bdbcb9f49cae05c433db6d18348b"],["m1p1n2g","0847b5d75c2259257c3619e761c64d5571d3ca3932e96a96ee07e8ce68cc63be"],["rr20tev","76e06b4811a688357ac4b912172283463cfaf1b7a1f0795d274fc733a2309ba7"],["ryhrskg","525583990e7871a2ba55739e8206abac2df0f19d30c86ad74f6cafdd7c3cbe25"],["tkxsmts","cc0bf73dd84e298da0d36c4b363c8d2bdc9b6d5738d1923d14c4a9028dca08d6"],["vd76637","33810e4da42f8e65a224b5369c06fe8db254890294b7b6760808fe6e039da21a"],["w0gr97q","f738a008336ac59b2f1d45cda2f045dc96d34f0f1378c431ce6ff8e434feb8a7"],["w264b74","2ba9cea0f5c07ee9f7b47c5d541c85e92465709322869fb6c0d994ab61c56cad"],["x3ns64d","6bfc0a055148d877dbaf28b7f62565de7b6926137bf032c382282c39a4876797"],["ycwgbx1","167d1551ca64cad5b1143431c5af6d3fc24530887470b7fd265df88d1f54f267"],["yvkd7xr","aab8791a24bc4067c7e37fc5f0244d2128205e0a169e65c2c0fad977aabce313"],["ztww0g8","bda85639faacb77e504c891c035012602836171c009ecfd21584de4d6461ba93"]],"rev":12,"root":"373a7d860a14b58e5bfa9b9ad3bc916091bcb6db7556f0dbc9c71972a612494d","scope":"targeted:paperclaim","signature":{"key":"ana","scheme":"ed25519","value":Line truncated
{"id":"size-3","minimum":10,"n":3,"rate":"0.05","size":3} {"id":"size-3","minimum":10,"n":3,"rate":"0.05","size":3}
{"id":"size-10","minimum":10,"n":10,"rate":"0.05","size":10} {"id":"size-10","minimum":10,"n":10,"rate":"0.05","size":10}
{"id":"size-199","minimum":10,"n":199,"rate":"0.05","size":10} {"id":"size-199","minimum":10,"n":199,"rate":"0.05","size":10}
+29
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,29 @@
{"annotation":{"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"kind":"trace","note":"The abstract states the two steps: a scan first, then vibrational frequencies.","proposer":{"model":{"name":"example-model","parameters":"998b5161e39e01c8bc43ef81ec89141e15b7ea53b2e936707920a6097dbcb2c5","processor":"local","prompt":"9cc338fba7c62db7266f530cb555a5ee36910d41a0120a3fe7fd7de1944d0931","provider":"Example Models (illustrative)","version":"2026-09","weights":"504b2d340045b92c22682b60020c21103aae7ff41172bb632fbe305eb4af9b5e"},"rank":1,"run":"illustrative-run-2","score":"0.8731"},"reference":"ebcq5cy","selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"mhp0at8","node_hash":"ee42c4780724a411697e3a95daf182d37c792d4689a7172f32929785d5fd968e","own_hash":"24cc437784bf358d639755dbf59984ad2c0c7a0e7f9448b23e965039b67f759b","quote":{"exact":"in two steps","prefix":"bond constants for twelve bonds ","suffix":", first to a scan and then to vi"},"rev":12,"span":[48,60],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"in two steps","prefix":"bond constants for twelve bonds ","suffix":", first to a scan and then to vi","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource","verdict":"supports"},"created":"2026-10-12T09:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:software:example-model","name":"A model (illustrative)","type":"Software"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/jh0e4st2c0kpt","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/tr6c3q8m","motivation":"linking","receipt":"qvckzaatz5d1v","status":"confirmed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"93a39490870e694299e88e6f475d42c38078d1442959e555bdbdf58488dcf187","own_hash":"e004436e7b28ff3dc41e0056f231ba707d9be985694e68acb911345a547842ed","quote":{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1"},"rev":0,"span":[26,38],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"},"cited":"fixtures/packages/hale2026harmonic-damb","cited_corrections":[],"citing":"fixtures/packages/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","citing_corrections":[],"expect":{"cited":{"node":"mhp0at8","node_hash":"ee42c4780724a411697e3a95daf182d37c792d4689a7172f32929785d5fd968e","result":"current","span":[48,60]},"cites":[],"citing":{"node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"93a39490870e694299e88e6f475d42c38078d1442959e555bdbdf58488dcf187","result":"current","span":[26,38]},"open":"smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb#mhp0at8@ee42c4[48:60]","reference":"ebcq5cy","resolution":{"doc":"smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"document"},"result":"current"},"id":"current-abstract","op":"resolve","same_as":[]}
{"annotation":{"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"kind":"trace","note":"Table 1 lists the fitted constants of both parameter sets.","reference":"ebcq5cy","selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"table","node":"hj4s7pb","node_hash":"6c6fba200faf41cd06fa8b64e06e2aa29ff8848568b859ae42d1902596348643","own_hash":"66310a9ab1c92568f4c6cae012e35d4245d4ca4b89d2542b7c2113a31ad379ed","rev":12,"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource","verdict":"supports"},"created":"2026-10-12T09:10:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:key:ana","name":"Ana Example","type":"Person"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/fhnynfb8jx0wc","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/tr6c3q8m","motivation":"linking","receipt":"qvckzaatz5d1v","status":"confirmed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"93a39490870e694299e88e6f475d42c38078d1442959e555bdbdf58488dcf187","own_hash":"e004436e7b28ff3dc41e0056f231ba707d9be985694e68acb911345a547842ed","quote":{"exact":"Its constants come from a two-step fit (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1"},"rev":0,"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"Its constants come from a two-step fit (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1","prefix":"","suffix":"","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"},"cited":"fixtures/packages/hale2026harmonic-damb","cited_corrections":[],"citing":"fixtures/packages/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","citing_corrections":[],"expect":{"cited":{"node":"hj4s7pb","node_hash":"6c6fba200faf41cd06fa8b64e06e2aa29ff8848568b859ae42d1902596348643","result":"current"},"cites":[],"citing":{"node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"93a39490870e694299e88e6f475d42c38078d1442959e555bdbdf58488dcf187","result":"current"},"open":"smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb#hj4s7pb@6c6fba","reference":"ebcq5cy","resolution":{"doc":"smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"document"},"result":"current"},"id":"current-table","op":"resolve","same_as":[]}
{"annotation":{"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"kind":"trace","note":"Says harmonic terms are common, not how the constants were fitted.","proposer":{"model":{"name":"example-model","parameters":"998b5161e39e01c8bc43ef81ec89141e15b7ea53b2e936707920a6097dbcb2c5","processor":"local","prompt":"9cc338fba7c62db7266f530cb555a5ee36910d41a0120a3fe7fd7de1944d0931","provider":"Example Models (illustrative)","version":"2026-09","weights":"504b2d340045b92c22682b60020c21103aae7ff41172bb632fbe305eb4af9b5e"},"rank":2,"run":"illustrative-run-2","score":"0.6410"},"reference":"ebcq5cy","selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"kea5026","node_hash":"b836d5872ca37471fa996be04c538254a8b1e37ca12e8f1b4a40837b503afa33","own_hash":"d673d236c03d9583ecf6e01fa819765ec324dc684bd9bbc6967fa50f216e34d2","quote":{"exact":"classical force fields.1","prefix":"ption of covalent stretching in "},"rev":12,"span":[81,105],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"classical force fields.1","prefix":"ption of covalent stretching in ","suffix":"","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource"},"created":"2026-10-12T09:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:software:example-model","name":"A model (illustrative)","type":"Software"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/arm3zmj6be9fz","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/tr6c3q8m","motivation":"linking","status":"rejected","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"93a39490870e694299e88e6f475d42c38078d1442959e555bdbdf58488dcf187","own_hash":"e004436e7b28ff3dc41e0056f231ba707d9be985694e68acb911345a547842ed","quote":{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1"},"rev":0,"span":[26,38],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"},"cited":"fixtures/packages/hale2026harmonic-damb","cited_corrections":[],"citing":"fixtures/packages/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","citing_corrections":[],"expect":{"cited":{"node":"kea5026","node_hash":"b836d5872ca37471fa996be04c538254a8b1e37ca12e8f1b4a40837b503afa33","result":"current","span":[81,105]},"cites":[{"node":"kea5026","refs":[{"node":"tb6syqq","resolution":{"doi":"10.5555/example.ref1","type":"doi"}}],"run":1,"span":[104,105],"text":"1"}],"citing":{"node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"93a39490870e694299e88e6f475d42c38078d1442959e555bdbdf58488dcf187","result":"current","span":[26,38]},"open":"smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb#kea5026@b836d5[81:105]","reference":"ebcq5cy","resolution":{"doc":"smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"document"},"result":"current"},"id":"current-candidate-with-citation","op":"resolve","same_as":[]}
{"annotation":{"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"kind":"trace","note":"The abstract states the two steps: a scan first, then vibrational frequencies.","proposer":{"model":{"name":"example-model","parameters":"998b5161e39e01c8bc43ef81ec89141e15b7ea53b2e936707920a6097dbcb2c5","processor":"local","prompt":"9cc338fba7c62db7266f530cb555a5ee36910d41a0120a3fe7fd7de1944d0931","provider":"Example Models (illustrative)","version":"2026-09","weights":"504b2d340045b92c22682b60020c21103aae7ff41172bb632fbe305eb4af9b5e"},"rank":1,"run":"illustrative-run-2","score":"0.8731"},"reference":"ebcq5cy","selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"mhp0at8","node_hash":"ee42c4780724a411697e3a95daf182d37c792d4689a7172f32929785d5fd968e","own_hash":"24cc437784bf358d639755dbf59984ad2c0c7a0e7f9448b23e965039b67f759b","quote":{"exact":"in two steps","prefix":"bond constants for twelve bonds ","suffix":", first to a scan and then to vi"},"rev":12,"span":[48,60],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"in two steps","prefix":"bond constants for twelve bonds ","suffix":", first to a scan and then to vi","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource","verdict":"supports"},"created":"2026-10-12T09:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:software:example-model","name":"A model (illustrative)","type":"Software"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/jh0e4st2c0kpt","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/tr6c3q8m","motivation":"linking","receipt":"qvckzaatz5d1v","status":"confirmed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"93a39490870e694299e88e6f475d42c38078d1442959e555bdbdf58488dcf187","own_hash":"e004436e7b28ff3dc41e0056f231ba707d9be985694e68acb911345a547842ed","quote":{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1"},"rev":0,"span":[26,38],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"},"cited":"fixtures/packages/hale2026harmonic-damb","cited_corrections":[{"at":"2026-10-13T12:00:00Z","author":{"key":"ana"},"evidence":[{"by":"ana","kind":"person"}],"find":"twelve bonds","op":"replace","reason":"Vector.","replace":"all bonds","target":"mhp0at8"}],"citing":"fixtures/packages/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","citing_corrections":[],"expect":{"cited":{"node":"mhp0at8","node_hash":"555e067abf00f7fe04208dad2f82e7e9a4c41fdf7b375705d80aa6062753506e","result":"reattached","span":[45,57]},"cites":[],"citing":{"node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"93a39490870e694299e88e6f475d42c38078d1442959e555bdbdf58488dcf187","result":"current","span":[26,38]},"open":"smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb#mhp0at8@555e06[45:57]","reason":"the cited anchor is reattached","reference":"ebcq5cy","resolution":{"doc":"smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"document"},"result":"changed"},"id":"changed-passage-moved","op":"resolve","same_as":[]}
{"annotation":{"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"kind":"trace","note":"The abstract states the two steps: a scan first, then vibrational frequencies.","proposer":{"model":{"name":"example-model","parameters":"998b5161e39e01c8bc43ef81ec89141e15b7ea53b2e936707920a6097dbcb2c5","processor":"local","prompt":"9cc338fba7c62db7266f530cb555a5ee36910d41a0120a3fe7fd7de1944d0931","provider":"Example Models (illustrative)","version":"2026-09","weights":"504b2d340045b92c22682b60020c21103aae7ff41172bb632fbe305eb4af9b5e"},"rank":1,"run":"illustrative-run-2","score":"0.8731"},"reference":"ebcq5cy","selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"mhp0at8","node_hash":"ee42c4780724a411697e3a95daf182d37c792d4689a7172f32929785d5fd968e","own_hash":"24cc437784bf358d639755dbf59984ad2c0c7a0e7f9448b23e965039b67f759b","quote":{"exact":"in two steps","prefix":"bond constants for twelve bonds ","suffix":", first to a scan and then to vi"},"rev":12,"span":[48,60],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"in two steps","prefix":"bond constants for twelve bonds ","suffix":", first to a scan and then to vi","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource","verdict":"supports"},"created":"2026-10-12T09:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:software:example-model","name":"A model (illustrative)","type":"Software"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/jh0e4st2c0kpt","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/tr6c3q8m","motivation":"linking","receipt":"qvckzaatz5d1v","status":"confirmed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"93a39490870e694299e88e6f475d42c38078d1442959e555bdbdf58488dcf187","own_hash":"e004436e7b28ff3dc41e0056f231ba707d9be985694e68acb911345a547842ed","quote":{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1"},"rev":0,"span":[26,38],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"},"cited":"fixtures/packages/hale2026harmonic-damb","cited_corrections":[],"citing":"fixtures/packages/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","citing_corrections":[{"at":"2026-10-13T12:00:00Z","author":{"key":"ana"},"evidence":[{"by":"ana","kind":"person"}],"find":"Its constants","op":"replace","reason":"Vector.","replace":"The constants","target":"qgh1k31"}],"expect":{"cited":{"node":"mhp0at8","node_hash":"ee42c4780724a411697e3a95daf182d37c792d4689a7172f32929785d5fd968e","result":"current","span":[48,60]},"cites":[],"citing":{"node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"a43c8dd69593e1300771383c98e27a15120479928d9c77023aef0f7646ec9a1f","result":"reattached","span":[26,38]},"open":"smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb#mhp0at8@ee42c4[48:60]","reason":"the citing anchor is reattached","reference":"ebcq5cy","resolution":{"doc":"smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"document"},"result":"changed"},"id":"changed-sentence","op":"resolve","same_as":[]}
{"annotation":{"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"kind":"trace","note":"Table 1 lists the fitted constants of both parameter sets.","reference":"ebcq5cy","selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"table","node":"hj4s7pb","node_hash":"6c6fba200faf41cd06fa8b64e06e2aa29ff8848568b859ae42d1902596348643","own_hash":"66310a9ab1c92568f4c6cae012e35d4245d4ca4b89d2542b7c2113a31ad379ed","rev":12,"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource","verdict":"supports"},"created":"2026-10-12T09:10:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:key:ana","name":"Ana Example","type":"Person"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/fhnynfb8jx0wc","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/tr6c3q8m","motivation":"linking","receipt":"qvckzaatz5d1v","status":"confirmed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"93a39490870e694299e88e6f475d42c38078d1442959e555bdbdf58488dcf187","own_hash":"e004436e7b28ff3dc41e0056f231ba707d9be985694e68acb911345a547842ed","quote":{"exact":"Its constants come from a two-step fit (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1"},"rev":0,"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"Its constants come from a two-step fit (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1","prefix":"","suffix":"","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"},"cited":"fixtures/packages/hale2026harmonic-damb","cited_corrections":[{"at":"2026-10-13T12:00:00Z","author":{"key":"ana"},"evidence":[{"kind":"crop","sha256":"de60579bacfab769f614fa74d26d20c7b1aa02caf60af1479dc46b98ddcbc106"}],"find":"553.0","op":"replace","reason":"Vector.","replace":"552.0","target":"jv1741a"}],"citing":"fixtures/packages/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","citing_corrections":[],"expect":{"cited":{"drift":{"count":1,"level":"low","share":"0.0400"},"node":"hj4s7pb","node_hash":"269c5d863994ffb4f4f4c796dfa4e1c0dc99d11bdbe77dbb0639c8c7efe1e030","result":"changed-below"},"cites":[],"citing":{"node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"93a39490870e694299e88e6f475d42c38078d1442959e555bdbdf58488dcf187","result":"current"},"open":"smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb#hj4s7pb@269c5d","reason":"the cited anchor is changed-below","reference":"ebcq5cy","resolution":{"doc":"smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"document"},"result":"changed"},"id":"changed-table","op":"resolve","same_as":[]}
{"annotation":{"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"kind":"trace","note":"The abstract states the two steps: a scan first, then vibrational frequencies.","proposer":{"model":{"name":"example-model","parameters":"998b5161e39e01c8bc43ef81ec89141e15b7ea53b2e936707920a6097dbcb2c5","processor":"local","prompt":"9cc338fba7c62db7266f530cb555a5ee36910d41a0120a3fe7fd7de1944d0931","provider":"Example Models (illustrative)","version":"2026-09","weights":"504b2d340045b92c22682b60020c21103aae7ff41172bb632fbe305eb4af9b5e"},"rank":1,"run":"illustrative-run-2","score":"0.8731"},"reference":"ebcq5cy","selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"mhp0at8","node_hash":"ee42c4780724a411697e3a95daf182d37c792d4689a7172f32929785d5fd968e","own_hash":"24cc437784bf358d639755dbf59984ad2c0c7a0e7f9448b23e965039b67f759b","quote":{"exact":"in two steps","prefix":"bond constants for twelve bonds ","suffix":", first to a scan and then to vi"},"rev":12,"span":[48,60],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"in two steps","prefix":"bond constants for twelve bonds ","suffix":", first to a scan and then to vi","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource","verdict":"supports"},"created":"2026-10-12T09:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:software:example-model","name":"A model (illustrative)","type":"Software"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/jh0e4st2c0kpt","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/tr6c3q8m","motivation":"linking","receipt":"qvckzaatz5d1v","status":"confirmed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"93a39490870e694299e88e6f475d42c38078d1442959e555bdbdf58488dcf187","own_hash":"e004436e7b28ff3dc41e0056f231ba707d9be985694e68acb911345a547842ed","quote":{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1"},"rev":0,"span":[26,38],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"},"cited":"fixtures/packages/hale2026harmonic-damb","cited_corrections":[{"at":"2026-10-13T12:00:00Z","author":{"key":"ana"},"evidence":[{"by":"ana","kind":"person"}],"find":"in two steps","op":"replace","reason":"Vector.","replace":"in three stages","target":"mhp0at8"}],"citing":"fixtures/packages/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","citing_corrections":[],"expect":{"cited":{"node":"mhp0at8","node_hash":"a4946bd7586cb81977f8b1c85d34de7d15b9a3e5cc33c0308da54b1148e124f9","reason":"the node changed and the quote does not occur exactly once","result":"stale"},"cites":[],"citing":{"node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"93a39490870e694299e88e6f475d42c38078d1442959e555bdbdf58488dcf187","result":"current","span":[26,38]},"open":null,"reason":"the cited anchor is stale: the node changed and the quote does not occur exactly once","reference":"ebcq5cy","resolution":{"doc":"smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"document"},"result":"stale","side":"cited"},"id":"stale-cited","op":"resolve","same_as":[]}
{"annotation":{"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"kind":"trace","note":"The abstract states the two steps: a scan first, then vibrational frequencies.","proposer":{"model":{"name":"example-model","parameters":"998b5161e39e01c8bc43ef81ec89141e15b7ea53b2e936707920a6097dbcb2c5","processor":"local","prompt":"9cc338fba7c62db7266f530cb555a5ee36910d41a0120a3fe7fd7de1944d0931","provider":"Example Models (illustrative)","version":"2026-09","weights":"504b2d340045b92c22682b60020c21103aae7ff41172bb632fbe305eb4af9b5e"},"rank":1,"run":"illustrative-run-2","score":"0.8731"},"reference":"ebcq5cy","selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"mhp0at8","node_hash":"ee42c4780724a411697e3a95daf182d37c792d4689a7172f32929785d5fd968e","own_hash":"24cc437784bf358d639755dbf59984ad2c0c7a0e7f9448b23e965039b67f759b","quote":{"exact":"in two steps","prefix":"bond constants for twelve bonds ","suffix":", first to a scan and then to vi"},"rev":12,"span":[48,60],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"in two steps","prefix":"bond constants for twelve bonds ","suffix":", first to a scan and then to vi","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource","verdict":"supports"},"created":"2026-10-12T09:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:software:example-model","name":"A model (illustrative)","type":"Software"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/jh0e4st2c0kpt","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/tr6c3q8m","motivation":"linking","receipt":"qvckzaatz5d1v","status":"confirmed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"93a39490870e694299e88e6f475d42c38078d1442959e555bdbdf58488dcf187","own_hash":"e004436e7b28ff3dc41e0056f231ba707d9be985694e68acb911345a547842ed","quote":{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1"},"rev":0,"span":[26,38],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"},"cited":"fixtures/packages/hale2026harmonic-damb","cited_corrections":[],"citing":"fixtures/packages/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","citing_corrections":[{"at":"2026-10-13T12:00:00Z","author":{"key":"ana"},"evidence":[{"by":"ana","kind":"person"}],"find":"two-step","op":"replace","reason":"Vector.","replace":"two-stage","target":"qgh1k31"}],"expect":{"cited":{"node":"mhp0at8","node_hash":"ee42c4780724a411697e3a95daf182d37c792d4689a7172f32929785d5fd968e","result":"current","span":[48,60]},"cites":[],"citing":{"node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"ad3c22febaf3476b9657fb57668de5c55d12a1df1b569cd9230239d915c1a8a5","reason":"the node changed and the quote does not occur exactly once","result":"stale"},"open":"smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb#mhp0at8@ee42c4[48:60]","reason":"the citing anchor is stale: the node changed and the quote does not occur exactly once","reference":"ebcq5cy","resolution":{"doc":"smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"document"},"result":"stale","side":"citing"},"id":"stale-citing","op":"resolve","same_as":[]}
{"annotation":{"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"kind":"trace","note":"The abstract states the two steps: a scan first, then vibrational frequencies.","proposer":{"model":{"name":"example-model","parameters":"998b5161e39e01c8bc43ef81ec89141e15b7ea53b2e936707920a6097dbcb2c5","processor":"local","prompt":"9cc338fba7c62db7266f530cb555a5ee36910d41a0120a3fe7fd7de1944d0931","provider":"Example Models (illustrative)","version":"2026-09","weights":"504b2d340045b92c22682b60020c21103aae7ff41172bb632fbe305eb4af9b5e"},"rank":1,"run":"illustrative-run-2","score":"0.8731"},"reference":"ebcq5cy","selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"mhp0at8","node_hash":"ee42c4780724a411697e3a95daf182d37c792d4689a7172f32929785d5fd968e","own_hash":"24cc437784bf358d639755dbf59984ad2c0c7a0e7f9448b23e965039b67f759b","quote":{"exact":"in two steps","prefix":"bond constants for twelve bonds ","suffix":", first to a scan and then to vi"},"rev":12,"span":[48,60],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"in two steps","prefix":"bond constants for twelve bonds ","suffix":", first to a scan and then to vi","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource","verdict":"supports"},"created":"2026-10-12T09:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:software:example-model","name":"A model (illustrative)","type":"Software"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/jh0e4st2c0kpt","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/tr6c3q8m","motivation":"linking","receipt":"qvckzaatz5d1v","status":"confirmed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"93a39490870e694299e88e6f475d42c38078d1442959e555bdbdf58488dcf187","own_hash":"e004436e7b28ff3dc41e0056f231ba707d9be985694e68acb911345a547842ed","quote":{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1"},"rev":0,"span":[26,38],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"},"cited":"fixtures/packages/hale2026harmonic-damb","cited_corrections":[{"at":"2026-10-13T12:00:00Z","author":{"key":"ana"},"evidence":[{"by":"ana","kind":"person"}],"find":"in two steps","op":"replace","reason":"Vector.","replace":"in three stages","target":"mhp0at8"}],"citing":"fixtures/packages/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","citing_corrections":[{"at":"2026-10-13T12:00:00Z","author":{"key":"ana"},"evidence":[{"by":"ana","kind":"person"}],"find":"two-step","op":"replace","reason":"Vector.","replace":"two-stage","target":"qgh1k31"}],"expect":{"cited":{"node":"mhp0at8","node_hash":"a4946bd7586cb81977f8b1c85d34de7d15b9a3e5cc33c0308da54b1148e124f9","reason":"the node changed and the quote does not occur exactly once","result":"stale"},"cites":[],"citing":{"node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"ad3c22febaf3476b9657fb57668de5c55d12a1df1b569cd9230239d915c1a8a5","reason":"the node changed and the quote does not occur exactly once","result":"stale"},"open":null,"reason":"the citing anchor is stale: the node changed and the quote does not occur exactly once; the cited anchor is stale: the node changed and the quote does not occur exactly once","reference":"ebcq5cy","resolution":{"doc":"smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"document"},"result":"stale","side":"both"},"id":"stale-both","op":"resolve","same_as":[]}
{"annotation":{"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"kind":"trace","note":"Table 1 lists the fitted constants of both parameter sets.","reference":"ebcq5cy","selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"table","node":"hj4s7pb","node_hash":"6c6fba200faf41cd06fa8b64e06e2aa29ff8848568b859ae42d1902596348643","own_hash":"66310a9ab1c92568f4c6cae012e35d4245d4ca4b89d2542b7c2113a31ad379ed","rev":12,"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource","verdict":"supports"},"created":"2026-10-12T09:10:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:key:ana","name":"Ana Example","type":"Person"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/fhnynfb8jx0wc","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/tr6c3q8m","motivation":"linking","receipt":"qvckzaatz5d1v","status":"confirmed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"93a39490870e694299e88e6f475d42c38078d1442959e555bdbdf58488dcf187","own_hash":"e004436e7b28ff3dc41e0056f231ba707d9be985694e68acb911345a547842ed","quote":{"exact":"Its constants come from a two-step fit (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1"},"rev":0,"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"Its constants come from a two-step fit (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1","prefix":"","suffix":"","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"},"cited":"fixtures/packages/hale2026harmonic-damb","cited_corrections":[],"citing":"fixtures/packages/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","citing_corrections":[{"at":"2026-10-13T12:00:00Z","author":{"key":"ana"},"evidence":[{"by":"ana","kind":"person"}],"find":"two-step","op":"replace","reason":"Vector.","replace":"two-stage","target":"qgh1k31"}],"expect":{"cited":{"node":"hj4s7pb","node_hash":"6c6fba200faf41cd06fa8b64e06e2aa29ff8848568b859ae42d1902596348643","result":"current"},"cites":[],"citing":{"node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"ad3c22febaf3476b9657fb57668de5c55d12a1df1b569cd9230239d915c1a8a5","reason":"the node changed and the quote does not occur exactly once","result":"stale"},"open":"smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb#hj4s7pb@6c6fba","reason":"the citing anchor is stale: the node changed and the quote does not occur exactly once","reference":"ebcq5cy","resolution":{"doc":"smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"document"},"result":"stale","side":"citing"},"id":"stale-citing-whole-sentence","op":"resolve","same_as":[]}
{"annotation":{"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"kind":"trace","note":"The abstract states the two steps: a scan first, then vibrational frequencies.","proposer":{"model":{"name":"example-model","parameters":"998b5161e39e01c8bc43ef81ec89141e15b7ea53b2e936707920a6097dbcb2c5","processor":"local","prompt":"9cc338fba7c62db7266f530cb555a5ee36910d41a0120a3fe7fd7de1944d0931","provider":"Example Models (illustrative)","version":"2026-09","weights":"504b2d340045b92c22682b60020c21103aae7ff41172bb632fbe305eb4af9b5e"},"rank":1,"run":"illustrative-run-2","score":"0.8731"},"reference":"ebcq5cy","selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"mhp0at8","node_hash":"ee42c4780724a411697e3a95daf182d37c792d4689a7172f32929785d5fd968e","own_hash":"24cc437784bf358d639755dbf59984ad2c0c7a0e7f9448b23e965039b67f759b","quote":{"exact":"in two steps","prefix":"bond constants for twelve bonds ","suffix":", first to a scan and then to vi"},"rev":12,"span":[48,60],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"in two steps","prefix":"bond constants for twelve bonds ","suffix":", first to a scan and then to vi","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource","verdict":"supports"},"created":"2026-10-12T09:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:software:example-model","name":"A model (illustrative)","type":"Software"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/jh0e4st2c0kpt","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/tr6c3q8m","motivation":"linking","receipt":"qvckzaatz5d1v","status":"confirmed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"93a39490870e694299e88e6f475d42c38078d1442959e555bdbdf58488dcf187","own_hash":"e004436e7b28ff3dc41e0056f231ba707d9be985694e68acb911345a547842ed","quote":{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1"},"rev":0,"span":[26,38],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"},"cited":"fixtures/packages/hale2026harmonic-damb","cited_corrections":[],"citing":"fixtures/packages/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","citing_corrections":[{"at":"2026-10-13T12:00:00Z","author":{"key":"ana"},"evidence":[{"by":"ana","kind":"person"}],"op":"relink","reason":"Vector.","refs":null,"run":3,"target":"qgh1k31"}],"expect":{"cited":{"node":"mhp0at8","node_hash":"ee42c4780724a411697e3a95daf182d37c792d4689a7172f32929785d5fd968e","result":"current","span":[48,60]},"cites":[],"citing":{"node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"401c7460dc29e50f3e6ecd8968118b41d7cfd8be24c81e6ef388eb66c7361044","result":"reattached","span":[26,38]},"open":"smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb#mhp0at8@ee42c4[48:60]","reason":"the sentence no longer cites the reference","reference":"ebcq5cy","resolution":{"doc":"smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"document"},"result":"unlinked"},"id":"unlinked","op":"resolve","same_as":[]}
{"annotation":{"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"kind":"trace","note":"The abstract states the two steps: a scan first, then vibrational frequencies.","proposer":{"model":{"name":"example-model","parameters":"998b5161e39e01c8bc43ef81ec89141e15b7ea53b2e936707920a6097dbcb2c5","processor":"local","prompt":"9cc338fba7c62db7266f530cb555a5ee36910d41a0120a3fe7fd7de1944d0931","provider":"Example Models (illustrative)","version":"2026-09","weights":"504b2d340045b92c22682b60020c21103aae7ff41172bb632fbe305eb4af9b5e"},"rank":1,"run":"illustrative-run-2","score":"0.8731"},"reference":"ebcq5cy","selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"mhp0at8","node_hash":"ee42c4780724a411697e3a95daf182d37c792d4689a7172f32929785d5fd968e","own_hash":"24cc437784bf358d639755dbf59984ad2c0c7a0e7f9448b23e965039b67f759b","quote":{"exact":"in two steps","prefix":"bond constants for twelve bonds ","suffix":", first to a scan and then to vi"},"rev":12,"span":[48,60],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"in two steps","prefix":"bond constants for twelve bonds ","suffix":", first to a scan and then to vi","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource","verdict":"supports"},"created":"2026-10-12T09:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:software:example-model","name":"A model (illustrative)","type":"Software"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/jh0e4st2c0kpt","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/tr6c3q8m","motivation":"linking","receipt":"qvckzaatz5d1v","status":"confirmed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"93a39490870e694299e88e6f475d42c38078d1442959e555bdbdf58488dcf187","own_hash":"e004436e7b28ff3dc41e0056f231ba707d9be985694e68acb911345a547842ed","quote":{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1"},"rev":0,"span":[26,38],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"},"cited":"fixtures/packages/hale2026harmonic-damb","cited_corrections":[],"citing":"fixtures/packages/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","citing_corrections":[{"at":"2026-10-13T12:00:00Z","author":{"key":"ana"},"evidence":[{"by":"ana","kind":"person"}],"op":"resolve","reason":"Vector.","resolution":{"doi":"10.5555/example.other.2020","type":"doi"},"target":"ebcq5cy"}],"expect":{"cited":{"node":"mhp0at8","node_hash":"ee42c4780724a411697e3a95daf182d37c792d4689a7172f32929785d5fd968e","result":"current","span":[48,60]},"cites":[],"citing":{"node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"93a39490870e694299e88e6f475d42c38078d1442959e555bdbdf58488dcf187","result":"current","span":[26,38]},"open":"smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb#mhp0at8@ee42c4[48:60]","reason":"the reference resolves to doi:10.5555/example.other.2020, not to the cited work","reference":"ebcq5cy","resolution":{"doi":"10.5555/example.other.2020","type":"doi"},"result":"misresolved"},"id":"misresolved-doi","op":"resolve","same_as":["doi:10.5555/example.hale.2026"]}
{"annotation":{"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"kind":"trace","note":"The abstract states the two steps: a scan first, then vibrational frequencies.","proposer":{"model":{"name":"example-model","parameters":"998b5161e39e01c8bc43ef81ec89141e15b7ea53b2e936707920a6097dbcb2c5","processor":"local","prompt":"9cc338fba7c62db7266f530cb555a5ee36910d41a0120a3fe7fd7de1944d0931","provider":"Example Models (illustrative)","version":"2026-09","weights":"504b2d340045b92c22682b60020c21103aae7ff41172bb632fbe305eb4af9b5e"},"rank":1,"run":"illustrative-run-2","score":"0.8731"},"reference":"ebcq5cy","selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"mhp0at8","node_hash":"ee42c4780724a411697e3a95daf182d37c792d4689a7172f32929785d5fd968e","own_hash":"24cc437784bf358d639755dbf59984ad2c0c7a0e7f9448b23e965039b67f759b","quote":{"exact":"in two steps","prefix":"bond constants for twelve bonds ","suffix":", first to a scan and then to vi"},"rev":12,"span":[48,60],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"in two steps","prefix":"bond constants for twelve bonds ","suffix":", first to a scan and then to vi","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource","verdict":"supports"},"created":"2026-10-12T09:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:software:example-model","name":"A model (illustrative)","type":"Software"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/jh0e4st2c0kpt","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/tr6c3q8m","motivation":"linking","receipt":"qvckzaatz5d1v","status":"confirmed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"93a39490870e694299e88e6f475d42c38078d1442959e555bdbdf58488dcf187","own_hash":"e004436e7b28ff3dc41e0056f231ba707d9be985694e68acb911345a547842ed","quote":{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1"},"rev":0,"span":[26,38],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"},"cited":"fixtures/packages/hale2026harmonic-damb","cited_corrections":[],"citing":"fixtures/packages/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","citing_corrections":[{"at":"2026-10-13T12:00:00Z","author":{"key":"ana"},"evidence":[{"by":"ana","kind":"person"}],"op":"resolve","reason":"Vector.","resolution":{"doc":"smithlab/okafor2025solvent-acth","type":"document"},"target":"ebcq5cy"}],"expect":{"cited":{"node":"mhp0at8","node_hash":"ee42c4780724a411697e3a95daf182d37c792d4689a7172f32929785d5fd968e","result":"current","span":[48,60]},"cites":[],"citing":{"node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"93a39490870e694299e88e6f475d42c38078d1442959e555bdbdf58488dcf187","result":"current","span":[26,38]},"open":"smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb#mhp0at8@ee42c4[48:60]","reason":"the reference resolves to smithlab/okafor2025solvent-acth, not to the cited work","reference":"ebcq5cy","resolution":{"doc":"smithlab/okafor2025solvent-acth","type":"document"},"result":"misresolved"},"id":"misresolved-document","op":"resolve","same_as":["doi:10.5555/example.hale.2026"]}
{"annotation":{"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"kind":"trace","note":"The abstract states the two steps: a scan first, then vibrational frequencies.","proposer":{"model":{"name":"example-model","parameters":"998b5161e39e01c8bc43ef81ec89141e15b7ea53b2e936707920a6097dbcb2c5","processor":"local","prompt":"9cc338fba7c62db7266f530cb555a5ee36910d41a0120a3fe7fd7de1944d0931","provider":"Example Models (illustrative)","version":"2026-09","weights":"504b2d340045b92c22682b60020c21103aae7ff41172bb632fbe305eb4af9b5e"},"rank":1,"run":"illustrative-run-2","score":"0.8731"},"reference":"ebcq5cy","selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"mhp0at8","node_hash":"ee42c4780724a411697e3a95daf182d37c792d4689a7172f32929785d5fd968e","own_hash":"24cc437784bf358d639755dbf59984ad2c0c7a0e7f9448b23e965039b67f759b","quote":{"exact":"in two steps","prefix":"bond constants for twelve bonds ","suffix":", first to a scan and then to vi"},"rev":12,"span":[48,60],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"in two steps","prefix":"bond constants for twelve bonds ","suffix":", first to a scan and then to vi","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource","verdict":"supports"},"created":"2026-10-12T09:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:software:example-model","name":"A model (illustrative)","type":"Software"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/jh0e4st2c0kpt","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/tr6c3q8m","motivation":"linking","receipt":"qvckzaatz5d1v","status":"confirmed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"93a39490870e694299e88e6f475d42c38078d1442959e555bdbdf58488dcf187","own_hash":"e004436e7b28ff3dc41e0056f231ba707d9be985694e68acb911345a547842ed","quote":{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1"},"rev":0,"span":[26,38],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"},"cited":"fixtures/packages/hale2026harmonic-damb","cited_corrections":[],"citing":"fixtures/packages/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","citing_corrections":[{"at":"2026-10-13T12:00:00Z","author":{"key":"ana"},"evidence":[{"by":"ana","kind":"person"}],"op":"resolve","reason":"Vector.","resolution":{"doi":"10.5555/example.hale.2026","type":"doi"},"target":"ebcq5cy"}],"expect":{"cited":{"node":"mhp0at8","node_hash":"ee42c4780724a411697e3a95daf182d37c792d4689a7172f32929785d5fd968e","result":"current","span":[48,60]},"cites":[],"citing":{"node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"93a39490870e694299e88e6f475d42c38078d1442959e555bdbdf58488dcf187","result":"current","span":[26,38]},"open":"smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb#mhp0at8@ee42c4[48:60]","reason":"the reference resolves to doi:10.5555/example.hale.2026, not to the cited work","reference":"ebcq5cy","resolution":{"doi":"10.5555/example.hale.2026","type":"doi"},"result":"misresolved"},"id":"misresolved-doi-without-same-as","op":"resolve","same_as":[]}
{"annotation":{"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"kind":"trace","note":"The abstract states the two steps: a scan first, then vibrational frequencies.","proposer":{"model":{"name":"example-model","parameters":"998b5161e39e01c8bc43ef81ec89141e15b7ea53b2e936707920a6097dbcb2c5","processor":"local","prompt":"9cc338fba7c62db7266f530cb555a5ee36910d41a0120a3fe7fd7de1944d0931","provider":"Example Models (illustrative)","version":"2026-09","weights":"504b2d340045b92c22682b60020c21103aae7ff41172bb632fbe305eb4af9b5e"},"rank":1,"run":"illustrative-run-2","score":"0.8731"},"reference":"ebcq5cy","selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"mhp0at8","node_hash":"ee42c4780724a411697e3a95daf182d37c792d4689a7172f32929785d5fd968e","own_hash":"24cc437784bf358d639755dbf59984ad2c0c7a0e7f9448b23e965039b67f759b","quote":{"exact":"in two steps","prefix":"bond constants for twelve bonds ","suffix":", first to a scan and then to vi"},"rev":12,"span":[48,60],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"in two steps","prefix":"bond constants for twelve bonds ","suffix":", first to a scan and then to vi","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource","verdict":"supports"},"created":"2026-10-12T09:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:software:example-model","name":"A model (illustrative)","type":"Software"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/jh0e4st2c0kpt","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/tr6c3q8m","motivation":"linking","receipt":"qvckzaatz5d1v","status":"confirmed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"93a39490870e694299e88e6f475d42c38078d1442959e555bdbdf58488dcf187","own_hash":"e004436e7b28ff3dc41e0056f231ba707d9be985694e68acb911345a547842ed","quote":{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1"},"rev":0,"span":[26,38],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"},"cited":"fixtures/packages/hale2026harmonic-damb","cited_corrections":[],"citing":"fixtures/packages/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","citing_corrections":[{"at":"2026-10-13T12:00:00Z","author":{"key":"ana"},"evidence":[{"by":"ana","kind":"person"}],"op":"resolve","reason":"Vector.","resolution":{"doi":"10.5555/Example.Hale.2026","type":"doi"},"target":"ebcq5cy"}],"expect":{"cited":{"node":"mhp0at8","node_hash":"ee42c4780724a411697e3a95daf182d37c792d4689a7172f32929785d5fd968e","result":"current","span":[48,60]},"cites":[],"citing":{"node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"93a39490870e694299e88e6f475d42c38078d1442959e555bdbdf58488dcf187","result":"current","span":[26,38]},"open":"smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb#mhp0at8@ee42c4[48:60]","reference":"ebcq5cy","resolution":{"doi":"10.5555/Example.Hale.2026","type":"doi"},"result":"current"},"id":"current-doi-in-same-as","op":"resolve","same_as":["doi:10.5555/example.hale.2026"]}
{"annotation":{"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"kind":"trace","note":"The abstract states the two steps: a scan first, then vibrational frequencies.","proposer":{"model":{"name":"example-model","parameters":"998b5161e39e01c8bc43ef81ec89141e15b7ea53b2e936707920a6097dbcb2c5","processor":"local","prompt":"9cc338fba7c62db7266f530cb555a5ee36910d41a0120a3fe7fd7de1944d0931","provider":"Example Models (illustrative)","version":"2026-09","weights":"504b2d340045b92c22682b60020c21103aae7ff41172bb632fbe305eb4af9b5e"},"rank":1,"run":"illustrative-run-2","score":"0.8731"},"reference":"ebcq5cy","selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"mhp0at8","node_hash":"ee42c4780724a411697e3a95daf182d37c792d4689a7172f32929785d5fd968e","own_hash":"24cc437784bf358d639755dbf59984ad2c0c7a0e7f9448b23e965039b67f759b","quote":{"exact":"in two steps","prefix":"bond constants for twelve bonds ","suffix":", first to a scan and then to vi"},"rev":12,"span":[48,60],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"in two steps","prefix":"bond constants for twelve bonds ","suffix":", first to a scan and then to vi","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource","verdict":"supports"},"created":"2026-10-12T09:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:software:example-model","name":"A model (illustrative)","type":"Software"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/jh0e4st2c0kpt","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/tr6c3q8m","motivation":"linking","receipt":"qvckzaatz5d1v","status":"confirmed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"93a39490870e694299e88e6f475d42c38078d1442959e555bdbdf58488dcf187","own_hash":"e004436e7b28ff3dc41e0056f231ba707d9be985694e68acb911345a547842ed","quote":{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1"},"rev":0,"span":[26,38],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"},"cited":"fixtures/packages/hale2026harmonic-damb","cited_corrections":[],"citing":"fixtures/packages/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","citing_corrections":[{"at":"2026-10-13T12:00:00Z","author":{"key":"ana"},"evidence":[{"by":"ana","kind":"person"}],"op":"resolve","reason":"Vector.","resolution":{"doc":"smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb.v2","type":"document"},"target":"ebcq5cy"}],"expect":{"cited":{"node":"mhp0at8","node_hash":"ee42c4780724a411697e3a95daf182d37c792d4689a7172f32929785d5fd968e","result":"current","span":[48,60]},"cites":[],"citing":{"node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"93a39490870e694299e88e6f475d42c38078d1442959e555bdbdf58488dcf187","result":"current","span":[26,38]},"open":"smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb#mhp0at8@ee42c4[48:60]","reference":"ebcq5cy","resolution":{"doc":"smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb.v2","type":"document"},"result":"current"},"id":"current-another-version","op":"resolve","same_as":[]}
{"annotation":{"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"kind":"trace","note":"The abstract states the two steps: a scan first, then vibrational frequencies.","proposer":{"model":{"name":"example-model","parameters":"998b5161e39e01c8bc43ef81ec89141e15b7ea53b2e936707920a6097dbcb2c5","processor":"local","prompt":"9cc338fba7c62db7266f530cb555a5ee36910d41a0120a3fe7fd7de1944d0931","provider":"Example Models (illustrative)","version":"2026-09","weights":"504b2d340045b92c22682b60020c21103aae7ff41172bb632fbe305eb4af9b5e"},"rank":1,"run":"illustrative-run-2","score":"0.8731"},"reference":"ebcq5cy","selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"mhp0at8","node_hash":"ee42c4780724a411697e3a95daf182d37c792d4689a7172f32929785d5fd968e","own_hash":"24cc437784bf358d639755dbf59984ad2c0c7a0e7f9448b23e965039b67f759b","quote":{"exact":"in two steps","prefix":"bond constants for twelve bonds ","suffix":", first to a scan and then to vi"},"rev":12,"span":[48,60],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"in two steps","prefix":"bond constants for twelve bonds ","suffix":", first to a scan and then to vi","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource","verdict":"supports"},"created":"2026-10-12T09:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:software:example-model","name":"A model (illustrative)","type":"Software"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/jh0e4st2c0kpt","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/tr6c3q8m","motivation":"linking","receipt":"qvckzaatz5d1v","status":"confirmed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"93a39490870e694299e88e6f475d42c38078d1442959e555bdbdf58488dcf187","own_hash":"e004436e7b28ff3dc41e0056f231ba707d9be985694e68acb911345a547842ed","quote":{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1"},"rev":0,"span":[26,38],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"},"cited":"fixtures/packages/hale2026harmonic-damb","cited_corrections":[],"citing":"fixtures/packages/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","citing_corrections":[{"at":"2026-10-13T12:00:00Z","author":{"key":"ana"},"evidence":[{"by":"ana","kind":"person"}],"op":"resolve","reason":"Vector.","resolution":{"type":"none"},"target":"ebcq5cy"}],"expect":{"cited":{"node":"mhp0at8","node_hash":"ee42c4780724a411697e3a95daf182d37c792d4689a7172f32929785d5fd968e","result":"current","span":[48,60]},"cites":[],"citing":{"node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"93a39490870e694299e88e6f475d42c38078d1442959e555bdbdf58488dcf187","result":"current","span":[26,38]},"open":"smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb#mhp0at8@ee42c4[48:60]","reference":"ebcq5cy","resolution":{"type":"none"},"result":"current"},"id":"current-reference-unresolved","op":"resolve","same_as":[]}
{"annotation":{"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"kind":"trace","note":"The abstract states the two steps: a scan first, then vibrational frequencies.","proposer":{"model":{"name":"example-model","parameters":"998b5161e39e01c8bc43ef81ec89141e15b7ea53b2e936707920a6097dbcb2c5","processor":"local","prompt":"9cc338fba7c62db7266f530cb555a5ee36910d41a0120a3fe7fd7de1944d0931","provider":"Example Models (illustrative)","version":"2026-09","weights":"504b2d340045b92c22682b60020c21103aae7ff41172bb632fbe305eb4af9b5e"},"rank":1,"run":"illustrative-run-2","score":"0.8731"},"reference":"ebcq5cy","selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"mhp0at8","node_hash":"ee42c4780724a411697e3a95daf182d37c792d4689a7172f32929785d5fd968e","own_hash":"24cc437784bf358d639755dbf59984ad2c0c7a0e7f9448b23e965039b67f759b","quote":{"exact":"in two steps","prefix":"bond constants for twelve bonds ","suffix":", first to a scan and then to vi"},"rev":12,"span":[48,60],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"in two steps","prefix":"bond constants for twelve bonds ","suffix":", first to a scan and then to vi","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource","verdict":"supports"},"created":"2026-10-12T09:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:software:example-model","name":"A model (illustrative)","type":"Software"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/jh0e4st2c0kpt","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/tr6c3q8m","motivation":"linking","receipt":"qvckzaatz5d1v","status":"confirmed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"93a39490870e694299e88e6f475d42c38078d1442959e555bdbdf58488dcf187","own_hash":"e004436e7b28ff3dc41e0056f231ba707d9be985694e68acb911345a547842ed","quote":{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1"},"rev":0,"span":[26,38],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"},"cited":"fixtures/packages/hale2026harmonic-damb","cited_corrections":[],"citing":"fixtures/packages/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","citing_corrections":[{"at":"2026-10-13T12:00:00Z","author":{"key":"ana"},"evidence":[{"by":"ana","kind":"person"}],"op":"relink","reason":"Vector.","refs":null,"run":3,"target":"qgh1k31"},{"at":"2026-10-13T12:00:00Z","author":{"key":"ana"},"evidence":[{"by":"ana","kind":"person"}],"op":"resolve","reason":"Vector.","resolution":{"doi":"10.5555/example.other.2020","type":"doi"},"target":"ebcq5cy"}],"expect":{"cited":{"node":"mhp0at8","node_hash":"ee42c4780724a411697e3a95daf182d37c792d4689a7172f32929785d5fd968e","result":"current","span":[48,60]},"cites":[],"citing":{"node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"401c7460dc29e50f3e6ecd8968118b41d7cfd8be24c81e6ef388eb66c7361044","result":"reattached","span":[26,38]},"open":"smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb#mhp0at8@ee42c4[48:60]","reason":"the sentence no longer cites the reference","reference":"ebcq5cy","resolution":{"doi":"10.5555/example.other.2020","type":"doi"},"result":"unlinked"},"id":"unlinked-before-misresolved","op":"resolve","same_as":[]}
{"annotation":{"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"kind":"trace","note":"The abstract states the two steps: a scan first, then vibrational frequencies.","proposer":{"model":{"name":"example-model","parameters":"998b5161e39e01c8bc43ef81ec89141e15b7ea53b2e936707920a6097dbcb2c5","processor":"local","prompt":"9cc338fba7c62db7266f530cb555a5ee36910d41a0120a3fe7fd7de1944d0931","provider":"Example Models (illustrative)","version":"2026-09","weights":"504b2d340045b92c22682b60020c21103aae7ff41172bb632fbe305eb4af9b5e"},"rank":1,"run":"illustrative-run-2","score":"0.8731"},"reference":"ebcq5cy","selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"mhp0at8","node_hash":"ee42c4780724a411697e3a95daf182d37c792d4689a7172f32929785d5fd968e","own_hash":"24cc437784bf358d639755dbf59984ad2c0c7a0e7f9448b23e965039b67f759b","quote":{"exact":"in two steps","prefix":"bond constants for twelve bonds ","suffix":", first to a scan and then to vi"},"rev":12,"span":[48,60],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"in two steps","prefix":"bond constants for twelve bonds ","suffix":", first to a scan and then to vi","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource","verdict":"supports"},"created":"2026-10-12T09:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:software:example-model","name":"A model (illustrative)","type":"Software"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/jh0e4st2c0kpt","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/tr6c3q8m","motivation":"linking","receipt":"qvckzaatz5d1v","status":"confirmed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"93a39490870e694299e88e6f475d42c38078d1442959e555bdbdf58488dcf187","own_hash":"e004436e7b28ff3dc41e0056f231ba707d9be985694e68acb911345a547842ed","quote":{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1"},"rev":0,"span":[26,38],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"},"cited":"fixtures/packages/hale2026harmonic-damb","citing":"fixtures/packages/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","expect":[],"id":"problems-none","op":"problems"}
{"annotation":{"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"kind":"trace","note":"Table 1 lists the fitted constants of both parameter sets.","reference":"ebcq5cy","selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"table","node":"hj4s7pb","node_hash":"6c6fba200faf41cd06fa8b64e06e2aa29ff8848568b859ae42d1902596348643","own_hash":"66310a9ab1c92568f4c6cae012e35d4245d4ca4b89d2542b7c2113a31ad379ed","rev":12,"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource","verdict":"supports"},"created":"2026-10-12T09:10:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:key:ana","name":"Ana Example","type":"Person"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/fhnynfb8jx0wc","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/tr6c3q8m","motivation":"linking","receipt":"qvckzaatz5d1v","status":"confirmed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"93a39490870e694299e88e6f475d42c38078d1442959e555bdbdf58488dcf187","own_hash":"e004436e7b28ff3dc41e0056f231ba707d9be985694e68acb911345a547842ed","quote":{"exact":"Its constants come from a two-step fit (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1"},"rev":0,"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"Its constants come from a two-step fit (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1","prefix":"","suffix":"","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"},"cited":"fixtures/packages/hale2026harmonic-damb","citing":"fixtures/packages/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","expect":[],"id":"problems-table","op":"problems"}
{"annotation":{"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"kind":"trace","note":"The abstract states the two steps: a scan first, then vibrational frequencies.","proposer":{"model":{"name":"example-model","parameters":"998b5161e39e01c8bc43ef81ec89141e15b7ea53b2e936707920a6097dbcb2c5","processor":"local","prompt":"9cc338fba7c62db7266f530cb555a5ee36910d41a0120a3fe7fd7de1944d0931","provider":"Example Models (illustrative)","version":"2026-09","weights":"504b2d340045b92c22682b60020c21103aae7ff41172bb632fbe305eb4af9b5e"},"rank":1,"run":"illustrative-run-2","score":"0.8731"},"reference":"ebcq5cy","selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"mhp0at8","node_hash":"ee42c4780724a411697e3a95daf182d37c792d4689a7172f32929785d5fd968e","own_hash":"24cc437784bf358d639755dbf59984ad2c0c7a0e7f9448b23e965039b67f759b","quote":{"exact":"in two steps","prefix":"bond constants for twelve bonds ","suffix":", first to a scan and then to vi"},"rev":12,"span":[48,60],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"in two steps","prefix":"bond constants for twelve bonds ","suffix":", first to a scan and then to vi","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/okafor2025solvent-acth","type":"SpecificResource","verdict":"supports"},"created":"2026-10-12T09:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:software:example-model","name":"A model (illustrative)","type":"Software"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/jh0e4st2c0kpt","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/tr6c3q8m","motivation":"linking","receipt":"qvckzaatz5d1v","status":"confirmed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"93a39490870e694299e88e6f475d42c38078d1442959e555bdbdf58488dcf187","own_hash":"e004436e7b28ff3dc41e0056f231ba707d9be985694e68acb911345a547842ed","quote":{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1"},"rev":0,"span":[26,38],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"},"cited":"fixtures/packages/hale2026harmonic-damb","citing":"fixtures/packages/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","expect":[{"message":"an anchor of the selector is in hale2026harmonic-damb, not in the source smithlab/okafor2025solvent-acth","rule":"layer.trace.source"}],"id":"source-is-another-document","op":"problems"}
{"annotation":{"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"kind":"trace","note":"The abstract states the two steps: a scan first, then vibrational frequencies.","proposer":{"model":{"name":"example-model","parameters":"998b5161e39e01c8bc43ef81ec89141e15b7ea53b2e936707920a6097dbcb2c5","processor":"local","prompt":"9cc338fba7c62db7266f530cb555a5ee36910d41a0120a3fe7fd7de1944d0931","provider":"Example Models (illustrative)","version":"2026-09","weights":"504b2d340045b92c22682b60020c21103aae7ff41172bb632fbe305eb4af9b5e"},"rank":1,"run":"illustrative-run-2","score":"0.8731"},"reference":"ebcq5cy","selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"93a39490870e694299e88e6f475d42c38078d1442959e555bdbdf58488dcf187","own_hash":"e004436e7b28ff3dc41e0056f231ba707d9be985694e68acb911345a547842ed","quote":{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1"},"rev":0,"span":[26,38],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","type":"SpecificResource","verdict":"supports"},"created":"2026-10-12T09:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:software:example-model","name":"A model (illustrative)","type":"Software"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/jh0e4st2c0kpt","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/tr6c3q8m","motivation":"linking","receipt":"qvckzaatz5d1v","status":"confirmed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"93a39490870e694299e88e6f475d42c38078d1442959e555bdbdf58488dcf187","own_hash":"e004436e7b28ff3dc41e0056f231ba707d9be985694e68acb911345a547842ed","quote":{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1"},"rev":0,"span":[26,38],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"},"cited":null,"citing":"fixtures/packages/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","expect":[{"message":"the source is the citing document itself; a trace leads to another paper","rule":"layer.trace.source"}],"id":"source-is-the-citing-document","op":"problems"}
{"annotation":{"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"kind":"trace","note":"The abstract states the two steps: a scan first, then vibrational frequencies.","proposer":{"model":{"name":"example-model","parameters":"998b5161e39e01c8bc43ef81ec89141e15b7ea53b2e936707920a6097dbcb2c5","processor":"local","prompt":"9cc338fba7c62db7266f530cb555a5ee36910d41a0120a3fe7fd7de1944d0931","provider":"Example Models (illustrative)","version":"2026-09","weights":"504b2d340045b92c22682b60020c21103aae7ff41172bb632fbe305eb4af9b5e"},"rank":1,"run":"illustrative-run-2","score":"0.8731"},"reference":"ebcq5cy","selector":[{"exact":"in two steps","prefix":"bond constants for twelve bonds ","suffix":", first to a scan and then to vi","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource","verdict":"supports"},"created":"2026-10-12T09:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:software:example-model","name":"A model (illustrative)","type":"Software"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/jh0e4st2c0kpt","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/tr6c3q8m","motivation":"linking","receipt":"qvckzaatz5d1v","status":"confirmed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"93a39490870e694299e88e6f475d42c38078d1442959e555bdbdf58488dcf187","own_hash":"e004436e7b28ff3dc41e0056f231ba707d9be985694e68acb911345a547842ed","quote":{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1"},"rev":0,"span":[26,38],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"},"cited":null,"citing":"fixtures/packages/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","expect":[{"message":"the body's selector has no AnchorSelector","rule":"layer.trace.source"}],"id":"source-without-anchor","op":"problems"}
{"annotation":{"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"kind":"trace","note":"The abstract states the two steps: a scan first, then vibrational frequencies.","proposer":{"model":{"name":"example-model","parameters":"998b5161e39e01c8bc43ef81ec89141e15b7ea53b2e936707920a6097dbcb2c5","processor":"local","prompt":"9cc338fba7c62db7266f530cb555a5ee36910d41a0120a3fe7fd7de1944d0931","provider":"Example Models (illustrative)","version":"2026-09","weights":"504b2d340045b92c22682b60020c21103aae7ff41172bb632fbe305eb4af9b5e"},"rank":1,"run":"illustrative-run-2","score":"0.8731"},"reference":"ebcq5cy","selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"mhp0at8","node_hash":"ee42c4780724a411697e3a95daf182d37c792d4689a7172f32929785d5fd968e","own_hash":"24cc437784bf358d639755dbf59984ad2c0c7a0e7f9448b23e965039b67f759b","quote":{"exact":"in two steps","prefix":"bond constants for twelve bonds ","suffix":", first to a scan and then to vi"},"rev":12,"span":[48,60],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"in three steps","prefix":"bond constants for twelve bonds ","suffix":", first to a scan and then to vi","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource","verdict":"supports"},"created":"2026-10-12T09:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:software:example-model","name":"A model (illustrative)","type":"Software"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/jh0e4st2c0kpt","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/tr6c3q8m","motivation":"linking","receipt":"qvckzaatz5d1v","status":"confirmed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"93a39490870e694299e88e6f475d42c38078d1442959e555bdbdf58488dcf187","own_hash":"e004436e7b28ff3dc41e0056f231ba707d9be985694e68acb911345a547842ed","quote":{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1"},"rev":0,"span":[26,38],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"},"cited":"fixtures/packages/hale2026harmonic-damb","citing":"fixtures/packages/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","expect":[{"message":"the TextQuoteSelector does not repeat the anchor's plain quote","rule":"layer.trace.source"}],"id":"source-quote-differs","op":"problems"}
{"annotation":{"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"kind":"trace","note":"The abstract states the two steps: a scan first, then vibrational frequencies.","proposer":{"model":{"name":"example-model","parameters":"998b5161e39e01c8bc43ef81ec89141e15b7ea53b2e936707920a6097dbcb2c5","processor":"local","prompt":"9cc338fba7c62db7266f530cb555a5ee36910d41a0120a3fe7fd7de1944d0931","provider":"Example Models (illustrative)","version":"2026-09","weights":"504b2d340045b92c22682b60020c21103aae7ff41172bb632fbe305eb4af9b5e"},"rank":1,"run":"illustrative-run-2","score":"0.8731"},"reference":"ebcq5cy","selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"zzzzzzz","node_hash":"ee42c4780724a411697e3a95daf182d37c792d4689a7172f32929785d5fd968e","own_hash":"24cc437784bf358d639755dbf59984ad2c0c7a0e7f9448b23e965039b67f759b","quote":{"exact":"in two steps","prefix":"bond constants for twelve bonds ","suffix":", first to a scan and then to vi"},"rev":12,"span":[48,60],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource","verdict":"supports"},"created":"2026-10-12T09:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:software:example-model","name":"A model (illustrative)","type":"Software"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/jh0e4st2c0kpt","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/tr6c3q8m","motivation":"linking","receipt":"qvckzaatz5d1v","status":"confirmed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"93a39490870e694299e88e6f475d42c38078d1442959e555bdbdf58488dcf187","own_hash":"e004436e7b28ff3dc41e0056f231ba707d9be985694e68acb911345a547842ed","quote":{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1"},"rev":0,"span":[26,38],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"},"cited":"fixtures/packages/hale2026harmonic-damb","citing":"fixtures/packages/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","expect":[{"message":"the passage's node zzzzzzz is not in the cited document","rule":"layer.trace.source"}],"id":"source-node-unknown","op":"problems"}
{"annotation":{"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"kind":"trace","note":"The abstract states the two steps: a scan first, then vibrational frequencies.","proposer":{"model":{"name":"example-model","parameters":"998b5161e39e01c8bc43ef81ec89141e15b7ea53b2e936707920a6097dbcb2c5","processor":"local","prompt":"9cc338fba7c62db7266f530cb555a5ee36910d41a0120a3fe7fd7de1944d0931","provider":"Example Models (illustrative)","version":"2026-09","weights":"504b2d340045b92c22682b60020c21103aae7ff41172bb632fbe305eb4af9b5e"},"rank":1,"run":"illustrative-run-2","score":"0.8731"},"reference":"ebcq5cy","selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"mhp0at8","node_hash":"ee42c4780724a411697e3a95daf182d37c792d4689a7172f32929785d5fd968e","own_hash":"24cc437784bf358d639755dbf59984ad2c0c7a0e7f9448b23e965039b67f759b","quote":{"exact":"in two steps","prefix":"bond constants for twelve bonds ","suffix":", first to a scan and then to vi"},"rev":12,"span":[48,60],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"in two steps","prefix":"bond constants for twelve bonds ","suffix":", first to a scan and then to vi","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource","verdict":"supports"},"created":"2026-10-12T09:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:software:example-model","name":"A model (illustrative)","type":"Software"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/jh0e4st2c0kpt","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/tr6c3q8m","motivation":"linking","receipt":"qvckzaatz5d1v","status":"confirmed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"paragraph","leaves":[["kda5wym","8f22f3f58beb618723a14dd8fee8caaeb5cef6b26f43d88a5ddb4ff42f86d63e"],["qgh1k31","fe82fa8560942e052e31d9b18cc8d3a9ba54ce01d91b66538ded6ff682a4e885"],["wbntyy4","9b297e00b7348c2df4c6b12f67b2f879217a0d71e1be382fc8a4f6bd7439ddd0"]],"node":"x9ryw92","node_hash":"b17dff0cff3ce730e52efca92b9fe585ffc956cc9f76e52a8b37721cbbec442f","own_hash":"494e069be36a18ecaabf5a63be7c31617ade7a5460218ca83a2de3d8d8f964e0","rev":0,"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"},"cited":"fixtures/packages/hale2026harmonic-damb","citing":"fixtures/packages/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","expect":[{"message":"the target anchor is not on a leaf with runs, whole or in part","rule":"layer.trace.target"}],"id":"target-is-a-paragraph","op":"problems"}
{"annotation":{"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"kind":"trace","note":"The abstract states the two steps: a scan first, then vibrational frequencies.","proposer":{"model":{"name":"example-model","parameters":"998b5161e39e01c8bc43ef81ec89141e15b7ea53b2e936707920a6097dbcb2c5","processor":"local","prompt":"9cc338fba7c62db7266f530cb555a5ee36910d41a0120a3fe7fd7de1944d0931","provider":"Example Models (illustrative)","version":"2026-09","weights":"504b2d340045b92c22682b60020c21103aae7ff41172bb632fbe305eb4af9b5e"},"rank":1,"run":"illustrative-run-2","score":"0.8731"},"reference":"ebcq5cy","selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"mhp0at8","node_hash":"ee42c4780724a411697e3a95daf182d37c792d4689a7172f32929785d5fd968e","own_hash":"24cc437784bf358d639755dbf59984ad2c0c7a0e7f9448b23e965039b67f759b","quote":{"exact":"in two steps","prefix":"bond constants for twelve bonds ","suffix":", first to a scan and then to vi"},"rev":12,"span":[48,60],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"in two steps","prefix":"bond constants for twelve bonds ","suffix":", first to a scan and then to vi","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource","verdict":"supports"},"created":"2026-10-12T09:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:software:example-model","name":"A model (illustrative)","type":"Software"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/jh0e4st2c0kpt","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/tr6c3q8m","motivation":"linking","receipt":"qvckzaatz5d1v","status":"confirmed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"kda5wym","node_hash":"dd438a68616e63fd1cd5050d308779af58dfed2b4d43cc5a4bbab3fc8d4f2bcb","own_hash":"46dfbddc0e456a2b7f4105b8d3636220ff9145acccf3bdf81a206f0b84f95b63","quote":{"exact":"The bond term is harmonic in the bond length."},"rev":0,"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"The bond term is harmonic in the bond length.","prefix":"","suffix":"","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"},"cited":"fixtures/packages/hale2026harmonic-damb","citing":"fixtures/packages/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","expect":[{"message":"the sentence does not cite the reference ebcq5cy","rule":"layer.trace.target"}],"id":"target-cites-nothing","op":"problems"}
{"annotation":{"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"kind":"trace","note":"The abstract states the two steps: a scan first, then vibrational frequencies.","proposer":{"model":{"name":"example-model","parameters":"998b5161e39e01c8bc43ef81ec89141e15b7ea53b2e936707920a6097dbcb2c5","processor":"local","prompt":"9cc338fba7c62db7266f530cb555a5ee36910d41a0120a3fe7fd7de1944d0931","provider":"Example Models (illustrative)","version":"2026-09","weights":"504b2d340045b92c22682b60020c21103aae7ff41172bb632fbe305eb4af9b5e"},"rank":1,"run":"illustrative-run-2","score":"0.8731"},"reference":"qgh1k31","selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"mhp0at8","node_hash":"ee42c4780724a411697e3a95daf182d37c792d4689a7172f32929785d5fd968e","own_hash":"24cc437784bf358d639755dbf59984ad2c0c7a0e7f9448b23e965039b67f759b","quote":{"exact":"in two steps","prefix":"bond constants for twelve bonds ","suffix":", first to a scan and then to vi"},"rev":12,"span":[48,60],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"in two steps","prefix":"bond constants for twelve bonds ","suffix":", first to a scan and then to vi","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource","verdict":"supports"},"created":"2026-10-12T09:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:software:example-model","name":"A model (illustrative)","type":"Software"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/jh0e4st2c0kpt","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/tr6c3q8m","motivation":"linking","receipt":"qvckzaatz5d1v","status":"confirmed","target":{"selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"qgh1k31","node_hash":"93a39490870e694299e88e6f475d42c38078d1442959e555bdbdf58488dcf187","own_hash":"e004436e7b28ff3dc41e0056f231ba707d9be985694e68acb911345a547842ed","quote":{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1"},"rev":0,"span":[26,38],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"two-step fit","prefix":"Its constants come from a ","suffix":" (Hale and Osei, Table 1).1","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"},"cited":"fixtures/packages/hale2026harmonic-damb","citing":"fixtures/packages/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","expect":[{"message":"the reference qgh1k31 is not a reference node of the citing document","rule":"layer.trace.target"}],"id":"target-reference-is-a-sentence","op":"problems"}
{"annotation":{"@context":["http://www.w3.org/ns/anno.jsonld","https://paperspec.scient.ing/context/scienting-1.jsonld"],"body":{"kind":"trace","note":"The abstract states the two steps: a scan first, then vibrational frequencies.","proposer":{"model":{"name":"example-model","parameters":"998b5161e39e01c8bc43ef81ec89141e15b7ea53b2e936707920a6097dbcb2c5","processor":"local","prompt":"9cc338fba7c62db7266f530cb555a5ee36910d41a0120a3fe7fd7de1944d0931","provider":"Example Models (illustrative)","version":"2026-09","weights":"504b2d340045b92c22682b60020c21103aae7ff41172bb632fbe305eb4af9b5e"},"rank":1,"run":"illustrative-run-2","score":"0.8731"},"reference":"ebcq5cy","selector":[{"anchor":{"doc":"hale2026harmonic-damb","format":"scienting-anchor/1","kind":"sentence","node":"mhp0at8","node_hash":"ee42c4780724a411697e3a95daf182d37c792d4689a7172f32929785d5fd968e","own_hash":"24cc437784bf358d639755dbf59984ad2c0c7a0e7f9448b23e965039b67f759b","quote":{"exact":"in two steps","prefix":"bond constants for twelve bonds ","suffix":", first to a scan and then to vi"},"rev":12,"span":[48,60],"store":"smithlab"},"type":"AnchorSelector"},{"exact":"in two steps","prefix":"bond constants for twelve bonds ","suffix":", first to a scan and then to vi","type":"TextQuoteSelector"}],"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:doc:smithlab/hale2026harmonic-damb","type":"SpecificResource","verdict":"supports"},"created":"2026-10-12T09:00:00Z","creator":{"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:software:example-model","name":"A model (illustrative)","type":"Software"},"id":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/jh0e4st2c0kpt","layer":"tag:scient.ing,2026:layer:smithlab/tr6c3q8m","motivation":"linking","receipt":"qvckzaatz5d1v","status":"confirmed","target":{"source":"tag:scient.ing,2026:annotation:smithlab/arm3zmj6be9fz","type":"SpecificResource"},"type":"Annotation"},"cited":"fixtures/packages/hale2026harmonic-damb","citing":"fixtures/packages/writer2027fixed-ynr7.v3","expect":[{"message":"the target is not a document selected by an AnchorSelector","rule":"layer.trace.target"}],"id":"target-is-a-reply","op":"problems"}
+3 -3
View File
@@ -1,6 +1,6 @@
{"alpha":"","beta":"90cf1df3b703cce59e2a35b925d411164068269d7b2d29f3301c03dd757876ff66b71dda49d2de59d03450451af026798e8f81cd2e333de5cdf4f3e140fdd8ae","id":"rfc9381-example-16","proof":"8657106690b5526245a92b003bb079ccd1a92130477671f6fc01ad16f26f723f26f8a57ccaed74ee1b190bed1f479d9727d2d0f9b005a6e456a35d4fb0daab1268a1b0db10836d9826a528ca76567805","public":"d75a980182b10ab7d54bfed3c964073a0ee172f3daa62325af021a68f707511a","secret":"9d61b19deffd5a60ba844af492ec2cc44449c5697b326919703bac031cae7f60"} {"alpha":"","beta":"90cf1df3b703cce59e2a35b925d411164068269d7b2d29f3301c03dd757876ff66b71dda49d2de59d03450451af026798e8f81cd2e333de5cdf4f3e140fdd8ae","id":"rfc9381-example-16","proof":"8657106690b5526245a92b003bb079ccd1a92130477671f6fc01ad16f26f723f26f8a57ccaed74ee1b190bed1f479d9727d2d0f9b005a6e456a35d4fb0daab1268a1b0db10836d9826a528ca76567805","public":"d75a980182b10ab7d54bfed3c964073a0ee172f3daa62325af021a68f707511a","secret":"9d61b19deffd5a60ba844af492ec2cc44449c5697b326919703bac031cae7f60"}
{"alpha":"72","beta":"8541f3ff9e0837a8a3c2b6da4326f0431a22bc7353edfedbc15089cab85bd4cb8108cbaf1e931fe2e6f477bb21a7bcdfe1c422c1ff2394b41379f4723ceb6b64","id":"rfc9381-key-alpha-72","proof":"cb809f3db77e2a15b9470e7b4cccb28ba08099a442bd357889505d3a5753143038392e8c6ec61b1796930d37bc58cbb5891b4d570a2180b3b18724ef9760bfffd4789004c970c70bd816cc104e9a110f","public":"d75a980182b10ab7d54bfed3c964073a0ee172f3daa62325af021a68f707511a","secret":"9d61b19deffd5a60ba844af492ec2cc44449c5697b326919703bac031cae7f60"} {"alpha":"72","beta":"8541f3ff9e0837a8a3c2b6da4326f0431a22bc7353edfedbc15089cab85bd4cb8108cbaf1e931fe2e6f477bb21a7bcdfe1c422c1ff2394b41379f4723ceb6b64","id":"rfc9381-key-alpha-72","proof":"cb809f3db77e2a15b9470e7b4cccb28ba08099a442bd357889505d3a5753143038392e8c6ec61b1796930d37bc58cbb5891b4d570a2180b3b18724ef9760bfffd4789004c970c70bd816cc104e9a110f","public":"d75a980182b10ab7d54bfed3c964073a0ee172f3daa62325af021a68f707511a","secret":"9d61b19deffd5a60ba844af492ec2cc44449c5697b326919703bac031cae7f60"}
{"alpha":"af82","beta":"9df8bd916435e1a2ec0185aa3fe11396f9cfcb6966d72bc50a24beaa6e2cc40fb91dc7f5959874a3d6165be18f675f783525d8c32e6488456152d5f9bfc15b46","id":"rfc9381-key-alpha-af82","proof":"06eecb68db258fdd7161d2ca4a85fa59eef631fd60ee546c4cf53b03541a4416ab41be1cc4c3aa0877c2d5c856b4f606f0d7d478818d305c499e60e37b8d9644a58c7b677bff66ed1562b79e3f688204","public":"d75a980182b10ab7d54bfed3c964073a0ee172f3daa62325af021a68f707511a","secret":"9d61b19deffd5a60ba844af492ec2cc44449c5697b326919703bac031cae7f60"} {"alpha":"af82","beta":"9df8bd916435e1a2ec0185aa3fe11396f9cfcb6966d72bc50a24beaa6e2cc40fb91dc7f5959874a3d6165be18f675f783525d8c32e6488456152d5f9bfc15b46","id":"rfc9381-key-alpha-af82","proof":"06eecb68db258fdd7161d2ca4a85fa59eef631fd60ee546c4cf53b03541a4416ab41be1cc4c3aa0877c2d5c856b4f606f0d7d478818d305c499e60e37b8d9644a58c7b677bff66ed1562b79e3f688204","public":"d75a980182b10ab7d54bfed3c964073a0ee172f3daa62325af021a68f707511a","secret":"9d61b19deffd5a60ba844af492ec2cc44449c5697b326919703bac031cae7f60"}
{"alpha":"7b22666f726d6174223a22736369656e74696e672d73706f742d636865636b2f31222c2272656365697074223a2261653137663838363661303563613162363731643936623737353839383465313161633639346163643637343338333566313037636235313363376363363030227d","beta":"124417f3bbb8fcfaca31a6f3eb5c230a78db44a22502411f245d9fd088d911843d9efb674ffcf29df1cd0f0d8ea6d944bc37d765d45aed9fd64ebe7edc650784","id":"ben-spot-seed-q1","proof":"def39199968be33a5682d6d9336f5f2ab5b180a38786d5eca4892eb42caa81981651a06f9980907c7b660880fe60d5b633e2c8afcb8c969abf2c3e5c229d2899044374a49321daf1a02c501c581cc20d","public":"ae4cf18a08c25e0f3af4f19214056be040d75d19b093e4bffb027dde5ac6e1d7"} {"alpha":"7b22666f726d6174223a22736369656e74696e672d73706f742d636865636b2f31222c2272656365697074223a2266373863373730346466316662643831356163336363663931313463383261313839663930333266666364373530323365313062323762393234663430366235227d","beta":"38b48ed32447c1f7eb3171504e9bd3910e902cd9c096180f9d20a4579bddd87019f8469bf92774bbd98ee49f0e31578f0e7b690b84a31d448395b69b6fe2064d","id":"ben-spot-seed-q1","proof":"dbc0e27a7488b67a39e6efc5fd816d3f5bae63cce0c83a71ff90334f0f7c984cd78ca2773271ba3605f973b143637892624b8aa9119490a9b2dde46dec05a8088405416ea9ac86509c30b8fac9702a01","public":"ae4cf18a08c25e0f3af4f19214056be040d75d19b093e4bffb027dde5ac6e1d7"}
{"alpha":"7b22666f726d6174223a22736369656e74696e672d73706f742d636865636b2f31222c2272656365697074223a2261653137663838363661303563613162363731643936623737353839383465313161633639346163643637343338333566313037636235313363376363363030227d","beta":null,"id":"tampered-challenge","proof":"def39199968be33a5682d6d9336f5f2ab5b180a38786d5eca4892eb42caa81981651a06f9980907c7a660880fe60d5b633e2c8afcb8c969abf2c3e5c229d2899044374a49321daf1a02c501c581cc20d","public":"ae4cf18a08c25e0f3af4f19214056be040d75d19b093e4bffb027dde5ac6e1d7"} {"alpha":"7b22666f726d6174223a22736369656e74696e672d73706f742d636865636b2f31222c2272656365697074223a2266373863373730346466316662643831356163336363663931313463383261313839663930333266666364373530323365313062323762393234663430366235227d","beta":null,"id":"tampered-challenge","proof":"dbc0e27a7488b67a39e6efc5fd816d3f5bae63cce0c83a71ff90334f0f7c984cd78ca2773271ba3604f973b143637892624b8aa9119490a9b2dde46dec05a8088405416ea9ac86509c30b8fac9702a01","public":"ae4cf18a08c25e0f3af4f19214056be040d75d19b093e4bffb027dde5ac6e1d7"}
{"alpha":"7b22666f726d6174223a22736369656e74696e672d73706f742d636865636b2f31222c2272656365697074223a2261653137663838363661303563613162363731643936623737353839383465313161633639346163643637343338333566313037636235313363376363363030227d78","beta":null,"id":"other-input","proof":"def39199968be33a5682d6d9336f5f2ab5b180a38786d5eca4892eb42caa81981651a06f9980907c7b660880fe60d5b633e2c8afcb8c969abf2c3e5c229d2899044374a49321daf1a02c501c581cc20d","public":"ae4cf18a08c25e0f3af4f19214056be040d75d19b093e4bffb027dde5ac6e1d7"} {"alpha":"7b22666f726d6174223a22736369656e74696e672d73706f742d636865636b2f31222c2272656365697074223a2266373863373730346466316662643831356163336363663931313463383261313839663930333266666364373530323365313062323762393234663430366235227d78","beta":null,"id":"other-input","proof":"dbc0e27a7488b67a39e6efc5fd816d3f5bae63cce0c83a71ff90334f0f7c984cd78ca2773271ba3605f973b143637892624b8aa9119490a9b2dde46dec05a8088405416ea9ac86509c30b8fac9702a01","public":"ae4cf18a08c25e0f3af4f19214056be040d75d19b093e4bffb027dde5ac6e1d7"}